BERNARD MAKGABO NGOEPE
I think it is relevant, Mr Memani, to, as to why the witness, as to whether or not the witness could have seen any political purpose being possibly served by targeting this particular person.  If he says that we attacked him because he was a hawker, then, well, that would be relevant, but in a negative way, but your client is not applying for amnesty for killing people because they are hawkers.  He is supposed to show that what they did to, well, the victims or the assault or whatever, was associated with a political objective and that must impact on the activities of the victims.