UNKNOWN
Yes, although I would assume on my learned friend's argument, once again, even with an attempt, they would suggest that the Committee disregard proportionality because the attempt never succeeded.  So - and one can also think of a different scenario where I planned to blow the Kewtown Youth but instead I blow up the members of the soccer team.  What you're going to be assessing in terms of (f) and I'm pretty sure this is what applicants on those facts would say, look at the objective that I was seeking to pursue, do not look at the objective which I in fact obtained because if you had to then take that argument to its full conclusion and say only look at what was attained, well then you would say if, due to genuine error, members of the soccer team were blown up by mistake, people in those circumstances would never be able to obtain amnesty because we only adjudicate from the perspective of what in fact happened, not what you in fact intended to do.  So the test must relate to your intention.