premise: "We Really Shouldn't Be Doing This" is a song written by Jim Lauderdale, and recorded by American country music artist George Strait. It was released in September 1998 as the third and final single from his album "One Step at a Time". It peaked at number 4 in the United States, and number 2 in Canada.
hypothesis: Jim Lauderdale is an American country song writer.
reason: I think it is neither incorrect nor correct because it doesn't state that he is American, just that it was recorded by an American artist.  I think it was difficult for the system because it just assumed based on who recorded it.