MR DEHAL
I agree Mr Chairperson.  Mr Chairperson, the second thing that I want to raise is Mr McBride raised the question of this list, I did not hear what the lady who came in, said.  I had my headphones on.  I don't know whether the question of that list has been appropriately addressed.  Sorry, Mr McBride is aware of pages 3 and 4 and the list of those persons. As I have mentioned earlier, we take issue with that list because it differs in number and names from the earlier list, but the basis for the request is to establish who in fact is opposing as opposed to the full list.