Does being thin really matter like I hate how they make that a selling point , does anyone actually care ? <| sep |> You ' re not wishing them good game ? What ? <| sep |> Thanks ! I ' m forever checking my local Winners that ' s all I really have near me , but I haven ' t seen anything with a drawer yet . Maybe one day I ' ll get lucky , haha <| sep |> It ' s probably because the organic one is more expensive . I am not sure how much the regular , non ultrapasteurized , milk costs at Costco because I haven ' t looked . $ 2 . 50 for a gallon sounds right . I am confident you are right . That said , what you quoted about the cream is wrong . Costco doesn ' t sell half a gallon of cream AFAIK . They sell it by the quart . but you are also right about the price . $ 10 for half a gallon of actual cream , not light cream ie diluted and not half and half . $ 10 sounds about right for 12 a gallon of cream . However , these items are almost always ultrapasteurized , like the organic milks , even if they aren ' t organic . This makes it last much longer . taste better imo too .