MR BOOYENS
Mr Chairman, there's just one aspect, perhaps my learned colleague Ms Patel can help us.  At the conclusion of proceedings in November I indicated if there was a statement for the 17th November, taken a further statement from the witness I would like to see it.  I accept my learned friend wasn't given to that, I accept her word one hundred percent without any qualification but is there perhaps, can she just inform us is there any explanation why that statement was only made available to us at such a late stage seeing that it was taken at the end of the proceedings in November?  It's of course maybe relevant because there does seem to be something one feels uncomfortable about here.