metals such as titanium , zirconium , tantalum , hafnium , niobium , vanadium and mixtures thereof , preferably titanium and zirconium , may be deposited in a substantially amorphous metallic state in accordance with the present invention by sputtering the metal in a nonreactive atmosphere substantially comprising inert gas , but also comprising a small amount of reactive gas , such as oxygen and / or nitrogen , preferably oxygen . the amount of oxygen is sufficient to effect the deposition of the metal in a substantially amorphous rather than crystalline state , but insufficient to effect the transition of sputtering from the metallic mode to the oxide mode . the appropriate amount of oxygen in the inert gas for purposes of the present invention is related to the cathode operating parameters , particularly the power , and the size of the target . [ 0009 ] fig1 and 2 illustrate the maximum oxygen concentration in argon at various levels of power for titanium and zirconium targets respectively operated in an airco ils - 1600 laboratory scale coater . at higher oxygen concentrations , the sputtering mode will switch from metallic to oxide , resulting in the slow deposition of amorphous metal oxide . therefore , the oxygen concentration is kept sufficiently low to avoid depositing metal oxide . however , it has been discovered that the higher the oxygen concentration , below the switching point , the harder the amorphous metal deposited in the metal sputtering mode . [ 0010 ] fig3 illustrates the voltage as a function of oxygen concentration for titanium films deposited at power levels of from 1 to 4 kilowatts in an airco ils - 1600 laboratory scale coater . the voltage peak for each curve illustrates the switching point between metallic and oxide sputtering modes , and indicates the maximum oxygen concentration for the specified power level using this coating apparatus . it is preferred to operate near the peak , i . e . at a relatively higher concentration of oxygen , for maximum metal hardness , but without switching from the metallic sputtering mode to the oxide sputtering mode . the amorphous metal film sputtered in an oxygen - containing but substantially nonreactive atmosphere is only slightly higher in transmission than a metal film sputtered in pure argon ; and the sputtering rate is approximately the same . however , the amorphous metal coating sputtered in an oxygen - containing but substantially nonreactive atmosphere is significantly harder and less dense than a crystalline metal film sputtered in pure argon . the relative hardness of such metal films is determined by abrasion of the film followed by visual examination and rating on the basis of film damage . a method of judging the hardness of metal films comprises repeated strokes of an abrasive pad ( scotch - brite ® 98 light duty cleaning pad from 3m ) followed by visual examination on a light board and rating the film damage on a scale of 1 to 9 , with 1 being insignificant damage and 9 being substantial removal of the metal film . the density of amorphous titanium metal film sputtered in an essentially nonreactive atmosphere comprising inert gas and 10 percent oxygen is 4 . 0 grams per cubic centimeter ( g / cm 3 ), compared with a density of 4 . 5 g / cm 3 for a titanium metal film sputtered in pure argon . the lower density of the amorphous titanium metal film enhances its rate of oxidation , so that the amorphous titanium metal film may be thoroughly oxidized at lower temperatures and / or in shorter times than required for oxidation of crystalline titanium metal film . the hard , dense , amorphous metal coating of the present invention , preferably in a thickness range of about 100 to 1500 angstroms , more preferably about 200 to 1000 angstroms for titanium , is sufficiently durable to withstand handling , shipping and processing , such as heat strengthening , tempering and bending . it is preferred to further process the amorphous metal film of the present invention by thermally oxidizing the metal to metal oxide . the hard amorphous metal film of the present invention may be thermally oxidized to metal oxide by heating to produce a haze - free , dense , substantially crystalline metal oxide coating which is sufficiently chemically and physically durable to be coated on the exposed surface of a glass substrate . the amorphous metal film is preferably heated to a temperature of at least 400 ° c ., preferably 500 to 700 ° c ., in air in order to effect complete oxidation in a reasonable time , e . g . a few minutes . the method of the present invention of heating an amorphous sputtered metal film to produce a crystalline metal oxide film is a more efficient method to produce thick metal oxide films than reactively sputtering such films . moreover , the crystalline thermally oxidized metal oxide films are more chemically durable than the substantially amorphous reactively sputtered metal oxide films . such crystalline thermally oxidized metal oxide films may be produced over a wide range of thicknesses having a wide range of desirable reflected colors produced by interference effects . the density of the titanium oxide coatings is determined using the measured thickness of the coating and the weight percent titanium in fully oxidized titanium oxide . the thickness was measured using a tencor p - 1 long scan profiler ; the weight percent titanium was measured using x - ray fluorescence . the density of the crystalline thermally oxidized titanium coating is greater than the density of amorphous reactively sputtered titanium dioxide coating ; the crystalline thermally oxidized titanium oxide coating has a density of 4 . 