The Lord of the Rings Online

The Lord of the Rings Online (previously titled The Lord of the Rings Online: Shadows of Angmar) is a massively multiplayer online role-playing game (MMORPG) for Microsoft Windows and OS X set in J. R. R. Tolkien's Middle-earth, taking place during the time period of "The Lord of the Rings". Developed by Turbine, Inc., the game launched in North America, Australia, Japan, and Europe in April 2007 as "The Lord of the Rings Online: Shadows of Angmar". Players could create characters of four races and seven classes and adventure throughout the region of Eriador. In November 2008, ' expansion was released, adding the region of Moria and two new playable classes. It was followed by the ' in December 2009. In 2010 the game underwent a shift from its original subscription-based payment model to being free-to-play, with a paid subscription and an in-game store.
The game saw continued development, alternating between paid expansions and free updates, which added new content in the regions of , and Gondor. In late 2016 it was announced that the publishing of the game would transfer from Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment to Daybreak Game Company, with development being taken over by Standing Stone Games, made up of former Turbine staff. The game development continued and in 2017 the ' expansion was released, bringing the main storyline to a close. The story then shifted to showing how various inhabitants of Middle-earth deal with the downfall of Sauron, with ' expansion released in 2019 and a Gundabad-themed expansion announced for 2021.
Gameplay.
Much of the gameplay is typical of the massive multiplayer online role playing game (MMORPG) format: the player controls a character avatar which can be moved around the game world and interacts with other players, non-player characters and other entities in the virtual world. Characters gain levels by earning experience points from defeating enemies and completing quests and improve their personal stats by equipping items and using consumable buffs. As characters increase in level, they earn both new skills and trait points, which can be assigned in various configurations to customize personal playstyle. Players can use the quest tracker to navigate objectives on the mini-map and traverse the game world either on foot or using personal mounts, which include horses, ponies, goats and elks. Instantaneous travel is also available by using in-game "stable-masters" and certain "quick travel" skills. In addition to the detailed Quest log, player characters also have a Deed log, which tracks their progress across a vast number of achievements, ranging from frivolous to being vital for character progression.
As opposed to other role-playing video games, the equivalent of health or hit points in "The Lord of the Rings Online" is morale, which can be raised via food, rest, music, and battle cries, and characters whose morale reaches zero in combat are considered "defeated" instead of killed. The equivalent of mana is called "power" because of the way magic in Tolkien's Middle-earth differs from other fantasy games such as "World of Warcraft", except for the Beorning class, which uses "wrath" instead. Player characters can own a personal house, which can be decorated and provide additional storage. The crafting system allows each character to master up to three professions, which are separated into "gathering" of materials and actual "crafting" of usable items. In consistency with the characterization of Hobbits in Tolkien's writings, a fair emphasis is placed on cooking and farming. Players can also customize the look of their characters by using the Cosmetic system, which can display armor and weapons other than those worn for combat effectiveness. In addition to character name, players can also choose their current PvMP rank and a title to be displayed.
"" added the concept of Legendary items, which gain experience points and levels alongside the player character, allowing them to increase in power over time. Each character can equip two class-specific legendary items (one of which is always the main weapon), which contain Legacies that provide modifiers to class-specific abilities. Alongside regular experience points, players gain Legendary Item experience, which can be applied to different Legendary items to increase their levels. Each item level in turn comes with a set amount of Legendary points, which can be assigned to specific Legacies to increase their potency. Players can further customize their Legendary items by naming them, giving them titles and slotting additional gems and runes. Characters can begin using Legendary items at level 50, but they have to be periodically replaced to make up for the difference in stats until level 100, when Legendary items can be "imbued". Imbued Legendary Items can stay relevant despite the increase in character level, but require the player to apply various crystals, scrolls and runes to remain so.
"" introduced the mounted combat to the game. While regular character mounts only provide a speed boost and a minimal protection against the attacks, the new rohirric war-steeds allow players to execute special "mounted" skills and attacks while on horseback. War-steeds have many of the same stats as player characters, including morale and power, and can be customized by selecting different types of war-steeds, investing in different trait lines and switching between different mounted stances. Players can also invest in a Legendary bridle item and customize the look of their war-steeds by mix-and-matching various appearance traits.
