MR MMESELI
I dispute that.  As I explained that on the first day I saw Oupa Makubalo in the office.  On second day as whether I was in office or not and again on the third day I do not know as whether I'm in the office or not but I I saw him in the office.  But its either on the second day or the third day I was in the office, I'm not sure. That's the way I have explained.