MR BLACK
My I possibly dispute that as a reply to that.  As far as the present applicant is concerned, Mr Patel had the opportunity as Mr Chairman has indicated to cross-examine and challenge what the present applicant has said.
	Mr Patel has also had the opportunity to challenge what the other two applicants both Mr Nkuna's have said.  He hasn't given me an indication of course as to whether or not he was satisfied with the Nkuna evidence, but I would assume that his indication of his cross-examination and limited extent of his cross-examination of Mr Skosana, he didn't seem to challenge it at any great lengths, so I don't anticipate, I could undertake to contact Mr Patel tonight and find out what his position is.