We focus on the word-level visual lipreading, which requires recognizing the word being spoken, given only the video but not the audio. State-of-the-art methods explore the use of end-to-end neural networks, including a shallow (up to three layers) 3D convolutional neural network (CNN) + a deep 2D CNN (, ResNet) as the front-end to extract visual features, and a recurrent neural network (, bidirectional LSTM) as the back-end for classification. In this work, we propose to replace the shallow 3D CNNs + deep 2D CNNs front-end with recent successful deep 3D CNNs --- two-stream (, grayscale video and optical flow streams) I3D. We evaluate different combinations of front-end and back-end modules with the grayscale video and optical flow inputs on the LRW dataset. The experiments show that, compared to the shallow 3D CNNs + deep 2D CNNs front-end, the deep 3D CNNs front-end with pre-training on the large-scale image and video datasets (, ImageNet and Kinetics) can improve the classification accuracy. On the other hand, we demonstrate that using the optical flow input alone can achieve comparable performance as using the grayscale video as input. Moreover, the two-stream network using both the grayscale video and optical flow inputs can further improve the performance. Overall, our two-stream I3D front-end with a Bi-LSTM back-end results in an absolute improvement of 5.3 over the previous art.
For the first time in this paper we present results showing the effect of speaker head pose angle on automatic lip-reading performance over a wide range of closely spaced angles. We analyse the effect head pose has upon the features themselves and show that by selecting coefficients with minimum variance w.r.t. pose angle, recognition performance can be improved when train-test pose angles differ. Experiments are conducted using the initial phase of a unique multi view Audio-Visual database designed specifically for research and development of pose-invariant lip-reading systems. We firstly show that it is the higher order horizontal spatial frequency components that become most detrimental as the pose deviates. Secondly we assess the performance of different feature selection masks across a range of pose angles including a new mask based on Minimum Cross-Pose Variance coefficients. We report a relative improvement of 50 in Word Error Rate when using our selection mask over a common energy based selection during profile view lip-reading. The integration of audio and visual information improves speech recognition performance, specially in the presence of noise. In these circumstances it is necessary to introduce audio and visual weights to control the contribution of each modality to the recognition task. We present a method to set the value of the weights associated to each stream according to their reliability for speech recognition, allowing them to change with time and adapt to different noise and working conditions. Our dynamic weights are derived from several measures of the stream reliability, some specific to speech processing and others inherent to any classification task, and take into account the special role of silence detection in the definition of audio and visual weights. In this paper, we propose a new confidence measure, compare it to existing ones, and point out the importance of the correct detection of silence utterances in the definition of the weighting system. Experimental results support our main contribution: the inclusion of a voice activity detector in the weighting scheme improves speech recognition over different system architectures and confidence measures, leading to an increase in performance more relevant than any difference between the proposed confidence measures. We propose a three-stage pixel-based visual front end for automatic speechreading (lipreading) that results in significantly improved recognition performance of spoken words or phonemes. The proposed algorithm is a cascade of three transforms applied on a three-dimensional video region-of-interest that contains the speaker's mouth area. The first stage is a typical image compression transform that achieves a high-energy, reduced-dimensionality representation of the video data. The second stage is a linear discriminant analysis-based data projection, which is applied on a concatenation of a small amount of consecutive image transformed video data. The third stage is a data rotation by means of a maximum likelihood linear transform that optimizes the likelihood of the observed data under the assumption of their class-conditional multivariate normal distribution with diagonal covariance. We applied the algorithm to visual-only 52-class phonetic and 27-class visemic classification on a 162-subject, 8-hour long, large vocabulary, continuous speech audio-visual database. We demonstrated significant classification accuracy gains by each added stage of the proposed algorithm which, when combined, can achieve up to 27 improvement. Overall, we achieved a 60 (49 ) visual-only frame-level visemic classification accuracy with (without) use of test set viseme boundaries. In addition, we report improved audio-visual phonetic classification over the use of a single-stage image transform visual front end. Finally, we discuss preliminary speech recognition results.