premise: Old Carthusians Football Club is an association football club whose players are former pupils of Charterhouse School in Godalming, Surrey, England. The club was established in 1876 and won the FA Cup in 1881, as well as the FA Amateur Cup in 1894 and 1897. The club currently plays in the Arthurian League and won league and Arthur Dunn Cup doubles in 2006, 2008, 2009, 2011, 2013 and 2014.
hypothesis: The Club did not play in the Arthurian League in 2005.
reason: The original statement does not say that they tried to win in all years, so they could have not played in 2005. Although they probably did. There is not enough information to definitely say for sure.