Receiving element
United States Patent [191 Cree [ 1 Apr. 8, 1975 1 RECEIVING ELEMENT [75] Inventor: David A. Cree, Webster, NY.  
 [73] Assignee: Eastman Kodak Company,  
 Rochester, NY.  
 [22} Filed: Nov. 5, 1973 [211 App]. No.: 413,067  
 Related US. Application Data [62] Division of Ser. No. 160,065, July 6, 1971, Pat. No.  
 [56] References Cited UNlTED STATES PATENTS 3,169,946 2/1965 Minsk 260/783 3,260,706 7/1966 Minsk et a1. 260/783 3565614 2/1971 Curreira et a1 117/37 LE 3,672,930 6/1972 Trachten&#39;berg 117/37 LE 3.814.599 6/1974 Cree 96/].4  
 FORElGN PATENTS 01R APPLlCATlONS 1,136,457 12/1965 United Kingdom 117/37 LE 1 Primary Examiner-Michael Sofocleous Attorney, Agent, or Firm-H. M. Chapin 1 ABSTRACT Image receiving elements are provided for receiving patterns of electroscopic toner particles. These elements are comprised of a fibrous support bearing on one surface thereof, a layer of an electrically conductive polymer comprising a salt of a carboxy ester lactone resin.  
 11 Claims, No Drawings RECEIVING ELEMENT This is a division of application Ser. No. 160,065 filed July 6, 1971, now U.S. Pat. No. 3,814,599, issued June 4, 1974.  
  This invention relates to electrography and more particularly to elements adapted for receiving liquid developed images formed from electrostatic charge patterns.  
  Electrographic imaging processing and particularly electrophotographic imaging processes and techniques have been extensively described in both the patent and other literature. 1n electrophotography, it is known to use an element comprised of a support bearing a layer ofa photoconductive composition typically comprising a resinous binder and a photoconductor which can be organic or inorganic. The photoconductive layer, while in the dark, will accept and retain an electrostatic charge. After charging, such an element is exposed in a suitable manner to an imagewise pattern of electromagnetic radiation. This exposure causes the charge on the surface of the element to be reduced in accordance with the amount of actinic radiation received by each area of the surface. After exposure, the resultant electrostatic charge pattern is developed by contacting it with electroscopic marking particles which adhere to the element in accordance with the charge pattern. The marking particles may be in the form of a dry powder or they may be carried in an electrically insulating organic liquid, as is well known in the art. In those cases in which high resolution is desired, liquid development is preferred, as the size of the toner particles contained in liquid developers is much smaller than can be readily obtained with dry developers, and the distribution of toner on the electrostatic image is much more uniform.  
  lf it is desired to reuse the electrophotographic element, the developed image must be transferred to a suitable receiving element. A developed toner image obtained through the use of a dry developer can be transferred to ordinary paper, for example, with the assistance of a corona charging device. It is found, however, that a liquid developed image does not transfer well to ordinary paper in this manner. In order to achieve good transfer, especially of liquid developed images, it is necessary to the various prior art receiver sheets that they be specially treated to obtain maximum electric conductivity therein. Then, during transfer, an  
 electrical field can be established between an electrode on the rear of such element and the conducting layer ofa photoconductive element bearing a developed image. The receiving elements of the prior art involve a necessary treatment of the paper support with a variety of expensive chemicals often involving a number of costly manufacturing steps. These prior elements have also been found to be extremely sensitive to environmental conditions which tend to produce undesirable curl, etc. Such prior elements also exhibit a lowering of the electrical conductivity thereof under low relative humidity conditions as often encountered in electrostatic copying apparatus. A lowering of the conductivity will inhibit good image transfer. Accordingly, there is a need for improved and less expensive transfer elements for receiving toner images which overcome these difficulties, and for an improved toner transfer process utilizing the novel elements.  
  It is, therefore, an object of this invention to provide novel receiving elements for use in electrography.  
  It is another object of this invention to provide improved receiver sheets for use in the transfer of liquid developed images, which receiver sheets enable the production of transferred images having increased sharpness and density.  
