MR MARTINI
Sorry Mr Commissioner, this is an unfair question.  My client, Mr van Zyl is testifying, he is not a Judge, he says I respect the decision.  If the Judge found that to be his decision, that is the decision.  He respects it.  Mr van Zyl is not sitting here as a Judge in appeal or to determine the validity of the Judge's judgement.  He says he respects it.