MR LAX
You see the court accepted his explanations for those contradictions, it's clear from the judgement and that's why it relied on that evidence.  What is difficult for us to understand and this is why I'm asking you this, because it seems he couldn't have been told all that information by the police, they wouldn't know that detail.  Only someone who was present would know that detail and yet you insisted he wasn't present and so that leaves us with a problem, we can't understand it.  That's why I'm asking for your explanation, you see?  So it's not a trick question, it's just to help us understand.