MR TIPP
Chairperson I am sorry. My learned friend put to the witness that he has now come up today with a third version which was not mentioned at the inquest and that is clearly incorrect. As Judge Ngcobo correctly points out. If one reads 3761 and 3762 it is quite clear that the evidence that was given at the inquest was repeated as Mr Llale says today. And my learned friend relies on a sentence which was "I did not see him fire those two volleys of shots." And that is correct. As the witness explains I saw the first one and not the second one. So it is correct to say I did not see the two. So for my learned friend to say that it is a third version is quite incorrect.