Photographic processes and products
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
     This application relates generally to photography and, more particularly, to a multicolor diffusion transfer photographic system. 
     Diffusion transfer photographic systems wherein images are formed in color by the use of dye developers are well known in the art. Generally, multicolor transfer images are formed by processing an exposed multicolor photosensitive silver halide element with a processing composition distributed between two sheet-like elements, one of the elements including an image receiving layer. The processing composition is so applied and confined within and between the two sheet-like elements as not to contact or wet outer surfaces of the two superposed elements, thus providing a film unit whose external surfaces are dry. The processing composition, which may be viscous or non-viscous, preferably is distributed in viscous form from a pressure rupturable container. Such pressure-rupturable processing composition containers are commonly referred to as &#34;pods&#34;. 
     Multicolor diffusion transfer images may be obtained using dye developers by several techniques. A particularly useful technique employs an integral multilayer photosensitive element such as is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 2,893,606 and in U.S. Pat. No. 3,345,163 wherein at least two selectively sensitized photosensitive strata, superposed on a common support, are processed, simultaneously and without separation, with a single (common) image-receiving layer. A suitable arrangement of this type for obtaining multicolor images utilizing subtractive color principles comprises a support carrying a red-sensitive silver halide emulsion stratum, a green-sensitive silver halide emulsion stratum and a blue-sensitive silver halide emulsion stratum, said emulsions having associated therewith, respectively, a cyan dye developer, a magenta dye developer and a yellow dye developer. The dye developer may be positioned in the silver halide emulsion stratum, for example in the form of particles, or it may be disposed in a stratum behind the appropriate silver halide emulsion stratum with respect to the exposing light. Each set of silver halide emulsion and associated dye developer strata may be separated from other sets by suitable interlayers, for example, by a layer or stratum of gelatin, polyvinyl alcohol, or other polymeric materials known in the art. In certain instances, it may be desirable to incorporate a yellow filter in front of the green-sensitive emulsion to avoid improper exposure of said emulsion, by blue light, and such a yellow filter may be incorporated in the appropriately positioned interlayer. However, such a separate yellow filter may be omitted where a yellow dye developer of the appropriate spectral characteristics is present in a quantity and state capable of functioning as the requisite yellow filter. Procedures and suitable components for preparing such integral multicolor photosensitive elements are described in numerous patents and are well known in the art. 
     Following photoexposure, the photosensitive element is processed by application of a processing composition, for example, by immersion, coating, spraying, flowing, etc., in the dark. The exposed photosensitive element may be superposed prior to, during, or after application of the processing composition on a sheet-like element which may include an image-receiving layer. In one commercial embodiment, the processing composition is applied to the photosensitive element in a substantially uniform layer as the photosensitive element is brought into superposed relationship with the image-receiving layer. The liquid processing composition permeates the layers of the photosensitive element to initiate and effect development of the latent images contained therein. The dye developers are immobilized or precipitated imagewise in developed areas as a consequence of and in proportion to the silver halide development. This immobilization is, at least in part, due to a change in the solubility characteristics of the dye developers upon oxidation and especially as regards its solubility in alkaline solution. In undeveloped and partially developed areas of the silver halide emulsion layers, the respective unoxidized (unreacted) dye developers are diffusible. Development thus provides an imagewise distribution of unoxidized dye developer, diffusible in the alkaline processing composition, as a function of the point-to-point degree of exposure of a silver halide emulsion layer. At least part of each of these imagewise distributions of unoxidized dye developer is transferred by imbibition to a superposed image-receiving layer, said transfer substantially excluding oxidized dye developer. The image-receiving layer receives a depthwise diffusion, from each developed silver halide emulsion, of unoxidized dye developer without appreciably disturbing the imagewise distribution thereof to provide a reversed or positive color image of each developed silver image. The image-receiving layer may contain a mordant and/or other agent to immobilize the dye developer transferred thereto. If the color of a transferred dye developer is affected by changes in the pH of the image-receiving layer, this pH may be adjusted in accordance with well known techniques to provide a pH affording the desired color. In the preferred embodiments of U.S. Pat. No. 2,983,606 and in certain commercial applications thereof, the desired positive multicolor image is viewed by separating the image-receiving layer from the photosensitive element at the end of a suitable imbibition period. 
