Remembering the year 2002
2002 is not a year that I often like to recall. I was 25 years old and there was so much going on in my life at the time that it all ended up falling down on top of me. I had just graduated from university but I had no idea what I wanted to do with my life so I just went on going to work day after day at my pointless retail job. As if that weren't daunting enough, my relationship of three years was coming to a particularly dramatic end. We would fight about everything. It got so bad at one point that one night, after coming home from having seen THE HOURS and CHICAGO back to back, we argued extensively over which was better as if that actually mattered. I was in THE HOURS camp. The manner in which Stephen Daldry brought depression to the forefront was shockingly palpable. Paul was adamantly pro-CHICAGO. I suppose escaping harsh reality for musical exuberance was where his head was at. With a little perspective and a heck of a lot of healing, I think I can finally admit that he may have been right after all … maybe … at least about that anyway.
I should clarify; I always loved CHICAGO. I felt that Bill Condon, the screenwriter who would go on much later to direct DREAMGIRLS, had found the most seamless way to adapt a stage musical to the screen. He borrowed the concept from the stage production itself but he brought it to such new heights that it made CHICAGO into a triumphant return for a genre that had long been suffering. The musical numbers that would ordinarily disrupt the story were all worked in as a means of escape in the mind of the star, Roxie Hart (Renee Zellweger). Having just been arrested for the capital murder of her lover, Roxie desperately needed a way to cope with her new reality. First time feature filmmaker and veteran theatre director, Rob Marshall, took Condon's sharp script and made sure that every nuance was not only handled delicately but honoured so that CHICAGO could do more than just be an excellent film experience. Marshall infused an energy to a show that is so stark on stage by keeping the pacing fast and the lighting always theatrical and richly colorful. Suddenly, you had a musical that didn't have numbers that stopped the story but rather commented on it at all times and made it that much more exhilarating. After winning the Oscar for Best Picture that year and taking in roughly $170 million at the box office, it was clear that Marshall's CHICAGO had saved the musical itself from certain death.
I should also clarify that I was depressed when I first saw THE HOURS. Perhaps, as I am now not depressed, I can look back on the two works and have an easier time delighting in the musical while feeling a degree of hesitation going back to darker times. At the time though, I distinctly remember feeling that the isolation of depression was captured not only so succinctly but in a fashion that was intricately complex and beautifully executed. THE HOURS is all about the actresses. A trio of incredible women, Nicole Kidman, Julianne Moore and Meryl Streep, play variations on the same woman throughout the eras to show the timeliness of depression and how it is seen and dealt with differently depending on the period and the surroundings. It does run the risk of being seen as a distinctly female experience but clearly that isn't so. One day around the time of the film's release, a woman came in to the record store I was working at and asked for the brilliant score by Philip Glass. I immediately began talking to her about how profoundly the film had affected me, even going so far as to cite specific scenes in detail. She had just come from the film and you could see she had been crying. This woman was bewildered that I was able to connect with this film coming from a male perspective. I simply told her straight up, as she left the store with the score in hand, that depression has no gender, that it is universal.
The truth is that neither Paul now I was right. Film appreciation, as I've said time and time again, is inherently subjective. The way we see film, the manner in which it moves or excites us, is directly affected by what we bring to the screen as viewers – whether that be because we are in the middle of a painful breakup or because we woke up with a musical bounce in our step. What matters more is that these films worked their way into our hearts and not at all how they got there in the first place. Of course, we weren't actually arguing about the movies; we were arguing about much harder, much more complicated issues. Our passion for the films allowed us to use them as our swords and shields. The films themselves helped us each move on.
Regardless, both films get ...
ADAPTATION, Directed by Spike Jonze
BOWLING FOR COLUMBINE, Michael Moore
CHICAGO, Rob Marshall
FAR FROM HEAVEN, Todd Haynes
FRIDA, Julie Taymor
THE HOURS, Stephen Daldry
THE PIANIST, Roman Polanski
PUNCH DRUNK LOVE, Paul Thomas Anderson
SECRETARY, Steven Shainberg
Y TU MAMA TAMBIEN, Alfonso Cuaron
Posted by Black Sheep at 12:06 pm
reassurance said...
Being 25 now, it seems like that everyone I know, including myself, is going through some sort of shittier-than-it-should-be break-up... however, I think you were right back then about The Hours > Chicago. Upon rewatching the latter, it's quite dazzling when it's supposed to be and terribly amateurish otherwise.
