MR PATEL
I must object to that question Mr Chairman.  This questions, I'm not sure what the answer is to it but it exposes Mr Mkhwanazi to other offences to which he hasn't claimed amnesty.  You will recall that his testimony relates to what he did in Ermelo and not in the Piet Retief area.  The whole general trend of the questions are in my submission irrelevant but I haven't objected for various reasons but on this particular point I think I must stress that it's not a permissable question.