     In another commercial application of the dye developer process the image-receiving layer is not separated from its superposed relationship with the photosensitive layers subsequent to formation of the transfer image. Instead the color image is viewed through a transparent support. The &#39;606 patent discloses such an embodiment wherein the processing composition includes a white pigment, such as titanium dioxide, in an amount effective to mask or &#34;hide&#34; from view the developed silver halide emulsions now positioned behind the image-receiving layer when the image-receiving layer is viewed through the transparent support. 
     U.S. Pat. No. 3,415,644 discloses and claims photographic products and processes wherein a photosensitive element and an image-receiving element are maintained in fixed, superposed relationship prior to exposure and this relationship is maintained as a laminate after processing and transfer image formation. The multicolor transfer image is viewed through a transparent (support) sheet against a reflecting, i.e., white, background. Photoexposure is made through said transparent support and the layers carried thereon, including the image-receiving layer, and application of the processing composition provides a layer of light-reflecting material to provide a white background. The light-reflecting material (referred to in said patent as an &#34;opacifying agent&#34;) is preferably titanium dioxide but a number of other materials have been disclosed as useful. In addition to providing a masking layer so the transfer image may be viewed without interference by the images in the developed silver halide emulsions, the light-reflecting material also performs an opacifying function by reflecting ambient light passing through the image-receiving layer and its transparent support when the photoexposed film unit is removed from the camera before transfer image formation is completed, thereby acting to protect the photoexposed silver halide emulsions from post-exposure fogging by such light. 
     U.S. Pat. No. 3,647,437 is concerned with improvements in the above-mentioned processes, and discloses the provision of a light-absorbing material, sometimes referred to as an optical filter agent, to permit such processes to be performed outside of the camera in which photoexposure is effected and to be so performed under much more intense ambient light conditions. The light-absorbing material or optical filter agent, preferably a dye, is so positioned in the film unit and/or constituted as not to interfere with photoexposure (by absorbing light during photoexposure) but so positioned between the photoexposed silver halide emulsions and the transparent support during processing after photoexposure as to absorb light which otherwise might fog the photoexposed emulsions. Furthermore, the light-absorbing material is so constituted and/or positioned after processing as not to interfere with viewing the desired image in its proper colors shortly after said image has been formed. In the preferred embodiments, the optical filter agent is a dye and is initially contained in the processing composition together with a light-reflecting material, e.g., titanium dioxide. The concentration of this light-absorbing dye is selected to provide the light transmission opacity required to perform the particular process under the selected light conditions, and a plurality of such dyes selected to together provide absorption over the visible spectrum is utilized in multicolor embodiments. 
     In a particularly useful embodiment, the light-absorbing dye is highly colored at the pH of the processing composition, e.g., 13-14, but is substantially non-absorbing of visible light at a lower pH, e.g., less than 10-12. This pH reduction may be effected by an acid-reacting reagent appropriately positioned in the film unit, e.g., in a layer between the transparent support and the image-receiving layer. Suitable acid-reacting reagents, preferably polymeric acids, are disclosed in the &#39;644 and &#39;437 patents. 
     Suitable materials for use as image-receiving layers are disclosed in the aforementioned patents. The image-receiving layers may comprise polyvinyl alcohol or gelatin containing a dye mordant such as poly-4-vinylpyridine as is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 3,148,061. 
     As disclosed in the previously cited patents, the liquid processing composition referred to for effecting multicolor diffusion transfer processes comprises at least an aqueous solution of an alkaline material, for example, sodium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide, and the like, and preferably possesses a pH in excess of 12, and most preferably includes a viscosity-increasing compound constituting a film-forming material of the type which, when the composition is spread and dried, forms a relatively firm and relatively stable film. Preferred film-forming materials comprise high molecular weight polymers such as polymeric, water-soluble ethers, for example, a hydroxyethyl cellulose or sodium carboxymethyl cellulose, which are substantially inert in alkaline solution. Other film-forming materials or thickening agents whose ability to increase viscosity is unimpaired if left in alkaline solution for extended periods of time also may be used. The film-forming material is preferably contained in the processing composition in such suitable quantities as to impart to the composition a viscosity appropriate for the particular method of application to be used, such viscosity being in excess of 100 cps, at a temperature of approximately 24° C. and preferably in the order of 100,000 cps. to 200,000 cps. at that temperature. 
