MR DEHAL
Mr Mbukazi, I don't want to be unfair to you, I'm not saying you're lying, but as I see it we've got about four versions from you on this aspect alone and I want to be fair to you and tell you what they are.  When Mr Sibanyoni asked you questions you said both you and your father arrived at about the same time to your brother on the ground, your deceased brother, the contradiction arose that you said your brother spoke when your father in his statement says your brother could not speak, you then said your father was under the influence.  You've remembered that and I have put that to you earlier.  The second is that when I dealt with those versions you said you arrived before your father arrived, you spoke to your deceased brother and when your father arrived, it is possible that your deceased brother was not able to speak.  Do you remember that second version?