 :::As a female she would not be singing bass (a woman singing B1?  Really, if Mariah, Rachelle, and even Georgia Brown aren't singing B1, you tell me how that girlie voice can.  secondly, how can you prove that MSN and All Music are wrong.  Just because you haven't heard her sing that note in a song doesn't mean it doesn't exist.  Somebody attributed that fact to her and if MSN and All Music are standing behind this, why are we denying it, without proof.   