MR BANADE
Mr Chairman, my response to that would be, as I said earlier today, there is a six year gap between the happenings on that day and today.  If one should be questioned today about details of an incident that took place six years ago, they would be a bit  vague, and obviously different people see things differently.  The Judges in the Supreme Court and magistrates are aware of that and I would have to attribute the differences to these two factors, the gap between when the incident took place and now and also the different individuals' way of seeing things.