CHAIRPERSON
But what Mr Patel is getting at, Mr Hlongwane, in the paper you say that it was Mr Mdu who identified to you boys as being ANC members and troublemakers.  This morning when you were giving evidence here, you said you were walking along with Mdu and Mphume and you heard these boys singing ANC songs, so you knew that they were ANC members because of the songs they were singing, which is not the same as what you say here.  And Mr Patel is asking you what exactly is the position.  Is what you say in the affidavit correct, or what you said in evidence this morning and could you explain.  That is all he is asking.