CHAIRPERSON
Let me again express our appreciation that you have come.  We obviously want to consult amongst ourselves, as I indicated, I mean there is no legal obligation at this stage.  We have not subpoenaed the Brigadier, he was coming voluntarily and we appreciate the courtesy that you have shown the Commission but we would like sort of to look at the implications of this and want to say thank you very much for coming and you are free to stand down.