Free for All (TV series)

Free for All is an American animated series created by Brett Merhar for Showtime. The series, set in Colorado, follows the day-to-day life of Johnny Jenkins, an innocent 19-year-old college student who has to deal with a bitter, cigarette smoking grandmother and a coarse, sometimes-violent, alcoholic father, in a rather dysfunctional family while his friend, Clay, is living large with the settlement money he got from suing a taco restaurant for personal injuries.
The show was developed for television by Merriwether Williams, the head writer for the first three seasons of "SpongeBob SquarePants". The show lasted for only seven episodes that aired over the summer of 2003, the last ending on a cliff-hanger. Despite favorable to mixed reviews from critics, the show had very low ratings, due to poor promotion and basing the series on an already-unsuccessful property. Showtime cancelled the animated series shortly after the last episode aired. Though the series is now considered "obscure" and no DVD release has been planned for it, the entire series is legally available on iTunes and Amazon.com.
In America, the series was rated TV-MA for explicit sexual content, including nudity and scenes of sexual intercourse (S), extremely offensive language (L), and adult content (AD on Showtime's content warning screen). In Germany, the series was aired on MTV Germany.
Development.
From underground comic to animated series.
In 1992, "Free For All" began life as an alternative comic strip published in college newspapers. The comic became nationally syndicated shortly afterwards, but eventually ended in 1998. A short pilot for the series - which was never aired on television - was made in 2001. Brett Merhar pitched the show to Showtime in 2001 as an animated series, wanting to do edgier jokes than what he could do in the comic. He brought in a friend of his, Merriwether Williams, who was, at the time, the head writer for Nickelodeon's "SpongeBob SquarePants". She worked on "Free For All" as showrunner and head writer alongside her duties as writer for "SpongeBob SquarePants".
Writers.
The show had three writers: Jeff Poliquin (future writer for Comedy Central's short-lived animated sitcom "Ugly Americans", and former writer for "The Simpsons" video games), Gil Ferro (who also served as the show's editor), and Williams herself; Brett Merhar also co-wrote the first episode, "The Deal", with Williams.
Voice actors.
The show had an all star cast:
Animation.
The show's animation was interesting, as it was a combination of CGI LightWave animation (cars/some buildings/panning backgrounds), and traditional hand drawn animation/backgrounds - drawn in pencil and ink on animation paper, then scanned into a computer and colored with Wacom tablets on ToonBoom Harmony. The show's animation was produced at Film Roman in Los Angeles and outraced to South Korea. Dave Marshall, a former animation director for "Animaniacs", was the series director. William Reiss and C.H. Greenblatt, two "SpongeBob SquarePants" veterans, worked on the show as storyboard artists. The two of them would go on to work on the Disney Channel hit series "Fish Hooks", while C.H. Greenblatt would also go on to create "Chowder" for Cartoon Network, and "Harvey Beaks" for Nickelodeon. Both "Fish Hooks" and "Chowder" would become far more successful and profitable than "Free For All".
Notable distinctions.
The show was also one of the first animated series to be broadcast in high definition. "Free For All" once held the distinction of being the first, and only, animated sitcom to air on Showtime up until the series Our Cartoon President in 2018. It is currently also the only traditionally animated, half-hour sitcom to air on a premium network (HBO has had six different animated shows, though "The Ricky Gervais Show" was not a sitcom, and was animated on Adobe Flash using the puppet tool. "The Life and Times of Tim", while it was a sitcom, was composed of two eleven-minute segments, and was created digitally with Photoshop and After Effects, and "Spawn" and "Spicy City" were, while traditionally animated, serial dramas rather than sitcoms).
After the cancellation.
After the show was cancelled, Brett Merhar went on to create a web series with Gabor Csupo titled "Beverly Hills Anger Management," which premiered on YouTube in 2007. He was beaten to death in July 2016. Williams went on to write for Cartoon Network's "Camp Lazlo" as the head writer, as well as "Johnny Test" (also on Cartoon Network), "" (on The Hub, now Discovery Family), and "Pound Puppies" (also on The Hub/Discovery Family).
Reception.
The show had received very favorable reviews from critics. IGN said:
""The Free for All pilot episode definitely has the feel of a comic strip, with various short storylines in the beginning as we're introduced to each character. But where some animated series adapted from comic strips consist solely of just that – short little stories that have no effect on or relation to anything else in the episode – FfA starts up a couple episode-long storylines and follows through on them. When Angus steals some Vicodin from Clay's medicine cabinet, the ferret needs to be detoxed. And when Johnny is being tormented by his crazy grandmother who wants him out of the house, Clay says he'll take care of Johnny's situation if Johnny detoxes Angus. What follows are some bizarre sequences involving Johnny trying to help the ferret with the aid of The Robert Downey Jr. Guide to Cold Turkey and Johnny's grandma getting busy with Eminem and Dr. Dre. The pop culture references strewn throughout the episode are reminiscent of Family Guy – though not always laugh-out-loud funny, at the very least they make you think, "I can't believe they just showed that. " From old lady nudity to Eminem blissfully cuddling with another man, Free for All goes places you just normally don't see in an animated world. Overall, FfA is off to an enjoyable start; it'll be interesting to see where this bizarre group of characters go from here.""
Entertain Your Brain.com Said:
"The show was both funny and disturbing. I had a real concern that it was going to suck when I began my research on it. The name being touted around in all the promotional material was the show's head writer and executive producer, Merriwether Williams. She has been the head writer for the horrible hit Nickelodeon cartoon "SpongeBob SquarePants" for the last three years. I was hoping I wouldn't see the lame stuff that passes for comedy on that show transferred to Showtime Late Nite. Fortunately, that didn't happen. I wonder if Williams was feeling the same pressure from Nickelodeon that John K. was when he was doing "Ren and Stimpy" for them. Anyway…the show was not lame and quite amusing. Watching the show felt much like reading a comic strip in its style of animation. Grandma was very gross, but still funny to watch. I found out that one of my favorite actors, Jeremy Piven, was originally supposed to be the voice of Clay, and I wonder how different the show would have been if he had done it. Merhar's voice-work of Clay isn't bad. In fact, his low, monotone style seems to fit the character.
""Free for All" is yet another reason to stay home on Friday nights, behind the already entertaining "Monk, "Dead Like Me," and "Spider-Man: The Animated Series." Is cable determined to keep me from having a life? More than the whole non-life thing, I'm ashamed that it took me so long to become aware of this Coloradoan made good. Maybe someday Merhar will achieve the heights of local heroes Trey Parker and Matt Stone. You may have heard of them…they created a little animated series for cable called "South Park?
and Variety stated:
"With a plot that involves detoxing the ferret, flying to Las Vegas for a Tom Jones concert and meeting Eminem and Grandma's seduction of Clay that involves a blend of "Basic Instinct" and "The Graduate," "Free for All" flashes moments of cleverness. Creator Merhar and Merriwether Williams (head writer of "SpongeBob SquarePants") have the characters. They just need to make their lives a bit more messy.""