MR LAX
Mr Radebe it's really quite simple.  You're confronted here with a contradiction.  In the first part of your evidence you testified that you were a member of the SDU in Small Farm.  We confirm from you whether, when this incident took place you were a member of that Small Farms unit, you were clear that it was the Small Farms unit.  You then indicated that you joined the Zone 12 unit sometime after this incident, because, as you put it, there were problems at Small Farms.  Later on in your testimony you then said something quite different.  You said that you had been a member of the Zone 12 SDU for about two to three months when this incident took place.  Do you understand that?  Now there is a contradiction there.  Do you understand that there's a contradiction?