About McCarty Law
Business & Corporate Law
Creditor Law & Debt Collection
Elder Law & Special Needs Planning
Estate Planning – Wills & Trusts
Probate Law & Estate Settlement
Title IX & Civil Rights in Education
Trademark Law & Intellectual Property
Benjamin M. Adams
Scott C. Barr
Katherine M. Canadeo
Steven J. Cerasoli
Kristy A. Christensen
Gregg Curry
Michael W. Curry
Melissa R. DeVantier
Jon L. Fischer
Kayla J. Giese
Rebecca L. Kent
Sarah J. Knutson
Yadira J. Rein
John J. Russo
William A. Woodrow
Reg P. Wydeven
Lora L. Zimmer
Randall A. Haak (of Counsel)
Angela M. Rust (of Counsel)
John A. Esler (Retired)
Philip A. Munroe (Retired)
Janet K. Porter (Retired)
Dennis M. Wydeven (Retired)
Legal Q&A Resources
Reg's Articles
McCarty Law Blog
920-882-4070 Blog
So Much for Being Polite
Posted on Jun 26, 2018 by Reg P. Wydeven
Identity theft is a scary and common problem today. People generally try to steal someone else's identify for their own personal gain, typically financially. But in an unusual case of a stolen identity, a Canadian woman pretended to be her boyfriend to tank his career, forcing him to stay with her.
Eric Abramovitz was one of the top clarinet players in Canada when he applied for a two-year scholarship at the Colburn Conservatory of Music in Los Angeles. If accepted, Abramovitz would have studied under Yehuda Gilad, a world-renowned clarinetist on the faculty at Colburn. The position would have virtually guaranteed that Abramovitz would have had the choice of a high-paying job performing with almost any symphony in America.
The scholarship would have covered Abramovitz's tuition and room and board, but would also have provided him with a stipend for food and other expenses, valuing it at approximately $50,000. It would obviously require him, however, to move from Montreal to L.A.
Instead of being happy and supportive, Abramovitz's live-in girlfriend, Jennifer Lee, opted for sabotage. Professor Gilad sent Abramovitz an email informing him that he was awarded the scholarship. Before Abramovitz had a chance to read it, though, Lee deleted the email.
Then Lee set up a fake email address and posed as her boyfriend. She then sent a message to Gilad thanking him for the honor, but notifying him that he had to turn it down. She next set up a fake email address in Gilad's name to inform Abramovitz that the total scholarship was given to someone else. However, she did say that he was eligible for a $5,000 scholarship, knowing he could not afford to go there without a full ride.
So Abramovitz enrolled at McGill University in Montreal, where Lee just happened to be attending. After graduating, Abramovitz enrolled in a two-year extension program offered through the University of Southern California, which cost him about $50,000. The program was taught by none other than Gilad. After comparing notes, the pair discovered Lee's ruse.
In addition to breaking up with her, Abramovitz sued Lee, asking for $300,000 in general damages. According to the Montreal Gazette, David L. Corbett, the judge in Ontario Superior Court, ruled in favor of Abramovitz and even awarded him an additional $50,000 of damages due to Lee's "despicable interference in Mr. Abramovitz's career."
"I accept and find that Mr. Abramovitz lost a unique and prestigious education opportunity, one that would have advanced his career as a clarinetist," Corbett's decision read. Abramovitz had worked at the Santa Barbara Orchestra and the Nashville Symphony Orchestra. Corbett's ruling continued, saying, "Imagining how his life would have been different if he had studied for two years under Mr. Gilad, and earned his teacher's respect and support, requires more speculation than the law permits."
"I cannot speculate as to how high and how quickly Mr. Abramovitz's career might have soared, but for the interference by Ms. Lee," Corbett's decision read, "But the law does recognize that the loss of a chance is a very real and compensable loss."
Abramovitz apparently drowned his sorrows at a local bar. When the bartender asked what he wanted to drink, Abramovitz just played a B flat, a G flat, and an E flat on his clarinet. "I'm sorry," the bartender said, "but we don't serve minors here."
If you'd like to receive more news and updates from our McCarty Law attorneys, please subscribe to our monthly newsletter below.
Elder Law and Estate Planning Attorney at McCarty Law LLP
Hoping to follow in his father's footsteps from a young age, Reg's practice primarily consists of advising individuals on estate planning, estate settlement and elder law matters. As Reg represents clients in matters like guardianship proceedings and long-term care admissions, he feels grateful to be able to offer families thorough legal help in their time of need.
Latest posts by Reg P. Wydeven (see all)
Rash Decisions About Uniforms - January 14, 2020
Upon Further Review… - January 7, 2020
Gift While the Gifting's Good - January 2, 2020
Tis the Season of Giving - December 24, 2019
Lawsuit is in the Bag - December 17, 2019
Posted in Identity Theft | Tagged identity theft | Comments Off on So Much for Being Polite
Categories Select Category Advertising Law Animal Rights Law Anti-Trust Law Business & Corporate Law Commercial Litigation Community Commitment Computer Law Conservation Law Constitutional Law Consumer Protection Contract/Insurance Law Criminal Law Discrimination Law Education Law Elder Law Elder Mediation Estate Planning Law Family Law Food Law Gambling Law Get to Know Us Gun Law Health Law Identity Theft Immigration Law Intellectual Property Law Labor & Employment Law Landlord/Tenant Law Liability Law Licensing Law Litigation McCarty News & Updates Miscellaneous Municipal Law Personal Injury Personal Injury Law Privacy Law Product Liability Real Estate Law Securities Law Social Security Tax Law Title IX Tort Law Traffic Law Transportation Law Unfair Trade Practices Law
Join Our LinkedIn Group Proud to Support the New North
Serving the Greater Fox Valley Area in Appleton, Kaukauna, Little Chute, Kimberly, Green Bay, Oshkosh, Neenah, Menasha, and Fond du Lac, Wisconsin.
McCarty Law LLP
2401 East Enterprise Avenue
Appleton, Wisconsin 54913-7887
Practice Areas - Our Legal Services Specialties Include:
Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Disclaimer
©2020 McCarty Law LLP.
Website Design and Development by Stellar Blue Technologies.
Stay connected with our monthly newsletter.