CHAIRPERSON
...[inaudible] it does appear - I'm not speaking for the whole Panel but we have the affidavits of all the policemen who talk of knocking on the door.  It seems unlikely that they would have all invented this but equally well some man who is fast asleep may not realise when he wakes that is was a knocking that he heard and not some other loud noise.  The question isn't really of great relevance, it's why he behaved as he did that is of importance.  And as you say there it seems that he was convinced they were being attacked and reacted as he thought a bodyguard should.