Campylocephalus

Campylocephalus is a genus of eurypterid, a group of extinct aquatic arthropods. Fossils of "Campylocephalus" have been discovered in deposits ranging from the Carboniferous period in the Czech Republic (the species "C. salmi") to the Permian period of Russia (species "C. oculatus" and "C. permianus"). The generic name is composed of the Greek words καμπύλος ("kampýlos"), meaning "curved", and κεφαλή ("kephalē"), meaning "head".
It was a member of the hibbertopterid family of eurypterids and probably looked much the same as the other members of the family, "Hibbertopterus" and "Vernonopterus", in that it was a large, broad and heavy animal quite different from the famous swimming eurypterids (such as "Pterygotus" and "Eurypterus") which had been common during earlier periods. Like all other stylonurine eurypterids, "Campylocephalus" completely lacked swimming paddles.
Hibbertopterids such as "Campylocephalus" were, as many other families within the stylonurine suborder, sweep-feeders. Sweep-feeding food strategies involve specialized appendages with blades that could be used by the animals to rake through the substrate of their living environments in search for small prey items.
The species "C. permianus", known from deposits of Late Permian age in Russia, is the only species of "Campylocephalus" preserved well enough to allow for size estimates, published estimates putting its size at potentially 1.4 metres (4.6 feet) in length. This species was the last known surviving eurypterid, living just before or during the Permian–Triassic extinction event 251.9 million years ago. Before the extinction event, eurypterids had been declining in numbers and diversity for millions of years; "Campylocephalus" had been the only known genus of living eurypterids for more than 20 million years since the extinction of the related genus "Hastimima".
Description.
Classified as a member of the hibbertopterid family of eurypterids, "Campylocephalus" was overall similar to the other members of the family. It was a large, broad and heavy creature quite unlike most earlier and more famous swimming eurypterids such as "Pterygotus" and "Eurypterus". As a member of the stylonurine suborder, "Campylocephalus" completely lacked swimming paddles.
Several distinguishing features separate "Campylocephalus" from other genera in its family, in particular from the closely related "Hibbertopterus". "Campylocephalus" had a subelliptical (almost elliptical) prosoma (head), which was subsemicircular (almost shaped like a semicircle) and strongly convex, being at its broadest in the midsection. The compound eyes of "Campylocephalus" were laterally placed (on the sides of the head) and were separated from each other by inflated lobes in the middle. Behind the eyes on the carapace (the exoskeleton segment covering the head) there were some further lobe-like structures referred to as palpebral lobes.
As with the prosoma, the tergites (segments on the upper side of the body) of the abdomen were convex in shape, and possessed articular processes (projecting structures that helped the segments to fit together). The appendages (limbs) of "Campylocephalus" are only very rarely preserved and are as such almost completely unknown.
Due to just how incomplete the fossil remains referred to "Campylocephalus" are, determining its size is difficult and as of yet, no formal published size estimates exist for either the type species "C. oculatus" or the species "C. salmi". The sole known fossil remains of "C. permianus", a massive incomplete carapace, suggests a very large eurypterid, potentially reaching lengths of 1.4 metres (4.6 feet).
In "C. oculatus", the eyes were semilunar in shape (almost moon-shaped) and placed near the middle of the carapace, with small ocelli (light-sensitive simple eyes) between them. Its carapace had small irregular prominences, a rounded anterior edge and an indented posterior edge. The thoracic segments (segments of the thorax) of the species were straight and narrow. The eyes of "C. salmi" were similar, being placed very close together. The eyes were also a distinguishing feature in "C. permianus", where they were placed more posteriorly than in the other species.
History of research.
Fossils today recognized as belonging to "Campylocephalus" were first described in 1838 as belonging to a species of the genus "Limulus", the same genus as the modern atlantic horseshoe crab, by Russian paleontologist Stepan S. Kutorga. Citing similarities with members of the modern genus in the appearance and anatomy of the somewhat incomplete fossil, Kutorga named it "Limulus oculatus".
