AZHAR CACHALIA
Chair no thank you, except to just state that I think the matter is a simple matter of being functus officio as you had decided yesterday.  I say that is the only remedy that he has in the circumstances, rightly or wrongly, it appears that the second application was received after the decision was made on the 4th of September and therefore at that time it would be, the Committee was already functus officio.  Thank you, sir.