I can ' t remember where I read it , it would either have been here or on WotW . IIRC Sansa and Lyanna and probably others but they were the only names I recall want to punish the Karstarks and Umbers by confiscating their lands , wealth etc and giving it to the victors , which is what usually happens after a big defeat . But Jon says no it ' s not fair , let ' s not repeat the mistakes of the past but do things a better way . Maybe he uses his KINGINDANORF status to do this ? I ' ve also seen that Sansa is happy Jon leaves her in charge of Winterfell so that might make up for being overruled if that ' s how she sees it . But that might be unconnected to the KarstarkUmber bit ? I love leaks but usually we get a slow drip , drip of them rather than everything in one go . Trying to remember everything is . well , trying ! You could well be right and this plays in to any SansaArya conflict but that ' s what I think I read . confused brainistoofull face