Scottish naturalist John Scouler described the genus "Eidothea" in 1831 based on a single fossil prosoma from Scotland, but did grant it any specific name. Creating a genus with no species goes against orthodox zoological nomenclature, specifically conflicting for instance with Opinion 65 of the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature;
Any taxonomical difficulties implied with Scouler's designation were easily avoided, however, by the discovery that the genus name was preoccupied by a genus of molluscs described in 1826. Nevertheless, the name "Eidothea" would be associated with the Scottish eurypterid species "Eurypterus scouleri", with a near identical prosoma, described in 1836.
In 1860 French paleontologist Edouard D'Eichwald recognized that the carapace and thoracic segments which had been described by Kutorga were quite distinct from "Limulus", and thus a new genus was named to contain "Limulus oculatus", dubbed by D'Eichwald as "Campylocephalus". This generic name is composed of the Greek words καμπύλος ("kampýlos"), meaning "curved", and κεφαλή ("kephalē"), meaning "head".
The second species of "Campylocephalus" to be described, "C. salmi", was named as a species of the quite distantly related "Eurypterus" by the Slovak geologist and paleontologist Dionýs Štúr in 1877. Štúr's description was based on two incomplete fossil carapaces. The first fragmentary carapace only preserved the lower part of the head, ending in two pointed and concave arches. The eyes of this carapace were close together, in the middle of the carapace, and on a triangularly shaped elevated portion similar to some specimens of the related "Hibbertopterus scouleri". In the second carapace specimen, the carapace began to stretch forward above the eyes. Both of these fossils also possessed protuberances of different sizes across the exoskeleton, showing vague forms and shapes not seen in other specimens of the genus.
Fossils of "Eurypterus scouleri" were compared to the carapace described by Kutorga in 1838 by Norwegian paleontologist Leif Størmer in 1951, who concluded that the two were clearly congeneric. At this point, D'Eichwald had already recognized the fossils designated as "Eidothea" by Scouler as representatives of "Campylocephalus". As such, "E. scouleri" was classified as "Campylocephalus scouleri". Though the legs of "Campylocephalus" were still unknown at the time, even with the addition of the Scottish species, any grouping with other genera would have to be made using features of the carapace. Comparing the ornamentation of the carapace to other eurypterids, Størmer found it to be similar to the genus "Tarsopterella" (where the legs were also more or less unknown) which allowed "Campylocephalus" to be firmly placed within the family Stylonuridae (which would later be raised to become the suborder Stylonurina, not to be confused with the presently recognized eurypterid family Stylonuridae).
English paleontologist Charles D. Waterston was the first to suggest that "C. scouleri" perhaps shouldn't be considered as congeneric with "Campylocephalus", raising the issue in a 1958 paper. He posited that though the dorsal anatomy of the prosoma was quite similar between "C. scouleri" and "C. oculatus", the designated type species, multiple well-preserved fossils had allowed for detailed research into the ventral anatomy and appendages of "C. scouleri" since the two had been placed in the same genus, whilst the ventral anatomy and appendages of "C. oculatus" remained unknown. A year later, in 1959, American paleontologist Erik Norman Kjellesvig-Waering created the new genus "Hibbertopterus" to contain "C. scouleri" (now "Hibbertopterus scouleri") and placed both genera within the family Hibbertopteridae.
Described by Russian paleontologist Alexey G. Ponomarenko in 1985, "C. permianus" was originally named as a species of "Hibbertopterus". The only known specimen of this species is the holotype, PIN N1209/2, an incomplete carapace, but Ponomarenko could list several features that distinguished it from other species referred to "Hibbertopterus". Among these were most prominently the posterior position of the lateral eyes and said eyes not being circular in shape. In 2012, American paleontologist James C. Lamsdell could demonstrate that these unique features were actually diagnostic features of the genus "Campylocephalus" and thus reclassified it as its current combination. Though Ponomarenko had mentioned several features that also distinguished "C. permianus" from the then currently recognized species of "Campylocephalus", including a different carapace shape and some thickening of the exoskeleton around the eyes, Lamsdell determined that these distinctions were not valid. In the view of Lamsdell, specimens of the type species "C. oculatus" are not well preserved enough to determine the precise structure of the eyes and because fossils of its carapace are either flattened or incomplete, its shape can not be ascertained with complete accuracy.
Classification.
