I believe he was cleared on handwriting and a solid alibi as well . If there was an intruder , it wasn ' t him . Sure , it is possible that someone could have broken in and subdued JBR for him , but that just doesn ' t seem likely IMO . Someone correct me if I ' m wrong , but I believe the whole Santa is paying me an extra visit has been theorized by many on here that it came from being explained to by adults that she would be attending extra functionsparties that evening where more presents would be given . I think the BlueCrab theory is interesting , and I ' m really curious as to what exactly happened to that user . I ' ve always felt that it ' s possible that someone who was either the killer or KNEW of the truth could have easily posted what actually happened on forums in the past , maybe even on this sub . There is at least one person out there who must know what happened whether the RDI or an IDI . As to the actual theory that it was Nathan and the college organization he was in , I really don ' t know . To be fair , I haven ' t read very much about the theory . I read BlueCrab ' s initial theory on Nathan but didn ' t read any updates or changes he may have made to the theory before he disappeared . It ' s an interesting theory , and I ' d like to know if the police actually eliminated him after questioning JR about him . I also think the theory about Doug being involved is REALLY interesting as well , but I don ' t know just how much merit it has . Edit as for the pictures , I have no idea . It probably wasn ' t anything majorly inappropriate , but I ' d like to know exactly what it was as well .