"Gondor" Introduced the essence gear that the players could customize their armour as they please, featured dungeons that reintroduced scaled old dungeons and newer ones that were changing each week and also roving threats around the world of middle earth that consisted of world bosses in many areas.
Character classes and races.
"Lord of the Rings Online" launched with four playable races: Dwarves, Elves, Hobbits and Men. In 2014 a new race of Beornings was added, although this race is only for the new class of the same name. ' expansion in 2017 added the new High Elf race. In 2019 a new race of "Stout-Axe Dwarves" was added, representing a dwarven clan from the far east of Middle-Earth with an appearance distinct from that of Longbeard dwarves. Released as part of ' expansion, Stout-Axes dwarves also allow players to choose either male or female sex for their character as with all other races, while the original Dwarven race only allows to create male characters. After selecting a character race, players are limited in choosing a character class based on that race, with the most radical exception being the Beorning race, which only allows the Beorning class.
The original seven character classes in the game are Burglar, Captain, Champion, Guardian, Hunter, Lore-master and Minstrel. "" added the Rune-Keeper and Warden classes, while a tenth Beorning class was added in a regular update on November 2014. These three additional classes have to be unlocked by both free-to-play players and subscribers either through the in-game Store or by purchasing the "Mines of Moria" expansion. A character of each class can further specialize in one of the three trait lines that further determine their skills and combat role. While players can switch between different trait lines at will, each requires a specific set of gear and Legendary Items to complement and fully utilize it. In addition to Class traits, Racial and Virtue traits can also be earned and upgraded by completing specific quests and deeds.
Game economy.
An in-game currency of gold, silver and copper coins allows player characters to accumulate wealth by completing quests and selling obtained loot and crafted items to NPCs or other players. Currency can also be used to acquire equipment from NPCs or players, pay to repair equipment after combat, fast travel, buy crafting materials, and purchase a house. Players can trade face-to-face, via in-game mail, or at in-game Auction Houses. LOTRO points (formerly "Turbine points") are used in the in-game store and can be both purchased with real money or earned in-game. LOTRO points can be spend on content unlocks, character boosts and convenience upgrades as well as "Mithril Coins", a meta-currency for various game-related purchases. The game also features a wide variety of barter currencies for specific regions, group instances and seasonal festivals, which are either placed in character bags or a Store-purchased "Barter wallet".
On reaching Level 15, players can purchase a house in an instanced neighborhood, which is shared between all of their characters on the same game server. Houses come in different sizes and include chests for additional storage, but require a weekly maintenance rent using in-game currency and can be locked on failure to pay upkeep. Players can decorate their houses by placing decorations and furniture obtained as rewards for various in-game activities, such as quests, deeds or seasonal festivals. Originally four themed neighborhoods were available based on the four playable races: Dwarves, Elves, Men and Hobbits. With the release of the first region in Gondor, Premium Housing became available in the Cape of Belfalas area, with upkeep required in Mithril Coins instead of gold. Additional Premium Housing areas in Rohan are slated for release in 2020.
Deeds and reputation.
Deeds are a means of tracking accomplishments for each character that are not part of any quest. Most common are regional deeds, found in all of the game's landscape regions, including Explorer, Slayer, Lore and Reputation deeds. Deeds are generally discovered upon completion of one of the goals of the deed (e.g., finding the first area of an Explorer deed or killing the first enemy of a Slayer deed), although some deeds are hidden and do not show up until all required objectives have been completed. Other deeds include those tied to individual character's class or race, while Epic story deeds are advanced by completing quests in the Epic Quest line. Additional deeds are also found in conjunction with the Skirmish and Instance features. A final Deed category is the Hobby, related to fishing, which currently is the only in-game Hobby. In addition, there are 'Meta' Deeds that require completion of several other deeds, usually all of the deeds in a region or in an Instance Cluster. Deed completion is generally rewarded by statistic boosts, often LOTRO points, and sometimes cosmetic/non-combat awards such as titles or emotes.
