This scene will always be emotional for me . <| sep |> You ' re spot on . The origination of the theory was , from my view watching it go down from afar , about the pizza references in the emails . The investigation should be taken back to that point and the rest should probably be tossed out . If details return with stronger foundations , cool . If the idea was to implicate someone in a crime I do believe that the first puzzle piece is there in those emails . Unfortunately , the rest of the puzzle was jammed together in haste with pieces from unrelated puzzles . It became not how do we determine what this means but instead how do we manipulate this data to fit our conclusion ? <| sep |> It ' s not that they were wrong at that point in time when they owned the game , but that view was just their opinion on how the game should be . There isn ' t a right answer on how the game should be run just 1000 ' s of opinions that vary hugely over the massive spectrum of players . You might agree with their opinion but that doesn ' t make it anymore right . I think a balanced view on the game is best , just let each individual player play how he or she wants to and don ' t try and box everyone into one mentality .