To S . M . EntertainmentPetition Summary ( The name S . M . Entertainment will be abbreviated to SM ) 1 . 1 . Calling themselves the fan communities of TVXQ and doing acts of what an anti - fan would do , we request that the agency ( S . M . Entertainment ) take measure for these actions from those sites , including DC Inside U - Know Yunho Gallery , and Daum Telzone TVXQ Gallery , which are the main two corresponding communities . 1 . The anti - behaviour from these sites include : calumniating one of the members of TVXQ , spreading false rumours , damaging the name value of TVXQ , encouraging conspiracies to be built up against one member / SM , and so on ( refer to attachment ) . 1 . 1 . To stop them from damaging TVXQ ’ s value and reputation in both long and short - term effects , we request that SM , who is responsible for its artists ’ management , does something about that matter . 1 . 1 . We , as TVXQ ’ s fans , promise that we will always support TVXQ and S . M . Entertainment ’ s endless prosperity , development and growth . * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ************************* As an agency which is in charge of the management system for TVXQ , we always thank you for your hard work . Furthermore , we decided that SM needs to confront the rumours that are created and spreading from specific fan communities made by individual fans that support one member of TVXQ and rebuke the other . The sites which apply to the statement above are DC Inside U - Know Yunho Gallery and Daum Telzone TVXQ Gallery . First , there is a need to think about this issue seriously . They have been calling themselves a ‘ fan community ’, but are saying things which are close to the actions of an anti - fan , and have crossed over the limit of what a fan can say to censure about their artist ’ s agency . For a long time , they have been actualising false rumours about TVXQ ’ s contract issue with SM , speaking badly of the staff of SM , making conspiracies against TVXQ being as a duo , substantially harming TVXQ ’ s activities . The levels of the contents included are serious and this should be considered carefully . The most important thing here is that the happenings listed above are slandering TVXQ ’ s reputation and image to the public . Therefore , we as TVXQ ’ s fans , felt the need for SM to come forward and act out , as this issue is above the level of what can be resolved inside a fandom itself . * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ************************* The content of what is spreading from those communities is as following : *( the names Yunho and Changmin will be abbreviated to YH and CM . )**( NOTE THAT THE TEXT BELOW IS SPEAKING FROM THE CORRESPONDING SITES ’ POINT OF VIEW EXCEPT FOR THE RED WRITING ) ** 1 . In TVXQ ’ s Japanese promotions , they ( SM ) are only focusing on Changmin . The reason for this is because CM ’ s mother is an alumnus with So - Young Nam , SM Japan ’ s Director . ( This can be called ‘ Nam - Line ’.) This leads to Yunho not getting much screen time at all in any of TVXQ ’ s Japanese DVDs , so YH ’ s fans do not need to buy it . The way how CM filmed ‘ Fly with the Gold ’ is due to having his back supported by the ‘ Nam - Line ’, therefore SM made CM film it , not YH . 2 . On the other side , SM is trying to erase / get rid of YH . S . M . Entertainment refused offers to sign a contract with drama / CF ( advertisement ) that is coming into YH as they said that they can only sign if it is together ( YH + CM ) , not YH on his own . Also , when YH had his drama schedule , SM deliberately made group ( TVXQ ) schedules to disturb YH ’ s activities . The reason why this was possible was because Team Leader Lee , who is in charge of TVXQ ’ s schedules , is a part of CM ’ s ‘ Line ’. 3 . SM is deliberately doing those things to YH as they ’ ve worried about YH getting too much popularity ( which can lead to them not having control over him in the future ) . In their 6 th Korean Album ( Catch Me ) promotions , they made YH wear clothes so that he wouldn ’ t stand out to the audience . Also , in their , 6 th Repackage Album ( Humanoids ) promotions , SM made YH ’ s bangs longer so that his eyes wouldn ’ t show . These kinds of things that SM does against YH also apply in the choreography for their 6 th Album ’ s ( and the Repackage ) songs . The choreography that YH had to dance to was a downward standardisation from CM ’ s . As well as the choreography , in their group shooting for CFs , SM is settling to not make YH look to advantage . There is evidence which Young - Pil Seo , the representative / Chief Director of ‘ Missha ’ ( a cosmetic brand which TVXQ is the model of ) , wrote on his Facebook account , that ‘ SM is very strict on things ’. From this information as a basis , we can be sure that SM is interfering with even tiny details to cause harm to YH . 