Anti-fouling marine paints containing microencapsulated anti-fouling agents and the process of microencapsulation
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
     1. Field of the Invention 
     This invention relates to microcapsules containing water-immiscible biocidal substances, to the methods for preparing such microcapsules, and to extended-life, anti-fouling marine paints containing such microcapsules. 
     2. Description of the Prior Art 
     Prior to the present invention, numerous anti-fouling marine paints were developed in which effective anti-fouling agents were incorporated into suitable marine paint bases. These paints were then applied to underwater surfaces in an effort to limit the growth of marine organisms. Prior art anti-fouling marine paint compositions of this type are disclosed, for example, in U.S. Pat. Nos. 2,970,923, 4,139,515 and 4,143,015. U.S. Pat. No. 2,970,923 discloses an anti-fouling marine paint composition containing varnish, pigment and triphenyl tin chloride as anti-fouling agent. The triphenyl tin chloride is uniformly dispersed throughout the paint vehicle. U.S. Pat. No. 4,139,515 discloses an anti-fouling paint for ship hulls which comprises an emulsion of a film-forming emulsion copolymer containing a triorganotin salt of an olefinically unsaturated carboxylic acid, and a substantially water-insoluble metalliferous pigment capable of reacting with seawater to form a water-soluble metal compound. As the paint dissolves, triorganotin ions are released into the seawater and act as biocides. U.S. Pat. No. 4,143,015 discloses an anti-fouling paint comprising a toxicant dispersed in an aqueous solution of vinyl acetate resin. Cuprous oxide and organotin compounds are suggested as suitable toxicants. 
     In the use of all such prior art anti-fouling marine paints, a coating of the paint is applied to the surface to be protected from fouling growth. As the coating dissolves or is worn down, the biocidal anti-fouling agents leach out of the surface in concentrations lethal to the marine organisms. After a period of time, the paint is no longer effective because the concentration of anti-fouling agent leaching from the surface falls below that which is lethal. This can occur when the paint has dissolved or when additional anti-fouling agent dispersed in the paint below the surface thereof does not leach out and contact the marine organisms. 
     Thus, it has been a goal of the prior art work on anti-fouling marine paints to control the rates of dissolution of the paint and leaching of the biocide in order to prolong the useful life of the paint. The economic importance of prolonging the effectiveness of anti-foulants is summarized in a recent report sponsored by the U.S. Navy (Ad Hoc Fouling, Biodeterioration Committee, Survey Report: Navy Biological Fouling and Deterioration, Report NUC TP 456, March, 1975). This report states that anti-fouling ship bottom coatings in use are effective for a maximum of 18 months, the cruising range of ships of all sizes is reduced by the increased drag of hull fouling, and fuel consumption increases markedly after only seven months immersion due to partial bottom fouling. It is estimated that the indirect cost to the U.S. Navy attributable to bottom fouling is an additional 80 million dollars per year in fuel utilization. In the Mediterranean, engine cooling-intakes can become completely clogged after only one or two months of submergence and rapid fouling of the water intakes of ships&#39; power plants accounts for costly shutdowns. The report notes that the major reason for expensive dry-docking is to scrape away the fouling organisms and to replenish the anti-fouling coating. For Navy vessels alone this direct cost is over 15 million dollars per year. In addition, marine pilings deteriorate due to fouling and the Navy spends over 200 million dollars per year to replace biologically deteriorated and structurally weakened pilings. 
     In tropical waters the most important biologic foulant is the barnacle (Janes GA: Problems in Testing Long Term Antifoulants, in: Proceedings of the 1976 Controlled Release Pesticide Symposium, Cardarelli NF, Editor, Engineering and Science Division, Community and Technical College, The University of Akron, Ohio). Other noxious marine surface fouling organisms are: encrusting bryozoa, tunicates, Bugula, hydroids, oysters, tube worms and algae. 
     As indicated above, the present invention relates to methods of microencapsulating biocidal substances. The classic method for encapsulation of oils is disclosed in Bungenbern de J, Colloid Science, Vol. II, pp. 339, 341, Elsevier Publishing Co. (H. R. Kruyt ed. 1949) and in U.S. Pat. Nos. 2,730,456 and 2,730,457. According to the patents, gum arabic is first dissolved in water. Then the oil to be encapsulated is emulsified into the gum arabic solution until the drop size of the oil is 2-5 microns. An aqueous solution of gelatin is then mixed with the emulsion. All of these steps are conducted at about 50° C. The gelatin-gum arabic colloid is then coacervated either by the addition of cold water or by lowering the pH by the addition of acid. Finally, the capsules are hardened by adding formaldehyde. 
     Additional complex coacervation processes for the encapsulation of liquids which are representative of the state of the art include U.S. Pat. Nos. 2,800,457, 3,956,172 and Re 28,779. Each of these prior art processes is similar to the classic method described above in which coacervation can be achieved by either lowering the pH or adding water. 
     SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
     In accordance with the present invention, microcapsules of water-immiscible liquid or solid chemicals can be prepared in which the chemicals are encapsulated with a macromolecular membrane of a complex coacervate of gelatin Type A and gum acacia. The present microencapsulation process comprises preparing at an elevated temperature a colloidal solution containing gelatin Type A, gum acacia and water and then preparing an emulsion or a slurry containing the chemical to be microencapsulated, a powdered inorganic substance, if the chemical is a liquid, and water. The emulsion or slurry of dispersed chemical is then poured into the colloidal solution of gelatin and gum acacia under constant gentle stirring and allowed to cool slowly to room temperature. During the cooling step, the dispersed chemical is encapsulated by the complex coacervate. After cooling the mixture further at low temperatures, the sedimented microcapsules are washed and then resuspended in water. Cold glutaraldehyde solution is then added to cross-link and stabilize the walls of the microcapsules. The microcapsules are washed and then dried. 
     Anti-fouling marine paints having an extended life are prepared in accordance with the present invention by adding dry microcapsules containing an anti-fouling biocidal substance made according to the present microencapsulation process to a marine paint. Such microcapsules slowly release anti-fouling agent from the surface of the paint and prolong the anti-fouling effect. Microcapsules of other water-immiscible fungicidal, bacteriocidal or other biocidal chemicals can be prepared in accordance with the present process and then added to coating compositions for use in applications in which the controlled release of such chemicals is desirable. 
    