Reputation is the measure of how well acquainted a player is with a specific group or faction. Each region in "The Lord of the Rings Online" features one or several factions, reputation for which may be gained by completing quests, deeds, defeating specific monsters and using Reputation items. Reputation factions in the original game and in the "Mines of Moria" favored advancement by collecting and using Reputation items, while those from "Siege of Mirkwood" onward lean towards repeatable quests that provide a set amount of Reputation each day instead. Each Reputation faction includes vendors with a set of specific rewards unlocked at various tiers, ranging from cosmetic pets and outfits to top-tier weapons and armour. Crafting Guilds are special Reputation factions for the crafting skills that provide access to exclusive crafting recipes, and each character can join up to two Crafting Guilds at a time.
Fellowship and group instances.
A fellowship is a band of up to six characters, created to complete quests and group instances, which can be formed and disbanded by the leader at any time. All players in a fellowship can communicate with each other in the fellowship chat panel, where a conversation is seen by all fellowship members. The fellowship leader also has the ability to invite or dismiss a member at any time. Members in a fellowship will also appear to each other on the regional maps, which enables them to easily find one another in the game world. A fellowship can also be transformed into a Raid, which can be composed of up to four separate fellowships and can contain anywhere from 6 to 24 players.
Fellowships (including those found in raids) can use the Fellowship Maneuver system to perform special group moves. Fellowship Maneuvers occur randomly and require that the target be stunned or knocked down in any group encounter with a "signature" or higher difficulty enemy. Certain classes also have special skills that can initiate Fellowship Maneuvers when triggered. When a Fellowship Maneuver is initiated, every player within the area will get a color wheel on their screen to choose one of four skill contributions, with different combinations resulting in different powerful attacks.
Fellowships are required to complete many of the group instances, which come in several different variations. A typical "instance" alternates between groups of strong enemies and boss encounters which often features unique game mechanics and provide a chest of rewards upon defeat. "Raids" are similar to instances, but feature "raid locks" which prevent characters from killing each boss more than once a week, but also allow to track progress of a difficult raid across multiple game sessions. "Skirmishes" were introduced with the ' expansions and feature both enemy groups of random composition and randomized "Skirmish Lieutenant" encounters across the instance. "Epic Battles" were introduced with the ' expansion and represent large-scale battles, in which numerous friendly NPCs engage the enemy alongside the player characters, whose focus lies on supporting their allies and completing specific objectives during the battle as opposed to simply defeating all of the enemies. While some group instances are fixed in both their size and intended level, others can be played on different group sizes, levels and tiers of difficulty for progressively higher rewards.
Monster Players in the game can also join Fellowships, though they are named Warbands instead. Monster characters (see below) in a PvP zone also gain access to the Fellowship Manoeuvers panel, which are renamed to Warband Maneuvers.
World regions.
The game's environment is J. R. R. Tolkien's Middle-earth, based on "The Lord of the Rings" and "The Hobbit". It has been noted that the game's license does not cover rights to any other works in Tolkien's legendarium, such as "The Silmarillion". The game world is broadly divided into larger sections of Eriador, Rhovanion, Gondor and Mordor. It is then divided into separate "Regions", which are then further further sub-divided into "Areas". In the original game regions the area division served mostly navigational purpose, but from Enedwaith onwards each area usually has a distinctive landscape aesthetic and its own separate storyline. The game's distinction of regions does not always match that of Tolkien's original definitions: for example, Northfarthing of the Shire is considered to be part of Evendim region, Rohan is considered to be part of Rhovanion and Kingdom of Gondor is split into several smaller regions.