0 grams per cubic centimeter ( g / cm 3 ) while the amorphous sputtered titanium oxide has a density of 3 . 4 g / cm 3 . the density of crystalline thermally oxidized titanium oxide coatings approaches the bulk density of 4 . 26 g / cm 3 for the rutile phase of tio 2 . the refractive index at 600 nanometers of an amorphous reactively sputtered titanium oxide film is 2 . 3 , whereas the refractive index at 600 nanometers of a crystalline titanium oxide film thermally oxidized from an amorphous titanium metal film sputtered in an essentially nonreactive atmosphere comprising argon and 10 percent oxygen is 2 . 5 , which is nearly the refractive index of the rutile phase of bulk crystalline tio 2 . in a preferred embodiment of the present invention , coatings are produced on a large - scale magnetron sputtering device capable of coating glass up to 100 × 144 inches ( 2 . 54 × 3 . 66 meters ). using a commercial production scale coater , the acceptable amount of reactive gas may be considerably higher without switching from the metal mode compared with a small - scale coater , particularly if multiple cathodes are sputtered simultaneously within a chamber at higher power density . in the following examples , the coatings are deposited on a smaller scale , using planar magnetron cathodes having 5 × 17 inch ( 12 . 7 × 43 . 2 centimeters ) targets . base pressure is in the 10 − 6 torr range . the coatings are made by first admitting the sputtering gas to a pressure of 4 microns and then setting the cathode power . in each example , glass substrates pass under the target on a conveyor roll at a speed of 120 inches ( 3 . 05 meters ) per minute . the transmittance is monitored every other pass during the sputtering process at a wavelength of 550 nanometers using a dyn - optics 580d optical monitor . after the coating is deposited , the transmittance and reflectance from both the glass and coated surfaces are measured in the wavelength range from 380 to 720 nanometers using pacific scientific spectrogard color system spectrophotometer . in a most preferred embodiment of the present invention , the amorphous metal film sputtered in an essentially nonreactive atmosphere comprising sufficient reactive gas to effect the deposition of a harder , less dense , amorphous , rather than crystalline , metal film , but insufficient to effect the transition of the sputtering process from the metallic to the oxide mode , is overcoated with a thin layer of reactively sputtered amorphous metal oxide . this layer of reactively sputtered amorphous metal oxide increases the thermal stability of the amorphous metal film sputtered in an essentially nonreactive atmosphere comprising inert gas and sufficient reactive gas to effect the deposition of an amorphous metal film but insufficient to effect the transition of the sputtering mode from metallic to oxide , during thermal oxidation . the amorphous sputtered metal oxide layer preferably comprises the same metal as the underlying amorphous metal layer . the thickness of the amorphous metal oxide layer is preferably in the range of 40 to 120 angstroms . the thickness of the underlying amorphous metal layer is preferably in the range of 200 to 1000 angstroms prior to thermal oxidation , for production of a wide range of chromas in the metal oxide films . the amount of reactive gas in the essentially nonreactive atmosphere may vary widely depending on the metal to be sputtered , size and geometry of targets , number and power level of cathodes , and so on . the upper limit in any case is below the point at which sputtering switches from the metallic to the oxide mode . for optimum hardness of the amorphous metal film , it is preferred to operate near this upper limit consistent with maintaining sputtering in the metal mode . a range of 2 to 30 percent oxygen , preferably 5 to 25 percent may be preferred when sputtering titanium . the present invention will be further understood from the descriptions of specific examples which follow . a clear glass substrate six millimeters thick was coated with titanium as follows . a titanium cathode target was sputtered in an atmosphere of argon containing 2 . 5 percent oxygen . the base pressure was 2 × 10 − 6 torr , operating pressure 4 . 0 microns . power was set at 3 . 0 kilowatts ( kw ), voltage was 381 volts ( v ), current was 7 . 8 amps and line speed 120 inches ( 3 . 05 meters ), per minute . after 1 pass , the transmittance was 19 . 