MR BERGER
Chairperson, do you want me to argue?  Chairperson, I don't share an identity of interests with this witness.  I represent certain victims of the massacre, this witness has been cross-examined on a statement that he made to Mongezi, statements which are before the Commission and I am attempting to ask the witness whose memory has been shown to be faulty, whether he agrees with certain evidence.  If he agrees with it, then there is no need to lead that evidence.  If I need to refresh his memory as is obviously the case, I submit I am entitled to do so.  I am not badgering the witness in any way, I am simply asking him in a very calm and ...