Anh Khoi Do said...
Although I'm not a fan of musicals, I got to admit that I liked Chicago. As you pointed it out, the singing performances didn't interrupt the storyline's evolution. As for Bowling for Columbine, I remember seeing it in High school and being surprised that it won an Academy Award for best documentary. In fact, although there are some true things that Moore say in it, I thought he distorted the reality by comparing gun violence in Canada to that in the USA. This goes without saying that I laughed when he said that Canada was heaven (based on a visit to Toronto).
Finally, I haven't seen most of the films in your list, but I'd have put Talk to Her.
Search The Sheep
What the sheep are flocking to ...
Black Sheep interviews David Cronenberg
On paper, it would make perfect sense to any outsider that famed Canadian director, David Cronenberg, would be the only appropriate choi...
Black Sheep interviews Daniel Radcliffe
THE BOY WIZARD GROWS UP An interview with THE WOMAN IN BLACK star, Daniel Radcliffe At this point in my career, I've interviewed a fair ...
Black Sheep Interviews Daniel Lindsay and T.J. Martin
THE WINNER'S CIRCLE An interview with UNDEFEATED directors, Daniel Lindsay and T.J. Martin "It was completely unexpected," filmmaker...
Black Sheep does TV: BOARDWALK EMPIRE Season 2
Wow. That was all I could say when the second season of HBO's BOARDWALK EMPIRE concluded. In fact, I think I may have said it about ...
Written and Directed by George Nolfi Starring Matt Damon, Emily Blunt, Anthony Mackie, Jack Slattery and Terence Stamp David Norris: If I&...
Written by Michael Arndt Directed by Lee Unkrich Voices by Tom Hanks, Tim Allen, Joan Cusack, Ned Beatty and Michael Keaton Hamm: C'mon, l...
CLOUD ATLAS Written and Directed by Andy Wachowski, Lana Wachowski and Tom Tykwer Starring Tom Hanks, Halle Berry, Jim Broadbent, Hugh Gra...
THE COMPANY MEN
Written and Directed by John Wells Starring Ben Affleck, Tommy Lee Jones, Chris Cooper, Rosemarie DeWitt and Kevin Costner Phil Woodward: ...
Written by Derek Cianfrance, Joey Curtis and Cami Delavigne Directed by Derek Cianfrance Starring Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams Cindy...
THE SQUID AND THE WHALE
THE SQUID AND THE WHALE Written and Directed by Noam Baumbach Starring Jeff Daniels, Laura Linney and Jesse Eisenberg So rarely does a f...
Subscribe to Black Sheep Reviews!
Now Playing on Black Sheep Reviews
A Good Day to Die Hard
Big Wedding, The
Croods, The
Dead Man Down
East, The
Fast and Furious 6
Gatekeepers, The
Great Gatsby, The
Hangover Part III, The
Kings of Summer, The
My Brother the Devil
Now You See Me
Place Beyond the Pines, The
We and the I, The
AND THE SHEEP GOES TWEET, TWEET, TWEET
Black Sheep Interviews
ANNA KENDRICK (End of Watch / Pitch Perfect / The Company You Keep)
ANTONIO BANDERAS (The Skin I Live In)
ARI GRAYNOR & LAUREN MILLER (For a Good Time, Call)
ATOM EGOYAN (Adoration)
BRANDON CRONENBERG (Antiviral)
CHARLIE TAHAN (Frankenweenie)
DANIEL LINDSAY & T.J. MARTIN (Undefeated)
DANIEL RADCLIFFE (The Woman in Black)
DAVID CRONENBERG (A Dangerous Method)
DAVID CRONENBERG (Cosmopolis)
DEEPA MEHTA (Midnight's Children)
DOLPH LUNDGREN (The Expendables)
DOMINIC COOPER (The Devil's Double)
DREW GODDARD (The Cabin in the Woods)
ELIZABETH OLSEN (Martha Marcy May Marlene)
GABOUREY SIDIBE (Precious: Based on the Novel "Push" By Sapphire)
GARETH EVANS (The Raid: Redemption)
GEMMA ARTERTON, The Disappearance of Alice Creed
GEORGE MILLER, (Happy Feet Two)
