MR CLAASSEN
Thank you Madam.  Madam this is true, and it is so that Ms Msibi stated that she did see the applicant as the person who actually threw something at the bus.  Madam Chair, it is as I have said, my instructions are that the applicant were indeed on the scene, but not actually throwing anything at this particular bus.
	In view of this, Madam Chair, it is my further humble submission that a mistake might have been made.  It is true that the applicant in his own version, said that he was present when this occurred and in view of this, it is my submission that surely the possibility arises that Ms Msibi might have seen the applicant, but not actually throwing these projectiles towards the bus.