    
     DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS 
     In accordance with the present microencapsulation process, liquid or solid chemicals can be encapsulated with a macromolecular membrane of a complex coacervate of gelatin Type A and gum acacia. First, a colloidal solution of gelatin and gum acacia is prepared by mixing from about 0.9 to about 1.1 parts by weight of gelatin Type A, from about 0.9 to about 1.1 parts by weight of gum acacia, and from about 45 to about 47 parts by weight of water with constant stirring at a temperature in the range of about 55° C. to about 60° C. Whenever water is employed in the present process, it is preferably distilled water. 
     If the chemical to be microencapsulated is a water-immiscible liquid, an emulsion of the chemical is prepared by mixing from about 3.9 to about 4.1 parts by volume of the chemical, from about 7.6 to about 7.9 parts by volume of water, and from about 0.1 to about 10 percent by weight of a suitable emulsifier, such as a finely divided inorganic substance based on the combined weight of the water-immiscible liquid and the water. Suitable finely divided inorganic substances include silica, such as Cab-O-Sil, bentonite and the like. Depending upon the degree of ease with which the water-immiscible chemical is emulsified in water, the finely divided inorganic substance is first mixed either with the water-immiscible liquid or with the water before mixture with the other. Those finely divided substances permit the production of microcapsules of controlled and uniform size. The chemical is then dispersed in the aqueous phase using an homogenizer until the dispersed droplets of the chemical to be encapsulated are of the desired size. During the emulsification the mixture is maintained at an elevated temperature. If the chemical to be encapsulated is a finely-divided water-immiscible solid, a slurry of the chemical is prepared by adding from about 0.9 to about 1.1 parts by weight of the chemical to about 4 to about 5 parts by weight of water and a dispersing agent, e.g., Tween 20, about 0.01 part by weight, if necessary. No emulsifying agent is required. This mixture is then stirred gently to form a slurry. 
     With both the colloidal solution of gelatin Type A and gum acacia and the emulsion or slurry of dispersed chemical to be encapsulated at a temperature of above about 50° C. and preferably in the range of about 55° C. to about 60° C. the emulsion or slurry is then poured into the colloidal solution, and at a pH of about 4.5 is allowed to cool slowly to room temperature with constant stirring. During this cooling step, the droplets or particles of chemical are encapsulated by the coalescing complex coacervate. The ratio of emulsion or slurry to colloidal solution can be varied over a wide range to achieve the desired wall thickness of the macromolecular membrane of the complex coacervate. A ratio of about 1 part by volume of emulsion or slurry to about 4 parts by volume of colloidal solution has been found to be suitable for the preparation of microcapsules for use in anti-fouling marine paints. 
     If the liquid or finely divided solid chemical hydrolyzes to produce the desired acidity of pH 4.5 the encapsulation proceeds without addition of acid. An example of a self pH shifting chemical is tributyltin chloride. However, with a water-immiscible solid such as tributyltin fluoride the gelatin-gum acacia colloid must be slowly acidified to pH 4.5 with an acid, e.g. HCl, for the coacervate to form at lower temperatures. 
     The mixture is then allowed to cool so that the droplets of particles of water-immiscible chemical are encapsulated by coalescing complex coacervate. The temperature of the mixture is further lowered and held at about 4° C. to about 10° C. Sedimented microcapsules are then washed several times in about five times their volume of cold distilled water, preferably at a temperature in the range of about 4° C. to about 10° C., to remove the excess complex coacervate not used in the encapsulation of the water-immiscible chemical. Following the final wash, the sedimented microcapsules are resuspended in cold distilled water at a volume equal to at least about that in which the complex coacervation occurred. 
     A cold solution of a mono- or polyvalent cross-linking or fixing agent, such as glutaraldehyde, formaldehyde or tannic acid, is then added to a final concentration of from about 1 to about 2 percent by volume to cross-link and stabilize the walls of the cold microcapsules. During this fixation step the mixture is stirred for at least about 15-30 minutes at a temperature of about 4° C. to about 10° C. and then held for at least about 4 hours at that temperature. The wet microcapsules are washed and then separated from the water by sedimentation and dried, for example, by lyophilization. 
     This process has been found to be particularly advantageous for the microencapsulation of biocidal anti-fouling agents. Tributyltin chloride, a water-immiscible liquid, and tributyltin fluoride, a water-immiscible solid, have been found to be particularly acceptable as ship bottom ant-fouling agents. Microcapsules containing anti-fouling agent can be added to marine paints that do not contain any other anti-fouling agent, or they can be added to marine paint specifically formulated to contain an anti-fouling agent. Any good quality ship bottom paint, such as U.S. Navy Formula #1020A base paint which is widely used in the trade, can be employed as the marine paint in accordance with the present invention. Microcapsules of two or more types of anti-fouling agents can be added to the paint when it is to be used to combat specific combinations of marine foulants. Because the anti-fouling agents are microencapsulated, the marine paint can be loaded with a higher concentration than when the biocide as a liquid is formulated directly in the paint. Microcapsules of anti-fouling agent prepared according to the present invention can be mixed with a base paint vehicle in amounts up to about 50 percent by weight of the total paint composition. 
