 ****First, it disturbs me that I can't answer the good issues you're raising, about number of copies sold, etc. without the sources at hand. I *think* that info might be in the Reynolds compilation of essays that I'd have to order again via interlibrary loan and that takes weeks. Beyond that, to your questions: I'll retire, or take a long break, or do whatever one does when fed up with this place. No, I wouldn't renominate - I'd let it go. I wrote it for WP to run in 1915 as an example of WWI literature; WP doesn't want it. It's been quite a lot of work, and doing a good review is a lot of work, and my feeling is it's not worth it if I can't speak to the issues adequately without the sources. The list of stories in this section, but I prosified it.   