` :Sorry, it's late at night depends which time-zone you're in, I suppose and my previous edit may have been unhelpful: what I meant was firstly that it was Looney, not the Ogburns, who first popularised the Oxford idea, and secondly that ``While scholars have acknowledged that this theory has a little more backbone than other authorship proposals, the idea has yet to convince the majority of scholars`` seems either completely circular, or - looked at another way - to be saying that Oxfordianism is correct but that scholars haven't grasped it yet.  `