     It was found that when microcapsules of anti-fouling agent prepared according to the present process were added to conventional marine paint vehicles, for example, Vinyl Rosin Formula 3723-21 (M &amp; T Chemicals Inc.), the agent was released slowly to the surface of the paint and the effectiveness against growth of marine foulants on the surface was significantly prolonged. By means of this controlled release of anti-fouling agent a concentration of the biocide in immersed, painted test panels was sustained at a 100% anti-fouling rating for a period of over 20 months. 
     By encapsulating fungicidal, bacteriocidal or biocidal chemicals in accordance with the present invention, microcapsules of chemical will be obtained which can be added to conventional paint of other coating vehicles for use in applications where a sustained release of the bioactive chemical is desired. 
     A more complete appreciation of the invention will be realized by reference to the following specific examples which relate to specific microencapsulation methods and compositions containing microcapsules within the scope of the invention. The following examples are not intended to limit the invention disclosed herein except to the extent that limitations are specifically stated or to the extent to which limitations appear in the appended claims. 
     EXAMPLE 1 
     The liquid anti-fouling agent tributyltin chloride was microencapsulated with a thin-walled macromolecular coacervate of gelatin and gum acacia, stabilized and dried in accordance with the present invention. In a first container 10 grams of gelatin Type A (USP), 10 grams of gum acacia (USP), and 460 ml. of distilled water were mixed and heated to 55° C., with constant stirring for at least 1 hour. In a second container 40 ml. of tributyltin chloride (M &amp; T Chemical Co.) was added to 75 ml. of distilled water containing 0.25 gram of Cab-O-Sil that had been sonicated to reduce any agglomerates of this extremely fine inorganic substance to its smallest size. The tributyltin chloride was dispersed in the aqueous phase using a Virtis (Virtis Co.) or Polytron (Brinkman Instruments) homogenizer. During the emulsification the mixture was maintained at about 55° C. to about 60° C. until the dispersed oil droplets were of the desired size (10-30 μm in diameter). With both components at about 55° C., about 115 ml. of the tributyltin chloride dispersed in water was poured into about  460 ml. of the colloidal solution of gelatin and gum acacia and with constant gentle stirring was allowed to cool to room temperature. During the cooling step the droplets of tributyltin chloride were encapsulated by the complex coacervate. The temperature of the mixture was then further lowered and held at 4° C. to 10° C. over night. The sedimented microcapsules were then washed four times in five times the volume of cold distilled water. After the final wash the sedimented microcapsules were resuspended in cold distilled water to the original volume in which the complex coacervation took place. 17 ml. of a 50% solution of cold glutaraldehyde was added to a final concentration of 1.5% to cross-link and stabilize the wall of the capsules. This mixture was stirred for about 15 minutes at 4° C. and then held without stirring for about 12 hours at 4° C. The microcapsules, ranging in size from 10-30 μm, were washed with tap water at room temperature to remove the fixative, and dried by lyophilization. The dried microcapsules were then ready to be added to any suitable ship bottom paint or stored at room temperature in a covered container for later use. 
     EXAMPLE 2 
     The process of Example 1 was modified to encapsulate tributyltin chloride with a thick-walled macromolecular coacervate of gelatin and gum acacia. The process of Example 1 was repeated using finely divided (about 5 to 50 μm size) bentonite (USP) in place of Cab-O-Sil, with the exception that to form the oil-in-water type emulsion the 0.25 gram of bentonite was thoroughly mixed with 40 ml. of tributyltin chloride instead of in the water as in Example 1. This mixture was then mixed with the 75 ml. of distilled water before it was emulsified and added to the colloidal solution of gelatin and gum acacia. The process was in all other respects the same as that described in Example 1. The microcapsules obtained had a diameter of about 50-100 μm. The thick-walled microcapsules release anti-fouling agents at the same slow rate as smaller capsules containing the same anti-foulant. 
     EXAMPLES 3-16 
     A first batch of microcapsules of tributyltin chloride having diameters of about 50-100 μm was prepared in accordance with the procedure set forth in Example 2 above using finely divided bentonite (USP). A second batch of microcapsules of tributyltin chloride having diameters of about 10-30 μm was prepared by homogenizing at a higher speed. Following the procedure of Example 1, a third batch of microcapsules of tributyltin chloride having diameters of about 10-30 μm was prepared using finely divided Cab-O-Sil, and a fourth batch of microcapsules of tributyltin chloride having diameters of about 1-10 μm was prepared by emulsifying at a higher speed. On the average, tributyltin chloride comprised about 58 percent by weight of the microcapsules in these batches. 
     Within two weeks after manufacture, the four batches of microcapsules were mixed in a base marine paint vehicle. The base paint employed was Vinyl Rosin AF Paint 3723-21 (M &amp; T Chemicals, Inc.) which has the composition set forth in Table I below: 
     
