 ::Whether a Muslim scholar or a scholar on Islam, doesn't matter, however just a bunch of modern day writers just because they published a book does not make them scholars. The subject has not changed though and that is a claim that Sunni sources have validated the Umar attacking Fatima story is outrageous and citing exact references need to be to the page. And spelling mistakes along with weak sentences is something that EVERYONE should fix, and I think you should stand down from protecting illegitimate statements that have no citation whatsoever if you want to call yourself neutral.