premise: Hudepohl Brewing Company is a brewery established in Cincinnati, Ohio in 1885 by founder Ludwig Hudepohl II. Hudepohl was the son of Bavarian immigrants and had worked in the surgical tool business before starting his brewery. Hudepohl combined with Schoenling Brewing Company in 1986. Today, the Hudepohl-Schoenling Brewing Company is a wholly owned subsidiary of Christian Moerlein Brewing Co..
hypothesis: The Schoenling Brewing Company was established after the Hudepohl Brewing Company.
reason: There is no indication of when the Schoenling Brewing Company was established, only when it combined with the Hudepohl Brewing Company.  Thus the statement could be correct or incorrect.  I assume the agent is confused by the date of 1986, when the two companies combined and doesn't understand that Schoenling could have existed for a long time before that.