Each region in the game contains non-player characters (NPCs) and quests within an established player character level range, with the main Epic storyline usually serving as a guide between the region's areas in progression from lowest to highest level. Each region also has a capital settlement, but only a few regions feature a proper "hub" for player activities, which is commonly defined as an area which includes all major in-game services for player characters, such as vault-keepers, auction houses and crafting halls. It is important to note that each Region is considered to be permanently set in a specific point in time during the War of the Ring despite the passage of time in the main story: this means that many characters such as Gandalf or Aragorn can be present in multiple places at once if those places are set during different portions of the story. Several major locations are even permanently available in more than one state: for example players can freely move from Isengard flooded by the Ents to Isengard at the height of Saruman's power and from Minas Tirith rebuilding after the battle of the Pelennor Fields to Minas Tirith before the battle, with the enemy still at the doorstep.
Player vs Monster Player.
Classic Player vs. Player (PvP) combat, found in many other MMOs, does not exist in "The Lord of the Rings Online". Free People characters can only "spar" each other on request and for no rewards. Instead, Player vs Monster Player (also known as PvMP or Monster Play) system allows players to create "Monster player" characters and engage Free People in combat in special secluded areas.
Monster player classes are Orc Reaver, Orc Defiler, Spider Weaver, Uruk Blackarrow, Uruk Warleader and Warg Stalker. Monster player characters are always of current maximum level and advance by gaining Infamy Ranks instead. Infamy is awarded for killing Free People characters, and higher ranks give access to better equipment and stat ratings. Monster players can equip no items, but can use consumable buffs and can be customized with specific appearance traits, purchased with Commendations given for quest completion or enemy kills. The quests, deeds and titles are similar to those of the regular characters, but Monster players are unable to leave the confines of the PvMP area and interact with Free People characters who do not wish to be a part of it. Originally, the only PvMP area was the Ettenmoors, where Free Players could travel and battle Monster players for control over the five keeps and minor outposts. In July 2015, a second PvMP area was added in the ruins of Osgiliath.
Plot.
Each game region contains from several dozens to over a hundred "Regional" quests which can be standalone missions or part of complete storyline with a clear culminating point, which often runs parallel to the Epic Story. The main storyline (also known as the "Epic Quest Line") is presented as a series of "Books", which consist of series of quests called "Chapters". Initially eight Books were available at the game's release, with a new book added with each content update. After the game's transion to free-to-play new Books stopped being strictly tied to updates, with some major updates containing no new Books while others adding several Books at once instead.
Volume I: Shadows of Angmar.
The original Epic Story focused mostly on events that were new additions to the "Lord of the Rings" story by the creators of the game. Starting shortly after Frodo and his company had left the Shire, the player character makes it to Bree, where they become acquainted to Aragorn and Gandalf and become involved in the larger affairs of Middle-Earth. After initially following in the footsteps of Aragorn and the Hobbits to Weathertop and the Trollshaws where they track the single Black Rider that was not swept away at the Ford of Bruinen, the player character soon gets involved into a campaign against resurgent Angmar, eventually stopping the plans of several powerful servants of The Witch King across Eriador.
Volume II: Mines of Moria.
Under orders of King Dain Ironfoot, a company of dwarves from Erebor known as the Iron Garrison is sent to investigate and potentially reclaim Moria. By sheer luck, they arrive mere days after Gandalf had fought and defeated Durin's Bane, throwing the denizens of Moria into disarray. Using the power vacuum in the wake of the Balrog's demise, the dwarves quickly claim major ground and establish several footholds within Khazad-dûm, but soon begin to face ever greater peril as the forces of evil in Moria begin to unite under new leadership. Making an alliance with the Elves of Lothlorien the dwarves attempt to hold their ground when a personal emissary of Sauron himself arrives from Dol Guldur to put an end to their expedition. This story concludes in the "" expansion where the Galadhrim launch a major assault against Dol Guldur in an effort to draw the Eye of the enemy away from the Fellowship as it departs from Lorien.
Volume III: Allies of the King.
