MR SARDIWALLA
Chairperson, yes, but the point here is that when he shot and they stopped at the point when they were satisfied that the driver was in fact killed and not only the driver, but Makeke was killed.  That was his evidence.  He said that he was satisfied and that's when they ran off.  They had done their job.  One can argue now, having the benefit of hindsight, that surely you should have gone and opened the door and checked whether Makeke was there, or shone a torch before, come closer to check whether it was Makeke or somebody else, but that has all other ramifications in that situation, in a war situation literally between parties.  One must put yourself in the shoes of the applicant at the time.