MR TIPP
You said in your evidence that they were ahead of you and that you saw people ahead of you, is that correct or are you not sure?  Can I just remind you further before you answer, that you also said in your evidence that they, after you turned from Noord into King George there were hundreds ahead of you and they passed peacefully on and they were left alone to go on ahead, they were not attacked.  Now is that what you saw Mr Ngobese?