Lady Galadriel tasks the player with leading the Rangers of the North to the aid of Aragorn in the south and the player travels across Eriador to assemble the Grey Company from their Ranger friends with whom they had become well-acquainted during the Angmar campaign. Led by Halbarad and the Sons of Elrond, the Grey Company rides south but encounters several perils, first losing several Rangers in Enedwaith and then suffering another major loss due to a betrayal in Dunland. Saruman's forces block the Company's passage across the Fords of Isen and as the Rangers recuperate, Lady Galadriel summons the player back to Lorien and tells them to follow the Fellowship down the river Anduin. Accompanied by a girl from Dunland, an elf from Lorien and a man from Rohan, the player follows the Fellowship to the Falls of Rauros, after which they follow the Three Hunters into the land of Rohan where they become closely familiar with many of the local rulers. Eventually the player fights in the battle of Helm's Deep, after which they accompany King Théoden to confront Saruman at Orthanc where the Rangers of the North finally meet with Aragorn.
Volume IV: The Strength of Sauron.
After the Grey Company follows into the Paths of the Dead, the player follows them and arrived into Gondor, which is now besieged by the Corsairs of Umbar. After making a stop at Dol Amroth, the player catches up with Aragorn's forces and takes part in the Battle of Pelargir, after which Aragorn bids them to find and inform either Faramir or Gandalf in Minas Tirith while his men will sail up Anduin in the Corsair ships. Unable to pass through the enemy blockade at Harlond, the player takes a detour through Ithilien and eventually reaches the besieged Osgiliath, narrowly escaping with the remaining Rangers of Ithilien and reaching the White City just as Faramir is shot by a Morgul dart and rendered unconscious. The player assists Gandalf in preparing the city for a siege and just before the city gates are shut is send by the wizard to find King Théoden's forces. The player reunites with their friends from Rohan in the Drúedain forest and fights in the battle of the Pelennor Fields. The player then joins the assembled Host of the West that marches through North Ithilien into Dagorlad and fights at the Battle of the Black Gates from where they see the One Ring destroyed and the forces of Sauron finally defeated.
The Black Book of Mordor: Where the Shadows Lie.
As Aragorn is crowned the King of Gondor, the Free Peoples of Middle-Earth begin to explore the lands of Mordor which were closed to them for over a thousand years. Assisting Gandalf, the player learns of the Gúrzyul – powerful servants of the Enemy which unlike the Nazgûl did not perish with him and continue to pose a danger to the people of Middle-Earth. One of the Gúrzyul known as Karazgar the Weeping Warrior has been suspiciously absent from the power struggle in Mordor, having escaped into the northern lands. The player character and Gandalf give chase after him, through the ruins of Dol Guldur into the halls of King Thranduil, eventually leading to the Kingdom Under the Mountain, now rules by Dain's son Thorin III. While running an errand for Thorin III in the Iron Hills, the player comes upon an artifact from Mordor – a Black Book which they deliver to Gandalf for safekeeping. Karazgar's forces assault Erebor but are repelled and a company of dwarves departs to reclaim their ancient strongholds in Ered Mithrin, believing them to be safe after the defeat of Sauron. They battle against Karazgar until Gandalf reveals his weakness and learns that Karazgar desires the very book that he carries. Gandalf departs to the lands of Beornings in the Vales of Anduin, where he and the player meet with the entourage of Lord Elrond who accompany Lady Arwen to her wedding in Minas Tirith.
Development and release history.
Sierra On-Line first announced the development of a licensed Middle-earth MMORPG in 1998. Sierra had financial troubles in 1999 and replaced the staff working on the game. Sierra continued to confirm development of the MMORPG but did not release any development details. Vivendi Universal Games, the parent company of Sierra, secured eight-year rights to produce computer and video games based on "The Lord of the Rings" books in 2001. Vivendi announced an agreement with Turbine in 2003 to produce "Middle-earth Online" (at that time expected to be released in 2004). In March 2005, Turbine announced that it had bought the rights to make an MMORPG based on Tolkien's literature and that Turbine would publish "The Lord of the Rings Online" instead of Vivendi. A closed beta was announced on September 8, 2006. An open beta began on March 30, 2007, and was open to all who pre-ordered the game's Founders Club edition. On April 6, 2007, the beta opened to the public.