     Dye developers are well known in the art and are compounds which contain both a silver halide developing function and the chromophoric system of a dye. By &#34;a silver halide developing function&#34; is meant a grouping adapted to develop exposed silver halide. The dye developer as incorporated in the photosensitive element may have a &#34;latent&#34; silver halide developing function, i.e., the dye developer may contain a moiety which is a precursor of the silver halide developing function or moiety, the active functional group being formed in situ following application of the processing composition, e.g., by alkaline hydrolysis of an esterified hydroquinonyl group. A preferred silver halide developing function is a hydroquinonyl group. Other particularly useful developing functions include orthodihydroxyphenyl and ortho- and para-amino substituted hydroxyphenyl groups. In general, the developing function includes a benzenoid silver halide developing function, that is, an aromatic silver halide developing group which forms quinonoid or quinone substances when oxidized. The dye developers usually are selected for their ability to provide colors useful in carrying out subtractive color photography, e.g., cyan, magenta and yellow. Other colors, of course, may be provided to meet the needs of a particular system. 
     In such multicolor applications of diffusion transfer color processes, variations in manufacturing conditions may result in undesirable variations in the sensitometric response, e.g., speed or contrast, of one silver halide emulsion relative to that of either or both of the other silver halide emulsions. Such undesirable variations may be reflected in changes of the H and D curve of, for example, the red record relative to the H and D curves of the green and blue records and may be manifested in the ultimate multicolor image as a shift in color balance, for example, toward the red. 
     U.S. Pat. No. 3,899,331 discloses a technique for reducing or avoiding such effects by performing the process in the presence of pyrazolo (3,4-d) pyrimidine compounds. The present application relates to the use of cyclic ligands in diffusion transfer photographic products and processes to improve the sensitometric response of a multicolor photosensitive element. 
     SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
     It is therefore the object of this invention to provide a novel diffusion transfer multicolor photographic system wherein a plurality of exposed silver halide emulsions are developed in the presence of cyclic ligands. 
     It is another object of this invention to provide a novel multicolor diffusion transfer system wherein the red, green or blue H and D curve may be preferentially shifted. 
     It is a further object to provide a novel multicolor diffusion transfer photographic system wherein the color saturation of an individual color in the final photographic reproduction may be increased. 
     Another object is to provide novel multicolor diffusion transfer products and processes. 
     BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
     These and other objects and advantages are accomplished in accordance with the invention by providing a multicolor diffusion transfer photographic system for forming multicolor dye developer transfer images wherein an exposed multilayer photosensitive element is processed in the presence of a cyclic ligand represented by the formula ##STR2## wherein R is hydrogen, alkyl or hydroxylakyl, preferably lower alkyl or hydroxyalkyl having from 1 to 3 carbon atoms such as hydroxyethyl and 2-hydroxypropyl; m is an integer of from 3 to 10 and n is 0 or an integer of from 1 to 3 with the proviso that the sum of m and n is not greater than 10.  The number of carbon atoms in the alkyl or hydroxyalkyl group as defined above should be sufficiently small such that the liquid may be dissolved in an alkaline processing composition and diffuse into the photosensitive element at a useful rate. Larger or other substituents may also be present provided the ligand may be dissolved and diffuse at a useful rate during processing. 
     It has been found that by processing an exposed multilayer photosensitive element in the presence of the cyclic ligands within the formula set forth above it is possible to shift the speed of an individual silver halide emulsion of the photosensitive element and/or to increase the color saturation of an individual color in the multicolor diffusion transfer image. 
    
    
     BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS 
     For a better understanding of the invention as well as other objects and further features thereof, reference is made to the following detailed description of various preferred embodiments thereof taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings wherein: 
     FIG. 1 is a reproduction of the characteristic curves of the red, green and blue densities of a multicolor transfer image obtained in a control experiment; and 
     FIG. 2 is a reproduction of the characteristic curves of the red, green and blue densities of a multicolor diffusion transfer image obtained in accordance with one embodiment of the invention. 
    
    
     DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS 
     The preferred cyclic ligands which are utilized in accordance with the invention are represented by the following structural formulas: ##STR3## 
     The cyclic ligands which are utilized according to invention may be prepared by reactions which are well knwn in the art. See, for example, C. J. Pedersen, Jour. Amer. Chem. Soc., 89, 7017 (1967). In addition many of these materials are commercially available. Accordingly, techniques for preparing the ligands need not be discussed here. 
