`Ta Ra Rum Pum  (Positive) * Express India ``Rani is Rani. Remarkable till the end. Although the 'cool college going girl' before marriage is not what Rani has done too often, the actor does carry it with strength and poise. But beyond the transformation, there is just one word to describe her – dignified!`` * BBC ``Rani Mukerji portrays Radhika's transformation from a music student to a mature and conscientious mother/wife with great proficiency. This actress is a natural.`` * IndiaFM ``Rani enacts the role of the mother/wife proficiently.``   * Rediff ``Rani Mukerji's Radhika is a confident lady. There is a certain polish in her taste and thoughts. Self-assurance comes naturally to the actress. And for this role, she makes the most of it. Also, there is just one word to describe Surily Goel's wardrobe for Rani: WOW!``  * Hindustan Times ``Rani Mukherji is lovely and delivers a near flawless performance.``  * Times of India ``Yet, all this familiarity fails to breed contempt because there is Saif and there is Rani: two consummate actors who squeeze out the ordinariness from any role and make it extraordinary. As the young NRI couple who dare to dream the American dream, the two lend a spiritedness to their characters which somehow makes them the most lovable mom-dad/husband-wife duo in town.`` * Indya.com ``Rani compliments him well and they both share a great chemistry. She is suitably restrained during the emotional scenes in the second half and thankfully not made to shed buckets of tears like her two previous films, (KANK and Baabul).`` * Business of Cinema ``Rani Mukerjee who has proved to be a storehouse of emotions, does well with her character. Her transformation from a sassy girl to a composed woman, allows her to perform and showcase an array of emotions.``  (Negative) * Indiatimes ``Rani Mukherjee does nothing different. She seems to have stepped straight out of ‘Baabul’ and ‘KANK’ with her rona dhona in the second half and looks really bad in the first with her hideous wig and outfits. She miserably fails to carry off the image of a trendy New Yorker. She should stick to her ‘Indian’ avatar in future.``  (Review critcizing the character that the director penned for Mukerji. Note: They are NOT criticizing her) * IBN Live ``Of the performances, neither Saif Ali Khan nor Rani is able to make much of an impression because their characters are so unidimensional and boring.`` Majority Opinion (Result): There are 10 reviews of the film posted here. 8 of them praise Mukerji's performance whilst only one criticizes her. The last review criticizes the director for wasting her talent/the character that Mukerji played so they're not really criticizing her. '''' 03:12, 26 Janaury 2008 (UTC)  `