The NM Political Report (https://nmpoliticalreport.com/2017/09/11/city-council-candidate-ordered-to-pay-almost-2k-for-campaign-violations/)
City council candidate ordered to pay almost $2K for campaign violations
By Andy Lyman | September 11, 2017
The City of Albuquerque Board of Ethics Monday afternoon voted to impose a $1,900 fine on an Albuquerque City Council Candidate for not following the city's election code.
The hearing was the latest related to a complaint by former mayoral candidate Stella Padilla and private investigator Carlos McMahon against city council candidate Javier Benavidez.
Padilla and McMahon alleged that Benavidez's campaign fraudulently obtained about $38,000 of public campaign funds by using some of their own money instead of collecting $5 from each petition signer.
Padilla and McMahon's lawyer, prominent Republican Pat Rogers, wrote in his closing argument that Benavidez should return the taxpayer-funded money his campaign received, be fined at least $21,000 and be removed from the City Council if he wins the race. Rogers also said the issue should be referred to the Bernalillo County District Attorney's office for possible criminal prosecution.
The city's public financing provision requires candidates requesting public funds to collect signatures and $5 contributions from a certain percentage of voters in their district. Benavidez's lawyers argued that while his campaign workers may have made mistakes, they were not intentionally fraudulent. Further, his lawyers wrote, the city's public financing rules are ambiguous and don't clarify whether a $5 contribution can be made on behalf of another person. They said the sanctions Rogers asked for were beyond the duties of the board.
"The Complainants' attack on Mr. Benavidez and his campaign was a singular affront to the fair election process and an ugly and ad hominin (sic) attack on a hard-working candidate with an excellent reputation," Benavidez's lawyers wrote.
Board of Ethics members excused themselves to a closed session to discuss the case and did not comment publicly on their discussions. The board agreed unanimously that Benavidez broke city election rules and imposed the fine.
One of Benavidez's lawyers, Molly Schmidt-Nowara, told NM Political Report the boards decision was fair and reflected that his campaign unintentionally broke the rules.
Rogers told NM Political Report the $1,900 fine did not go far enough to address what he said were false statements by Benavidez, under oath, and fraudulent campaign finance records.
"Mr Benavidez cheated," Rogers said. "Mr. Benavidez's representatives cheated."
Perjury occurred, Rogers said, when Benavidez testified that City Clerk Natalie Howard gave him permission to "vouch" for his campaign workers. Howard denied that claim during her testimony.
Schmidt-Nowara said Rogers' perjury claim is a "conflation" of a statement Benavidez made about telling Howard he trusted his campaign workers.
"Javier did not lie," Schmidt-Nowara said.
Rogers added that he thinks the fine sends a message of leniency to other potential candidates.
"He's made a joke of the public financing," Rogers said.
Schmidt-Nowara, on the other hand, thinks the drawn-out hearing will actually deter canidates
from breaking the rules.
According to public financing records filed last week, Benavidez's campaign still has about $21,000 on hand. If the board would have taken Rogers' suggestion for financial punishment, Benavidez's campaign would be more than $38,000 in the hole.
Rogers said he will confer with Padilla and McMahon and assess his current caseload before deciding whether to pursue the case in state district court.
Albuquerque Newsdesk
2017 Albuquerque City Council election
Albuquerque Board of Ethics
Javier Benavidez
Molly Schmidt-Nowara
BernCo Commission votes down Democracy Dollars ballot access
The Bernalillo County Board of Commissioners voted on Tuesday against adding a public finance proposal to the November general election ballot. The proposal, known as Democracy Dollars, would provide vouchers to citizens, who could apply them to publicly-financed candidates of their choice.
Groups want 'Democracy Dollars' to bolster ABQ publicly-financed candidates
View all Albuquerque Newsdesk articles →
Former ABQ city council candidate suing current councilor for releasing personal information
Update: Added a response from Don Harris Almost a year after the Albuquerque municipal election, a former city council candidate is suing his former opponent, who won the council seat. Byron Powdrell, who owns and operates a local, non-profit radio station, filed a lawsuit against City Councilor Don Harris and a private investigator hired by Harris during the 2017 mayoral and city council election season.
Could Democratic victories in ABQ, Las Cruces preview 2018?
Voter turnout in ABQ runoff nearly matched first round of voting
View all 2017 Albuquerque City Council election articles →
Ethics board: Keller violated rule with 'in-kind' donations
The City of Albuquerque Board of Ethics Rules & Regulations unanimously found that Tim Keller violated the city's elections and ethics codes, but it did not impose any penalty. The board decided the case involving in-kind donations Monday, the day before voters cast ballots in the runoff election.
Campaign complaint sent back to ethics board
Mayoral ethics complaints unlikely to be settled before election
View all Albuquerque Board of Ethics articles →
On New Mexico's primary election day, in almost triple-digit heat, former state Senator Dede Feldman stood outside an Albuquerque middle school with a signature-filled clipboard in hand. It's not uncommon to see people gathering signatures outside of polling locations for various political efforts.
Complaint: Watchdog P.I. committed fraud, used intimidation
What to know on election day in ABQ
View all Javier Benavidez articles →
A self-proclaimed government watchdog could have his private investigator's license revoked, depending on what a governing board could decide next month. Another private investigator filed an official complaint with the New Mexico Regulation and Licensing Department (RLD) last month against Carlos McMahon that alleged he obtained his private investigator license fraudulently and abused his position as an investigator.
View all Molly Schmidt-Nowara articles →
New Mexico adapts to decades of drought caused by climate change
Relatives of undocumented children caught up in ICE dragnet