For me , the issue is mostly that people make these statements as if they and the jurors are coming from same place when they ' re not . The jurors play the game with the finalists and have their own perspectives , experiences , and relationships to the finalists to consider . We as viewers see only an edited show and confessionals . You as a viewer cast your vote in a vacuum . None of the finalists were your friends or enemies . None of them voted you out or betrayed you or saved your skin or voted to keep you when everyone else put you out . I think it ' s one thing to talk about who you wanted to win or who you think you would have voted for . I think its different to act as though you certainly would have voted for Player X and that jurors A , B , C and D did their jobs as jurors wrong by failing to vote correctly because they didn ' t vote for Player X .