TOP STORIES / Environment
Unlikely bedfellows for climate talks
Doha Climate Conference
The limits of what Doha can reach
Polish minister: 'We need a global agreement'
Altmaier: 'We need a new way of making decisions'
'Societal resilience is not tied to affluence'
Chief negotiator: 'Open for discussion'
'Alliance of Ambition' unravels at Doha
Climate impasse settles over Doha talks
Convincing delegates in Doha isn't easy
World renewables agency calls for major change
Sea levels rising faster than expected
Poor countries hit hardest by climate change
Qatari solar expert: 'Moving towards renewables'
Climate offender Qatar hosts the world
What is at stake at the Doha climate talks?
'The whole world thinks Arab youth don't care'
At climate conferences, various countries and groups of nations form alliances to pursue certain goals. Together there is a lot they can do, but it is still no guarantee for long-term success.
They wanted to form an "Alliance of Ambitions" to extend the Kyoto Protocol. A year ago, the effort between the European Union and the Association of Small Island States (AOSIS) made headlines during the last climate conference in Durban in South Africa. The joint approach animated other countries to get on board and ultimately paved the way for the current summit in Doha, where the extension of the Kyoto Protocol is on the agenda again.
Disappointed expectations
In the meantime, little is left of the once ambitious goals. This time around, in Qatar, the EU is making headlines of a different sort; namely, for not doing enough to protect the climate. And so, the EU has ended up in the crosshairs of international criticism.
The European Union is not prepared to clearly reduce its emissions in the coming years. It argues that it has practically achieved the goals set down in the Kyoto Protocol. The group of small island states expected more and, as a result, is disappointed with its erstwhile ally.
That is not a good omen for the outcome of the Doha climate conference. After all, together with the United States and China, the EU is responsible for more than 60 percent of global emissions. "At least two of the three big players will have to take a big step forward," said Christoph Bals, political director of Germanwatch, a non-governmental organization, "otherwise it will not be possible to limit the global temperature increase to two degrees."
Diverging interests
While industrial countries generate the most emissions, it is the developing countries that suffer most from the effects of climate change. Hence, their respective interests differ. Christoph Bals has identified three groups: "Those who possess fossil fuels or are dependent on them generally play a destructive role in climate protection," he says. "Those who are poor or especially vulnerable play a constructive role, as do those who are relatively far along in using renewable energies."
The obvious conflict of interests makes climate negotiations particularly complicated. "Only when these normal fronts are broken up is there any movement in the negotiations," says Bals. "That's why crossover alliances are so important for getting results."
That was also the secret to success last time around in Durban. The alliance between the EU and AOSIS in South Africa succeeded because the small island nations were also members of the G77, a loose coalition of developing countries designed to promote their interests within the United Nations. The group is predominately made up of developing countries, plus China. "When those countries worst affected by climate change say that for serious climate protection they need both industrial and threshold nations on board, then China is suddenly also responsible," explained Bals.
Tactical decisions
This effect, however, now seems to be blunted since the EU no longer appears to be as interested as before. And it shows that alliances in the climate debate are often tactical rather than strategic. Katherina Reiche, an under-secretary in the German environment ministry, can only hope that the EU-AOSIS alliance does not break up: "The next few days will see if the group stays together," she said. But there was no talk of ambitious goals.
DW recommends
Many key issues remain unaddressed halfway through a UN climate conference in Doha. While the technical means exist to prevent a climate catastrophe, experts wonder if there is enough political will to reach a deal. (02.12.2012)
Although country representatives at the UN climate talks in Doha meet up behind closed doors, NGOs feel they are having an influence on proceedings. But, not everyone is satisfied with how far they're getting. (30.11.2012)
At the Doha talks, environment organization Germanwatch has presented its climate risk index, showing which countries are most affected by climate change: of course, it's the poorest that are worst hit. (27.11.2012)
Author Anne Allmeling /gb
Related Subjects European Union (EU), Climate Change
Keywords Climate conference, Doha, EU, AOSIS, Durban, climate change
Permalink https://p.dw.com/p/16vaS
UN climate conference talks deadlocked in Madrid 14.12.2019
Discussions continued in Madrid to try to resolve a split between rich and poor nations over climate funding and cooperation rules. Many delegates said they were "disappointed" by weak commitments to climate protection.
Climate change: Thousands form a human chain in Brussels 08.12.2019
Belgian citizens have been raising awareness for a greener planet at a "United for Climate" demonstration. Demonstrators encircled both the federal parliament and the Royal Palace.
Climate change protests: Marches worldwide ahead of UN talks 29.11.2019
As part of a fresh round of global climate protests, demonstrations are taking place in over 500 German cities — from Aachen to Zwickau. In Berlin alone, over 50,000 protesters are converging on the government district.
New environment podcast
Listen to our new podcast!
Gabriel and Neil go green, taking an open-minded, relevant and entertaining approach to various environmental issues.
Subscribe to DW's environment podcast
DW's half-hour radio show and podcast brings you environment stories from around the globe.
Eco@Africa
Welcome to the newest edition of Eco Africa
This week on Eco Africa: The impact of droughts in southern Africa and reviving an island off the Tanzanian coast.
Eco@India
Eco India - The Environment Magazine
This week Eco India takes a look at marine biodiversity and pollution in our oceans.
Indigenous communities resist Bolsonaro
As violence escalates in Brazil, indigenous Amazonians have vowed to protect their land and way of life.
Second death reported from mystery virus in China
Scared of getting attached ⁠— Why we run away from relationships
SARS - a dangerous viral infection in the lungs
How dangerous are bushfires and volcanic ash for the lungs?
UK will not align with EU rules after Brexit, says finance minister
Boeing discovers new software problem in 737 Max
China job market worries mount as economy slows to 3-decade low