I say Lions because the Vikings are 44 in conference and the Lions are 42 . That might come into play for a tie breaker . Currently the Bucs are 43 in the conference . <| sep |> The problem with demanding testable objective arguments in film criticism is that art is subjective . The way we interpret and absorb art varies from person to person . I ' ll try to provide you with some simple arguments for why I thought the film wasn ' t good you ' ll probably find some variation of these in most negative reviews 1 flimsily constructed first half . The scenes are placed in this haphazard order that prevents any sort of momentum from building . I ' ll give you an example there ' s a scene where Perry White demands to know where Clark went Does he click his heels and go back to Kansas ? You would assume that the next scene would be Clark in Kansas . But the next scene involves Lois Lane , then the next involves Lex Luthor , then the next involves Batman , and THEN we cut to Superman . The movie hops around randomly to these different characters , leaving the audience little time to actually care or become invested in what ' s going on . Another good example of this is the Knightmare sequence the scene is never mentioned again after it happens , and its events don ' t effect the rest of the movie whatsoever . It doesn ' t belong in the movie . 2 boring , nonsensical action in the second half . When the disjointed , dull first half gives way to the second , we ' re treated to two overly loud , obnoxious fight scenes . The BatmanSuperman fight makes no sense why wouldn ' t Superman just explain the situation to Batman while he holds him down ? Why would he keep flicking him across the street ? The Martha moment is also extremely contrived and unbelievable I know a lot of people defend that moment but to the vast majority of people who saw the movie , it wasn ' t remotely believable . If Superman ' s mom was named Amanda would Batman have just stabbed him in the face ? The Doomsday fight is just really generic and boring it ' s just the heroes punching a giant cave troll for ten minutes . Doomsday only exists in this movie to give them something to punch . 3 Lex Luthor is a terribly written character . Eisenberg ' s twitchy , crazy Lex Luthor makes the villains in Batman ' 66 seem nuanced and subtle . Luthor and his master plan also make no sense at all why would he outfit his mercenaries in the desert with experimental weapons that can be traced back to him ? He may as well just autograph every single bullet casing . Also how does Superman know whenever Lois is in danger but have no idea that his mother is being kidnapped ? Also why would Luthor have his men bring Martha Kent to Metropolis ? Why not just hold her hostage in some underground bunker somewhere to ensure that there ' s no chance she is rescued ? Those are some basic reasons people hate the movie . I ' m happy to provide more , but these are a good starting point .