MR DORFLING
My learned friend is indeed correct Mr Chair. I specifically asked the witness did you see as opposed to just hearing. Mr Chair you actually remarked whether you want us to have a specific answer as to whether he saw it. And I got a specific answer to that being in the negative. "No I did not see." And that is the line of questioning I am pursuing. The witness had the opportunity today to give an explanation as to perceptions but he chose to say: "I did not see anybody firing."