MR SMUTS
Well Mr Chairman, I'd go so far as to say that they acted in bad faith.  It is was indeed their objective to identify whites who were associated with violence, once they had gone to scout the area at the camp at Mpande, discovered on the evidence heard today from Mr Guleni that there was a family group there, that this family group was not locally based but had come from afar and that elements from this group had gone fishing.  It is apparent and it was apparent to them at the time that what they were dealing with was holidaymakers, it was a holiday season, there were people from afar from a family grouping who had gone fishing for the day.  With that information at their disposal they set an ambush and committed murder and with respect, on their evidence that could not comply with the requirements with the message they wished to send and subjectively, they were not acting bona fide in furtherance of a political struggle.
	Mr Chairman, one can speculate as to what actually was the motivation but the Committee is confronted with the evidence tendered by the applicants.  They say those were the requirements and their evidence is that they took no steps to ensure that they were meeting those requirements.