We ' ve tried to do similar things to liberals . It just has never worked , it never takes off . You ' ll get debunked within the first two comments and then the whole thing just kind of fizzles out . No shit . <| sep |> Did you type this or did spez type this ? <| sep |> It ' s been a while since I ' ve read After Virtue , but doesn ' t MacIntyre advocate a return to an objective system of morality based on Aristotelian virtues ? In other words , regaining moral coherence is all about taking an objective look at what habits result in human flourishing and attempting to cultivate those habits on a broad scale . While that ' s certainly compatible with many religions specifically Thomistic Catholicism , it ' s not contingent upon any particular religion , or even a religious worldview . EditIn theory objective means that it would be pretty easy to implement on a universal scale in practice , you ' re right that it would be a LOT more difficult than MacIntyre makes it sound .