JUDGE WILSON
But here he has denied the common purpose, that is the problem facing his application.  It's not a case, we have many of them where someone says, well actually I wasn't one of the people who did it but I was part of the mob who were there.  He specifically said, and he was led at great length on this, that they resolved to kill five named people, that they went there to kill those people only, that as soon as he heard this child screaming he went and intervened and stopped the attack on the child.  You remember all that evidence he gave?