House Report on IRS Targeting Finds No White House Connection
There are two reasons why a Congressional committee would release a major report two days before Christmas when Washington is a virtual ghost town. The first is that the contents are so important they must be made public immediately. The second is that the authors hope the report will escape notice and sink into obscurity. The decision by the House Oversight and Government Reform to release its report on the Internal Revenue Service's targeting of conservative groups seems pretty clearly to have been driven by the latter.
The 226-page report issued by Committee Chairman Darrell Issa (R-CA) is the culmination of more than a year of hearings and document dumps aimed at finding out who was responsible for a policy under which the agency's Department of Exempt Organizations systematically applied extra scrutiny to applications for non-profit status from organizations that appeared to have a political agenda. While the program targeted both liberal and conservative groups, the pressure fell disproportionately on the conservatives.
The chief investigative committee of the U.S. House of Representatives spent more than a year, and untold resources, on investigating the IRS, in large part looking for a connection between the White House and the targeting scandal. The failure to find any such connection bolsters critics' claims that the effort was largely political.
Related: Issa's Watchdog Successor – A New Breed of Bulldog
Issa made no secret about what he expected to find: top-down instructions from the White House to target conservative groups in the run-up to the 2012 elections. But the report, while chock full of evidence of wrongful conduct that almost certainly damaged the ability of legitimate non-profit organizations to raise money and pursue their goals, found no evidence that the program was directed by Washington.
That didn't prevent Issa from implying that a connection existed. The report opens by recounting that in October 2014, the president gave a speech in which he complained that a recent Supreme Court ruling had made it easier for corporations to funnel money into political campaigns. Five days later, it notes, and IRS employee who would become synonymous with the targeting program, Lois Lerner, the director of the Department of Exempt Organizations, gave remarks at Duke University in which she expressed concern about the same decision.
The report quotes Lerner: "And everyone is up in arms because they don't like it. . . . They want the IRS to fix the problem. . . . I won't know until I look at their [tax return form] 990s next year whether they have done more than their primary activity as political or not. So I can't do anything right now."
Apparently based on little more than the two statements' proximity in time, the report finds, "The pressure to 'fix the problem,' as articulated by Lois Lerner, originated with President Obama and senior party leadership."
Related: Issa's Hearing on Secret Service Lapses Could Bring Fireworks
However, the report stops notably short of claiming that the White House or administration officials in Washington ordered the targeting.
Issa's determination to uncover a link to the White House in the targeting scandal led to increasingly hostile relations between him and Rep. Elijah Cummings, the Maryland Democrat who serves as ranking member on the committee. In one memorable exchange, Issa walked out of a hearing room and instructed his staff members to turn off Cummings microphone as the Democrat was in the middle of speaking.
Lerner invoked her Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, and declined to testify before Issa's committee, sparking widespread Republican outrage. Later, when it was determined that the IRS had lost an untold number of emails to and from Lerner and other senior officials that it ought to have archived, many in the GOP became convinced there was a conspiracy to cover up wrongdoing at the agency.
Related: Gruber Won't Say How Much He Made as Obamacare Architect
The release of the Issa report, though, doesn't mean that IRS conspiracy theorists need give up hope. The report notes that it is not the final word on the targeting scandal, but is simply Rep. Issa's summing up of his work on the matter. Because he is term-limited as chairman, he will depart as committee chair in January.
Rep. Jason Chaffetz (R-Utah), who takes over from Issa in January, has been an enthusiastic participant in the IRS hearings, and will continue to receive new evidence in the case when the 114th Congress convenes next month.
Exit Elmendorf, Enter a New Politicized CBO?
Why Drones Could Cause the Next Mid-Air Disaster
ISIS Closing in on Israel from the North and South
Taxpayer Advocate: The IRS Needs More Funding
National Taxpayer Advocate Erin Collins released her annual report to Congress Wednesday, and it came with a blunt...
Trump's Payroll Tax Plan Is Hung Up in a Dispute With the IRS: Report
President Trump's effort to suspend employee Social Security taxes starting September 1 is hung up over a dispute over...
IRS Will Send 14 Million Taxpayers Interest on Their Tax Refunds
Nearly 14 million taxpayers who waited until July 15 to file their taxes will be paid interest on their refunds, the...