No thanks not a fan of disco <| sep |> Also it seems like your community needs to step up its jail game . They aren ' t scary enough . <| sep |> I SET A FLAIR BUT ITS NOT SHOWING <| sep |> Sorry , that ' s sort of what I meant , I just didn ' t explain it properly . In principle , the bedroom tax is not a bad idea , in practice , you ' re absolutely right . It was a lazily worded comment on my part . <| sep |> Feel sorry for the dudes saluting . This will be a while . <| sep |> The whole point of Space Marine recruiting worlds is that simply living on a planet like that is such hell that it is equivalent or even more punishing than being put through regimented training from birth . There ' s no reason why the regimented training shouldn ' t be about as hard , if not harder , than life on a feral world . And you make sure that they are nourished enough to become as swole as necessary . It ' s possible that ' s true , but it would require the Chapter to set up the infrastructure for that type of organisation . A Chapter ' s resources are better spent elsewhere , which is why they recruit from harsh worlds where the environment and local culture perform an equivalent purpose . It also requires infrastructure to seek out people living in obscure death worlds , observe them , and take them back , probably overseen by other Space Marines . Perhaps , although it also means that you now have a Space Marine who knows nothing about what it ' s like to be a normal citizen , living in the Imperium . Chapters are already insular and xenophobic organisations who often drift so far away from the Imperial mainstream that they become completely disconnected from the plights of common humans . A chapter that raised their recruits from birth would be even more disconnected , and possibly run a greater risk of disregarding the lives of citizens and Imperial Guard simply for being beneath them . That ' s a good point . However , this could be offset by education and some kind of leave , and you have the added benefit of only giving as much time as absolutely necessary to ensure they have empathy , which prevents poisonous thoughts from infecting them . Also , it could be useful for them to disregard necessary civilian casualties that serve the greater good .