BERNARD MAKGABO NGOEPE
But Mr Mpshe, I, whereabouts page 18 and so on of the, of bundle A, how does it relate to page six of the bundle which Mr Bizos has just given us, because both, they have a commonality.  Paragraph, they all purport to be paragraph 9(4), nature and particulars, but the contents differ.  Now, I do not know whether what you are saying is that pages 18 and so on replaced pages six of Mr Bizos' documents and so on.