Compulsory purchase in England and Wales

Compulsory purchase is the power to acquire rights over an estate in English land law, or to buy that estate outright, without the current owner's consent in return for compensation. In England and Wales, Parliament has granted several different kinds of compulsory purchase power, which are exercisable by various bodies in various situations. Such powers are "for the public benefit", but this expression is interpreted very broadly.
History.
Although land may be acquired by consent, and conduct which raises another party's reasonable expectations, these private methods of acquiring land are often insufficient for adequate public regulation. Building national infrastructure, such as railways, housing, and sewerage, as well as democratically determined planning rules, either by national or local government, typically requires compulsory purchase, because private owners might not give up land required for public works except at an extortionate price. Historically, compulsory purchases were carried out under the Inclosure Acts and their predecessors, where enclosure was frequently a method of expropriating people from common land for the benefit of barons and landlords. In the industrial revolution, most railways were built by private companies procuring compulsory purchase rights from private Acts of Parliament, though by the late 19th century, powers of compulsory purchase slowly became more transparent and used for general social welfare, as with the Public Health Act 1875, or the Housing of the Working Classes Act 1885. Compulsory purchase legislation was significantly extended during the First World War for military use, and after the war for housing, as certain principles became standardised.
Local authority purchase.
Today, the Land Compensation Act 1961 section 5 generally requires that the owner of an interest in land (e.g. a freehold, leasehold or easement as in "Re Ellenborough Park") receives payment for the "value of the land ... if sold on an open market by a willing seller". Compensation is often also available for losses to a home, or if one's business has to move. The [[Compulsory Purchase Act 1965]] sets conditions for a purchase to be made, and the [[Acquisition of Land Act 1981]] regulates the conditions for granting a "[[Compulsory Purchase Order]]". Typically, either central government represented by a Secretary of State, or a [[Local government in the United Kingdom|local council]] will be interested in making a compulsory purchase. The authority of local councils for make purchases for specific reasons can be set out in specific legislation, such as the [[Highways Act 1980]] to build roads when strictly necessary. However the [[Town and Country Planning Act 1990]] section 226, which allows compulsory purchase to "facilitate the carrying out of development, re-development or improvement" for the area's economic, social, or environmental well being, must be confirmed by the Secretary of State, and similarly the [[Local Government Act 1972]] section 121 requires the council seek approval from the government Minister.
Leasehold purchase.
[[File:Upper Brook Street - geograph.org.uk - 1422552.jpg|Left|thumb|The [[Grosvenor family]] have owned most of [[Mayfair]] and [[Belgravia]] in [[central London]] since [[Sir Thomas Grosvenor, 3rd Baronet|Sir Thomas]] married into inheritance of the land in 1677. The [[Grosvenor estate]] lost human rights challenges to the [[Leasehold Reform Act 1967]], giving tenants a "[[right to buy]]", but the legislation was restricted.]]
The most general power originally appeared in the [[Leasehold Reform Act 1967]]. Under that Act, the [[Leasehold Reform Act 1987]], and the [[Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1992]], private individuals who are leaseholders have the power in certain circumstances to compel their landlord to extend a lease or to sell the freehold at a valuation.
Recompense, under compulsory purchase, is not necessarily a monetary payment of open market value (see "[[James v United Kingdom]]" [1986]), but in most cases a sum equivalent to a valuation made as if between a willing seller and a willing purchaser will fall due to the previous owner.
Utility companies.
Utility companies have statutory powers to, for example, erect electrical substations or lay sewers or water pipes on or through someone else's land. These powers are counterbalanced by corresponding rights for landowners to compel utility companies to remove cables, pipes or sewers in other circumstances (see for example section 185 of the [[Water Industry Act 1991]]).
Compulsory purchase only applies to the extent that it is necessary for the purchaser's purposes. Thus, for example, a water authority does not need to buy the freehold in land in order to run a sewer through it. An [[easement]] will normally suffice, so in such cases the water authority may only acquire an easement through the use of compulsory purchase.
Procedure.
In most cases a [[Compulsory Purchase Order]] (CPO) is made by the purchasing authority or the Secretary of State. The CPO must unambiguously identify the land affected and set out the owners, where these are known. The order is then served on all owners and tenants with a tenancy with more than a month to run, or affixed to the land if some owners or tenants cannot be traced. A period of at least 21 days is allowed for objections. If there is a valid objection that is not withdrawn, an inquiry chaired by an inspector will take place. The inspector reports to the Secretary of State. If the Secretary of State confirms the CPO, then it becomes very difficult to challenge.
Once the CPO is confirmed, the purchasing authority must serve a Notice to Treat within three years, and a Notice of Entry within a further three years. It may take possession of the land not less than 14 days after serving the Notice of Entry. The Notice to Treat requires the land's owner to respond, and is usually the trigger for the land's owner to submit a claim for its value. If no claim is submitted within 21 days of the Notice to Treat, the acquirer can refer the matter to the Lands Tribunal. If the land's owner cannot be traced and does not respond to a Notice to Treat affixed to the land, then the purchasing authority must pay the compensation figure to the Court.
Crichel Down rules.
The [[Crichel Down affair|Crichel Down]] principles oblige central and local government, when, having acquired an estate compulsorily, they find they no longer need it, to offer it in the first instance to the person from whom they acquired it at its market value. However, this only applies where the land has not materially changed in character, and does not withstand the principle that councils may not dispose of land "for a consideration less than the best that can be obtained" under the [[Local Government Act 1972]], section 123. This means that where it is difficult to value land for some reason, the land may need to be sold by tender or auction.
Human rights.
Because of property's social importance, either for personal consumption and use or for mass production, compulsory purchase laws have met with human rights challenges. One concern is that since the 1980s privatisations, many compulsory purchase powers can be used for the benefit of private corporations whose incentives may diverge from the public interest. For example, the [[Water Resources Act 1991]] continues to allow government bodies to order compulsory purchases of people's property, although profits go to the private shareholders of [[UK water companies]]. In "[[R (Sainsbury's Supermarkets Ltd) v Wolverhampton CC]]" the Supreme Court held that [[Wolverhampton City Council]] acted for an improper purpose when it took into account a promise by [[Tesco]] to redevelop another site, in determining whether to make a compulsory purchase order over a site possessed by [[Sainsbury's]]. [[Robert Walker, Baron Walker of Gestingthorpe|Lord Walker]] stressed that "powers of compulsory acquisition, especially in a 'private to private' acquisition, amounts to a serious invasion of the current owner's proprietary rights. Nevertheless compulsory purchase orders have frequently been used to acquire land that is passed back to a private owner, including in "[[Alliance Spring Ltd v First Secretary]]" where homes in [[Islington]] were purchased to build the [[Emirates stadium]] for [[Arsenal Football Club]]. By contrast, in "[[James v United Kingdom]]", [[Gerald Grosvenor, 6th Duke of Westminster]], the inherited owner of most of [[Mayfair]] and [[Belgravia]], contended that leaseholders' right to buy had violated their [[right to property]] in [[ECHR Protocol 1, article 1]]. The [[European Court of Human Rights]] ruled that the [[Leasehold Reform Act 1967]], which allowed tenants to purchase properties from their private landlords, was within a member state's margin of appreciation. It was competent for a member state to regulate property rights in the public interest.
External links.
[[Category:English land law]]
[[Category:Eminent domain]]