MR PATEL
Whose mistake is this now?  In your affidavit you say, paragraph fifty eight (58)
"I was with Mdu and my girlfriend Mphume walking in Thembisa Location when we came across three or four boys who Mdu identified as being members of the ANC and troublemakers from a school."
Your evidence this morning is:
"Three boys were singing ANC slogans.  Mdu says, 'Do you hear them'.  I said, 'Yes, step aside'."
Two totally different stories.  Why so?  Which one is the truth first, tell us?  Tell us that.  The one in your affidavit or your evidence this morning?