Geithner Kool-Aid Is All The Rage
November 15th, 2010 Posted in Uncategorized
Nov, 15 2010
Comments Off on Geithner Kool-Aid Is All The Rage
Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner's "charm offensive", began one year ago. At that time, a number of financial bloggers were invited to the Treasury Department for an "open discussion" forum led by individual senior Treasury officials (including Turbo Tim himself). Most of the invitees were not brainwashed to the desired extent. I reviewed a number of postings from those in attendance – most of whom demonstrated more than a little skepticism about the entire affair. Nevertheless, Secretary Geithner and his team held another conclave with financial bloggers on Monday, August 16, 2010. The second meeting worked more to Geithner's advantage. The Treasury Secretary made a favorable impression on Alex Tabarrok, just as he had done last November with Tabarrok's partner at Marginal Revolution, Tyler Cowen. Steve Waldman of Interfluidity provided a candid description of his own reaction to the August 16 event. Waldman's commentary exposed how the desired effect was achieved:
First, let me confess right from the start, I had a great time. I pose as an outsider and a crank. But when summoned to the court, this jester puts on his bells. I am very, very angry at Treasury, and the administration it serves. But put me at a table with smart, articulate people who are willing to argue but who are otherwise pleasant towards me, and I will like them.
I like these people, and that renders me untrustworthy. Abstractly, I think some of them should be replaced and perhaps disgraced. But having chatted so cordially, I'm far less likely to take up pitchforks against them. Drawn to the Secretary's conference room by curiosity, vanity, ambition, and conceit, I've been neutered a bit.
More recently, a good deal of attention has focused on a November 4 article from Bloomberg News, revealing that back on April 2, Turbo Tim paid a call on Jon Stewart. The disclosure by Ian Katz raised quite a few eyebrows:
Geithner and Stewart, host of Comedy Central's "The Daily Show," held an off-the-record meeting at Stewart's office in New York on April 2, according to Geithner's appointments calendar, updated through August on Treasury's website.
Since that time, we have heard nothing from Jon Stewart about his meeting with Geithner. I expect that Stewart will continue his silence about that topic, focusing our attention, instead, on the controversy concerning a book, which should have been titled, Pedophilia For Dummies, while referring to Amazon.com as "NAMBLAzon.com". If he uses that joke – remember that you saw it here, first.
The November 13 New York Times article by Yale economics professor, Robert Shiller, raises the question of whether Professor Shiller is the latest victim of the Geithner Kool-Aid. Shiller's essay reeks of the Obama administration's strategy of approaching the nation's most pressing crises as public relations concerns — a panacea for avoiding the ugly task of actually solving those problems. The title of Shiller's article, "Bailouts, Reframed as 'Orderly Resolutions'" says it all: spin means everything. The following statement is a perfect example:
Our principal hope for dealing with the next big crisis is the Dodd-Frank Act, signed by President Obama in July. It calls for bailouts of a sort, but has reframed them so they may look better to taxpayers. Now they will be called "orderly resolutions."
Yves Smith of the Naked Capitalism website had no trouble ripping this assertion (as well as Shiller's entire essay) to shreds:
Huh? It's widely acknowledged that Dodd Frank is too weak. In the Treasury meeting with bloggers last August, Geithner didn't argue the point much, but instead contended that big enough capital levels, which were on the way with Basel III, were the real remedy.
It's also widely recognized that the special resolution process in Dodd Frank is a non-starter as far as the institutions that pose the greatest systemic risk are concerned, the really big international dealer banks. A wind-up of these firms is subject to the bankruptcy proceedings of all the foreign jurisdictions in which it operates; the US can't wave a magic wand in Dodd Frank and make this elephant in the room vanish.
In addition, no one has found a way to resolve a major trading firm without creating major disruption.
Shiller's insistence that the public is so dumb as to confuse a windown with a bailout reveals his lack of connection with popular perceptions. The reason the public is so angry with the bailouts is no one, particularly among the top brass, lost his job, and worse, the firms were singularly ungrateful, thumbing their noses at taxpayers and paying themselves record bonuses in 2009.