     The cyclic ligands may be incorporated in various locations within the multicolor diffusion transfer photographic film units of the invention. It is preferred to incorporate the ligands in the processing composition. Although the ligands may be present in any useful amount, generally these materials are incorporated in the processing composition in an amount of from about 0.25% to about 4% by weight and preferably from about 1% to about 2% by weight. It is preferred to incorporate the ligands in the processing composition so that they will be in solution when development is initiated. Where a delay in the availability of some or all of the ligand is desired an appropriate amount may be located initially in a layer of the film unit, the time required to dissolve and diffuse from that location thus providing the desired delay. 
     It has been found that the cyclic ligands which are used according to the invention are effective to shift the speed of the individual silver halide emulsions of the multilayer dye developer photosensitive element and, further, that the speed shift may be effected as a function of the concentration of the ligands. For example, the H and D curve of the green record of the multicolor diffusion transfer image may be shifted toward the H and D curves of the blue and red records of the image so as to provide improved color balance. Thus in such an instance the effect would be manifested in the ultimate multicolor image as a shift in color balance toward the magenta record. It has been found also that a desirable increase in the saturation of a particular color may be obtained according to the invention. For example, in areas of the film which have not received any green light exposure and where, therefore, the fullest possible transfer of green light absorbing image dye developer (the magenta dye developer) is desired, the presence of the ligands may effect an increase in the amount of this dye developer which is transferred. Such an increase in the amount of dye developer transferred to the image-receiving layer can be measured as the &#34;reflected green density on the toe of the magenta column&#34; of a photographic test target commonly used for such testing or such an increase may be referred to as an increase in the saturation of a particular color, in this illustrative example, &#34;magenta saturation.&#34; 
     In general, a shift in the speed of one of the silver halide emulsions of a multicolor photosensitive element and/or the increase in the saturation of a particular color in the ultimate multicolor image may be obtained through the use of additional alkali content in the processing composition. Thus, the effects obtained through the use of the ligands according to the invention are, in some respects, akin to those obtained by increasing the alkali content of the processing composition. However, increasing the alkali content of the processing composition is not without at least one important disadvantage. It has been found that the use of additional alkali in the processing composition to provide a speed shift for the silver halide emulsion or to increase the saturation of a particular color in the ultimate image can cause a substantial increase in the D min  of the image when the film is processed at a relatively high temperature, for example, about 35° C. or more. Such an effect is, of course, undesirable. 
     Experimentation has shown that the use of the cyclic ligands according to the invention can provide the desired speed shift and/or increased color saturation without any substantial increase in D min  when processing is carried out at such elevated temperatures. 
     It has also been found according to the invention that the preferred ligand in any particular instance is dependent primarily upon which dominant metal cation is present in the processing composition. For example, it was found that a processing composition whose dominant metal cation is the relatively small sodium ion exhibits the maximum response in terms of green speed shift and magenta saturation with the small cyclic ligand I whereas a composition whose dominant metal cation is the larger rubidium ion exhibits little sensitometric response until the relatively larger cyclic ligand V is used in conjunction therewith. Thus, optimum response may be obtained by choosing the ligand with respect to the dominant metal cation present in a particular processing composition. 
     The surprising effects obtained through the use of the ligands according to the invention are not well understood. However, in order to better aid those skilled in the art to understand and practice the invention the proposed theoretical mechanism by which the advantageous results are thought to be effected will be discussed here. It should be noted however that the invention has been proved to be operable and highly effective through actual experimentation and the proposed theoretical mechanism is not to be construed as being limiting of the invention. The pattern of performance observed through experimentation suggests that the advantageous effects obtained according to the invention are related to the tendency of the cyclic ligands to form strong complexes with metal cations. This characteristic of the cyclic ligands is disclosed, for example, in the article by C. J. Pedersen cited above herein and J. J. Christensen et al, Chem. Rev. 74, 351 (1974). It is believed that the advantageous effects obtained according to the invention are due, at least in part, to the formation of a complex between the alkali metal cation and the ligand as a result of which the associated hydroxide ion is rendered more reactive. Such an explanation is consistent with the observation that the sensitometric advantages obtained by the use of the ligands are similar in some ways to the effects noted when the hydroxide concentration in the processing composition is increased as was referred to above. 
