 ===In an effort to move this forward=== I have edited a bit in the proposed page.  I must say that I can not find any fundamental problem with it other than that it is far too long and that the battle descriptions should be shortened. If that is not done, there is a risk that newer edits on the respective battle pages will not be reflected in the main article.  This does not mean there are no errors or questions remaining about the proposed page.  I am sure there are some, that is normal in an article of this length, but I am quite impressed with the effort spent on the article and the attempt to source.  I also believe it is reasonably balanced.  I have added verify tags where I felt more work is needed.  I would therefore propose to:    a) Replace the currently locked article with the proposed article I linked to above since it is of much higher quality.  b) Archive this discussion in an attempt to calm things down, and to give those who participated in it the chance to make peace  c) Keep the new article locked, and ask for comments to be made on the talk page to avoid an immediate edit war.   d) Open the new article once we can be sure that a reasonable consensus has been reached on the talk page.  I have no idea if these suggestions are in line with Wiki policies, but it appears to me that something needs to be done to overcome the impasse.  That's my 2 pence.  Between them and another 73 pennies you can get a cuppa at a greasy spoon. Regards  