                       TABLE I                                                     
______________________________________                                    
Ingredients             Parts by Wt.                                      
______________________________________                                    
Red iron oxide              15.12                                         
Talc                        11.22                                         
Zinc oxide                  7.08                                          
Rosin                       3.73                                          
MIBK                        13.31                                         
Cyclohexanone               13.00                                         
Xylene                      12.84                                         
Bentone 27                  0.51                                          
           Pre-wet                                                        
Methanol                    0.15                                          
VAGH (Union Carbide)        11.16                                         
______________________________________                                    
 The microcapsules of tributyltin chloride comprise about 8.2 percent by
 weight of the paint mixtures. Each of the four paints containing
 microcapsules was then applied by brush to one side of three sanded
 8&#34;×10&#34; fiberglass panels. The three panels were coated respectively
 with one, two and three coats of one of the four paints with air drying
 between coats. Each coat had a thickness of about 5 mils. Unless otherwise
 indicated, the thickness of each coat of paint in all of the Examples
 herein was approximately 5 mils.
 
    
     Two control paints were also employed. The first control paint used was the vinyl rosin base paint without microcapsules (Example 15). The second control paint (Example 16) was prepared by mixing microcapsules of an inert, non-antifoulant, high temperature oil (Dow Oil #550, Dow Chemical Co.) with the vinyl rosin base paint at the same concentration as the paints containing tributyltin chloride microcapsules. The microcapsules of Dow oil were prepared in accordance with the procedure of Example 1 above with the exception that no finely divided inorganic emulsifying agent was required. It was also necessary to add hydrochloric acid to adjust the pH of the mixture of emulsion and colloidal solution to about 4.5. A single coat of each of the control paints was applied to one side of a sanded fiberglass panel as described above. 
     All of the coated panels were then immersed in Biscayne Bay, Dade County, Florida so that the tops of the panels remained 1 to 4 feet below the surface of the water. The test panels were removed at monthly intervals for visual inspection and evaluation and then immediately returned to the sea water environment. The percent overall performance at one month intervals for each of the test panels is set forth in Table II below. This overall performance rating reflects fouling resistance of the panel as a whole taking into account adhesion and durability of the paint as well as the anti-fouling properties, the resistance of the paint to fouling, and the anticorrosive properties applicable to paints intended for use on metal surface. A rating of 100 indicates no fouling and a rating of 0 indicates that the panel was completely fouled. 
     
                                           TABLE II                                
__________________________________________________________________________
      Finely                                                              
     Divided                                                              
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
            Number                                                        
                 Months Immersed                                          
 Number                                                                   
      Substance                                                           
            of Coats                                                      
                 1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8    9                       
                                                   10  11                 
__________________________________________________________________________
3    lg. bentonite                                                        
            1    100 100 100 82  70  50  0                                
4    lg. bentonite                                                        
            2    100 100 100 100 100 100 92  82    79  74                 
5    lg. bentonite                                                        
            3    100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 100                
6    sm. bentonite                                                        
            1    100 100 84  50  30  30  0                                
7    sm. bentonite                                                        
            2    100 100 100 100 100 100 100 92    92  82                 
8    sm. bentonite                                                        
            3    100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 100                
9    lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
            1    100 100 90  80  50  40  40  0                            
10   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
            2    100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100   92  92                 
11   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
            3    100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 92                 
12   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
            1    100 100 100  75 65  30  30  30    0                      
13   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
            2    100 100 100 85  60  60  50  50    0                      
14   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
            3    100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 100                
15   None   1    70  25  0                                                
16   None   1    65  25  0                                                
__________________________________________________________________________
     Finely                                                               
     Divided                                                              
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
             Number                                                       
                   Months Immersed                                        
Number                                                                    
     Substance                                                            
             of Coats                                                     
                   12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21                 
__________________________________________________________________________
3    lg. bentonite                                                        
             1                                                            
4    lg. bentonite                                                        
             2     74  60  50  40  40  30  30  30  30  0                  
5    lg. bentonite                                                        
             3     100 100 100 93  93  93  91  80  75  65                 
6    sm. bentonite                                                        
             1                                                            
7    sm. bentonite                                                        
             2     75  75  70  65  55  50  40  40* 40* 40*                
8    sm. bentonite                                                        
             3     100 100 100 100 100 100 90  65* 60* 20*                
9    lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1                                                            
10   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2     92  92  75  65  65* 60* 50* 50* 50* 30*                
11   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3     92  92  92  92  92* 80* 75* 90* 75* 75*                
12   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1                                                            
13   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2                                                            
14   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3     90  90  85  90  75  55  50  50  50  50                 
15   None    1                                                            
16   None    1                                                            
__________________________________________________________________________
 *Indicates peeling.                                                      
 
    
     EXAMPLES 17-30 
     Six marine paint compositions were prepared following the procedures of Examples 3-16 above, with the exception that all of the paint compositions additionally contained 6.9 percent by weight of liquid tributyltin chloride. Fourteen sanded fiberglass panels were coated and immersed in accordance with the procedures of Examples 3-16. The present overall performance at monthly intervals for all of these panels is set forth in Table III below: 
     
