`::::::::::::::There is nothing in Eric's response that indicates he has taken offense, and there is nothing hysterical (although there was no need to mention anatomical features). Re talking down: if it's not that, it's just misguided to characterize taking the article on an important author to FA as ``important to you`` as if Eric chose the article randomly and might have picked Plumbers Don't Wear Ties. What ``contradictory statement``? Rather than poking Eric it would be better to identify some content that is missing due to a gender gap.    `