     The sensitometric response of any multicolor diffusion transfer film unit may be altered according to the invention. Particularly preferred film units according to the present invention are those diffusion transfer integral negative-positive film units of the type described in detail in U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,415,644, 3,594,165 and 3,647,437. Other preferred film units are those which are designed to be separated after processing such as those described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 2,893,606 and 3,345,163. Extensive discussion of the film units of the invention is not required in view of the state of the art. For convenience the entire disclosure of each of the five patents listed immediately above is hereby incorporated by reference herein. 
     The invention will now be described further in detail with respect to specific preferred embodiments by way of examples, it being understood that there are intended to be illustrative only and the invention is not intended to be limited to the materials, conditions, process parameters, etc., recited therein. All parts and percentages are by weight unless otherwise indicated. 
     EXAMPLE I 
     As a control the following experiment was carried out. A film unit was prepared as follows: the negative element was prepared by coating a gelatin-subcoated 4-mil opaque polyethylene terephthalate photographic film base with the following layers, in succession: 
     1. a layer of a cyan dye developer represented by the formula ##STR4## dispersed in gelatin and coated at a coverage of about 742 mg/m 2  of dye and 1485 mg/m 2  of gelatin and including 68 mg/m 2  of 4&#39;-methyl phenyl hydroquinone and about 270 mg/m 2  of 2-phenylbenzimidazole; 
     2. a red sensitive gelatino silver iodobromo emulsion coated at a coverage of about 1291 mg/m 2  of silver and about 775 mg/m 2  of gelatin; 
     3. an interlayer of a 60-30-4-6 tetrapolymer of butyl acrylate, diacetone acrylamide, styrene and methacrylic acid at a coverage of about 2505 mg/m 2  of the tetrapolymer and about 77 mg/m 2  pf polyacrylamide; 
     4. a layer of a magenta dye developer represented by the formula ##STR5## dispersed in gelatin and coated at a coverage of about 646 mg/m 2  of the dye developer, about 452 mg/m 2  of gelatin and including about 226 mg/m 2  of 2-phenylbenzimidazole; 
     5. a green sensitive gelatino silver iodobromo emulsion coated at a coverage of about 796 mg/m 2  of silver and about 387 mg/m 2  of gelatin; 
     6. an interlayer including about 1365 mg/m 2  of the tetrapolymer described in layer 3, about 87 mg/m 2  of polyacrylamide and about 71 mg/m 2  of succinaldehyde; 
     7. a layer of a yellow dye developer represented by the formula 
     
         ______________________________________                                    
 ##STR6##                                                                 
Potassium hydroxide                                                       
(45% solution in water)      11.67 g                                      
N-Phenethyl-α-picolinium bromide                                    
(50% solution in water)      2.54 g                                       
Titanium dioxide             37.40 g                                      
Carboxymethyl hydroxyethyl cellulose                                      
                             1.99 g                                       
N-2-Hydroxyethyl-N,N&#39;,N&#39;-                                                 
tris carboxymethyl ethylene diamine                                       
                             0.75 g                                       
Polyethylene glycol (MW 4000)                                             
                             0.45 g                                       
Benzotriazole                0.55 g                                       
4-Aminopyrazolo (3,4-d) pyrimidine                                        
                             0.25 g                                       
6-Methyluracil               0.70 g                                       
Bis-2-benzimidazolylmethyl sulfide                                        
                             0.04 g                                       
Colloidal silica (30% aqueous dispersion)                                 
                             1.85 g                                       
 ##STR7##                    0.30 g                                       
 ##STR8##                    1.35 g                                       
Water to make a total of     100 g                                        
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     The film unit was then exposed (2 meter candle seconds) on a sensitometer to a photographic test exposure scale, or step wedge, through the transparent support of the image-receiving element and processed with the processing composition by passing the film unit through a pair of pressure follers at a gap spacing of about 0.0030 inch (about 76 microns). The film unit was retained intact and viewed through the transparent base. There was obtained a well developed image. 
     The neutral density column of the multicolor transfer image was measured on a densitometer to obtain the D max  and D min  values for red, blue and green, respectively. The reflection density vs the log exposure curves for red, blue and green are illustrated in FIG. 1. In addition, the speed of the green curve (defined as the negative log of the relative exposure required to give green absorption in the neutral column a reflection density of 0.75) and the green density in the toe of the magenta column were measured. The values are shown in Table I below. It will be seen that in this control example the film is initially balanced to neutral. 
     EXAMPLE IA 
     The control experiment described in Example 1 was repeated. 