                                           TABLE III                               
__________________________________________________________________________
      Finely Divided                                                      
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
             Number                                                       
                  Months Immersed                                         
Number                                                                    
      Substance                                                           
             of Coats                                                     
                  1  2   3   4   5   6   7    8  9  10  11                
__________________________________________________________________________
17   lg. bentonite                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100 84  50  0                                        
18   lg. bentonite                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 100                
19   lg. bentonite                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 100                
20   sm. bentonite                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 80  70  70  70    60  60                 
21   sm. bentonite                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 85                 
22   sm. bentonite                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 100                
23   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100 100 75  45  45  30  0                            
24   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 100                
25   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 100                
26   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100 89  60  60  50  30  0                            
27   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 90  90  90  90    90  90                 
28   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 100 100 100 100   100 100                
29   None    1    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 100 93  93  93    93  93                 
30   None    1    100                                                     
                     100 100 100 100 100 91  91    91  86                 
__________________________________________________________________________
     Finely Divided                                                       
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
              Number                                                      
                   Months Immersed                                        
Number                                                                    
     Substance                                                            
              of Coats                                                    
                   12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21                 
__________________________________________________________________________
17   lg. bentonite                                                        
              1                                                           
18   lg. bentonite                                                        
              2    100 100 90  80* 80  80  65* 65* 65* 65*                
19   lg. bentonite                                                        
              3    100 100 100 90  90  90  90  90  90  90                 
20   sm. bentonite                                                        
              1    40  30  0                                              
21   sm. bentonite                                                        
              2    85  85  65  30  30  30  30  30  30  30                 
22   sm. bentonite                                                        
              3    100 100 100 70  80* 60* 50* 50  50  30*                
23   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
              1                                                           
24   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
              2    100 80  65  65  65  65  65  65  60  60                 
25   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
              3    100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 85  85                 
26   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
              1                                                           
27   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
              2    90  85  85  75  70  60  50  50  50  50                 
28   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
              3    100 100 93  93  93  93  88  78  70  60                 
29   None     1    80  80  70  70  70  65  30  30  30  0                  
30   None     1    81  81  81  81  81  81  76  60  55  55                 
__________________________________________________________________________
 *Indicates peeling.                                                      
 
    
     EXAMPLES 31-44 
     Six marine paint compositions were prepared in accordance with the procedures set forth in Examples 3-16 above, with the exception that Chlorinated Rubber A/F Paint Formula 1A (3723-24-2) (M &amp; T Chemicals, Inc.) was employed as the base marine paint vehicle instead of the vinyl rosin paint base. The chlorinated rubber paint base has the composition set forth in Table IV below: 
     
                       TABLE IV                                                    
______________________________________                                    
Ingredients            Parts by Wt.                                       
______________________________________                                    
Red iron oxide             4.50                                           
Zinc oxide                 20.80                                          
Talc                       7.70                                           
Bentone 27                 0.44                                           
               Pre-wet                                                    
Methanol                   0.12                                           
Parlon-S-20                11.20                                          
Rosin                      5.98                                           
Xylene                     35.14                                          
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     Fourteen panels were coated with the compositions prepared and immersed according to the procedures set forth in Examples 3-16. The percent overall performance at monthly intervals for these panels is set forth in Table V below: 
     
                                           TABLE V                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
     Finely Divided                                                       
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
             Number                                                       
                  Months Immersed                                         
Number                                                                    
     Substance                                                            
             of Coats                                                     
                  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11                         
__________________________________________________________________________
31   lg. bentonite                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                      90                                                  
                         90                                               
                            60                                            
                               0                                          
32   lg. bentonite                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 82 82 77   77 72                         
33   lg. bentonite                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100  100                           
                                               100                        
34   sm. bentonite                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                         85                                               
                            75                                            
                              60 55 55 55   55 55                         
35   sm. bentonite                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                            91                                            
                              83 83 83 83   83 83                         
36   sm. bentonite                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              94 86 86 86   89 89                         
37   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                         80                                               
                            65                                            
                               0                                          
38   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                            93                                            
                              80 75 75 60    0                            
39   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              90 90 90 80   80*                           
                                               80*                        
40   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                         80                                               
                            60                                            
                               0                                          
41   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              90 90 87 87   87*                           
                                               87*                        
42   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                            90                                            
                              90 90 90 90   90*                           
                                               90*                        
43   None    1     75                                                     
                      45                                                  
                         0                                                
44   None    1     75                                                     
                      45                                                  
                         0                                                
__________________________________________________________________________
      Finely Divided                                                      
Example                                                                   
      Inorganic                                                           
              Number                                                      
                   Months Immersed                                        
Number                                                                    
      Substance                                                           
              of Coats                                                    
                   12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21                          
__________________________________________________________________________
31    lg. bentonite                                                       
              1                                                           
32    lg. bentonite                                                       
              2    72 68 63 35 25  0                                      
33    lg. bentonite                                                       
              3    95*                                                    
                      90*                                                 
                         90*                                              
                            80*                                           
                               80*                                        
                                  80*                                     
                                     75*                                  
                                        75*                               
                                           65*                            
                                              50*                         
34    sm. bentonite                                                       
              1    50 40  0                                               
35    sm. bentonite                                                       
              2    83 83*                                                 
                         83*                                              
                            50*                                           
                               45*                                        
                                  20  0                                   
36    sm. bentonite                                                       
              3    89 85*                                                 
                         85*                                              
                            85*                                           
                               85 85 75 70*                               
                                           60*                            
                                              50*                         
37    lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                       
              1                                                           
38    lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                       
              2                                                           
39    lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                       
              3    80*                                                    
                      80*                                                 
                         80*                                              
                            60*                                           
                               55*                                        
                                  40*                                     
                                     25*                                  
                                        25*                               
                                           25*                            
                                               0                          
40    sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                       
              1                                                           
41    sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                       
              2    87*                                                    
                      70*                                                 
                         70*                                              
                            70*                                           
                               67*                                        
                                  57*                                     
                                     50*                                  
                                        50*                               
                                           50*                            
                                              50*                         
42    sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                       
              3    90*                                                    
                      80**                                                
                         80**                                             
                            60*                                           
                               60*                                        
                                  60*                                     
                                     60*                                  
                                        60*                               
                                           60*                            
                                              60*                         
43    None    1                                                           
44    None    1                                                           
__________________________________________________________________________
 *Indicates peeling.                                                      
 **Indicates no fouling.                                                  
 
