An Alabama Woman's Neighborly Vaccination Campaign | The New Yorker
The New Yorker Documentary
An Alabama Woman's Neighborly Vaccination Campaign
In "The Panola Project," Dorothy Oliver fights vaccine hesitancy with kindness.
Film by Rachael DeCruz and Jeremy S. Levine
Text by Yasmine Al-Sayyad
When asked how she talks people into signing up to get immunized, Oliver said, "I just be nice to them."
In a recent, widely circulated Op-Ed, the New York Times columnist Ezra Klein derided the "conventional wisdom" in the public-health discussion of covid-19 vaccines that "there is some argument, yet unmade and perhaps undiscovered, that will change the minds of the roughly 30 percent of American adults who haven't gotten at least one dose." The vaccinated are at the end of their tether with the holdouts. With covid cases on the rise once again, business executives, local governments, universities, and, most recently, the federal government are out of patience, exchanging solicitations for tougher vaccine mandates. "Persuasion," Klein argues, "is by no means impossible or unimportant, but on electric topics, it is a marginal phenomenon."
The New Yorker Documentary An Alabama Woman's Neighborly Vaccination Campaign In "The Panola Project," Dorothy Oliver fights vaccine hesitancy with kindness. Film by Rachael DeCruz and Jeremy S. Levine Text by Yasmine Al-Sayyad August 11, 2021 When asked how she talks people into signing up to get immunized, Oliver said, "I just be nice to them." In a recent, widely circulated Op-Ed, the New York Times columnist Ezra Klein derided the "conventional wisdom" in the public-health discussion of covid-19 vaccines that "there is some argument, yet unmade and perhaps undiscovered, that will change the minds of the roughly 30 percent of American adults who haven't gotten at least one dose." The vaccinated are at the end of their tether with the holdouts. With covid cases on the rise once again, business executives, local governments, universities, and, most recently, the federal government are out of patience, exchanging solicitations for tougher vaccine mandates. "Persuasion," Klein argues, "is by no means impossible or unimportant, but on electric topics, it is a marginal phenomenon." "The Panola Project," a short documentary by Rachael DeCruz and Jeremy S. Levine, is a heartwarming story of this marginal phenomenon. It follows the efforts of a retired Black woman, Dorothy Oliver, and the county commissioner, Drucilla Russ-Jackson, to bring the vaccine to her isolated hamlet of about four hundred residents in rural Alabama, and to persuade enough of her community to take it. "I just felt like I had to do it because the government, nobody does enough in this area," she says. "This area here is majority Black. Kind of puts you on the back burner. That's just it. I mean, you don't have to put nothing else with that. That's just it. I don't have to elaborate on that one." The New Yorker Documentary View the latest or submit your own film. Panola never had its own vaccine center. The closest options were thirty to forty miles away, and many residents don't have cars. In the film, Oliver and Russ-Jackson arrange for a hospital to set up a pop-up site in Panola, but the site will only be established if they get at least forty people to sign up to take the vaccine. We follow Oliver as she goes door to door, talking people into signing up, lightly cajoling them about their fears and concerns. When I asked her how she does it, her answer was disarmingly simple: "I just be nice to them," she said. "I don't go at them saying, 'You gotta do that.' " DeCruz, too, was struck by the way Oliver and Jackson talked to people who were on the fence about the vaccine, an issue more often discussed with stridency of various types. "There's this very warm and kind of loving and caring way that Dorothy and Ms. Jackson approached those conversations, even when people aren't in agreement. And it wasn't done in a way that's, like, 'I know better than you.' " Oliver's charm with the skeptics is remarkable, but so is her determination to bring the vaccine to her underserved town. Most of the women and men Oliver talked to leaped at the opportunity to sign up for the vaccine. On vaccine day, they rolled down their car windows to thank her. "We appreciate y'all giving it to us, because a lot of people don't really know where to go to take these vaccines," one woman tells her. Vaccine hesitancy in Black communities has been harped on in the media, but those conversations can gloss over questions of availability. Levine told me that they were struck by how many people had put off vaccination for logistical rather than ideological reasons. In Panola, he says, they regularly heard people say, "I want the shot. How do I get this? I don't have a car; how am I going to get forty miles to the closest hospital and back?" Alabama has one of the lowest vaccination rates in the country; only fifty-six per cent of adults have gotten at least one dose. Nearly everyone in Panola has—a striking ninety-four per cent of adults—including every single person above the age of sixty-five. DeCruz and Levine were living in Alabama when they worked on the film. "With everything that was happening there, we were looking for a story that had some hope in it," DeCruz told me, "to show people doing good work. Just finding some light in some dark times." Meanwhile, Oliver is keeping on. "I have the names of everyone who hasn't been vaccinated, and I'm still working on them," she told me.
