So as an update , I went last night and was able to complete my check . The website is completely out of datewrong on the ID requirements . I took a blurry picture of an informational poster at the station , I ' ll transcribe it here for anyone else looking for this information . It may be worth noting that I was able to use a credit card as secondary ID , even though it is not listed here . YMMVPrimary ID Provincial Driver ' s License or ID Card Passport Nexus Card Permanent Residence Card IndianMetis Status CardSecondary ID Provincial Health Care National Defence Card Birth Certificate Social Insurance Card Canadian Blood Services Card WIN Card CNIB ID Card Citizenship Card Firearm Acquisition Card Immigration Papers Work or Study Permit