Commission initiates formal investigations against Microsoft in two cases of suspected abuse of dominant market position
European Union February 7 2008
The European Commission has decided to initiate two formal antitrust investigations against Microsoft Corp concerning two separate categories of alleged infringements of EC Treaty rules on abuse of a dominant market position (Article 82). The first case where proceedings have been opened is in the field of interoperability in relation to a complaint by the European Committee for Interoperable Systems (ECIS). The second area where proceedings have been opened is in the field of tying of separate software products following inter alia a complaint by Opera.
As regards interoperability, in its Microsoft judgment of 17 September 2007, the Court of First Instance confirmed the principles that must be respected by dominant companies as regards interoperability disclosures. In the complaint by ECIS, Microsoft is alleged to have illegally refused to disclose interoperability information across a broad range of products, including information related to its Office suite, a number of its server products, and also in relation to the so called .NET Framework. The Commission's examination will therefore focus on all these areas, including the question whether Microsoft's new file format Office Open XML, as implemented in Office, is sufficiently interoperable with competitors' products.
As for the tying of separate software products, in its Microsoft judgment of 17 September 2007, the Court of First Instance confirmed the principles that must be respected by dominant companies. In a complaint by Opera, a competing browser vendor, Microsoft is alleged to have engaged in illegal tying of its Internet Explorer product to its dominant Windows operating system. The complaint alleges that there is ongoing competitive harm from Microsoft's practices, in particular in view of new proprietary technologies that Microsoft has allegedly introduced in its browser that would reduce compatibility with open internet standards, and therefore hinder competition. In addition, allegations of tying of other separate software products by Microsoft, including desktop search and Windows Live have been brought to the Commission's attention. The Commission's investigation will therefore focus on allegations that a range of products have been unlawfully tied to sales of Microsoft's dominant operating system.
This initiation of proceedings does not imply that the Commission has proof of an infringement. It only signifies that the Commission will further investigate the case as a matter of priority. [14 January 2008]
Bird & Bird LLP - Catherine Erkelens, Dr. Jörg Witting and Prof. Dr. Frank Immenga, LL.M.
IT & Data Protection
EU General Court
Dominance (economics)
Treaty of Rome
Article 102 TFEU
What does the Brexit Agreement say about data protection? *
A New Year, a new approach to digital regulation: the DSA and Online Harms *
Brexit: aviation and travel regulation *
The effect of Brexit on UK consumer protection law *
EU Commission Proposes to Update the NIS/Cybersecurity Directive Only Two Years After Implementation *
Commission investigates Microsoft *
Commission launches case against Microsoft *
New EU competition investigation against Microsoft announced by the European Commission *
Innovation in the balance? Courts and agencies take another look at product innovation and the competition laws * - USA
Once again competition rules force "software interoperability" * - Italy
Antitrust issues continue flaring up in China's IT sector * - China
Audrey E Mross
Labor & Employment Attorney
Munck Carter LLP
"The Lexology newsfeed is very relevant to my practice and I like that you can tailor the newsfeed to include specific practice areas. I enjoy seeing a variety of approaches and I will read multiple articles on the same topic for the purpose of getting the fullest understanding of a new law, a court case or other legal development."