The difference being , he did not smash the treat over his hand . I don ' t think that analogy is fair since there will be far more banana material on the other hand than there would be from a treat . Bananas are sticky though , if you did this with a chunk of banana without smashing it assuming the dog even wants banana some banana material would be on the other hand , and surely the dog would smell that , but a much stronger more concentrated smell is coming off the hand with the banana chunk . Both hands have a similar amount of banana coated on their hand , but one has an entire chunk of fresh banana as well . <| sep |> I ' m guessing NYC winters are like Toronto winters . And in that case , try the North Face or mountain warehouse . Both really good jacket brands . MW is a British company and doesn ' t have that many stores in North America but I bought a jacket from there last year and it kept me super warm when I went skiing up in mountains . It ' s also versatile , I wore it whenever I walked to school and didn ' t feel the cold on a super chilly 20 minute walk . Hope that helps