MS PATEL
If one looks at the manner of the assault then as much as I'm fully aware of us not taking an armchair approach to the tensions prevalent at the time and the levels of anger.  If one looks at the victims that were shot, they were all almost shot in the upper part of the body.  Two of them were shot in the face  If the mandate to the applicants as stated by Mr Bhayi was clear and he said the other members of the group would have known about the ambit of that mandate, then surely despite the levels of anger and the tension, the applicants have still gone beyond their motivation - not beyond their motivation, beyond the level of the authorization in a sense.