commercially pure titanium has been employed as the best material for dental implants due to its biocompatibility and excellent mechanical properties .
healing of peri - implant tissue can be influenced by the physicochemical and mechanical properties of the implant material , microstructures , macrostructures , and surface chemistry of the implant .
the surface topography and chemistry of an implant material can have beneficial or disadvantageous influence on cell adhesion and proliferation , thereby controlling the osseointegration process .
studies on the effects of surface modified materials on the adherence and spreading of cells have recently been reported or are in progress.1,2,3,4,5 one of the handicaps of titanium from an esthetic point of view , as a dental implant material , is that the dark gray color of titanium can shine through the thin soft tissues . soft tissue shrinkage leading to gingival recession or peri - implantitis may leave the cervical titanium component visible . implants or transgingival abutments from tooth - colored materials such as zirconia
ceramic may be one possible solution to these problems with the dark color of titanium .
zirconia has tooth - like ivory color and somewhat translucency , making it sufficient material for esthetic restorations .
zirconia ceramic is a biocompatible material that has optimal esthetic and mechanical properties for dental implants .
the biomaterial - related properties of zirconia are as advantageous as those of titanium.6 tissue reaction and stability of zirconia , which are important factors in maintaining zirconia restorations free of periodontal problems , proved to be satisfactory.7,8 bacterial coverage and accumulation on zirconia was reported to be lower than on titanium.9,10 inflammation associated processes in peri - implant soft tissues were found to be higher around titanium than around zirconia.11 the material composition and profile of transgingival implant components seems to influence cell behavior and growth .
the macrostructures of the zirconia ceramic are able to provide contact guidance and gingival contouring to provide biological seal.1,12 zirconia ceramic can be suitable for transgingival implant components13 resulting in final esthetic results , but more clinical and mechanical trials are necessary for a complete understanding of the behavior of zirconia abutments and implants over a long time period . in hard tissue engineering , calcium phosphate ( cap ) ceramics , such as hydroxyapatite
[ ha ; ca10(po4)6(oh)2 ] and tricalcium phosphate [ tcp , ca3(po4)2 ] , have attracted attention due to their excellent biocompatibility and osteoconductivity.14 clinical reports on the cap ceramics proved their direct bonding to bone and complete osseointegration . however , their poor mechanical properties , such as low strength and fracture toughness , limited wide application in hard tissue implants .
calcium phosphate was accumulated on zirconia surfaces by ion beam assisted deposition ( ibad ) and hydroxyapatite by aerosol deposition .
the compositional degradation of calcium phosphate coatings is caused by the deposition process involving very high temperatures , low binding strength , and thick coatings .
the binding strength between the coating and the implant material is one of the critical characteristics which affect the long - term stability of the bone - implant interface .
the cell culture system used in this study was rat bone marrow - derived osteoblasts .
after implantation , the surface properties of biomaterials can affect the osteogenic and differentiation potentials of mesenchymal cells .
this study was performed to characterize the attachment and growth behavior of bone marrow - derived osteoblasts cultured on zirconia surfaces with calcium phosphate coatings and hydroxyapatite coatings compared to smooth surfaced zirconia .
paul , mn , usa ) of y - tzp ( yttrium - stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystal ) with a diameter of 10 mm and a thickness of 2 mm were prepared by pressing and sintering at 1500 for 2 hours .
one type was y - tzp with a smooth surface ( zs group ) , another was y - tzp with ibad ( ion beam assisted deposition ) ca - p coating ( cap group ) , the third was y - tzp with ha deposition ( ha group ) .
twenty discs of each group were fabricated and tested for proliferation , differentiation , osteogenic potential , and gene expression .
disc samples were cleaned ultrasonically in acetone , ethanol , and de - ionized water .
calcium phosphate film ( up to 500 nm ) was deposited on zirconia disk by the electron - beam deposition system .
mixed powder of hydroxyapatite ( alfa aesar , johnson matthey , london , uk ) and calcium oxide ( sigma , st .
an electron beam evaporator ( telemark , battle ground , wa , usa ) at 7.5 kv and 0.13 a , and an end - hall type ion gun ( ionbeam scientific , berks , uk ) at 90 v and 2.0 a were employed for deposition .
heat treatment after the deposition was conducted at 400 in the vacuum of 3 mm torr .
the raw ha powder ( alfar aesar , ward hill , ma , usa ) used in this study was subjected to the pre - deposition treatment consisting of heating to 1100 for 1 hour .
