CHAIRPERSON
No, you didn't give a version, that's where we have a problem with that.  We actually, on this point, obviously should blame our evidence leader as well, because when your client was giving evidence it was never put to him as it should have been done by our evidence leader that she will lead evidence to the effect that at the time when the people were attacked, some were wearing balaclavas and that there was one particular person who participated in the attack, whose face was uncovered.  So we have not been able to ventilate this issue because of lack of proper procedures having been followed in the leading of evidence, but you yourself did not lead this kind of evidence, so we have not been able to take the matter any further.