Arms Trade Treaty legal blog
A legal blog on the negotiations of a United Nations Arms Trade Treaty.
Down is up and up is down
'It seems very pretty,' she said when she had finished it, 'but it's rather hard to understand!' (You see she didn't like to confess, ever to herself, that she couldn't make it out at all.) "Somehow it seems to fill my head with ideas — only I don't exactly know what they are!" So speaks Alice in Lewis Carrolls' Alice through the Looking Glass.
© Jesper Waldersten
Indeed, it was hard to escape the feeling that we too today had stepped through a mirror to an alternative world. For we heard Iran, Egypt, Malaysia, and a number of others, including those cited below--many of whom are not known for their unremitting hunger for an ATT--all complain that there was no real negotiation going on and no rolling text with which to negotiate.
India may have spoken for many when it said that there was a "general concern" to move forward with the negotiations. One could turn the proposals into a rolling text/conference room paper or ask states to submit treaty text by a specific deadline. It stated that there is a need to move forward, and India needs to see a text for negotiation. Syria similarly saw the need to begin "in a practical manner" the negotiation on a specific text. Time is flying. It will not be possible to negotiate if we wait longer. Negotiation should start quickly.
Cuba helped to give clarity to this seemingly parallel universe, by expressing its fear that there will be an attempt at the end to impose a text on the delegations. "Hopefully it is not the intention of the President"; however it was a realistic scenario "that needs to be avoided". There is, it too claimed, a need to start with a true negotiation exercise. So far it has been an exercise in repetition and general statements. The problem is that there is no text available for negotiation. The compilation of ideas is useful; however a document of this type is not an effective tool. It supported the views of others that a deadline should be established for delegations to submit concrete proposals to prepare a rolling text. (It added, in case of doubt, its view that the objectives of the ATT should be only to contribute to combating illicit trafficking in conventional weapons.) Syria agreed with this.
So, did we see a game-changer today, a watershed in what appeared to be a negotiating desert? The answer should come on Friday, when rolling texts on at least scope and implementation (and possibly other sections) will be presented by the respective chairs. But let's not get ahead of ourselves. There's been very little shift in positions from delegations, which are as wide apart as ever on the key issues, but this was all too predictable given that there was no text to deliberate and on which to seek compromise. Until then, let us keep in mind the words of Alice and the Queen, which seem to describe a current mental state.
"I don't understand you," said Alice. "It's dreadfully confusing!"
"That's the effect of living backwards," the Queen said kindly: "it always makes one a little giddy at first."
Posted by ATT Legal bloggers at 5:45 PM
Sandhya Delhi Escort Service August 18, 2020 at 1:45 AM
Also known to come with crucial offerings for its sensible, down-to-earth and important clients,Call Girls in Aerocity really means in fulfilling their lives with cheerful moments to make love in concern to ensure them live their lives in abetter way. Check our other Services...
Female Call Girls in Agra
Call Girls in Agra
Air Hostess Call Girls in Gurgaon
Call Girls Contact no in Agra
Air Hostess Call Girls in Agra
Geneva Academy of International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights
Oxford Martin School Programme on Human Rights
ATT Legal bloggers
One more push in the UN or shall we do it right?
The Arms Trade Treaty: so near and not so far?
Hungover or hung under?
History in the making?
Don't blink ... or you may miss it
A fightback ... of sorts
Brace yourselves for the sell-out
Follow the yellow brick road?
A defining moment?
Eton Mess
Shadow boxing against the clock
Stop thinking and go in?
A preamble to the real negotiations...?
It's not the despair, it's the hope I can't handle
Out of the paddock and into the sheep dip?
The End of the Beginning
Palestinian statehood and an effective Arms Trade ...
The End of the beginning or the beginning of the End?
ADH Geneva
Illustrations by Jesper Waldersten jesperwaldersten.com/
Documents and Analysis
President's Non-Paper (22.03.2013)
Comprehensive Draft ATT (26.07.12)
Criteria/Parameters Chairman Paper (16.07.2012)
Elements of provision on Scope in an ATT (13.07.2012)
President's Discussion Paper (03.07.2012)
Provisional Rules of Procedure
Chairman's Draft ATT (14.07.2011)
Chairman's Draft Paper - Implementation (11.07.2011)
Chairman's Draft Paper (03.03.2011)
Chairman's Draft Paper - Second PrepCom (28.02.2011)
Boston Symposium: Official Summary Report (October 2010)
Facilitator's Summary for Scope (22.07.2010)
Facilitator's Summary on Parameters (22.07.2010)
Facilitator's Summary on Implementation and Application (22.07.2010)
Chairman's Draft Principles (14.07.2010)
Chairman's Draft Elements (14.07.2010)
Informal discussions (7.07.2010) Geneva Forum
How weapon dealers are using the UK to export illegal consignment of arms to Middle East and conflict zones (BBC report, 13.07.2010)
Rule of Law in Armed Conflicts Project (RULAC)
Background UN documentation
UN Arms Trade Treaty - Preparatory Committee
UN Register of Conventional Arms
The Wassenaar Arrangement
UNIDIR (UN Institute for Disarmament Research)
The Geneva Forum
Small Arms Survey
Arms Trade Treaty Monitor
Illustrations by Jesper Waldersten - www.jesperwaldersten.com. Watermark theme. Powered by Blogger.