MR MALAN
No, I don't want you to tell me what he did and the good man he was, I accept that.  The case before us is one of, as you put it, a quality or a level of intelligence that shouldn't be called intelligence.  This is what you observed, having listened to Mr Olifant, but that's the perspective.  You accept that Olifant's intelligence, as his understanding of intelligence I mean as a basis for your argument here, you didn't challenge that.  Now from that perspective, wouldn't that have been a fair deduction to Olifant and he's not making the decision, he's simply reporting, for the sake of argument, "I've seen Hamlyn with Muff Anderson, they shared the same house.  Yes, I did see him at that address, he fixed her motor bike which was broke" and he reports back.  What would the - I'm not making a case for good intelligence, I share you opinion of the level of intelligence, but that's not the measure for deciding, necessarily.