RUSSELL ALLY
Meriam, what happened to your mother is obviously a great tragedy and we, we sympathize with you but there's just some things in your statement that I need to, to ask you about which, which will help us in, in our work cause when Mr Manthata asked you about this march.  Is it, it was during  a march to, to protest against De Klerk who was coming to campaign in the area that the teargas cannisters were thrown and landed in, in your house.  In the family house.  When Mr Manthata asked you about the march you said that it was a peaceful march yet in your statement when you described those events and I'm going to read what is in your statement and I want you to just tell us which is the more acurate account.  You say in your statement, Mr De Klerk was in Messina to canvass for the 1994 elections.  All the black political organizations in Messina protested, throwing stones and the police responded with teargas to disperse the masses.  So what actually was happening on that day?