Bill Maher's Real Time program of November 12 is just the most recent example of how Bill Maher and most of his guests from the entire season are Geithner Kool-Aid drinkers. The show marked the ten-trillionth time Maher claimed that TARP was a "success" because the banks have "paid back" those government bailouts. Bill Maher needs to invite Yves Smith on his program so that she can debunk this myth, as she did in her June 23 piece. "Geithner Yet Again Misrepresents TARP 'Performance'". Ms. Smith is not the only commentator who repeatedly calls out the administration on this whopper. Marshall Auerback and almost everyone else at the Roosevelt Institute have said the same thing. Edward Harrison of Credit Writedowns wrote this piece for the Seeking Alpha website, in support of Aureback's TARP critique. Will Wilkinson's October 8 essay in The Economist's Democracy in America blog presented the negative responses from a number of authorities in response to the claim that TARP was a great success. With all that has been written to dispute the glorification of TARP, one would think that the "TARP was a success" meme would fade away. Nevertheless, the Geithner Kool-Aid is a potent brew and its effects can, in some cases, be permanent.
Alex Tabarrok, Amazon com, August 16, Bailouts Reframed as Orderly Resolutions, bank bailouts, Basel III, Bill Maher, Bloomberg news, charm offensive, Comedy Central, Credit Writedowns, Democracy in America, Dodd-Frank Act, Edward Harrison, financial bloggers, Geithner Kool-Aid Is All The Rage, Ian Katz, Interfluidity, Jon Stewart, Marginal Revolution, Marshall Auerback, Naked Capitalism, NAMBLAzon com, New York Times, Obama Administration, Pedophilia For Dummies, President Obama, Real Time, Robert Shiller, Roosevelt Institute, Seeking Alpha, special resolution process, spin means everything, Steve Waldman, systemic risk, TARP was a success, TARP was a success meme, taxpayers, The Daily Show, The Economist, too big to fail, Treasury Department, Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner, Turbo Tim, Turbo Tim Geithner, Tyler Cowen, Will Wilkinson, Yves Smith
Time To Toss The Tool
November 6th, 2008 Posted in Uncategorized
Comments Off on Time To Toss The Tool
November 5 (the day after Election Day) left us with a nearly breathless Chris Matthews on MSNBC's Hardball. His guests included their correspondent, David Schuster, who had attended the election night speech by Barack Obama in Chicago's Grant Park. Schuster described the scene in Grant Park, immediately after the west coast results were announced at 11:00 p.m. (Eastern Time). Strangers were hugging each other and crying. This could have only happened in Chicago. I had been in Grant Park on several occasions to celebrate many a Bulls championship, back in the day when Phil Jackson was coach and Michael Jordan defied the laws of gravity. The post-championship celebration in Grant Park became a rite of summer: the weather was just getting nice and Fourth of July was right around the corner. I still return to Grant Park for the annual Independence Day fireworks show (that actually takes place on July 3) even though I now live a long way from there. The consensual spirit of Chicago's people brings life to the theories expressed by Carl Jung. Myth, archetype and symbol hold important places in the collective soul of that community.