"The Panola Project," a short documentary by Rachael DeCruz and Jeremy S. Levine, is a heartwarming story of this marginal phenomenon. It follows the efforts of a retired Black woman, Dorothy Oliver, and the county commissioner, Drucilla Russ-Jackson, to bring the vaccine to her isolated hamlet of about four hundred residents in rural Alabama, and to persuade enough of her community to take it. "I just felt like I had to do it because the government, nobody does enough in this area," she says. "This area here is majority Black. Kind of puts you on the back burner. That's just it. I mean, you don't have to put nothing else with that. That's just it. I don't have to elaborate on that one."
View the latest or submit your own film.
Panola never had its own vaccine center. The closest options were thirty to forty miles away, and many residents don't have cars. In the film, Oliver and Russ-Jackson arrange for a hospital to set up a pop-up site in Panola, but the site will only be established if they get at least forty people to sign up to take the vaccine. We follow Oliver as she goes door to door, talking people into signing up, lightly cajoling them about their fears and concerns. When I asked her how she does it, her answer was disarmingly simple: "I just be nice to them," she said. "I don't go at them saying, 'You gotta do that.' " DeCruz, too, was struck by the way Oliver and Jackson talked to people who were on the fence about the vaccine, an issue more often discussed with stridency of various types. "There's this very warm and kind of loving and caring way that Dorothy and Ms. Jackson approached those conversations, even when people aren't in agreement. And it wasn't done in a way that's, like, 'I know better than you.' "
Oliver's charm with the skeptics is remarkable, but so is her determination to bring the vaccine to her underserved town. Most of the women and men Oliver talked to leaped at the opportunity to sign up for the vaccine. On vaccine day, they rolled down their car windows to thank her. "We appreciate y'all giving it to us, because a lot of people don't really know where to go to take these vaccines," one woman tells her. Vaccine hesitancy in Black communities has been harped on in the media, but those conversations can gloss over questions of availability. Levine told me that they were struck by how many people had put off vaccination for logistical rather than ideological reasons. In Panola, he says, they regularly heard people say, "I want the shot. How do I get this? I don't have a car; how am I going to get forty miles to the closest hospital and back?"
Alabama has one of the lowest vaccination rates in the country; only fifty-six per cent of adults have gotten at least one dose. Nearly everyone in Panola has—a striking ninety-four per cent of adults—including every single person above the age of sixty-five. DeCruz and Levine were living in Alabama when they worked on the film. "With everything that was happening there, we were looking for a story that had some hope in it," DeCruz told me, "to show people doing good work. Just finding some light in some dark times." Meanwhile, Oliver is keeping on. "I have the names of everyone who hasn't been vaccinated, and I'm still working on them," she told me."
For Joe Manchin, Corruption and Greed Are a Family...
"A Moral Crisis": Reverend William Barber on Why C...
Live Updates: Congress Votes to Avert Government S...
Rep. Ocasio-Cortez On The Standoff Between Progres...
Sen. Elizabeth Warren On Getting All 50 Dem Senato...
Democrats Reportedly Urge Biden To Crack Down On S...
All This Could Happen Again America is running out...
'Follow The Money': Obama Vet Blasts Joe Manchin A...
Joe Manchin, Kyrsten Sinema Contradict Constituent...
The Plot to Kill Julian Assange: Report Reveals CI...
Fate of Biden's economic agenda at stake as House ...
Liberals Dig In Against Infrastructure Bill as Par...
GOP Launches Fundraising Frenzy Off Biden Vax Mand...
The 'Absolutely Frightening' Way Republicans Are A...
The U.S. Military Said It Was an ISIS Safe House. ...
Rep. Maxine Waters: Biden Admin Must End "Inhumane...
