No . Even if guest right exists in this context , which I doubt , Catelyn can ' t be held responsible for Masha Heddle ' s death , which was an indirect consequence . You might as well say Robert violated guest right by asking Ned , his host at Winterfell , to be Hand , thereby setting off the chain of events that got Ned killed . <| sep |> Just because there is pie missing doesn ' t mean it was eaten . How can you prove you ate the pie when there is no evidence for it ? The pie could be anywhere and the spirit testifies to me that the pie you think you ate was actually cake and that the rest of the pie will still be discovered and revealed one day according to gods will . <| sep |> Nope . He doesn ' t want you to tell your mom because it ' s a dick move that he can ' t defend . No matter what , I would distance myself from my brother if he asked me to do something like that for such a stupid reason .