the fine particles were carried by oxygen gas and sprayed onto the zirconia disk in the deposition chamber .
bone marrow - derived osteoblasts were harvested and cultured following the methods described by maniatopoulos et al.15 femurs of two six - week - old male sprague - dawley rats were removed .
the bones were washed with 70% alcohol and immersed twice in alpha - mem ( sigma , st .
louis , mo , usa ) culture medium containing 100 units / ml penicillin - g , 100 g / ml streptomycin ( gibco brl , life technologies bv , bleiswijk , the netherlands ) .
the condyles were removed and the bone marrow flushed out using complete cell culture medium ( alpha - mem ) with 15% fetal bovine serum ( gibco , invitrogen ltd . , paisley , uk ) and supplemented with 50 g / ml ascorbic acid ( sigma , st .
louis , mo , usa ) , 7 mm na - beta - glycerophosphate ( sigma , st .
after seven days of primary culture , cells were trypsinized and resuspended in complete culture medium .
cells culture on disks placed in a 24-well plate was carried out for all experiments .
cells were collected and seeded at a density of 1  10 cells / ml by using 0.1% trypsin and 0.02% edta in ca and mg - free eagle 's buffer for cell release .
each set of wells contained 24 sterile zirconia disks at 37 in 5% co2 for 24 hours .
the samples were then moved to new dishes , fresh media were added , and the plated disks were cultured at 37 in 5% co2 for an additional 24 hours . all cell culture media were supplemented with 100 units / ml penicillin - g , 100 g / ml streptomycin , and 0.25 g / ml fungizone ( gemini bio - products inc . , woodland , ca , usa ) .
the cellular viability and proliferation of cells were examined with an mtt based cell growth determination kit ( cgd1 ; sigma , st .
louis , mo , usa ) . 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyl - tetrazoliumsalt ( mtt ) , which turns into a blue formazan product due to the viable mitochondria in active cells was used .
the osteoblasts were seeded at a density of 2  10 cells / ml and incubated at 37 in 5% co2 for 24 hours and 48 hours .
after 24 hours and 48 hours of incubation , the discs were moved to well plates and new media were added . then , diluted mtt ( 5 mg / ml ) solution was added , and the incubation was continued at 37 in 5% co2 for 4 hours .
the incubation medium was then removed , 400 l of isopropanol with 0.04 n hcl was added to each well , and the resulting formazan crystals were dissolved .
the absorbance of the formazan product at 490 nm was measured with a microplate reader ( bio - kinetics reader , el312e , winooski , vt , usa ) .
cells were seeded at a density of 2  10 cells / ml . the cultured cells were incubated for 24 and 48 hours at 37 in 5% co2 . the loosely - adherent or unbound cells were removed from the wells by aspiration .
wells were washed twice with a 0.1 m phosphate buffered saline ( pbs ) buffer ( ph 7.4 ) , and the remaining bound cells were fixed with 2.5 % glutaraldehyde in 0.1 m sodium cacodylate buffer , ph 7.3 , for more than 1 hour . the excess glutaraldehyde solution was removed and the cells were rinsed once more in pbs before being dehydrated in ethanol baths of progressively higher concentrations ( 50 , 60 , 70 , 80 , 90 , 95 , and 100% , 10 min in each bath ) . after the cells were dried to a critical point , the samples were sputtered with a 100 nm thick layer of gold using an ion coater ( ib-3 , eiko co. , tokyo , japan ) .
attachment and morphology of the cells on the discs were observed by vega sem ( tescan , brno , czech republic ) .
osteoblast differentiation generally implies expression of alkaline phosphatase ( alp ) , specific protein and mineralization capacity .
alp is a widely used osteoblast marker , and increased alp activity is associated with elevated osteoblastic activity .
the cells were seeded on the substrate at a density of 5  10 cells per well .
cells were washed twice in cold tris - buffered saline ( tbs ) , lysed with tbs - triton and centrifuged , and the supernatant was analysed for alp activity using 1 mg / ml p - nitrophenylphosphate ( pnpp ; sigma , st louis , mo , usa ) .
the absorbance at 409 nm was measured using the microplate reader ( bio - rad , hercules , ca , usa ) .
x - ray photoelectron spectroscopy ( xps ) is a surface - sensitive quantitative spectroscopic technique that measures the elemental composition of the surface ( top 0 - 10 nm usually ) .
surface chemistry of the substrates was analyzed by x - ray photoelectron spectroscopy ( xps , k - alpha ; thermo fisher scientific , ma , usa ) .