4 . The size of CM ’ s fandom is much smaller than that of YH ’ s . Even though they are smaller in number , they are deliberately making communities / sites to speak badly about YH , and to falsely ‘ increase ’ their size of fandom . SM , who believed in these numbers , put YH and CM ’ s individual version on sale for the 6 th Album ‘ Catch Me ’. It is known that those CD versions were sold on a ratio of YH - 8 : CM - 2 ( * HOWEVER , THERE IS NO EVIDENCE TO PROVE THIS STATEMENT . *). Because the Black version did not sell much ( Black = CM ’ s individual version . ) , SM made YH promote the Black version when it is not even his ( YH ’ s version = Red ) , such as uploading photos with YH holding the Black version on different SNS sites . Eventually , to make up for the poor result of the Black version , SM made a “ Special Version ” of the Catch Me album , which included the stockpile of the Black version . For that reason , YH fans SHOULD NOT buy the Black version . ( There is evidence that YH fans posted on internet , such as captures of them saying that they have refunded / thrown away the albums . ) 5 . However , if you see CM ’ s fandom , it is certain that there is a connection between them and SM . CM ’ s fandoms refer to themselves as ‘ TVXQ ’ s fans ’, while trying to subtly use YH ’ s fans . All the sites which “ support ” TVXQ as a duo are CM ’ s fandom deep inside . Nevertheless , the size of CM ’ s fandom is small . The thing that is making all these happenings possible is SM ’ s supporting of CM . SM does not authenticate supports put in from YH ’ s fandom , while authenticating those from CM ’ s fandom . They even confirmed the 6 th Album Project Team ’ s support , even though they are CM ’ s individual fans ( and just are calling themselves the fans of TVXQ ) . SM always lets CM ’ s fandom know first it there are any new updates / information about TVXQ . ** For reference : ( FROM OUR POINT OF VIEW ) While they ( DC YH Gallery & Daum Telzone ) are stating that all of the happenings are closely related to SM , they are creating rumours about CM , and even his family . In DC YH Gallery , there are people protecting themselves with a nickname who wrote several pages related to CM ’ s private life and his family . The contents are found to be severely against CM , and they include false reports , with no evidence to back it up . These rumours are periodically often mentioned in Daum Telzone TVXQ Gallery , and the people have fixed the rumours to be true ( in another words , they have made themselves believe in it , forcing it to be the truth ) . This has made CM ’ s rumours spread more in result . They are indirectly saying that one of CM ’ s families is being told information / updates about TVXQ from a SM staff , and is passing that onto CM ’ s fandom ( the reason that this issue is passing around is because CM ’ s fandom ’ s gathering of information is very fast ) . They also mention about the ‘ 6 . 25 Incident ’ ( a happening which relate to people who no longer have anything to do with SM as they consented to the lawsuit challenging the validity of their contract with SM - meaning JYJ . Their parents issued orders to the fans at this incident . ) , and how CM has ‘ learnt a lot from that time ’ ( using sarcasm ) . This is another example of a groundless supposition . They do not DIRECTLY say it using the exact terms , but the fact that they say what they like without taking responsibility makes it worse . In addition to this , they have been writing posts stating that they are the parties concerned , trying to create more reliability on the rumour of YH being unfairly treated . Referring back to 2 . , the rumour that SM stopped YH taking solo CF shoots has been also confirmed as ‘ true ’ by the assertion of the ‘ unknown parties concerned ’. If anyone dares to say a word against it , they will be called an ‘ SM staff ’, so there is no way that these rumours can be contradicted in those communities . **( THE TEXT BELOW IS SPEAKING FROM THE CORRESPONDING SITES ’ POINT OF VIEW AGAIN , EXCEPT FOR THE RED WRITING ) ** 6 . SM changed YH ’ s solo CF to group CF shooting and tried to make CM stand out more . But because YH stands out so much in every way , they used an example of a downward standardisation to make the CF look more ‘ balanced ’. In order to do this , they made sure that the CF was shot in a gay / homosexual concept . SM is known to have put orders to Lafuma for this to be done . 7 . There is a high possibility that YH is getting unfairly treated because of the extension of his contract with SM . CM made an extension contract with SM , while YH didn ’ t , which makes him much more disadvantageous . The reason why YH didn ’ t renew his contract with SM is because YH can still carry on well without SM , and TVXQ is enough with YH alone . He doesn ’ t need an agency , or another member by him . ** For reference : ( FROM OUR POINT OF VIEW ) The sites mention that the matter of renewing the contract and the issue of SM being ‘ worried that they won ’ t be able to control YH properly ’ together . They twist YH ” s sayings of him trusting SM / or complimenting CM in a completely distorted way , thinking that SM has ordered him to say those things . Also , they interpret YH ’ s compliments of CM in a bad way as well , saying that YH is ‘ meaningfully dissing ’ CM . Likewise , they use malicious terms against CM to say that he is criticising against YH , and is ruining his image . * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ************************* All of the contents above are conspiracies which derived from an unexplainable sense of self - victimisation . Of course , one can ignore all of this , but in long - term effects , those issues can cause more damage due to the fact that they are being perpetrated from places where it calls itself ‘ fan communities ’. Creating distrust and conflict within a fandom , the amount of damage , harm and bad influence that it