MR BERGER
If I can just put to you Mr Khanyile why I am asking you these questions.  I suggest to you that you are deliberately playing down your role in the massacre, that you are aware of many more people who were killed or injured and in particular you are aware and well aware at the time, that most of the people who were attacked, were the elderly, the children and the women of Boipatong.  That is what I am putting to you.