MR DORFLING
With the greatest respect Mr Chair the whole line of questioning was aimed at obtaining from this witness an answer as to whether he saw shots being fired from the marchers, from members amongst the marchers. And he specifically responded by answering no. That was his choice to say no I did not see that. He didn't offer the explanation that what I tried to convey to Mr Justice Nugent was that there might have been shots or that, that might have been a perception. He now today offers that explanation. I am putting to the witness that what is quite clear from the evidence in front of Mr Justice Nugent is that he not only contradicts this evidence but I will get to the other portions in the record where he contradicts himself at the time of the inquest.