  It is yet another object of this invention to provide such receiver elements having improved liquid carrier holdout.  
  It is a further object of this invention to provide novel receiver elements which can be used with an improved toner transfer process.  
  It is still a further object of this invention to provide improved processes for the production of transferred liquid developed images using the improved receiver elements described herein.  
  These and other objects and advantages are achieved through the production of receiving elements comprising a porous, fibrous web support bearing on at least one surface thereof a layer of an electrically conductive film-forming polymeric material, said layer having a surface resistivity less than about 10 ohms per square. Although conductive layers of many kinds, such as cuprous iodide, Calgon 261 Conductive Polymer, polystyrene sulfonic acid sodium salt in binders such as vinyl polymers, gelatin, etc, could be used to form conductive layers, the present elements preferably utilize conductive layers comprised of salts of carboxy ester lactones prepared from resinous interpolymers derived from the polymerization product of any of several unsaturated afi dicarboxylic acid anhydrides with the vinyl ester of an organic acid. When the above polymerization product is modified by reaction with a monohydric alcohol and an acid catalyst, it is deacylated and simultaneously esterified with the monohydric alcohol and converted into the lactone. These compounds and their preparation have been described in McNally and VanDyke U.S. Pat. No. 2,306,071, dated Dec. 22, 1942. The compounds of McNally et al are insoluble in water, and are insoluble in alkali unless hydrolyzed. The hydrolysis treatment comprises heating a solution of the interpolymer with a mixture of a monohydric hydroxy acid and! a monohydric alkanol under acid conditions, as further described in Minsk U.S. Pat. No. 3,007,901, dated Nov. 7, 1961. They are then coverted to a water-soluble form by dissolving in an appropriate solvent and adding just sufficient alkaline regent thereto to fix the pH of the solution at from about 5 to about 8 whereby the inherently hydrophobic, unneutralized resinous carboxy ester lactone is converted to the inherently hydrophilic alkali salt of the lactone, maintaining the original lactone rings substantially intact. The conversion to the water-soluble form is further set forth in detail in Minsk U.S. Pat. No. 3,169,946, dated Feb. 16, 1965. Other suitable polymers for use in the conductive layers are prepared similarly to the method set forth above, except that the interpolymer of McNalley et al. is instead treated with a mixture of water, a monohydric alcohol and an acid catalyst in which the water is present in a molar ratio of at least 1.8:1 to the monohydric alcohol or without any alcohol present, wherein the starting polymer has an inherent viscosity of more than about 0.25 measured in acetone solution. This procedure is set forth in more detail in Minsk et a1. U.S. Pat. No. 3,260,706, dated July 12, 1966. The resulting polymer can readily be converted to the water-soluble form by the method of the Minsk 1946 patent already referred to. These polymers may contain conventional coating addenda such as matting agents, etc, if desired.  
  A particularly advantageous embodiment is obtained when the carboxy ester lactone resin is coated from an aqueous solution having a pH between about 5 and 6. This can be accomplished by precipitating the lactone in water followed by acid washing as described in the above patents. Next, the polymeric lactone is converted to a salt form by the addition of sodium bicarbonate, for example. The pH can thus be adjusted by varying the amount of sodium bicarbonate added, with lower amounts of bicarbonate giving a lower pH value.  
  The elements of this invention are typically formed on a fibrous support of relatively low conductivity. Useful materials include any of a variety of matted fibrous materials, which may be natural or synthetic, such as polyesters, polyamides, and cellulose fibers and the like. Conventional paper which has received no treatment to increase its conductivity at normal humidities is particularly useful. Generally, the volume resistivity of the support is in excess of about to 10 ohm-cm. The present invention thus provides receiving sheets which can use ordinary, inexpensive paper supports with a conducting overlayer, rather than expensive conductive papers having an insulating layer thereon as referred to in the prior art.  
