I was a blue collar democrat . emphasis on was . Just got tired of the transformation of the party to what it is now . <| sep |> Great , where ' s your evidence that she routinely goes on this loop ? I gave you four pieces of evidence that you basically wished away . Back to your points though 1 . A retrieval guy is sent in William ' s time to take her back to the ranch . This is conclusive that she is off her loop in William ' s time . 2 . That is not obvious . In fact , we see the part of her loop where she drops the can of milk in William ' s time . Hint Hint ! It ' s the same loop . 3 . How could it be part of her loop if she has no input or activity regarding the chain of events ? She ' s accompanying a guest , which is how she is able to break her loop . 4 . Again , that is her loop . If you have any flow charts from the show that explain your theorized loop , I ' d love to see it . We know it is the same loop , because we see her drop the can in William ' s time .