4.   All of the applicants have either tenancy rights to their flats on the basis of occupancy vouchers (yaşayış sahəsi orderi) issued by the relevant executive authorities or ownership rights to them on the basis of an ownership certificate issued by the competent domestic authority (see Appendix - Table I). 5.  In four of these cases, the applicants’ flats were unlawfully occupied by internally displaced persons (“IDPs”) from different regions of Azerbaijan under occupation by Armenian military forces following the Armenian Azerbaijani conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh, and in one case (application no. 7928/11) by a family of refugees from Armenia. 6.  The applicants lodged separate civil actions before the domestic courts seeking the eviction of the IDPs from their flats. 7.  On the dates indicated in the Appendix (Table I), the applicants’ claims were granted by various domestic courts, which ordered the eviction of the IDPs from their flats. 8.  The respective judgments became final and enforceable. However, the IDP families refused to comply with those judgments and despite the applicants’ complaints to various authorities, the judgments were not enforced. 9.  According to the Government’s letter of 17 May 2012, the judgments in the applicants’ favour in applications nos. 58265/09, 73346/10, 7928/11 and 16785/11 were enforced in April 2012.