  The paper or other support is then coated on one surface with a solution containing the conductive polymer herein described. The concentration of polymer in the solution may be from about 10 gm/l to about 150 gm/l as desired to produce optimum coating conditions. The concentration is not critical to the operation of the invention, and any concentration found to be convenient can be used. Similarly, coating thickness can be varied over a wide range, so that there results a dried layer of conductive polymer having a surface resistivity less than about 10 ohm/sq. It is found that typically this level of conductivity can be obtained by coating the polymer at a dry weight of from about 2 to about 10 g/m of support. Similarly, coating temperature can be varied over a rather wide range. Useful results are obtained when the solution is coated at a temperature between about and about 75C, with a particularly preferred temperature being between about and 40C.  
  If desired, there may be provided an interlayer between the support and the conductive layer. This interlayer is preferably formed of a polymeric material resistant to the penetration of the carrier liquid with which the element will be brought into contact during image transfer. It may optionally contain brighteners or reflecting means in order to enhance the contrast and brilliance of the image which will ultimately reside on the element. Suitable polymeric materials include, for example, polystyrene, gelatin, polyvinyl acetate, polyvinyl alcohol, polyvinyl butyral. A preferred composition for the interlayer comprises polyethylene which contains a pigment such as, for example, titanium dioxide, barium sulfate or other higher reflective, particulate material.  
  Preferred receiving elements according to the invention also bear a backing layer on the side of the support opposite to that bearing the image-receiving layer. The.  
 backing layer functions to reduce curl and to prevent any carrier liquid from penetrating into the support from the reverse side. In general, the electrical and solventresistance properties of this layer are the same as,  
 are required for the optional intermediate layer, so that it may be formed of any material suitable for that layer.  
 Optical brighteners generally are not necessary in the backing layer, as the light necessary to view the image is that light relfected from the interlayer and from the support. Similarly, reflecting pigments are not reuquired, for the same reason. The contribution of reflecting means in the backing layer is negligible compared to that of the support and any layers between the support and the image-receiving layer.  
  The image-receiving sheets of the invention are used in an electrophotographic process involving toner transfer. An electrophotographic recording element is first used to produce an electrostatic charge pattern corresponding to a pattern of actinic radiation to be recorded. Particularly useful recording elements comprise a conductive support bearing a layer of an organic photoconductive composition of the type well known in the art. The photosensitive surface of the element is first charged electrostatically to a convenient predetermined potential, for example, about 500-600 volts, in the absence of activating radiatiomand is then exposed to a pattern of such radiation which is to be recorded, thereby producing a pattern of electrostatic charge corresponding to the radiation pattern. The surface bearing. the charge pattern is then contacted with electroscopic marking particles, preferably carried in the form of a dispersion in an electrically insulating liquid. The particles adhere to the surface of the element in accordance with the charge pattern to form a reproduction of the original from which the charge pattern is derived. The image-receiving surface of the imagereceiving element is then bfought into contact with the toner-bearing surface of the recording element, and simultaneously therewith, a bias potential is applied between the conductive support of the recording element and the conductive layer of the image-receiving element. The two elements are then carefully peeled apart, whereupon a sharp, high-quality transferred image is found on the image-receiving element. After separation, the bias voltage is disconnected. The image on the receiving element typically needs no further treatment to be smudge-proof and permanent.  
  Liquid developers suitable for forming the image to be transferred may be chosen from a wide variety of materials. These developers typically comprise suitable marking particles dispersed in an insulating carrier liquid. Preferably, the carrier liquid has a low dielectric constant and a very high electrical resistance such that pattern being developed. In general, useful carrier liquids should have a dielectric constant of less than about- 3, should have a volume resistivity greater than about 10 ohm-cm and should be stable under a variety of conditions. Suitable carrier liquids include halogenated hydrocarbon solvents such as, for example, fluorinated lower alkanes, such as trichloromonofluoromethane, trichlorotrifluoroethane, etc, having a boiling range typically from about 2C to about 55C. other hydrocarbon solvents are useful, such as isoparaffmic hydrocarbons having a boiling range of from about C to about C, such as lsopar G (Humble Oil &amp; Refining- Co.) or cyclohydrocarbons such as cyclohexane. Additional carrier liquids which may be useful in certain situations include polysiloxanes, odorless mineral spirits, octane, etc. The marking particles dispersed in the carrier liquid typically comprises a resinous binder and optionally contains various colorants and/or charge control agents as is well known in the art.  
