CHAIRPERSON
On that point I don't think it really turns on anything in respect of your application.  You have now seen her explanation about her disappearance, which appears on page 187 and at paragraph 16, that she was ordered by her parents to go to Tembisa.  And then if you check again paragraph 19, the reason why she later came back to her home was after she had again tried to avoid the comrades who were harassing her simply because she was once abducted and subjected to long hours of rape by a gang who stayed at Kwamadala Hostel.  Were you sensitive at all to her plight?  When you heard about her kidnapping, and the fact that she had been gang raped repeatedly for weeks?  If you say you were sensitive, what did you show as comrades, about your sensitivity?  How did you show your sensitivity towards her plight?  Did you read her statement?  She says neither her parents even believed her.