CHAIRPERSON
Now that is precisely what we are asking.  If we are of the view that amnesty should be granted at the end of the day, must we grant it in respect of assault, murder, attempted murder, rape, whatever.  That is what we are asking.  Is this applicant one of those who falls in the category where specific crimes for which he applies can be identified?  That is all I'm asking you.  Has this never been done yet, Mr Samuels?