    
     EXAMPLES 45-58 
     Six marine paint compositions were prepared following the procedures of Examples 17-30 above, with the exception that chlorinated Rubber A/F Paint Formula 1A (3723-24-2) was used instead of the vinyl rosin paint base. Fourteen fiberglass panels with these compositions and immersed according to the procedures set forth in Examples 3-16 above. The percent overall performance at monthly intervals for these panels is set forth in Table VI below: 
     
                                           TABLE VI                                
__________________________________________________________________________
     Finely Divided                                                       
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
             Number                                                       
                  Months Immersed                                         
Number                                                                    
     Substance                                                            
             of Coats                                                     
                  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8 9 10                             
                                             11                           
__________________________________________________________________________
45   lg. bentonite                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                         86                                               
                            60                                            
                              60 40  0                                    
46   lg. bentonite                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              70 70 70 70  70*                            
                                             70*                          
47   lg. bentonite                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 80 80 80  80*                            
                                             80*                          
48   sm. bentonite                                                        
             1     75                                                     
                      92                                                  
                         50                                               
                            50                                            
                               0                                          
49   sm. bentonite                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                         80                                               
                            50                                            
                               0                                          
50   sm. bentonite                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 70 40 30  30*                            
                                             30*                          
51   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                         85                                               
                            50                                            
                               0                                          
52   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    92 80* 89*                            
                                             89*                          
53   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 90 90 85  85                             
                                             85                           
54   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                         85                                               
                            70                                            
                              50 40  0                                    
55   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 85 85 75  75                             
                                             75                           
56   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       92  92                             
                                             80*                          
57   None    1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           70  0                                          
58   None    1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                         90                                               
                           60  0                                          
__________________________________________________________________________
             Finely Divided                                               
        Example                                                           
             Inorganic                                                    
                     Number                                               
                          Months Immersed                                 
        Number                                                            
             Substance                                                    
                     of Coats                                             
                          12                                              
                            13                                            
                              14                                          
                                15                                        
                                  16                                      
                                    17                                    
                                      18                                  
                                        19                                
                                          20                              
                                            21                            
__________________________________________________________________________
        45   lg. bentonite                                                
                     1                                                    
        46   lg. bentonite                                                
                     2    60*                                             
                            50*                                           
                              50*                                         
        47   lg. bentonite                                                
                     3    80*                                             
                            60*                                           
                              60*                                         
        48   sm. bentonite                                                
                     1                                                    
        49   sm. bentonite                                                
                     2                                                    
        50   sm. bentonite                                                
                     3    0**                                             
        51   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                
                     1                                                    
        52   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                
                     2    84*                                             
                            74*                                           
                              74*                                         
        53   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                
                     3    85                                              
                            85                                            
                              85                                          
                                60*                                       
                                  50*                                     
                                    30*                                   
                                       0                                  
        54   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                
                     1                                                    
        55   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                
                     2    70*                                             
                            60*                                           
                              60*                                         
        56   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                
                     3    80*                                             
                            80*                                           
                              80*                                         
                                40*                                       
                                  40*                                     
                                    40*                                   
                                      10                                  
                                        10*                               
                                          10*                             
                                            10*                           
        57   None    1                                                    
        58   None    1                                                    
__________________________________________________________________________
 *Indicates peeling.                                                      
 **Indicates coating loss.                                                
 
    
     EXAMPLES 59-62 
     After the four different batches of tributyltin chloride microcapsules prepared in Examples 3-16 above had been stored for four months, four marine paint compositions were prepared by mixing each of the batches with the vinyl rosin paint base at a concentration of about 14 percent by weight based on the total paint composition. A single coat of each of the four paint compositions was then brushed onto four sanded fiberglas panels and immersed in accordance with the procedure set forth in Examples 3-16 above. The percent overall performance at monthly intervals for these four panels is set forth below in Table VII: 
     