     EXAMPLE II 
     The procedure described in Example I was repeated with the exception that the processing composition further included 2.0 g of ligand II. The reflection density vs the log exposure curves for the red, blue and green are illustrated in FIG. 2. It is apparent that the presence of ligand II was effective to shift the speed of the green curve of the neutral density column in the magenta direction, i.e., the speed of the green curve was decreased by the presence of ligand II. 
     EXAMPLES III-V 
     The experiment as described in Example I was repeated with the exception that the processing composition further included 2.0 g of ligands I, III, and VI respectively. 
     
                       TABLE I                                                     
______________________________________                                    
                   Relative     Green Density                             
Example  Ligand    Green Speed  In Magenta Toe                            
______________________________________                                    
I        --        1.45         0.85                                      
Ia       --        1.44         0.81                                      
II       II        1.39         1.06                                      
III      I         1.36         1.02                                      
IV       III       1.33         1.19                                      
V        VI        1.42         1.02                                      
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     These results clearly illustrate that the presence of the ligands in the processing composition is effective to shift the speed of the green curve of the neutral density column and also to increase simultaneously the magenta saturation in the magenta color column. 
     EXAMPLE VI 
     A. The experiment described in Example II was repeated with the exceptions that the potassium hydroxide in the processing composition was replaced by an equimolar amount of rubidium hydroxide and ligand IV was substituted in place of ligand II. 
     B. As a control the experiment of Example VIA was repeated except that ligand IV was omitted from the processing composition. The resulting speeds of the green curves from the neutral density columns of the multicolor transfer images and the green densities in the toes of the magenta columns are indicated in Table II. 
     EXAMPLE VII 
     A. The experiment of Example II was repeated except that the potassium hydroxide in the processing composition was replaced by an equimolar amount of sodium hydroxide. 
     B. As a control the experiment of Example VIIA was repeated except that ligand II was omitted from the processing composition. The green speeds and the magenta saturations of the prints are shown in Table II. 
     
                       TABLE II                                                    
______________________________________                                    
                   Relative     Green Density                             
Example  Lingand   Green Speed  In Magenta Toe                            
______________________________________                                    
VI A     IV        1.44         0.59                                      
VI B     --        1.70         0.41                                      
VII A    II        1.36         1.09                                      
VII B    --        1.50         0.89                                      
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     These results clearly indicate that the presence of the ligands in processing compositions having rubidium hydroxide and sodium hydroxide, respectively, are effective to shift the speed of the green curves of the neutral density columns and also to increase simultaneously the magenta saturations of the magenta columns. 
     EXAMPLE VIII 
     This example illustrates the sensitometric effects of the alkali level in the processing composition at both 23° C. and 35° C. and compares these sensitometric effects with those obtained according to the invention under the same conditions. 
     The control experiment described in Example IA was repeated with the following modifications of the processing composition: 
     A. No modification 
     B. 14% more KOH 
     C. 2% of ligand II present 
     D. 2% of ligand III present 
     In each instance processing was carried out at 23° C. From the respective multicolor transfer images there were recorded the speed of the green curve from the neutral density column and the green density from the toe of the magenta column. In addition, processing was carried out in each instance at 35° C. and the red D min  of the respective multicolor images recorded. The results are listed in Table III. 
     
                       TABLE III                                                   
______________________________________                                    
            23° C.                                                 
       Processing            Magenta 35° C.                        
Example                                                                   
       Composition                                                        
                  Green Speed                                             
                             Saturation                                   
                                     Red Dmin                             
______________________________________                                    
VIII A --         1.55       0.90    0.28                                 
       Additional                                                         
VIII B 14% KOH    1.51       1.01    0.36                                 
VIII C Ligand II  1.50       1.04    0.28                                 
VIII D Ligand III 1.51       1.06    0.28                                 
______________________________________                                    
 
    
     It is clearly apparent from these results that the addition of more potassium hydroxide to the processing composition is effective to both shift the green speed and increase magenta saturation. However, the use of additional alkali to effect these desirable changes also has the undesirable effect of significantly increasing the red D min  when processing is carried out at 35° C. On the other hand the use of the ligands according to the invention brings about the desirable green speed and magenta saturation changes without any undesired increase in the red D min  for processing at 35° C. 
     Although the invention has been described with respect to various preferred embodiments it is not intended to be limited thereto but rather those skilled in the art will recognize that variations and modifications may be made therein which are within the spirit of the invention and the scope of the appended claims.