`  == GA Review == After reviewing the article according to the Good Article Criteria, I have to decline the article's nomination for GA status at this time for concerns that are listed below. While reviewing, I also looked to for comparison the Eric Bana, Uma Thurman and Julia Stiles articles. I encourage the article's editors to look to those pages as examples and guides for what this article could become.  1. It is well written. - Pass * There were some minor copy edits that took the liberty of correcting but overall the article seems to pass this criteria with no glaring violation of WP:MOS. 2. It is factually accurate and verifiable. - Needs Improvement * There was some ``citation needed`` tags prior to the review that need to be cited.  * Considering the sensitive nature of BLP's, I would also look into citing some of the ``dating history`` with reliable sources. Some celebrities consider that information private and personal. Having that type of information attached to a strong reliable source would not only put that info in the clear but would also help curb the insertions of ``dubious former lovers`` into the paragraph.   3. It is broad in its coverage. - Needs Improvement *Outside of a brief mention of the ``dim pretty boys`` characterization, there is not really any coverage on Kutcher's acting reputation and how it is perceived by the critics and mainstream viewers alike. What is his acting style like? What do critics say are his strengths and weakness? What do movie studios or viewers think of his box office draw? Are there any director's quotes about working with him? 4. It follows the neutral point of view policy - Needs Improvement * I would rework the Selected Filmography section to be more comprehensive (looks like you're missing 5-7 projects). The very description ``selected`` is POV oriented in that it is using some unknown (and presumably un-objective) criteria for inclusion in the list.  5. It is stable - Pass * The article is a bit of a vandal target but the editors are prompt in maintaining the integrity of the article. Overall the article seems to have progressed gracefully in development. 6. It contains images, where possible, to illustrate the topic. - Needs Improvement * The article has images but part of the criteria is that the all the images included be properly tagged (Criteria 6a). Image:Welling and kutcher.jpg has a deletion notice due to improper sourcing.    I encourage the editors to consider renominating after the above concerns have been addressed. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me.  `