   I think that the editing of the Eragon articles should be restricted to members only, or a few members. There too many people pranking these pages by needlessly editing stuff here.  Would be good to stop that, it means a lot less work cleaning up.  Also, I think that only the base of criticism, plus a few examples should be posted, with a citation, and a link to articles or sites which have all the information ready, rather than listing it all here. 