MS THABETE
I'm indebted to Madame Chair and Ms Thabete, you may mention that it's not clear from both the written application, the written application form as well as the affidavit that the attack on the grandfather was as a result of two groups meeting and fighting, it was as though the grandfather was in fact attacked at his home by a particular group which was led by Mr Nkosi.  I think you correctly made that and that's what I make out of both the written application form and the affidavit which obviously is conflicting with the version given by Mr Ndlangamandla during his vive voce evidence.