In most biological tissues, light scattering due to small differences in refractive index limits the depth of optical imaging systems. Two-photon microscopy (2PM), which significantly reduces the scattering of the excitation light, has emerged as the most common method to image deep within scattering biological tissue. This technique, however, requires high-power pulsed lasers that are both expensive and difficult to integrate into compact portable systems. Using a combination of theoretical and experimental techniques, we show that if the excitation path length can be minimized, selective plane illumination microscopy (SPIM) can image nearly as deep as 2PM without the need for a high-powered pulsed laser. Compared to other single-photon imaging techniques like epifluorescence and confocal microscopy, SPIM can image more than twice as deep in scattering media (∼10 times the mean scattering length). These results suggest that SPIM has the potential to provide deep imaging in scattering media in situations in which 2PM systems would be too large or costly.
A model for the propagation of a focused light beam in a strongly scattering medium is used to analyse various factors that limit the capability of two-photon fluorescence microscopy (TPFM) to image deep sections of optically thick biological specimens. The TPFM imaging depth is shown to be limited by three main factors: (1) beam broadening as a result of multiple small-angle scattering, leading to a loss of submicron lateral resolution; (2) strong near-surface fluorescence at large imaging depths as a result of the increase in average source power in order to compensate for scattering losses; (3) reduction in useful two-photon fluorescence signal level because of the exponential attenuation of the excitation power. The influence of these factors is examined in a small-angle diffusion approximation of radiative transfer theory. The first two of them are shown to set a fundamental TPFM limit, whereas the last is an instrumental limitation and appears to be the most critical to state-of-the-art commercial two-photon laser scanning microscopy systems for the vast majority of fluorophores in current use.