I ' ve played both , if you count the digital version of San Juan . I like both , honestly . I am considering buying the San Juan physical version as well . They are pretty similar , but Roll has tons of little dice , plastic cups , and a bag full of tiles . It ' s a little most indepth , but not by much . Would she like it ? Hard to say . I kinda want to suggest something a little different , if that ' s OK . Legacy The Testament of Duke de Crecy . It ' s a little bit of workerplacement , and a little bit of tableaubuilding , in a way , as you build out your family tree . It has more depth than Roll , in my opinion , because you get secret objectives and you can earn points in a lot of ways . I dunno , my wife just really likes it and so do I . Love it , even . If I have to pick to play between Roll and Legacy , I go with Legacy , as long as it ' s just the two of us . My table can ' t fit more than 2 players for Legacy smallish table . Family trees take up a lot of room !