1 percent , after three passes 2 . 0 percent , and zero after four passes . the resistance of the titanium film was 41 . 9 ohms per square . the coated surface was wiped with an abrasive pad ( scotch - brite from 3m ), and the coated substrate placed on a light board for visual examination . it was rated 7 in transmittance and 5 in reflectance . a glass substrate was coated as in example 1 except that the atmosphere was argon with 5 percent oxygen , the voltage was 385v and the current 7 . 7 amps . the transmittance after one pass was 21 . 0 percent , after three passes 2 . 6 percent , and less than one percent after four passes . the resistance of the titanium film was 48 ohms per square . the coated surface was rated 5 in transmittance and 4 in reflectance after abrasion . a glass substrate was coated as in examples 1 and 2 except that the atmosphere was argon with 10 percent oxygen , the voltage was 393v and the current 7 . 6 amps . the transmittance after one pass was 26 . 4 percent , after three passes 6 . 0 percent , and 2 . 0 percent after four passes . the resistance of the titanium film was 82 ohms per square . the coated surface was rated 2 in both transmittance and reflectance after abrasion . a glass substrate was coated as in the previous examples except that the atmosphere contained 15 percent oxygen , the voltage was 432v and the current 6 . 9 amps . the transmittance after one pass was 57 . 0 percent , after three passes 21 . 0 percent , and 13 . 6 percent after four passes . the resistance of the titanium film was 330 ohms per square . the coated surface was rated 1 in both transmittance and reflectance after abrasion . the increasing transmittance and resistance indicate that the oxygen concentration is approaching the maximum for sputtering in the metal mode , although the film is still metallic , since the resistance is still very low in comparison with the resistance of titanium oxide , which is infinite , i . e . titanium oxide is an insulating material . a glass substrate was coated as in the previous examples except that the atmosphere was pure argon , the voltage was 378v and the current 7 . 85 amps . the transmittance after one pass was 18 . 0 percent , after three passes 1 . 8 percent , and zero after four passes . the resistance of the titanium film was 24 ohms per square . the coated surface was rated 9 in both transmittance and reflectance after abrasion . a tinted glass ( solex ® glass from ppg industries , inc .) substrate 4 . 0 millimeters thick was coated with titanium and titanium dioxide as follows . the first layer of coating is prepared by sputtering a planar titanium cathode in an atmosphere of argon containing 10 percent oxygen . the base pressure was 7 . 0 × 10 − 6 torr , operating pressure 4 . 0 microns , power set at 3 . 4 kilowatts , voltage was 399 volts , current 8 . 42 amps and line speed 120 inches ( 3 . 05 meters ) per minute . after 4 passes , the transmittance was 1 . 4 percent . the titanium layer thickness was 599 angstroms . this layer deposition was followed by reactively sputtering titanium in a 50 / 50 argon / oxygen gas mixture . power was set at 5 . 0 kilowatts , voltage was 470 volts , current 10 . 57 amps and the line speed 120 inches ( 3 . 05 meters ) per minute . after 6 passes , the final transmittance was 2 . 0 percent . the coating thickness for the reactively sputtered titanium oxide layer was 76 angstroms . the two layer coating was then heated for 4 minutes to a temperature of 650 ° c ., producing a single homogeneous layer of titanium oxide coating with thickness of 1062 angstroms . the optical properties of the coated article were analyzed and are shown in the table following the examples . a clear glass substrate 6 . 0 millimeters thick was coated with titanium as follows . a coating was prepared by sputtering a planar titanium cathode in an atmosphere of argon containing 10 percent oxygen . the base pressure was 5 . 9 × 10 − 6 torr , operating pressure 4 . 0 microns , power set at 3 . 4 kilowatts , voltage was 398 volts , current 8 . 45 amps and line speed 120 inches ( 3 . 05 meters ) per minute . after 6 passes the transmittance was zero . the coating thickness was 893 angstroms . the coating was then heated for 6 . 5 minutes to a temperature of 6370c producing an oxide coating with a thickness of 1469 angstroms . the optical properties are shown in the table following the examples . a clear glass substrate 6 . 0 millimeters thick was coated with titanium as follows . a coating was prepared by sputtering a planar titanium cathode in an atmosphere of argon containing 10 percent oxygen . the base pressure was 5 . 0 × 10 − 6 torr , operating pressure 4 . 0 microns , power set at 3 . 4 kilowatts , voltage was 398 volts , current 8 . 45 amps and line speed 120 inches ( 3 . 05 meters ) per minute . after 5 passes the transmittance was 0 . 5 percent . the coating thickness was 742 angstroms . the coating was then heated for 6 . 