the xps spectra were recorded using normal al k ( 1486.6 ev ) with a probing beam size of 125 m .
the recorded spectra were calibrated to the binding energy of c 1s ( 284.6 ev ) owing to the charge effect .
xps spectra were obtained at zr 3d , y 3d , c 1s , o 1s , p 2p , ca 2p , and al 2p .
the osteoblastic differentiation was evaluated by rt - pcr for examination of type i collagen , glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase ( gapdh ) , osteocalcin , and osteonectin .
total rna extraction was performed with the rneasy mini kit ( qiagen , chatsworth , ca , usa ) .
amplitaq dnapolymerase ( amersham pharmacia biotech , piscataway , nj , usa ) was used to amplify the cdna .
the pcr products were fractionated by 1.5% agarose gel electrophoresis and visualized by ethidium bromide staining .
the intensity of the bands was quantified under uv transillumination ( eagle eye ii , stratagene , la jolla , ca , usa ) .
dissolution behavior of ca and p ions from the coatings were evaluated by immersion of cap and ha group specimens in physiological saline solution ( 0.9% ) nacl . at the predetermined time periods ( 4 , 8 , 12 , 16 , and 20 hours )
, the concentration of the ca and p ions released from the coated substrate was calculated with inductively coupled plasma - atomic emission spectrophotometer ( icp - aes ; icps-1001v , shimadzu , tokyo , japan ) analysis .
the mean values ( mv ) and standard deviations ( sd ) will be computed for the mtt test and alp analysis , and an analysis of variance ( anova ) and scheffe post hoc tests for multiple comparisons were conducted to assess the statistical significance of the differences between the groups .
all statistical analyses were performed using spss 18.0 for windows ( spss inc . , chicago , il , usa ) .
the optical densities of the formazan produced by osteoblasts in the zs , cap , and ha groups were measured after 4 , 24 and 48 hours via a mtt assay ( fig .
after 48 hours of cell culture , all three groups showed increased cellular activity and proliferation , however , no significant differences were observed among the groups ( p>.05 ) .
overall , the osteoblasts seeded onto the three groups of zirconia specimens showed similar degrees of vitality and proliferation .
the general morphology and growth pattern of the osteoblasts for each group were observed using sem for each group ( fig . 2 and fig .
sem images after 24 and 48 hours of culture show that the cells were triangular or elongated in shape and spread or irregularly with some long filopodia attached to the substrate .
after 48 hours of culture , cells on all discs showed increased contact to each other and firm adhesion to the substrate with increased formation of filopodia compared to 24 hours of culture .
overall , the osteoblasts cultured on smooth zirconia group showed comparative initial adhesion properties and growth pattern , compared to the surface treated groups .
alp assays were performed to compare the differentiation rate of osteoblasts on each group and the following results were obtained ( fig .
4 ) . after 14 days of incubation , alp was highest in the cap group and then the zs group with ha group the lowest .
xps was used to determine the surface composition of the substrates of each group ( fig .
the zirconia surface was oxidized as zirconium oxide and polluted by carbon contaminants in all groups .
however , the zs samples exhibited zirconia , yttrium , and aluminum peaks . samples with surface treatment showed peaks with calcium and phosphorous due to the different substances of the coating .
the cells were incubated for 24 h and the mrna levels of type i collagen , osteocalcin , and osteonectin were analysed by rt - pcr .
the levels of mrna for type i collagen , osteocalcin , and osteonectin on the zs , ha , and cap groups were comparable and showed no significant differences ( fig .
. the dissolution rate of ca and p was higher with cap group than ha group ( fig .
7 ) . also , the ca and p concentration increased with time for the cap group .
however , it decreased with time and became generally stable at 20 hours for the ha group .
research for new bioactive coatings for dental implants to improve tissue integration and stability are still in progress.16,17 the topography and the surface chemistry are of great importance.18,19 recently , surface - modified zirconia implants have been studied for long - term stability and strong bone tissue response.20 monoclinic zirconia coated on titanium has been proved to have positive osteoblastic behavior and is potentially useful in hard tissue replacements.21 calcium phosphate has been used as surface coatings on implants due to its bioactivity , which enables earlier stabilization of implants to the surrounding bone.22 coatings with high dissolution behavior have high concentration of ca which enhances osteoblast responses and improves bone formation around the implant.23 however , the dissolution behavior and the low adhesion strength of the coating layer have raised concerns on the stability of the implants.24 in the present study , the concentration of ca and p released from the coatings was higher with the cap group than the ha group . also , the ca and p concentrations increased with time on the cap group .
