The EURO ROADEF 2010 Challenge aimed to schedule the maintenance and refueling operations of French nuclear power plants, ranking the approaches in competition for the quality of primal solutions. This paper justifies the high quality of the best solutions computing dual bounds with dual heuristics. A first step designs several Mixed Integer Programming (MIP) relaxations with different compromises between computation time and quality of dual bounds. To deal with smaller MIPs, we prove how reductions in the number of time steps and scenarios can guarantee dual bounds for the whole problem of the Challenge. Several sets of dual bounds are computable, improving significantly the former best dual bounds of the literature. Intermediate results allow also a better understanding of the problem and offer perspectives to improve some approaches of the Challenge.
We address the problem of planning outages of nuclear power plants submitted by EDF (Electricite De France) as the challenge EURO ROADEF 2010. As our team won the first prize of the contest in the senior category, our approach may be of interest: it is conceptually simple, easy to program and computationally relatively fast. We present both our method and some ideas to improve it.