CHAIRPERSON
I think it's just a question of semantics.  Why are you attacking me, why are you trying to kill me, and also I know just from experience in matters of this nature they often refer to attacks as being tried to be killed.  And it's a question of interpretation as well, so I don't think it's such a, it's not such a big bull point that he said why are you trying to kill me in evidence-in-chief and now he says why are they attacking me.