Destroying a common myth and exposing government greed at once.
Michigan State Police Say Most Speed Limits are Too Low
In his capacity as the former head of the MSP's Traffic Services Section it was Lt. Megge's job to eliminate speed traps set up by local municipalities. A few years ago Megge told the Detroit News, "I've spent eight years in traffic services, and I was a crash reconstructionist for five years before that, so I've seen my share of fatal wrecks, and I can tell you: Deaths are not caused by speeding. They're caused by drinking, drugs and inattentiveness. The old adage that speed kills just isn't realistic. The safest speed is the speed that is correct for that roadway at a given time. A lot of speed limits are set artificially low."
The state police were one of the groups who backed, against the lobbying of municipalities, a change in Michigan law that required speed limits to be set based on actual traffic data and engineering studies. That law, Public Act 85 proposed to set limits based on what is known as the 85th percentile rule, a widely used measure that sets speed limits at how fast 85% of drivers travel safely. "It just doesn't seem right to me that we would enforce a law where 90-98 percent of the people are in violation of it," Lieutenant Megge told the DetNews in 2008. "It's not the way we should do business in this country."
After that law was passed, cities, towns and villages, through the Michigan Municipal League, pointed out that the law didn't specifically require traffic studies and lobbied against revisions to Public Act 85 that would force them to due such studies. At the time, Megge agreed with them, to a point. "There is nothing in the code that specifically requires a municipality to conduct traffic studies," said Megge, "but enforcement of any law must match the criteria of the law," technically making invalid those tickets issued on roads whose speed limits were not compliant with P.A. 85. The cities opposed using such studies because they almost invariably call for higher speed limits, potentially reducing revenue from speeding tickets. The revisions eventually passed in 2010.
Since then, Lt. Megge's job has been overseeing such compliance. Over his career he's had a hand in the raising of over 400 speed limits across Michigan (though in a small number of cases the studies resulted in lower speed limits). By now there's more than a decade's worth of data from those raised speed limits and Megge insists that higher speed limits don't mean that people drive significantly faster. They drive just as fast as they always did before, and just as safely. They just do so without risking points on their drivers' licenses. The lieutenant says, "Over the years, I've done many follow up studies after we raise or lower a speed limit. Almost every time, the 85th percentile speed doesn't change, or if it does, it's by about 2 or 3 mph."
In addition to the fact that they don't really do anything to promote traffic safety, Lt. Megge says that unreasonably low speed limits actually make roads less safe by diverting resources away from the kind of law enforcement that has measurable effect. Megge recommends, instead of zealous speed enforcement against drivers who are effectively safe, focusing on drunk drivers, red light runners, drivers and passengers who don't buckle up, and, an important point, enforcing realistic speed limits against the small minority of drivers who unreasonably and excessively speed.
Alex Mayyasi, at pricenomics.com, has an extensive look at how speeds limits have been and are being set, including an interview with Lt. Megge. As the good Prof. Reynolds says, read the whole thing, then come back here and share your views.
Ronnie Schreiber edits Cars In Depth, a realistic perspective on cars & car culture and the original 3D car site. If you found this post worthwhile, you can get a parallax view at Cars In Depth. If the 3D thing freaks you out, don't worry, all the photo and video players in use at the site have mono options. Thanks for reading – RJS
Labels: auto industry, bureaucracy, Freedom, government workers
Judicial malfeasance. Waste on absurdity. The evid...
How to make everyone other then the elites poorer,...
Two sets of rules: One for Jews the other for Pale...
Closing the Ethics Committee empowered to investig...
I may have missed but have you heard the UN say an...
Here is a true picture of who is at war with Israe...
If DHS compiled the numbers you can bet it's much ...
Not enough money for essential services but plenty...
As Obama famously said he'd stand by Muslims and t...
Hamas has been successful in terrorizing journalis...
A cabal of far leftists.
Clinton's thugs are out working to suppress a book...
