MR HATTINGH
Thank you, Mr Chairman, I'll proceed.   If you'll just bear with me for one moment, I just want to quickly page to where I still need to cross-examine on.   With regard to the death of Chris Ngwenya, were you aware of the fact that on the Saturday prior to the killing of Mr Ngwenya on the Sunday, that Mr John Mndebele laid a charge of assault with the police against Chris Ngwenya?