Audit ⋅ Accounting ⋅ Tax ⋅ Legal ⋅ Business Advisory
Belarus155
Belgium *164
Croatia179
Czech Republic182
Denmark10017
Ethiopia10688
Germany246
Greece *187
Hungary188
Italy191
Kazakhstan285
Kenya9721
Latvia192
Lithuania193
Luxembourg *10018
Mauritius *147
Moldova232
Netherlands *196
Norway *10019
Poland221
Romania219
Russian Federation200
Slovakia209
Slovenia211
Sweden207
Switzerland206
Tunisia *150
Turkey7109
United Kingdom203
About Rödl & Partner
Chambers and Associations
Corporate and Tax Law
Financial accounting | Payroll accounting
New technologies & cybersecurity
Personal advisory
Advisory services for enterprises
State Aid Advice
Career with Rödl & Partner
Recruitment for clients
Press report
Financial audit in Poland
Transfer pricing in Poland
Doing business in Poland
EU funding in Poland
Personal Data Protection in Poland | GDPR
Tax avoidance in Poland
The Tax Act in Poland
Tax-deductible costs in Poland
Excise Duty in Poland
Corporate Income Tax (CIT) in Poland
PIT and lump-sum taxation in Poland
VAT in Poland
Civil proceedings in Poland
Bankruptcy law and enterprise restructuring
Labour law and social insurance in Poland
Company law and M&A
Public Procurement Law in Poland
Special economic zones in Poland
Tax advisory services in Poland
Accounting outsourcing in Poland: benefits of transferring the accounting function to an outside supplier
Appointment of a sales representative vs. risk of permanent establishment
Judiciary reform in Ukraine
Hot news >
Renewable energy >
A good change in the RES Act?
Renewable electricity sales prices offered by auction in the context of VAT
A few legal notes on the first auctions for renewable energy sources
The RES Act's amendment which is of key importance to investors has landed in Parliament
New Wind Farm Investment Act – the so-called distance act
Foreign enterprises investing in wind farms in Poland can claim compensation from the state
Industrial customers – eligibility for reduction in the purchase cost of electricity
Cross-border RES auctions to start in Poland
State Aid in the RES Act
Auction rules and the auction in support of renewable energy sources
Record generation of wind energy and its impact on the National Electric Power System
Current status of PPA in Poland
Amended Renewable Energy Law in Poland
Tadeusz Piekłowski
Customs agent (Poland)
Phone: +48 71 60 60 411
In the lawmakers' view the amended Renewable Energy Sources Act of 20 February 2015, which entered into force on 1 July 2016, was supposed to clarify the principles of the production and use of electricity from renewable energy sources for own needs. The above applies to the so-called prosumers, that is persons who produce electricity on their own using PV installations which they mostly have mounted on the roofs of their own houses. The amended act stipulates directly that prosumers' actions must not be oriented at profits but at satisfying prosumers' own energy needs. Prosumers may produce electricity from micro-installations for their own needs and feed the unused surpluses into the grid. They will not receive any payments for the electricity fed into the grid but they will be able to exchange it. Under the Act, prosumers will be able to set off the energy fed into the grid against the energy taken from it in the ratio 1 to 0.7 and 1 to 0.8 (for installations with the output under 10 kW). Consequently, for each unit of energy fed into the grid prosumers will get back only a part of it amounting to 0.7 or 0.8, respectively. The remaining amount of energy they feed into the grid free of charge.
This means that we now have two kinds of energy fed by prosumers into the grid: energy that they can claim back and energy for which they will get no compensation. The seller will use the part of the energy which prosumers do not take back to cover the handling costs – the seller can sell this energy to other purchasers at market prices.
The new provisions do not treat the use of free energy as a free of charge benefit. According to the law, the surplus does not constitute the seller's revenue in the meaning of the CIT Act. Please note that the sale of energy produced by prosumers to obligated sellers is exempt from excise duty because it has not been listed as a transaction subject to excise duty in the meaning of Article 9(1)(2) of the Excise Duty Act (this provision provides for the taxation of sales to the end purchaser who has no licence for distribution, transfer, production or sales of electricity while the obligated seller has such a licence). But this does not mean that energy supplied by prosumers is not subject to taxation later if the requirements for the exemption from the excise duty are not met.
Obligated sellers supplying electricity to prosumers who are end purchasers in the meaning of the Excise Duty Act but have no energy production, sales, transfer or distribution license, may not charge the excise duty only on the surplus of the energy supplied by prosumers over the energy generated by his installation and fed into the grid because all electricity supplied by prosumers is subject to excise duty. This standpoint was confirmed by the Tax Chamber in Katowice in its advanced tax ruling of 2 December 2015 (file no. IBPP4/4513-114/15/LG). The Tax Chamber concluded that the seller must charge excise duty on all sold electricity, irrespective of whether the end purchaser is a prosumer who owns the so-called micro-installation (that is a RES installation which does not require an energy license, with a total output of 40kW, connected to a grid with a nominal voltage below 110 kV or with a cogenerated heat capacity of no more than 120 kW)) or an entity with no such installation which uses energy for its own purposes. The tax authority pointed out the fact that "the reducing of the taxable base for the electricity sold to the end purchaser and charging the excise duty on only the difference between the electricity sold and purchased between the above-mentioned entities, which the applicant proposed, had no legal basis in the Excise Duty Act which is in force since 1 January 2016." In its judgement of 11 October 2016 (file no. III SA/Gl 270/16), the Provincial Administrative Court in Gliwice backed the argumentation of the tax authorities and dismissed the taxable person's (obligated seller's) appeal.
To sum up, the amended RES Act of 1 July 2016 introduced changes for prosumers which do not encourage them to produce energy but rather discourage them from doing it. Under the new law, prosumers will never earn revenue from feeding energy into the grid. It is incomprehensible that a seller who receives a part of the energy produced by the prosumer for free does not pay any tax on the free-of-charge benefit. The prosumers' obligation to pay excise duty on the energy that they consume but which they earlier produced themselves is also controversial. An exemption from this duty should be considered.
If you would like to discuss this topic in more detail or if you are interested in a legal advice in Poland, Rödl & Partner experts from Cracow, Gdansk, Gliwice, Poznan, Warsaw or Wroclaw will be glad to help.
Rödl & Partner Privacy Policy
Our website uses cookies. By continuing to use our website you agree to the use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings in your browser at any time. Further information is available in our privacy policy.