The problem is it ' s a very convincing theory and due to Blizzard ' s conscious choice to not communicate we have no reason to disagree with it . Remember how people mocked others who said those who got one legendary had a much greater chance to get another ? Turned out they were right . People noticed a cap of 4 legendaries . guess what it turns out ? That they put in a soft cap of 4 . Until Blizzard changes its attitude and communicates better they are going to be breeding grounds for these theories . Each time someone is shown right it makes it worse . Blizzard continually brings this drama on themselves for absolutely no reason and frustrates players who play their game passionately . This is why when people go rabid angry and produce verbal vomit an vitriol towards the devs I have no sympathy most of the time . Better communication would have cut most of those arguments at the knees but they continually choose not to communicate or only choose to communicate when it ' s about to be a PR nightmare . Thinking ahead is not their strong suit .