"Campylocephalus" is classified as part of the family Hibbertopteridae, a family of eurypterids within the superfamily Mycteropoidea, alongside the genera "Hibbertopterus" and "Vernonopterus". The genus contains three species; "C. oculatus" and "C. permianus" from the Permian of Russia and "C. salmi" from the Carboniferous of the Czech Republic. The classification of "C. salmi" is considered somewhat uncertain, with "C. salmi" being fragmentary (as all other species of the genus) and possessing some unique features (e.g. the differently sized protuberances around the carapace).
The hibbertopterids are united as a group by being large mycteropoids with broad prosomas, a hastate (e.g. shaped like a "gladius", a Roman sword) telson with paired keels on the ventral side, ornamentation consisting of scales or other similar structures on the exoskeleton, the fourth pair of appendages possessing spines, the more posterior tergites of the abdomen possessing tongue-shaped scales near their edges and there being lobes positioned poterolaterally (posteriorly on both sides) on the prosoma.
The features of "Campylocephalus" and "Vernonopterus" makes it clear that both genera represent hibbertopterid eurypterids, but the incomplete nature of all fossil specimens referred to them make any further study of the precise phylogenetic relationships within the Hibbertopteridae difficult. Both genera could even represent synonyms of "Hibbertopterus" itself, though the highly incomplete nature of their remains again makes that hypothesis impossible to confirm.
The cladogram below is adapted from Lamsdell (2012), collapsed to only show the superfamily Mycteropoidea.
Paleoecology.
Hibbertopterids such as "Campylocephalus" were sweep-feeders, having modified spines on their forward-facing prosomal appendages that allowed them to rake through the substrate of their living environments. Though sweep-feeding was used as a strategy by many genera within the Stylonurina, it was most developed within the hibbertopterids, which possessed blades on the second, third and fourth pair of appendages. Some species of the closely related "Hibbertopterus" had specialized comb-like rachis (shafts) that were able to entrap small prey and other organic food particles.
Though they would have been slow owing to their massive size and robust form, studies on "Hibbertopterus" footprints discovered in Scotland have demonstrated that hibbertopterids would have been able to walk on land for at least short periods of time. The tracks discovered indicate that they would have utilized a lumbering, jerking and dragging movement and that the keeled belly and the telson (tail spike) left a central groove behind. Some studies suggest that eurypterids possessed a dual respiratory system, which would have allowed for this kind of occasional terrestrial movement.
"C. salmi" is known from the Ostrava Formation of the Czech Republic and would have lived during the Arnsbergian age (326.4–318.1 million years ago) of the Carboniferous period. The deposits were the eurypterid fossils were found are lacustrine, meaning that they formed on the bottom of an ancient lake. Spiders of the genus "Eophrynus", part of the extinct arachnid order Trigonotarbida, are known from the same location and age, and numerous anthozoans (the group that contains animals such as corals and sea anemones) are known from the same age within the Ostrava Formation.
It is difficult to make any statements on the paleoecology of the type species, "C. oculatus", as the precise location and dating of the fossil specimen remains somewhat unclear. Most accounts place the fossil as having been found at a location named Dourasovo in Russia and being from the Guadalupian epoch (272.3–259.8 million years ago) of the Permian period.
The species of "C. permianus" represents the latest known surviving eurypterid species. The sole fossil representing the species was discovered in the Komi Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic of the Soviet Union (the modern Komi Republic of Russia) in deposits of approximately the age of the Permian–Triassic extinction event 251.9 million years ago. In the Permian, Komi would have been a coastal region of the supercontinent Pangaea. Though no other fossils of the exact same age have been reported, other Permian-age life known from the region include bryozoans and bivalves.
By the beginning of the Permian, the eurypterids were already in decline relative to what their numbers and diversity had once been. The group was one of many heavily affected by the Late Devonian extinction, which rendered all but a single genus of eurypterine (those with swimming paddles) eurypterids extinct ("Adelophthalmus"). Of the 16 eurypterid families that had lived during the beginning of the Devonian period, three families survived and persisted into the Carboniferous period, all of which contained only non-marine species. By the Permian, only three genera were still alive; "Adelophthalmus" (a adelophthalmid), "Hastimima" (a mycteroptid) and "Campylocephalus" itself. Both "Adelophthalmus" and "Hastimima" went extinct during the Early Permian, which left "Campylocephalus" as the sole living genus of eurypterids for more than 20 million years until its own extinction in the Permian–Triassic extinction event.