MR DU PLESSIS
My Lord, with respect may I just make one point, that is why I am dealing with this now.  I thought it was cleared up in his evidence, there was clearly and I will argue that My Lord, there was clearly a misunderstanding when the questions were put to the witness, about this issue, and it has developed now into a situation where the witness is faced with allegations that he has made, has told under evidence, certain different versions, whereas I could clearly before my eyes see the development of the misunderstanding.