  The following examples are included for a further understanding of the invention.  
 EXAMPLE l A receiver sheet is prepared by coating one surface of an untreated paper support with an electrically insulating layer comprising clear polyethylene having a thickness of about microns. The other surface bears a -micron thick polyethylene layer containing titanium dioxide, over which is a conductive layer comprising the sodium salt of a resinous carboxy ester lactone, prepared by the method of Examples 2 and 17 of the aforementioned Minsk US. Pat. No. 3,169,946. The dried weight of the conductive coating is 9 grams per square meter. An electrostatic charge pattern is formed on the surface of an electrophotographic element comprising a conductive support bearing a layer comprising an organic photoconductor which has been optically sensitized so as to give it essentially panchromatic response. The charge pattern is formed by uniformly charging the surface of the photoconductive layer to about +1000 volts and exposing it to the light from a 3000K tungsten source which has passed through a test color negative and a Corning 5-60 Blue filter. The test negative bears the image of an archery target containing concentric black, blue, red and yellow annuli. The charge pattern is rendered visible by contacting it with a yellow pigmented positive liquid developer comprising an alkyd resin, a phenolvformaldehyde resin, a hydrocarbon solvent and a charge control agent, all dispersed in an isoparaffinic hydrocarbon liquid carrier (lsopar G). A development electrode biased at +900 volts was also utilized. The toner image is then transferred to the receiver sheet of the invention by placing the conductive layer of the receiver sheet in contact with the image-bearing layer of the photoconductive element and applying a 900 volt DC. bias potential between the conductive layer of the receiver sheet and the conductive support of the electrophotographic element, the receiver sheet being connected to the negative terminal of the bias supply. The element and the sheet are then separated and the bias removed. The image is found to have transferred cleanly to the receiver sheet. A second and a third image are formed in a similar manner by exposing through a Kodak Wratten No. 61 green filter and a Kodak Wratten No. 70 red filter, respectively, followed by development of the resultant charge patterns with magenta and cyan liquid developers, respectively. The resulting images are each transferred in register to the same receiver sheet. A second print is made in the same manner from a test color negative bearing the image of a girl sitting on a ladder in front of a standard archery target. As a control, a receiver sheet containing Calgon Conductive Polymer 261 is overcoated with a conductive Baryta layer at g/m followed by the application of a layer comprising the sodium salt of a resinous carboxy ester lactone coated at 9 g/m Transfers are made in the above manner to this receiver sheet. Reflection density measurements are made on a reflection densitometer at various locations on the two subjects reproduced in the prints. The densities measured are given in Table I below.  
 Table l Receiver Sheet Subject Specific Area Filter Control lnvention Target Outer yellow circle Blue 1.16 1.24 Target Outer red circle Green 1.32 1.32 Blue 1.37 1.44 Target Outer blue circle Green 0.80 0.86 Red 1.26 1.36 Target Outer black circle Visual 1.71 1.77 Girl Forehead Visual 0.24 0.28 Girl Knee Visual 0.34 0.38 Girl Thigh Visual 0.46 0.48  
 It is seen that the receiver sheet prepared according to the invention gives appreciably greater image density than the receiver sheet with Calgon 261. In a further experiment to demonstrate the improved results that can be obtained with the reciever sheets of the present invention, gloss measurements are made using a goniophotometer adjusted so that the incident light strikes the surface at from the normal, and reflected light is collected at 75 on the opposite side of the normal, the incident light, the reflected light and the normal all being contained in the same plane. The results using the same two subjects referred to above are given in Table 11 below.  
