premise: USS "Ludlow" (DD-438), a "Gleaves"-class destroyer , was the third ship of the United States Navy to bear the name. The second and third "Ludlow" ships were named for Lieutenant Augustus C. Ludlow, second in command of USS "Chesapeake" . He was, like his captain, mortally wounded in their ship's engagement with HMS "Shannon" on 1 June 1813, and died at Halifax, Nova Scotia on 13 June.
hypothesis: Lieutenant Augustus C. Ludlow died at Halifax on 13 June 1812.
reason: Lieutenant Augustus C. Ludlow died on 13 June 1813 after the battle on 1 June 1813, not in 1812.  He could not have died before a battle that he was in.  Since the context did not print the year of his death directly with the day of death, the system did not understand that the mortally wounded Lieutenant Ludlow  would have died just days after the battle.