Lois Lerner and why there is a Hatch Act.
Good news: Wisconsin court backs Walker, controver...
UNRWA complicit in murdering Jewish soldiers in Ga...
Obamacare and the web of deceit.
The debacle that is Libya or "what difference does...
Islamist war on Christians. Where's the outrage? S...
What running out of other people's money looks lik...
MSNBC libels Israel and sticks to it.
How liberalism spreads disease
Islamic State jihadists issue 30-minute killing sp...
Another government bureaucracy masters in waste-fr...
Unions and the loony left join to celebrate a conv...
Clinton inc. rakes it in. Insider trading at the g...
Hamas command center bunker under hospital
Israel praised by Hamas co-founder's son
Islamist terrorism in Nigeria
The UN is complicit in empowering Hamas
Obama's success in "skyrocketing" your electricity...
The anti gun Bloomberg encourages victimhood
The politicalization of the bureaucracy bodes ill ...
Mika's freudian slip...just like her father the an...
Hamas kills protesters in Gaza...they'll just blam...
In case there were any doubts about the Palestinia...
Selective references to G-d by Democrats when it s...
The Extended Obama Family
Funding the war on ourselves
The unrealistic, fantastical Obama worldview
Venezuela: When socialism fails it falls back on c...
Obama projects weakness and Russia behaves accordi...
Facebook says calling for death to Israel isn't ha...
IRS and the radical atheists, a perfect match of a...
Here's proof the judicial system is screwed up bey...
VA bonuses for incompetence and killing veterans. ...
"The problem with socialism is that sooner or late...
You didn't build that. The Muslims did. Obama
Caught in an outrageous anti Israel proposal, the ...
5 New Muslim Calls for Genocide of the Jews...for ...
A blistering indictment of Hamas by Senator Rubio
Madison's injunction in Federalist 47
Destroying a common myth and exposing government g...
The decline of the auto industry in Russia
Life in Pakistan.
Obama: the history of an anti, anti Communist. The...
The end of Christianity in Iraq.
Is there really a shortage of American tech worker...
Unfortunately, you can't put the toothpaste back i...
Africa and Ebola
The growing acceptance of anti Semitism in America...
Israel's most dangerous enemy...
Palestinian Islamists and their Nazi supporting fr...
Turkey to raise the stakes in the mideast. Remembe...
Egypt destroys Gaza tunnels.
Making America a less safe place.
The Administration's pea in the shell scam
Tony Dungy, Israel and the Media's Selective Relig...
True to Democrat form he takes other people's mone...
Unscrupulous trial lawyers lie, cheat to steal mon...
Now why would anyone need to protect themselves in...
REPORT: HAMAS USED CHILD LABOR TO BUILD TERROR TUN...
Government approved predation. When the governmen...
Obama snatching defeat from the jaws of victory. N...
Obama and Hillary's excellent adventure in Libya. ...
Why would anyone think Kerry or Obama for that mat...
An out of control government bureaucracy will cont...
Hamas used the concrete meant for building houses ...
Kerry cease fire plan: jews you lose. Latent jew h...
Checked out leaving chaos in his wake.
Gaza Nazi supporters...same goal
Hamas and North Korea: the barbaric anti west tota...
A heartwarming story.
Eleanor Holmes Norton says 'you don't have a right...
Too many unhinged people walking among us.
Hamas had plans for the Jewish New Year and they'r...
The shia axis of Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran.
An open letter to the Democrat Socialists
Ignorant or the spawn of the Nazi linked Hamas
The problem is that bureaucrats don't want to work...
The corrupt underbelly of the parasitic non profit...
Palestinians cynical use of the term civilian casu...
Proving some stereotypes are justifiable.
Obamacare tax
Tomb of Jonah destroyed by Islamists.
Islamists show their barbarism
Real massacres.
cognitive dissonance as practiced by Michelle Obam...
A moment of judicial sanity. But, it will make Cod...
Obtuse?