I had small little inklings but I just thought it was him being a quirky photography teacher . I didn ' t really think about it until he showed up at the End of the World Party . There was just something . off . Whether intentional or not I felt really worried after that encounter and thought there was more going on than I initially thought . Of course when the episode ended I was like I KNEW IT ! but I only kind of figured maybe ten minutes before that . It ' s weird because if he wasn ' t a fucked up psychopath of a man , he ' d actually be a pretty chill teacher honestly . When I play this game again I just watch him interact with people and be pretty normal and actually cool , like whenever he shuts down Victoria trying to take advantage of him in some way . It ' s so weird to see him actually be cool and I actually laugh and feel good about some of the ways he handles SOME situations like during the opening to episode three where he completely shuts down Victoria on the steps of the front courtyard at Blackwell . This is all of course overshadowed by the fact that the man is a complete psycho .