MR BERGER
Chairperson, I'm asking a question about a particular person who was on duty at a particular gate and with respect to my learned friend he led Mr Mthembu for two purposes, (a) to give evidence in support of his own application and (b) to give evidence in support of the application of all the other applicants.  With respect I submit I'm entitled to question Mr Mthembu on matters which might have a bearing on the applications?