MR NOMPOZOLO
Thank you Mr Commissioner.  Mr Commissioner he is saying, no I think the first point which we'd need to look at is that it was not his initiative to bring the weapon in question to the scene.  It was the plan, it was part of the plan, which he is not part of it, but he was just a tool in that situation.  When he had to use his discretion in terms of shooting, he is saying he shot where he thought that it was in front of the crowd, as a result dust came up.  He does not dispute that it might  have hit the crowd, but he is saying:  "Well, as far as I was concerned, it hit in front of them.  As a result they did not come nearby again."  That is the proportionality that he used to circumvent what was the crowd coming towards them.