  == Welsh Floods 2012 ==  Hello Ritchie,  Thank you for taking the time to review my article about floods in Wales during June 2012 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:Articles_for_creation/2012_Welsh_floods). I would be most grateful if you could read the following text and possibly revisit your decision.  This Wiki page is part of a community flood risk project to create web resources for a village in Wales that was badly flooded in June 2012. Essentially, the page I created is a summarised version of a 53 page report that I wrote for Aberystwyth University (see ref 5 - S. Foulds is me). There was a lot of information in the original report that was too detailed for the general public so I cut the report down into a more useful document. Since submitting the page for review I attended a meeting with a local flood group to preview the page. They were excited about it and commented on how useful it will be as a teaching resource for local schools. Following from this I must disagree that the article is not neutral - it is merely a statement of scientific data throughout. I have added some useful Wiki refs detailing context about the floods and some YouTube video footage. I fail to see how the YouTube footage could be unreliable as it shows videos of the floods that took place on the 12 June 2012. There is no commentary. Also, surely saying that other Wiki pages are unreliable is a circular argument – you are saying that the resources that you help to create can’t be trusted? Furthermore, I must disagree with your comments about the references - they are far more reliable than most you will find on a Wiki page because they are peer reviewed scientific articles. The article is also written in an encyclopaedic manner with facts and tables etc.  Please could you revisit my page and let me know your decision.  Thanks,  Dr. Simon Foulds  Anti-spam check. Do NOT fill this in!        Subject/headline