                                           TABLE VII                               
__________________________________________________________________________
     Finely Divided                                                       
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
             Number                                                       
                  Months Immersed                                         
Number                                                                    
     Substance                                                            
             of Coats                                                     
                  1  2  3  4 5  6  7  8  9   10                           
                                                11                        
__________________________________________________________________________
59   lg. bentonite                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100  100                                          
                                100                                       
                                   100                                    
                                      100                                 
                                         100                              
                                            100                           
                                               100                        
60   sm. bentonite                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100  100                                          
                                100                                       
                                   100                                    
                                      100                                 
                                         100                              
                                            100                           
                                               100                        
61   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100  100                                          
                                100                                       
                                   100                                    
                                      100                                 
                                         100                              
                                            100                           
                                               100                        
62   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100  100                                          
                                100                                       
                                   100                                    
                                      100                                 
                                         100                              
                                            100                           
                                               100                        
__________________________________________________________________________
       Finely Divided                                                     
Example                                                                   
       Inorganic                                                          
               Number                                                     
                    Months Immersed                                       
Number Substance                                                          
               of Coats                                                   
                     12                                                   
                        13                                                
                           14                                             
                             15 16 17 18 19 20 21                         
__________________________________________________________________________
59     lg. bentonite                                                      
               1    100                                                   
                       100                                                
                          100                                             
                             100                                          
                                100                                       
                                   90 90 75 75 75                         
60     sm. bentonite                                                      
               1    100                                                   
                       100                                                
                          100                                             
                             100                                          
                                100                                       
                                   100                                    
                                      100                                 
                                         100                              
                                            100                           
                                               90                         
61     lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                      
               1    100                                                   
                       100                                                
                          100                                             
                             94 94 93 93 85 85 85                         
62     sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                      
               1     90                                                   
                        90                                                
                           90                                             
                             90 90 90 90 90 90 90                         
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     EXAMPLES 63-66 
     Microcapsules of tributyltin chloride having a size range of 1-10 μm prepared in accordance with the procedure of Example 1 except that the homogenizaton step was carried out at a higher speed were mixed with a boot top marine paint (#8223, Petit Paint Co., Inc., Belleville, N.J.). The microcapsules comprised 14 percent by weight of the total paint composition. A single coat of this paint was applied to one side of a sanded fiberglass panel and immersed pursuant to the procedures set forth in Examples 3-16 above (Example 63). 
     A second marine paint composition was prepared by mixing 14 percent by weight of these microcapsules, 6.9 percent by weight of liquid tributyltin chloride and 79.1 percent by weight of the boot top marine paint. A single coat of this paint was similarly applied to a sanded fiberglass panel and immersed (Example 64). Two control marine paints were also tested. The first control paint used was the boot top marine paint base without any antifoulant added. (Example 65). The second control was boot top marine paint containing liquid tributyltin chloride (Example 66). The tributyltin chloride comprised 6.9 percent by weight of the total paint composition. A single coat of each of the control paints was applied to one side of a sanded fiberglass panel. The two coated control panels were then immersed as set forth in Examples 3-16 above. The percent overall performance at monthly intervals for the four panels tested is set forth in Table VIII below: 
     
                                           TABLE VIII                              
__________________________________________________________________________
     Finely Divided                                                       
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
             Number                                                       
                  Months Immersed                                         
Number                                                                    
     Substance                                                            
             of Coats                                                     
                  1  2  3  4 5  6  7  8  9 10                             
                                             11                           
                                               12                         
                                                 13                       
                                                   14                     
                                                     15                   
                                                       16                 
__________________________________________________________________________
63   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100  100                                          
                                100                                       
                                    90                                    
                                       90                                 
                                         85                               
                                           85                             
                                             85                           
                                               80                         
                                                 75                       
                                                   75                     
                                                     75                   
                                                       70                 
64   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100  100                                          
                                100                                       
                                   100                                    
                                      100                                 
                                         93                               
                                           93                             
                                             93                           
                                               90                         
                                                 90                       
                                                   90                     
                                                     90                   
                                                       85                 
65   None    1     50                                                     
                      0                                                   
66   None    1     75                                                     
                      70                                                  
                         65   65                                          
                                 30                                       
                                    0                                     
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     EXAMPLES 67-70 
     A first batch of anti-fouling marine paint was made by adding microcapsules of tributyltin chloride prepared in Examples 63-66 above to the vinyl rosin paint base used in Examples 3-16 above in an amount equal to about 14 percent by weight based on the total weight of the composition. A single coat of this paint was applied to one side of a sanded fiberglass panel. (Example 67). A second batch was made which contained 14 percent by weight of the microcapsules and 6.9 percent by weight of liquid tributyltin chloride with the remainder being vinyl rosin base paint. A single coat of this paint was likewise applied to one side of a sanded fiberglass panel (Example 68). The vinyl rosin base paint was applied to another panel as first control paint (Example 69), and vinyl rosin base paint containing 6.9 percent by weight of liquid tributyltin chloride was applied to a fourth sanded fiberglass panel as the second control (Example 70). A single coat of the boot top marine paint used in Examples 63-66 was then applied over the four painted panels. After drying the four panels were immersed as described in Examples 3-16 above. The percent overall performance at monthly intervals for these four panels is set forth in Table IX below: 
     
                                           TABLE IX                                
__________________________________________________________________________
     Finely Divided                                                       
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
             Number                                                       
                  Months Immersed                                         
Number                                                                    
     Substance                                                            
             of Coats                                                     
                  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10 11                        
                                                  12                      
                                                    13                    
                                                      14                  
                                                        15                
                                                          16              
                                                            17            
__________________________________________________________________________
67   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1/1  100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100   100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             93 91                        
                                                  91                      
                                                    91                    
                                                      87                  
                                                        87                
                                                          16              
                                                            65            
68   sm. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1/1  100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100   100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             100                          
                                                90                        
                                                  90                      
                                                    90                    
                                                      85                  
                                                        85                
                                                          85 85           
69   None    1/1   80                                                     
                      0                                                   
70   None    1/1  95*                                                     
                      90                                                  
                         90                                               
                            90    90                                      
                                     90                                   
                                        90                                
                                           90                             
                                             84*                          
                                                84*                       
                                                  84*                     
                                                    84*                   
                                                      80                  
                                                        80                
                                                          70 60           
__________________________________________________________________________
 *Indicates blistering.                                                   
 
