Why Geralt made that Wish ? Cause of fear for Rinde ? Nope . Cause he wanted to use Yen in his own plans ? Nope . Cause he had just sympathy to Yennefer ? Again nope . Cause he completely fell in love with her ? Absolutely . He realized whom she was before sorceress poor hunkback girl and didn ' t give a f about it . He realized how rude and mean Yennefer is on that moment and didn ' t give a f about it . He realized that he needs to smell her perfume , to follow her , to be with her . A minute passion ? No , it ' s possible only because love was born . book facts . If look carefully we can find that in the books and the games Love is something parallel and uncontrollable for Magic . Love even can break it , break the powerful magical curses . Remember Nivellen from the books , remember Graham and Annabelle from the last game . True Love literally can everything in The Witcher . And when love is so strong and uncontrollable you think that someone can fake it ? Witcher II Flashbacks . This point is about possibility of Yennefer and Geralt happiness . What we have ? Geralt and Yennefer after Ciri ' d left them had a really peaceful and cozy life at an island full of apples legendary Avalon . And only Wild Hunt violated their peace and did separate them . Fact . Before the release of Wild Hunt we knew that possibility of spell could be real Not because Geralt didn ' t love , because we didn ' t know how real Yen ' s feeling is And The Last Wish Quest . Hurrah ! No we ' ll break the spell and get free ! Aand baaang ! But what ' s happened ? Geralt , nothing ' s changed . Yen loved him with a real love too . Weird to argue that fact . And if Geralt fell in love with Yen by his own and she still loves himDoes it mean that love live ? Love lives . I know it ' s hard when you already fall in love with a character and suddenly arrives someone another . But that ' s a time when we don ' t have a choice in standard game notion . We have choices for ourselves . I can choose for myself . You can choose for yourself . But Geralt chose what he wants many years ago . And there are no facts to say that it ' s false .