Tihić je jako kritiziran od strane nekih članova stranke da je načinio pretjerane ustupke u Prudskom sporazumu 2008, koji je usmjeren na sukcesiju državne imovine i ustavne promjene, a potpisali su ga srpski i hrvatski lideri u BiH.
Tihic has been highly criticised by some party members for making excessive concessions in the 2008 Prud Agreement, which focuses on the succession of state property and constitutional changes, and was signed by BiH's Serb and Croat leaders.