I would consider Quake Live , Quake 4 and Warsow to be as close to perfect in regards to gameplay as any game has comeFor 1 v 1 they are insanely good at the respective elements they want to emphasise . Mind games , individual skill , mental strain , strategy and decision making . I cant call them all perfect however as they still have their own flaws . Quake Live I believe gives the player too much ammo and favours defensive play too much . Quake 4 is pretty much perfect but is lacking in good duel maps Warsows mega health respawn system I think favours the incontrol player too much and makes it incredibly hard for the out of control player to time it . I also think the rail hits a little too hard compared to the max stack you can acquire and should either have an extended cooldown or lower damageAll subjective though and despite this all 3 games have excellent gameplay . They are only near perfect in my own mind though , not in the mind of the gaming world