 Table 11 Percent Reflectance Control Receiver Sheet Several polyethylene coated paper supports as described in Example 1 having a back coating of unpigmented polyethylene are each overcoated with a conductive layer as described in Example 1 only each conductive layer is formed from an aqueous solution of polymer having a different pH value. The resin lactone is prepared as described in Example 2 of Minsk US. Pat. No. 3,169,946 to give a solution of product having a pH of about 5.2. Sodium bicarbonate is then added in varying amounts to give greater or lesser conversion to the sodium salt and to give a higher or lower pH value. The following pH values are obtained when the designated amount of sodium bicarbonate is added to 1000 ml. of a 7% solution of the lactone as prepared above.  
 Solution No. NaHCO (g) P surface of an electrophotographic element comprising a conductive support bearing a layer comprising a sensitized organic photoconductor in a resin binder. The surface of the photoconductive layer is uniformly charged to about 600 volts and imagewise exposed to a 3,000K tungsten source. The charge pattern is rendered visible by contacting it with a liquid developer as in Example 1. The toner image is then transferred to one of the receiver sheet by placing the conductive layer of the receiver sheet in contact with the imagebearing layer of the photoconductive element and applying a 900 volt bias potential. This potential is applied between the conductive layer of the receiver sheet and the conductive support of the electrophotographic element with the receiver sheet being connected to the negative terminal of the bias supply. The element and the sheet are then separated and the bias removed. The image is found to have transferred to the receiver sheet. This process is repeated for each of the several receiver sheets prepared as described earlier in this Example. A visible image is obtained with all six receiver sheets; however, the quality of the transfer print, as judged on the basis of the uniformity and degree of image transfer, is better with elements 1 through 4.  
  The invention has been described in detail with particular reference to certain preferred embodiments thereof, but it will be understood that variations and modifications can be effected within the spirit and scope of the invention.  
 I claim:  
  1. An electrographic image-receiving element adapted to receive a pattern of electroscopic toner particles derived from a liquid xerographic developer, said element comprising an essentially nonconductive cellulosic paper web support having a volume resistivity of at least about ohm-cm, said support bearing on one surface thereof an outermost image-receiving layer comprising an electrically conductive salt of a carboxy ester lactone film forming resin, said layer having a surface resistivity less than about 10 ohms per square.  
  2. An element according to claim 1 additionally comprising an electrically insulating, liquid developer resistant layer on the surface of said web opposite to that bearing said conductive layer.  
  3. An element according to claim 1 wherein said resistant layer consists essentially of polyethylene.  
  4. An element according to claim 2 additionally comprising a layer between said support and said imagereceiving layer, said additional layer being resistant to penetration of liquid developer therethrough.  
  5. An element according to claim 4 wherein said additional layer resistant to penetration of liquid developer through said support consists essentially of polyethylene.  
  6. An element according to claim 1 wherein said salt of a polymeric lactone is selected from the group consisting of alkali metal and ammonium salts of a hydrated interpolymer of maleic anhydride and vinyl acetate.  
  7. An element according to claim 6 wherein the alkali metal forming said salt is sodium.  
  8. An element according to claim 1 comprising an additional layer between said support and said imagereceiving layer, said additional layer being resistant to penetration of liquid developer therethrough.  
  9. An element according to claim 1 wherein said conductive salt is coated at a dry weight of about 2 to 10 g/m of said support.  
  10. An electrographic image-receiving element adapted to receive a pattern of electroscopic toner particles derived from a liquid xerographic developer, said element comprising an essentially nonconductive support having a volume resistivity of at least about I0 ohm-cm and which comprises a cellulosic paper web; a layer of polyethylene on one surface of said paper web; and an outermost image-receiving layer on said polyethylene layer comprising an electrically conducting polymer consisting essentially of a sodium salt of a hydrated interpolymer of maleic anhydride and vinyl acetate, said layer of electrically conducting polymer having a surface resistivity less than about l0 ohms per square.  
  11. An element according to claim 10 additionally comprising an electrically insulating layer of polyethylene on the surface of said paper web opposite to that bearing said image-receiving layer.