5 minutes to a temperature of 637 ° c ., producing an oxide coating with a thickness of 1220 angstroms . the optical properties are shown in the table following the examples . a clear glass substrate 6 . 0 millimeters thick was coated with titanium as follows . a coating was prepared by sputtering a planar titanium cathode in an atmosphere of argon containing 10 percent oxygen . the base pressure was 3 . 9 × 10 − 6 torr , operating pressure 4 . 0 microns , power was set at 3 . 4 kilowatts , voltage was 398 volts , current 8 . 45 amps and line speed 120 inches ( 3 . 05 meters ) per minute . after 4 passes the transmittance was 1 . 6 percent . the coating thickness was 599 angstroms . the coating was then heated for 6 . 5 minutes to a temperature of 637 ° c ., producing an oxide coating with a thickness of 986 angstroms . the optical properties are shown in the table following the examples . a clear glass substrate 6 . 0 millimeters thick was coated with titanium as follows . a coating was prepared by sputtering a planar titanium cathode in an atmosphere of argon containing 10 percent oxygen . the base pressure was 5 . 9 × 10 − 6 torr , operating pressure 4 . 0 microns , power was set at 3 . 4 kilowatts , voltage was 398 volts , current 8 . 45 amps and line speed 120 inches ( 3 . 05 meters ) per minute . after 3 passes the transmittance was 3 . 9 percent . the coating thickness was 447 angstroms . the coating was then heated for 6 . 5 minutes to a temperature of 637 ° c ., producing an oxide coating with a thickness of 735 angstroms . the optical properties are shown in the table following the examples . a clear glass substrate 6 . 0 millimeters thick was coated with titanium as follows . a coating was prepared by sputtering a planar titanium cathode in an atmosphere of argon containing 10 percent oxygen . the base pressure was 5 . 2 × 10 − 6 torr , operating pressure 4 . 0 microns , power was set at 3 . 4 kilowatts , voltage was 398 volts , current 8 . 45 amps and line speed 120 inches ( 3 . 05 meters ) per minute . after 2 passes the transmittance was 8 . 9 percent . the coating thickness was 301 angstroms . the coating was then heated for 6 . 5 minutes to a temperature of 637 ° c ., producing an oxide coating with thickness of 495 angstroms . the optical properties are shown in the table following the examples . a tinted glass ( solex ® glass from ppg industries , inc .) substrate 4 . 0 millimeters thick was coated with titanium as follows . a coating was prepared by sputtering a planar titanium cathode in an atmosphere of argon containing 10 percent oxygen . the base pressure was 7 . 0 × 10 − 6 torr , operating pressure 4 . 0 microns , power was set at 3 . 4 kilowatts , voltage was 400 volts , current 8 . 4 amps and line speed 120 inches ( 3 . 05 meters ) per minute . after 4 passes the transmittance was 1 . 5 percent . the coating thickness was 599 angstroms . the coating was then heated for 4 minutes to a temperature of 650c , producing an oxide coating with thickness of 986 angstroms . the optical properties are shown in the table following the examples . table ex - am - reflectance * ple transmittance * film side glass side # y x y y x y y x y 5 74 . 46 . 3102 . 3646 12 . 25 . 3038 . 2152 10 . 34 . 3032 . 2286 6 65 . 71 . 3444 . 3373 30 . 43 . 2418 . 3182 28 . 94 . 2412 . 3209 7 82 . 90 . 3451 . 3792 13 . 23 . 2056 . 1833 12 . 82 . 2074 . 1884 8 79 . 31 . 2968 . 3374 17 . 33 . 3733 . 3072 16 . 37 . 3679 . 3105 9 60 . 37 . 2897 . 3022 36 . 54 . 3574 . 3914 34 . 31 . 3502 . 3922 10 56 . 63 . 3205 . 3374 40 . 09 . 2985 . 3205 37 . 76 . 2940 . 3224 11 72 . 15 . 2925 . 3398 17 . 51 . 3794 . 3165 14 . 73 . 3652 . 3264 the above examples are offered to illustrate the present invention . other metals such as zirconium , tantalum , vanadium , hafnium and niobium may be sputtered in an atmosphere which contains a reactive gas but which remains essentially nonreactive . other reactive gases such as nitrogen may be used instead of or in addition to oxygen . the amount of reactive gas is kept sufficiently low so that the sputtering mode is essentially metallic , and the film deposited is essentially metallic . to optimize the hardness of the metal film , the amount of reactive gas in the inert gas is preferably as high as is consistent with maintaining an essentially nonreactive atmosphere , i . e . sputtering in the metallic mode . when the reactive gas is oxygen , the minimum amount is sufficient to effect deposition of amorphous metal , generally at least about 2 percent , and higher amounts , at least about 10 percent , are preferred in order to thermally oxidize at an efficient rate . thermal oxidation of the metallic film may be performed throughout a range of temperatures sufficient to oxidize the metal without deteriorating the integrity of the film . typically , a temperature of at least 400 ° c . is selected to thoroughly oxidize the metal film in a reasonable time , e . g . a few minutes . film thicknesses may vary over a wide range to obtain desirable properties , particularly interference color effects in reflectance . the scope of the invention is defined by the following claims .