Yes ! !! I liked her so much after that . We ' re going to prom together . <| sep |> I think I actually combined two games in my head here because Rejack is definitely most of what I ' m remembering , but not the game I ' m actually looking for ! Thanks though ! I ' m going to consider this solved until I can sort my brain out and remember the game I ' m actually looking for ! <| sep |> You don ' t mention using any lubricant at any point . Don ' t you use none ? Could also be something the condoms have , the little lubricant they come with . Maybe try a condom with your fingers . Or your fingers alone , with a glove , see if you notice anything or feel the same discomfort . The sensation you describe I had in the past with a jelly toy when it started degrading , but I also felt that way with lack of lubrication . If you feel unfomfortability at any point , you can start feeling overall uncomfortable and it will start feeling all wrong .