GUS VAN SANT (Restless)
JACOB TIERNEY (Good Neighbours)
JAKE GYLLENHAAL (End of Watch)
JAVIER BARDEM (Biutiful)
JAY BARUCHEL (Goon)
JAY BRANNAN (Shortbus)
JEAN-MARC VALLEE (Cafe de Flore)
JEFFREY SCHWARZ (Vito)
JULIA LEIGH (Sleeping Beauty)
KIM WAYANS (Pariah)
LEE DANIELS (Precious: Based on the Novel "Push" by Sapphire)
LEE HIRSCH (Bully)
LOUIS PSIHOYOS (The Cove)
MARC-ANDRE GRONDIN (Goon)
MARK ANDREWS (Brave)
MARK RUFFALO (The Avengers)
MATHIEU ROY (Surviving Progress)
MATTHEW GOODE (Burning Man)
MATTHEW MCCONAUGHEY (The Lincoln Lawyer)
MAX MINGHELLA (The Ides of March)
MICHAEL FASSBENDER (Shame)
MICHAEL MOORE (Capitalism)
MICHAEL SHANNON (Take Shelter)
MICHEL HAZANAVICIUS & JEAN DUJARDIN (The Artist)
MIKE MILLS (Beginners)
MORGAN SPURLOCK (Comic-Con Episode IV: A Fan's Hope)
MORGAN SPURLOCK (POM Wonderful presents The Greatest Movie Ever Sold)
NIGEL COLE (Made in Dagenham)
PADDY CONSIDINE (Tyrannosaur)
PATRICK WANG (In the Family)
PAUL GROSS (Passchendaele)
PAUL HAGGIS (The Next Three Days)
RALPH FIENNES (Coriolanus)
RICHARD LEMAY (Naked as We Came)
RICHARD LEWIS (Barney's Version)
ROB STEWART (Revolution)
ROBERT PATTINSON (Cosmopolis)
ROMAN COPPOLA (A Glimpse Inside the Mind of Charles Swan III)
RYAN GOSLING (Drive)
RYAN REYNOLDS (Buried)
SAM FELL (Paranorman)
SHAWN KU (Beautiful Boy)
STEVE MCQUEEN (Shame)
STEVEN SODERBERGH (The Girlfriend Experience)
THOM FITZGERALD (Cloudburst)
WILL FERRELL (Everything Must Go)
XAVIER DOLAN (Heartbeats)
About Black Sheep Reviews
ABOUT THE SITE ... In September of 2005, Joseph Belanger, sat down to write what would become the first Black Sheep review. Between then and now, BLACK SHEEP REVIEWS, has been finding its voice amidst a sea of sheep. Seeing what the herd wants is fine from time to time but sometimes this sheep needs a quiet empty theatre where he can be alone and more himself. Reviewing is just his way of playing shepherd for a change ... ABOUT THE SHEEP HIMSELF ... JOSEPH BELANGER (Writer and Founder of BLACK SHEEP REVIEWS) ... I have filled out so many online "About Me" sections now and they are always a large attempt at sounding witty and important. How about an "About Me, the Film Reviewer" instead this time. Seems fitting ... Some call me a film snob ... ok, my brother calls me a film snob. I don't see myself so. I just like films to be well-intentioned, to be about something, to not talk down to me. I have a sensitive soul and I like to write about the quiet conversations that my soul has with the movies on the screen.
To make a suggestion, or a special request or to speak directly with the sheep:
joseph@blacksheepreviews.com
Black Sheep Sees Stars!
Click for star system breakdown
Sheep Served
Join the Black Sheep Reviews FACEBOOK group
Another way to follow Black Sheep ...
Past Black Sheep Reviews
Black Sheep Previews: DO THE RIGHT THING
Black Sheep @ The Box Office: Transformers More Th...
Black Sheep @ The Box Office: Yes, Sandra Bullock!...
THE SODERBERGH EXPERIENCE
FOOD INC
BLU-TUESDAY .. June 16
Really? GRAN TORINO?
Black Sheep @ The Box Office
ABC: A CLOCKWORK ORANGE
Really? HE'S JUST NOT THAT INTO YOU?
WEEKEND BOX OFFICE: UP! Stays Up
Black Sheep Previews: NEW MOON
BLU-TUESDAY .. June 2
Mouton d'Or Awards
Black Sheep's Blog Roll
Sundance Review: Fantastic Machine Offers a Sprawling History of the Moving Image with a Too-Concise Lens - The history of film is filled with fascinating symmetries, with Edison's early kinescopes like Fred Ott's Sneeze and The Kiss resembling the kinds of sto...
