MR PHOSA
Actually now what your - what Mr Chairman says is not the same as the objection.  I thought I was going to deal with the objection which was: "Why do I want to know that" but what Mr Chairman is saying is the answer I wanted to ascertain, I wanted to ascertain exactly that.  And I said to him: "I understand him as your" - Mr Chairman says that he only thinks that he was at home but he can't be sure.  I wanted clarity on that.  Now the question was, I shouldn't have asked that question.
	Now I don't know which to answer because if the answer is exactly what Mr Chairman says, that's what I wanted clarity on, there's nothing wrong with that.  I wanted to know whether his answer is exactly as you say Mr Chairman: "Yes, as far as I'm concerned I think I was at home, but it can well be that I wasn't at home" - because I was going to deal with that later.  Is that your answer Sir?