premise: "All My Life" is a song by the American band Foo Fighters, released as the first single from their fourth album, "One by One". The song won a Grammy Award for Best Hard Rock Performance, and spent ten straight weeks at number 1 on the Hot Modern Rock Tracks chart and it peaked at number 3 on the Hot Mainstream Rock Tracks chart. It was also a top 5 hit on the UK Singles Chart.
hypothesis: All My Life was a popular song
reason: An award-winning song that spent 10 straight weeks on the charts, etc., was by definition popular at that time