Porter Airlines launches new aircraft and daily routes from Pearson airport - Porter Airlines launches their new Embraer E195-E2 aircraft today, flying from Toronto's Pearson Airport to a number of new Canadian destinations for the...
Cindy Williams and the Sneaky Progressivism of 'Laverne & Shirley' - Sometimes you get ahead with laughter. Actually, I'm willing to bet a lot of the time we all do. It's a strange, tough world out there, and progress is nev...
Academy Board of Governors Taking No Action Over Andrea Riseborough Controversy - [image: Andrea-Riseborough, Governors-Awards, Oscars-2018][image: Academy Board of Governors Taking No Action Over Andrea Riseborough Controversy] The Acad...
The Audient
Lights out at Mission Tiki - I guess it wasn't the rain after all. In my last -- and what now appears to be penultimate -- post about Mission Tiki Drive-In in Montclair, California, ...
Wilnervision!
Victory Laps - So here's the thing: Someone Else's Movie has already done an episode on Jeanne Dielman, 23 Quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles. Wayne Wang picked the film in...
Critics At Large
The Art of Burning: The Dilemma of Ideas - Adrianne Krstansky (far left), Michael Kaye, and Rom Barkhordar (far right) in *The Art of Burning*. (Photo: T Charles Erickson) Kate Snodgrass's play *T...
DARKMATTERS - The Mind Of Matt
Matt gets The Second Last Communiqué (review) - *The Second Last Communiqué* D.J. Hall Reviewed by Matt Adcock (@Cleric20) *"As the aging woman woke to the sounds of magpies warbling outside...
The Matinee : : Cinematic Passion & PerspectiveThe Matinee : : Cinematic Passion & Perspective | The Matinee : : Cinematic Passion & Perspective
Episode 299 – THE WHALE - Talkin' Darren Aronofsky's new film with Andrew Robinson
The Film Doctor
The Best Video Essays of 2022, the Sight and Sound poll - It's fascinating how the art form of the video essay has evolved. The *Sight and Sound *poll of the best video essays has been released. Here's one of ...
The Moving Arts Film Journal
How to Strengthen Joints for Dancing with More Flexibility - Adding more flexibility to your dancing is essential for staying injury-free and taking your performances to the next level. To achieve this, strengthening...
MTV Movies Blog
Hocus Pocus 2 Resurrects The Sanderson Sisters For A New Generation - The Sanderson sisters are back for revenge! Watch the spooky teaser trailer for 'Hocus Pocus 2.'
The Dancing Hotdogs Present...
Summer 2021 Bucket List - Hello friends! It is hard to believe that it will be August in just a few days and even more unbelievable that is has been March since our last post. Hon...
The Rockport Film Review
You're Invited to watch "Murder Party" - 3/25/2021 Writer/Director Jeremy Saulnier's breakthrough film was the 2013 crime thriller "Blue Ruin". Loved critics and audience this was not however ...
Cinemablographer
Moving On -
subtitledonline.com
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration won't regulate supplements - A vitamin is understood to be an organic compound required by an organism in limited amounts being a vital nutrient, because these aren't made by the body ...
Row Three
Cinecast Episode 505 – Ten Damn Years - It's difficult to believe that another ten years has flown by and your gracious hosts are digging through an entire decade of film for the second time in t...
Peterloo (2019) - See!?! America's not all that bad after all! On August 16, 1819, at St. Peter's Field in Manchester calvary soldiers shot into a crowd of unnarmed citizens...
Toronto Screen Shots
TIFF 2018: My Picks - For the sixth year in a row, I'll be working during TIFF but this year is going to be much easier. I work six days from Tuesday the 4th (I know, that's bef...
Knifed in Venice
COMIC: Invasion From Planet Wrestletopia [Issue 1 and 2] - The Bout to Knock The Other Guy OutI have been a wrestling fan since the day, and minute I became a big brother. I cheered when Bret Hart won his first W...
Free Documentaries Online
3 myths about the future of work – TED Talk by Daniel Susskind - The 3 Myth are: Terminator Myth Intelligence Myth Superiority Myth "Will machines replace humans?" This question is on the mind of anyone with a job to l...
Mr. Anthony Writes...
The Last Jedi: Beauty and Brilliance - There are many remarkable, enjoyable, and surprising facets to the latest in an ever-growing world of Star Wars films. The Last Jedi contains callbacks an...
A Look Back At The New York Film Festival - It's been two weeks since the New York Film Festival wrapped, nearly 4 weeks since Hollywood has imploded following the news of Harvey Weinstein's dirty be...