    
     EXAMPLES 71-74 
     Since it did not appear from any of the previous examples that there was any difference among the four batches of tributyltin chloride microcapsules prepared in Examples 3-16 above, the third batch having a size range of 10-30 μm containing Cab-O-Sil was used in all subsequent examples. 
     A marine paint composition was prepared by mixing the vinyl rosin paint base with microcapsules of tributyltin chloride which had been stored dry for nine months. The microcapsules comprised about 14 percent by weight of the total paint composition. Two sanded fiberglass panels were each painted with two coats of this paint composition. One of these panels was additionally painted with a single coat of the boot top marine paint used in Examples 63-66 (Example 72). As controls, a third and fourth panel were each painted with two coats of a paint composition comprising the rosin vinyl base paint and 6.9 percent by weight of liquid tributyltin chloride based on the total paint composition. One of these panels was also painted with a single coat of the boot top marine paint (Example 74). These four panels were immersed as described in Examples 3-16 above and the percent overall performance at monthly intervals for each of them is set forth in Table X below: 
     
                                           TABLE X                                 
__________________________________________________________________________
     Finely Divided                                                       
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
             Number                                                       
                  Months Immersed                                         
Number                                                                    
     Substance                                                            
             of Coats                                                     
                  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9                               
__________________________________________________________________________
71   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
72   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2/1  100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
73   None    2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
74   None    2/1  100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
__________________________________________________________________________
       Finely Divided                                                     
Example                                                                   
       Inorganic                                                          
               Number                                                     
                    Months Immersed                                       
Number Substance                                                          
               of Coats                                                   
                     10                                                   
                        11                                                
                           12                                             
                              13                                          
                                 14                                       
                                    15                                    
                                       16                                 
                                          17                              
__________________________________________________________________________
71     lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                      
               2    100                                                   
                       100                                                
                          100                                             
                             100                                          
                                100                                       
                                   100                                    
                                      100                                 
                                         100                              
72     lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                      
               2/1  100                                                   
                       100                                                
                          100                                             
                             100                                          
                                100                                       
                                   100                                    
                                      100                                 
                                         100                              
73     None    2    100                                                   
                       100                                                
                          100                                             
                             100                                          
                                100                                       
                                   100                                    
                                      100                                 
                                         80                               
74     None    2/1  100                                                   
                        90                                                
                           80                                             
                              75                                          
                                 60                                       
                                    55                                    
                                       55                                 
                                         55                               
__________________________________________________________________________
 
    
     EXAMPLES 75-86 
     A series of marine paint compositions were prepared and tested to investigate the stability of the microencapsulated anti-fouling agent. A batch of microcapsules of tributyltin chloride stored less than one week was mixed into the vinyl rosin base paint described in Examples 3-16 in an amount equal to about 14 percent by weight based on the total paint composition. Six sanded fiberglass panels were painted with this paint composition. Two of panels were painted with one coat, two were painted with two coats and two were painted with three coats. Three of the panels having one, two and three coats, respectively, were immersed as described in Examples 3-16 above (Examples 75-77) and the remaining three panels were additionally painted with a single coat of boot top marine paint and then immersed (Examples 78-80). 
     Four other sanded fiberglass panels were painted with a marine paint composition comprising the vinyl rosin paint base and about 14 percent by weight of microcapsules of tributyltin chloride based on the total composition (Examples 81-84). The marine paint composition containing the microcapsules had been stored for 11 months prior to application to the panels. One of the panels was painted with one coat, two were coated with two coats, and one was coated with three coats. One of the panels painted with two coats was additionally painted with a single coat of boot top marine paint over the other two coats (Example 84). These four panels were then immersed as described in Examples 3-16 above. 
     Another marine paint composition was prepared by mixing vinyl rosin base paint with about 14 percent by weight of microcapsules of tributyltin chloride based on the total composition. The microcapsules had been stored dry for 14 months prior to mixing into the paint. Two sanded fiberglass panels were each painted with two coats of this marine paint composition. One of these panels was additionally painted with a single coat of boot top marine paint (Example 86). These two panels were likewise immersed as described in Examples 3-16. The percent overall performance at monthly intervals for each of the twelve panels just described is set forth in Table XI below: 
     
                                           TABLE XI                                
__________________________________________________________________________
     Finely Divided                                                       
Example                                                                   
     Inorganic                                                            
             Number                                                       
                  Months Immersed                                         
Number                                                                    
     Substance                                                            
             of Coats                                                     
                  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9   10                          
                                                 11                       
__________________________________________________________________________
75   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                     90                                   
                                        80                                
                                           80                             
                                              80                          
                                                 80                       
76   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             100                          
                                                100                       
77   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             100                          
                                                100                       
78   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1/1  100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             100                          
                                                 82                       
79   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2/1  100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             100                          
                                                100                       
80   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3/1  100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             100                          
                                                100                       
81   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             1    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                     94                                   
                                        94                                
                                           89                             
                                              89                          
                                                 80                       
82   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             100                          
                                                100                       
83   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             3    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             100                          
                                                100                       
84   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2/1  100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             100                          
                                                100                       
85   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2    100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                       100                                
                                          100                             
                                             100                          
                                                100                       
86   lg. Cab-O-Sil                                                        
             2/1  100                                                     
                     100                                                  
                        100                                               
                           100                                            
                              100                                         
                                 100                                      
                                    100                                   
                                        92                                
                                           92                             
                                              92                          
                                                 92                       
__________________________________________________________________________