In April 2007, Salon.com reported that the game had dropped a planned feature for in-game players marriage because of the controversy around the possibility of same-sex and inter-species weddings. One developer stated that the design rule was for weddings to be allowed if examples could be found in the book, as between elves and humans. The online magazine for gay gamers, GayGamer.net commented that, while Tolkien was a devout Christian, his stance on gay rights isn't known as the topic wasn't a public issue at the time. Video game critic Ian Bogost compared it to the case of "The Sims" 2, which did allow same-sex marriage three years prior.
The game was developed and maintained by Turbine after Jeffrey Anderson secured the rights from Vivendi. In January 2014 it was announced that the license for "The Lord of the Rings Online" had been renewed to 2017. Executive producer Aaron Campbell transferred to other duties in 2015, and "Dungeons and Dragons Online" franchise director Athena Peters replaced him. Peters announced a new roadmap for the future of "Lord of the Rings Online", including improvements to the legendary item system, new fellowship quests, and various "quality of life" fixes. Also on the agenda for the summer of 2015 were server merges and new datacenters. On December 19, 2016, it was announced that Turbine would no longer develop the game, rather a new independent game studio was formed under the name Standing Stone Games, the staff of whom would made up of the people that have been working on "The Lord of the Rings Online" and "Dungeons & Dragons Online" under Turbine before. The publishing of the game would transfer from Warner Brothers to Daybreak Game Company. While a reason was not given for the transition, it was assured that the game would continue with new development.
Releases and subscription model.
In North America, players who pre-ordered the game were offered a special founder's offer, a lifetime subscription for $199 or reduced cost of $9.99 per month. Standard monthly fee is $14.99 with three, six, twelve month, and lifetime discounts available. European players had a similar program from Codemasters. A holiday subscription was available in December 2007 and January 2008 for $9.99/month for a 3-month commitment. A special edition, which cost $10 more than the regular edition, included a full-color manual, an item called "Glass of Aglaral," a cloak of regeneration, which is visually different from the one in the regular edition, a "Making of" DVD, soundtrack, and a 10-day buddy key. The one year anniversary edition included a $9.99/month subscription or a $199.99 Lifetime subscription, which was again offered during the lead-up to the release of Mines of Moria. However the lifetime subscription option is no longer available and is unlikely to return.
On June 4, 2010, it was announced the game was to add a free-to-play option in the autumn, with an in-game store. Free-to-play was successfully launched in North America on September 10, 2010. After a delay in Europe, free-to-play went live on November 2, 2010. During the following six months the company reported tripled revenues from the title. On April 26, 2011, it was announced that Codemasters would relinquish control of the European service back to Turbine, and on June 1, the servers were transferred. After a transition period of a few days, they reopened under a unified "Lord of the Rings Online" global service. Finally, on June 6, 2012, "The Lord of the Rings Online" was made available for download on Steam. On November 1, 2012, a beta of the OS X version was released and a 64-bit client was added in June 2019.
Soundtrack.
The game features a variety of original music, with most regions and instances containing a selection of specific themes, most of which was composed by either acclaimed video game composer Chance Thomas or in-house composers including Stephen Digregorio, Geoff Scott, Brad Spears, Egan Budd, Matt Harwood and Bill Champagne. According to Thomas, all references that were made to the music of the peoples of Middle-earth in the books were used to extrapolate as much information as possible about the instruments and styles that each race would have used to create their music. This information was then used as the base for creating the score. In the first two years of the game Thomas and DiGregorio each contributed roughly half of all music, which was released as soundtrack CD available with the Special Edition of 2007 "Shadows of Angmar" or pre-order of 2008 "" expansion, in addition to 61 songs that were made available for free in mp3 format using a download manager released by Turbine. Their collaboration continued on the "Mines of Moria" soundtrack, released as a CD with the Collector's Edition of the expansion.
Neither ' nor ' expansions received a dedicated soundtrack release, with no music added to the game between 2009 and 2012 made officially available until the ' expansion, for which Chance Thomas returned to work on LOTRO after years of absence, releasing a soundtrack available both on CD and as digital download. Music for the next year's ' expansion was entirely composed by Stephen DiGregorio and was released as an album on SoundCloud while music added between 2013 and 2017 was likewise not covered by any official releases. In 2017 Chance Thomas returned once more to contribute music to the game, releasing a soundtrack album for "" expansion in addition to a commemorative 10th Anniversary Soundtrack which covered a collection of his work for the game from all previous soundtracks. After Mordor all music so far has been composed by Bill Champagne, with full soundtracks for free updates and expansions alike released on the game's YouTube channel. Soundtrack for "Lord of the Rings Online" has received much praise for its quality and variety.
