MR DEHAL
Thank you Mr Chairperson.  Mr Chairperson, firstly, briefly to deal with some of the legal aspects Mr Richard raised.  Firstly in regard to what he termed the in limine submission, that this argument is premature.  I have some difficulty with that in that you will recall Mr Chairperson, that when first bundle C came into play, when Mr Richard endeavoured to cross-examine Mr Ismail if I recall correctly, there on, there were objections to it and I outlined at that stage, that I would be objecting to its inclusion in these proceedings.  I think it is you, Mr Chair, who decided that it would be prudent and in my view, correctly so, to have this argument aired out at this stage, before Mr McBride seeks to give evidence.