The demographics of Portland and Williamsburg , Brooklyn are unique insofar that they attract tons of older SJWs . Lots of people in Portland are actually OG SJWs who have self selected there from other parts of the country . You ' ve just made my point for me . If there ' s so much demographic overlap in the US then why are you trying to argue that altright is old and SJW ' s are young ? You ' ve already pointed out exceptions . I ' m trying to figure out how your reasoning leads to greater understanding . What about your thesis adds to the pool of knowledge and what point does it ultimately lead to ? You seem to be doing a lot of work to try to separate the altright and the SJW ' s into groups of oldyoung respectively , yet you are clearly aware of the exceptions that those SJW ' s are old . If those lines weren ' t blurry and there was a clear dividing line then what purpose does it serve in the long run ?