the xps results show that the ion compositions of the cap and ha group are very similar .
thus , the different coating methods of the cap or ha may explain the improved chemical stability of the ha group .
this implies that aerosol deposition method can produce more stable coatings with implants and transgingival components . to verify the long - term stability of the zirconia coated with bioactive ceramics , evaluation of the adhesion strength between the coating and the substrate
alp activity is an important parameter that allows for the assessment of the differentiation level of the mineralization of osteoblasts , and is considered as a marker of the early stage of osteogenic differentiation.25 in this study , alp activity of the cap coated group was shown to be the highest .
although no significant differences were observed among the groups , it can be speculated that calcium phosphate coating may have positive effects on the early stage of osteogenic differentiation .
type i collagens are major extracellular matrix components of osteoblasts and involved in adhesion . as osteocalcin is produced by osteoblasts , it is known as a marker for the bone formation process . also , osteonectin is an extracellular matrix glycoprotein which is secreted by osteoblasts during bone mineralization and modulates cell proliferation .
no significant differences were found in the level of mrna for type i collagen , osteocalcin , and osteonectin during the 24 hours cell culture period .
surface texture of machined zirconia is known to enhance bone apposition and has benefits on the removal torque values.6 however , in this study , smooth zirconia and surface coated zirconia showed overall comparable cellular viability which implies that surface chemistry affects osteoblast attachment and spreading .
more in vivo and in vitro investigations are needed to establish the ideal surface roughness and biochemical coating for the zirconia implants . from the semi
- quantitative xps analyses , it can be speculated that surface treatment affected the surface chemical composition of the zirconia surface .
although sandblasting with al2o3 was not performed , xps results documented the presence of al on the smooth zirconia surface group which might have been incorporated for increasing the toughness of the zirconia.26 these al2o3 particles would not affect the osseointegration pattern as shown by animal studies.27 however , the role of residual al2o3 on implant surfaces is still a matter of controversy28 and it is difficult to conclude whether there is a positive or negative effect because of the low content of residual al on the smooth zirconia surface group .
fluoride incorporation into the coating layer is known to bring about lower dissolution and greater chemical stability.29 therefore , further studies on the incorporation of other ions and coating techniques for the best resistance to dissolution and higher positive cell stimulating effects are needed .
thus , we need to focus on the control of the in vivo degradation behavior and the mechanical properties of the coatings on the zirconia .
the attachment and growth behavior of bone marrowderived osteoblasts cultured on smooth zirconia and surface coated zirconia showed comparable results .
however , considering the dissolution behavior of the surface coatings of the zirconia , the ha coating was more stable compared to the cap coating .
more in vitro and in vivo researches are necessary to identify a stable surface with controlled and standardized chemistry .
 purposethis study was performed to characterize the effects of zirconia coated with calcium phosphate and hydroxyapatite compared to smooth zirconia after bone marrow - derived osteoblast culture.materials and methodsbone marrow - derived osteoblasts were cultured on ( 1 ) smooth zirconia , ( 2 ) zirconia coated with calcium phosphate ( cap ) , and ( 3 ) zirconia coated with hydroxyapatite ( ha ) . 
 the tetrazolium - based colorimetric assay ( mtt test ) was used for cell proliferation evaluation . 
 scanning electron microscopy ( sem ) and alkaline phosphatase ( alp ) activity was measured to evaluate the cellular morphology and differentiation rate . 
 x - ray photoelectron spectroscopy ( xps ) was employed for the analysis of surface chemistry . 
 the genetic expression of the osteoblasts and dissolution behavior of the coatings were observed . 
 assessment of the significance level of the differences between the groups was done with analysis of variance ( anova).resultsfrom the mtt assay , no significant difference between smooth and surface coated zirconia was found ( p>.05 ) . from the sem image , 
 cells on all three groups of discs were sporadically triangular or spread out in shape with formation of filopodia . from the alp activity assay , 
 the optical density of osteoblasts on smooth zirconia discs was higher than that on surface treated zirconia discs ( p>.05 ) . 
 most of the genes related to cell adhesion showed similar expression level between smooth and surface treated zirconia . 
 the dissolution rate was higher with cap than ha coating.conclusionthe attachment and growth behavior of bone - marrow - derived osteoblasts cultured on smooth surface coated zirconia showed comparable results . 
 however , the ha coating showed more time - dependent stability compared to the cap coating . 