MR BERGER
Well I must just put it to you Mr Mbele that that's completely contradictory to what you state in your statement.  Do you have any explanation for that?  In other words what I'm saying to you is that your evidence now is that you were at the back of the group only when the group was leaving Slovo Park.  What you state in your statement is that you were at the back of the group when you were entering Boipatong.  I'm putting to you that there's a difference, a material difference.