Chicago has its own approach to politics, as well. The city's history is rich with tales of "back alley" politics, giving rise to legendary figures and laying waste to contenders. As a result, I can't keep my mind off the subject of what might be in store for Senator Joe "The Tool" Lieberman of Connecticut. The remark by Stephen Colbert during Indecision 2008 on Comedy Central, caught my attention. After the announcement that Obama had won 64 percent of the vote in Connecticut, compared to McCain's 35 percent, despite McCain's unfailing support from The Tool, Colbert wondered: "Where could the people of Connecticut have learned such disloyal behavior?" As you may recall: Lieberman was re-elected to the Senate in 2006 as an Independent candidate (after having lost the Democratic primary to Ned Lamot). Although they were irked by The Tool's mercenary act to preserve his own political skin, the Democrats struggled to keep Joe in their "Big Tent". The Senate Democratic Caucus (or Conference) currently consists of 49 regular Democrats and 2 Independents, one of whom is Joe "The Tool" Lieberman, who calls himself an "Independent Democrat". Prior to the 2008 election, the Democrats had been desperate to maintain their 51-percent majority in the Senate, so they did all they could to make sure The Tool was a happy camper. All that changed when Barack Obama became the presumptive Democratic Presidential nominee. Many commentators saw in Obama, not only a winner, but one with long enough coattails to bring more Democrats into the Senate. The Tool realized that his betrayal of the Democrats could result in the loss of his many important appointments, should Obama get elected. He had already "sold his soul" to Bush, Cheney and Rove in his quest for re-election. At that point, he had no choice but to "go for broke" by endorsing John McCain. However, The Tool went beyond that. He spoke ill of Obama at the Republican Convention. He followed McCain around throughout the Presidential campaign, giving rally speeches himself, in addition to serving as McCain's "nodder" when McCain would question Obama's patriotism.
It is now time for the Senate Democrats to throw The Tool under The Trash Talk Express, before it departs for that great bus barn in the sky. It has been widely reported that The Tool is scheduled to meet with Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, at some point this week. My familiarity with Chicago politics leads me to believe that on his way to this meeting, The Tool will be alone in a dark alley. He will reach a spot alongside a blue dumpster and that will be the signal. Suddenly, Democratic Senators will step out from their positions, in the shadows, to surround him. The Tool will be cut … and he will be cut quite thoroughly. He will be cut from the Senate Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship. He will be cut from the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs (where he is Chairman). He will be cut from the Senate Armed Services Committee. He will be cut from the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, including its Subcommittees on: Clean Air and Nuclear Safety, Private Sector and Consumer Solutions to Global Warming and Wildlife Protection (where he is Chairman). He will also be cut from the Subcommittee on Public Sector Solutions to Global Warming, Oversight, and Children's Health Protection. He will be left, writhing on the back bench of the Senate. "Backbenchers" have no influence to peddle … or, perhaps I should say: They have difficulty raising campaign contributions.
The Tool assumed that by joining himself to McCain's hip, he could secure the Vice-Presidential nomination or a high-level Cabinet appointment. This must have appeared as his only route to avoid obscurity. It didn't work.
The Tool now has a "date with destiny" somewhere in a dark alley . . .
2008 campaign, 2008 election, back alley politics, backbencher, Barack Obama, Cabinet appointment, Carl Jung, Chicago, Chicago Bulls, Chicago politics, Chris Matthews, coattails, Comedy Central, Commentary, Connecticut, date with destiny, David Schuster, Democrat, Democratic Party, Democratic primary, Democratic Senators, Democratic ticket, Democrats, Dick Cheney, Election Day, election night speech, George Bush, GOP, Grant Park, Hardball, Indecision 2008, Joe The Tool Lieberman, John Burke, John McCain, John T Burke Jr, Karl Rove, McCain campaign, McCain-Palin, Michael Jordan, MSNBC, Ned Lamot, New York Times, News, Obama, Obama - Biden ticket, Obama Biden, Opinion, Phil Jackson, Political, Politics, President of the United States, Presidential campaign, Republican, Republican Convention, Republican Party, Republican ticket, Senate Armed Services Committee, Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Senate Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship, Senate Democrats, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, Senator Joe Lieberman, Senator Lieberman, Stephen Colbert, Subcommitte Chairman, Subcommitte on Clean Air and Nuclear Safety, Subcommitte on Private Sector and Consumer Solutions to Global Warming and Wildlife Protection, Subcommittee on Public Sector Solutions to Global Warming Oversight and Childrens Health Protection, the center lane, The Trash Talk Express, The White House, thecenterlane, Time To Toss The Tool, Vice President, Vice-Presidential nomination