can cause to TVXQ ’ s name value when these rumours spread outwards to the public as ‘ the opinion of TVXQ fans ’ is unimaginable . We can prove this by evidence . For instance , the actions of those corresponding sites regarding the newest advertisement shooting for the brand ‘ Lafuma ’ show this . Just because some people didn ’ t like the concept and how the photos came out , they carried out a high - intensity boycott against Lafuma ’ s products ( this is NOT simply choosing whether they want to buy the product or not ) . In the name of TVXQ ’ s fans , they expressed strong dislike to Lafuma ’ s Customer Service Centre , and also put up reviews regarding this issue saying that ‘ If you are YH ’ s fans , you should not even think of mentioning this CF shoot in the future ’ ( creating a forceful boycott atmosphere ) . Starting from TVXQ ’ s albums to their concert DVDs and group advertisement shooting , they criticise nearly everything that is related to ‘ TVXQ ’ s U - Know Yunho ’, and looking at the actions that they carried out until now , it is not at the level of them simply expressing discontent . They are creating a big hole in TVXQ ’ s name value by making and spreading rumours , which creates a bad image of them . on top of this , they are making it harder for a new group of fans to join by the conflict within the fandom , causing a vast amount of damage and loss . Even though they are using those sites as a ‘ fan community ’, we cannot see them in any better way that a community of anti - fans . Of course , we understand that it is hard to stop / punish their actions as they are still called ‘ fans ’. However , considering the seriousness of this situation , our decision is that all thresholds which can grow problems should be clearly resolved now in order for those issues to not be a stumbling block in TVXQ ’ s future . As both communities could be closed by SM ’ s notice ( they are an open - gallery type ) , we hope that SM will officially request the server provider of those sites ( Daum Telzone and DC Inside ) considering the levels of human profanity , defamation and the rumours spread . Even though it would be difficult to punish every single person , we request you to ask the question of taking responsibility to the whole community as what they did is wrong . If the question of the existence of the specific community becomes a problem , at least , we hope that SM will no longer treat those communities as ‘ fans ’. We also ask that SM sends out notices to them that they are no longer standing on the same side as them , in order to stop their wrongdoings listed above . The present TVXQ ( YH , CM ) has experienced many times in the past of being unfairly blamed for the breaking down of TVXQ . We understand that SM couldn ’ t really do anything then because of the ongoing lawsuit . However , the damages that the actions of those communities did to TVXQ and its brand value are excessive . This fandom does not want history repeating what happened to TVXQ in the past . The corresponding sites have past experiences when they spread rumours to TVXQ ’ s international fans , titled ‘ SM ’ s erasing of YH ’. It is easier that way for them to spread the false rumours to international fans compared to Korean fans , and harder to resolve the rumours once they are spread . Therefore , it is undoubtedly clear that these acts are detrimental to SM , TVXQ , and its fandom , considering that they are twisting the truth AND spreading it out to more fans . As TVXQ have a strong and powerful fandom , they are actively promoting in both Korean and other countries . Especially , in Japan , they finished the Tone Tour in success ( which brought in the most amount of audience in the past ) , and are now going to start their 5 - Dome Tour , which they are the 5 th foreign artist in the whole world to launch it . Please take note that these communities have baldly expressed discontentment over TVXQ ’ s group promotions , and also are sending out messages that they ‘ do not support the group , but only their preferred member ’. They are capable of creating conflicts between TVXQ ’ s international fandom , which increases the possibility of affecting their international promotions very negatively in the future . As there were lots of problems due to the chaos inside this fandom , to not let this situation repeat again , we request close administration from SM . If the actions currently happening from DC Inside U - Know Yunho Gallery and Daum Telzone TVXQ Gallery are ignored , S . M . Entertainment is not taking the responsibility as a management agency , which has the responsibility of supporting its artist . Regarding those matters , as mentioned , we request that SM take measure and resolve these issues . We thank and trust S . M . Entertainment for being TVXQ ’ s managing enterprise , and we hope , as fans that cheer and support TVXQ , that we can cooperate with SM , under the same vision that TVXQ has , for its long - term upgrowth . May an endless prosperity and development be with S . M . Entertainment and TVXQ in the future . 2013 . 03 . 13 All members of the sites which support TVXQ ( Members of : The Bamboo Forest for Dong - Sunis , DC Inside TVXQ Gallery , Youjacha , 2 PARADISE ) http : / / tvxqbamboo . cafe 24 . com / xe / http : / / gall . dcinside . com / list . php ? id = dongbang _ newhttp : / / www . youcha 1226 . comhttp : / / www . 2 paradise . us