In keeping with Tolkien's heavy use of song and music in his books, "Lord of the Rings Online" has a player music sub-system akin to MIDI that has been the subject of a Harvard anthropological study. Characters on reaching level 5 can learn to play musical instruments, including Bagpipes, Clarinet, Cowbell, Drum, Harp, Horn, Lute, Pibgorn, and Theorbo. Using keyboard macros, instruments can be played in real time on three octaves and abc notation, with the music broadcast to nearby player characters. Players can also play pre-programmed pieces from user-created ".ABC" script files using the game's music notation, similar to MIDI files. Players often hold impromptu public performances, in solo or as bands at places such as The Prancing Pony Inn in Bree. Communities also regularly organize music events and mini-concerts such as "Weatherstock": Woodstock above the Weathertop.
Reception.
"The Lord of the Rings Online" received wide acclaim.
GameDaily awarded the game 9/10, praising its rich, fantasy-themed universe, well-integrated trait and title system, and a story that remains true to the works of Tolkien. Yahoo! Video Games wrote a review with few negative mentions, awarding the game a score of 4/5, while "Computer and Video Games" called the game an essential purchase for "Lord of the Rings" fans, scoring the game a 9.2/10. Eurogamer scored the game a 9.0/10, calling it tough to resist. GameSpy gave it 4.5/5 stars, claiming the game "opened up Middle-Earth to the masses" but commented negatively on its weak PvP content, while GameTrailers awarded it 8.5/10, citing its interesting tweaks to the MMO genre. IGN ranked it a similar 8.6/10, praising it for its solid experience, though criticizing it for its lack of major improvements to the genre. "The New York Times" called the game "a major achievement of interactive storytelling, the first game truly worthy of the ‘"Lord of the Rings"' franchise and a must-play for just about anyone with an interest in Tolkien or the future of online entertainment." In a GameSpot review, the product was awarded an 8.3/10, praising its appealing polish and intriguing Monster Play feature. "GamePro"'s review gave it an overall 4.25/5, pointing out how engaging the epic quests are, as well as how faithful to the novels the game managed to stay.
GameSpy declared "The Lord of the Rings Online" 'Game of the Month' for May 2007. Midway announced that the game sold over 172,000 copies in North America during its second quarter.
In August 2007, Codemasters announced that "The Lord of the Rings Online" had received five Golden Joystick Awards nominations for the five applicable categories for the game, and in October 2007 that it had won the "PC Game of the Year" at these awards. It won the same award again on October 2008.
In 2007, GameSpy awarded "The Lord of the Rings Online" 6th place in the top ten PC games of the year. Turbine also won the GameSpy MMO of the Year award.
In 2010, RPGFan's Adam Tingle named "The Lord of the Rings Online" the best MMORPG of all time in a top-10 countdown while RPGLand gave its "Best Free-to-Play MMORPG" annual award. That year, the NPD Group reported that the game was "the third most played massively multiplayer role-playing game" with Turbine citing their free-to-play model as the reason for the growing subscriber base.
In January 2011, "PC Gamer" chose "The Lord of the Rings Online" as the MMO of the year. Praise was given for treating fans to two new Epic Books worth of quests, two added regions, expansion of in-game events, improved UI elements, and the revamp of the character creation and starter regions. Also noted was the success of the move to free-to-play, stating "Lord of the Rings Online" is "quickly redefining the way a successful subscriptionless MMO is run."
In both 2018 and 2019, gaming blog Massively (formerly known as Joystiq) rated "The Lord of the Rings Online" as Most Underrated MMORPG of the year for its expansions and updates, vast, diverse world, some excellent storytelling, and a friendly and dedicated community.