Toronto Film Scene
TIFF 2017 Review: The Children Act - Fiona Maye (Emma Thompson) is a revered albeit controversial justice in England, whose professional priorities override her relationship with husband Jack ...
Have Your Say: Fun With Sequel Titles - And now for something silly. I was discussing films with a friend, as happens, and we started talking about obscure horror films. And my friend mentioned ...
At A Theater Near You: RSS Feed
The Mummy (2017) - Talk About Mercury Poisoning
ScottFeinberg.com
Oscars: A Closer Look at the Results That Were Overshadowed By the Chaos - By: Scott Feinberg The Hollywood Reporter It's early Monday morning, and I'm finally back at my desk and starting to process what I witnessed only a few ho...
Daily Film Dose
Fellini's Roma - *Fellini's episodic romp through the space and time of the eternal city at the time of its release might have felt like an indulgent recycling of his usua...
Read Eisner Nominated Short Story BLACK DEATH IN AMERICA! - For those unfamiliar, the Eisner Awards are considered the Academy Awards of the comicbook industry. With voting ending in a few weeks, Vertigo Comics h...
The Grapevine | Scrooging filmjuice all over your daily thoughts.
The Best & The Worst Of Oscars 2016 By A Brutally Honest Oscar Watcher. - The 2016 Oscar season has showcased the very best and the very worst of the grotesquely entertaining awards event. Like a horrendous car accident that you ...
Little White Lies Magazine
LWLies 62: The Carol Issue - Pick up our latest issue and fall in love with Todd Haynes' breathtaking period romance.
GabnDad
Mayors Gone Bad book trailer - Mayors Gone Bad book trailer Mayors Gone Bad, a series of profiles of recent and current Canadian mayors gone amok, is an entertaining companion volume t...
celluloidical
Trailer Talk – March 2015: 'Before I Wake', 'Tomorrowland', 'Self/less' & 'Pixels' - Some thoughts on a few new trailers. Unfortunately I'm unable to embed the videos as iOS sucks. Anyway, live long and phosphorous…  'Before I Wake' (US...
The Velvet Café
I hope this Swedish fantasy movie will conquer the world - When I grew up, it never occurred to me that Sweden could be the setting for stories of fantasy, magic or horror. Or rather: it could, but only in fairy ta...
Eternal Sunshine Of The Logical Mind
Blindspot - "A Night At The Opera" and "The Navigator" - I remember a Saturday evening many years ago sitting down with my Dad to watch the Marx Brothers. I think we had tuned into PBS around 7PM and a double b...
skip rip or play
The thing about Gone Girl is that it's all about Rosamund Pike - Hello, hello! It's amazing how hard it is sometimes to get back on the horse. But here we go...after a very long hiatus, (again) let's try this. So, a c...
Subtitle Literate
RIP Subtitle Literate - Hello all, and welcome to the final post of *Subtitle Literate* (2008-2014). I've had a lot of fun with my first blog over the years, and I surely hope you...
FILMFEST.CA
CUB, A Campfire Story That Fizzles Out - Cub is another of those genre films that has a terrific premise, some really nice moments, but overall comes across as pretty flat and uninteresting. The s...
Okinawa Assault
This Woman's Work. Motifs in Cinema 2013: Work and the Workplace - Motifs in Cinema is a discourse across film blogs, assessing the way in which various thematic elements have been used in the 2013 cinematic landscape. How...
Teen Film Enthusiast
- This site has now moved to: http://youngfilmreviewer.blogspot.com
The Best Movies of 2013: #20 – #1 - Congratulations, my players and playerettes! You finally made it, the big day has finally arrived! For those just tuning in, here's what you've been missin...
Big Thoughts From A Small Mind
One Chapter Ends...Another One Begins - Today marks the end of a lengthy, and I would say very unexpected, journey. After seven years it is time to close the door on this little film blog known...
Match Cuts
Try and Get Me (Endfield, 1950) - The phrase "a friend in need is a friend indeed" takes on a darkly cynical meaning in Cy Endfield's harrowing film noir, Try and Get Me. To trust anyone an...
Montreal Film Journal
Somewhere - Even though it's ostensibly about *ennui* (like every Sofia Coppola flick), that's not an excuse for it being so damn dull. (KL)
I HEART MOVIES TO
The Film Emporium
Movie Reviews by Tom Clift
Now streaming at a couch near you