MR BLACK
Yes.   Madam Chair, perhaps if I start on the last point.   I had made a point in my notes and it's an omission on my part, to put to Mr O'Farrell, but I'm sure the leader of evidence could consult with him and perhaps she could either confirm my submissions which would be made to you.   What I intended to put, Mr O'Farrell says that he identified the brother and the father of the applicant as being party, or some part of the party that attacked him.  Now my obstructions are, objectively, that first of all the father does not live on the premises, but apart from that, that no charges of assault have ever been brought or laid against these two parties, who have been identified.