Senator Klobuchar FINALLY reveals Manchin's stance...
Voting Rights: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver ...
Trump Reveals He Asked Georgia Governor To 'Help U...
Opinion | The Mendacity of Joe Biden - The New Yor...
Opinion | Democrats: Political suicide is not a st...
Opinion | Our constitutional crisis is already her...
Democrats, Modify The Filibuster And Pass Voting R...
Haiti City In Shambles 🇭🇹
Help For Haiti 🇭🇹
This Is No Way to End a Pandemic
They Investigate Police Killings. Their Record Is ...
Joe: Trump Lost The Republicans Everything. And It...
Joe Biden Is Not My Uncle
Chris Hayes takes apart the racist right-wing immi...
Wole Soyinka: 'This book is my gift to Nigeria' | ...
Opinion | Ron DeSantis Was a Slam Dunk in Florida....
Opinion | The Tax Loophole That Helps America's Ri...
Man With Covid Changes Mind About Vaccine Just Bef...
True Idiot: Ted Cruz Blasted By Voting Expert As H...
Ted Cruz asks question at hearing and IMMEDIATELY ...
Crowded camps, garbage piles, extreme heat: migran...
A Black Composer Finally Arrives at the Metropolit...
Mary Trump: 'We Really Dodged A Bullet'
Republican governor makes dumbest misstep possible...
Herd Immunity: Covid Deaths Devouring the South Ar...
High Covid Hospitalizations Have Delayed Elective ...
Trump Campaign Knew Lawyers' Dominion Claims Were ...
Haitian immigrants gathered at southern border adv...
Homeland security officials will investigate after...
Covid-19 live updates U.S. reported deaths surpass...
It's Not the Left That's Causing Biden Problems
Deported by U.S., Haitians Are in Shock: 'I Don't ...
How This "Untouchable" From India's Lowest Caste E...
Trump, Republicans and white evangelicals are form...
Guess what the three Democrats blocking lower medi...
Opinion: If Republicans can't get behind an issue ...
Haiti Protests Mass U.S. Deportation of Migrants t...
Randall Kennedy — Say It Loud!: On Race, Law, Hist...
Coronavirus vaccines for kids: What I tell parents...
Afghan family ravaged by drone strike mistake asks...
Opinion | Joe Manchin Got the Voting Bill He Wante...
What to know about the FDA's decision on Pfizer bo...
Media FINALLY Calls Out Joe Manchin's Obstruction
Afghans Somber but Not Surprised as U.S. Calls Dro...
Pentagon acknowledges Aug. 29 drone strike in Afgh...
Eminent American Economist Jeffrey Sachs Exposes T...
'We deserve justice': McKayla Maroney testifies at...
Pence sought way to hand election to Trump; Dan Qu...
Opinion: Joe Manchin repeats a dangerous myth abou...
Biden comes to Milley's defense after revelation t...
Democrats Continue to Struggle With Men of Color
DeSantis 'Anti-Vaccine Mandate' Event Turned Anti-...
Newsom Survives California Recall Vote and Will Re...
Chris Christie has his worst day yet on national TV
Did a U.S. Drone Strike in Afghanistan Kill the Wr...
Notorious Anti-Mask QAnon Supporter Dies Of Covid
Some states fell far behind in vaccinating against...
The Man Behind Critical Race Theory As an attorney...
'Weird, patronizing behavior': AOC lets rip at Man...
What You Need To Know About The Planned Sept. 18th...
Opinion | The worst Catch-22 of all for Afghans wh...
Coronavirus live updates: Americans support vaccin...
Opinion | David Simon: The Selfless Art of Michael...
Helping For Haiti 🇭🇹
The Unnecessary Cruelty of America's Immigration S...
Sanders: 'I'm Tired Of Talking About Mr. Manchin A...
Hayes: GOP Tantrums Over Vaccine Mandates Are Ridi...
Analysis of the U.S. drone strike's aftermath in K...
Southlake: A viral video, a diversity plan, and an...
Opinion | The Limits of My Empathy for Covid-Denie...
The Un-vaccinated Are A Public Menace
Justice Department announces lawsuit against Texas...
Judge rules against DeSantis ban on mask mandate
Blood Brothers: the friendship and fallout of Malc...
Opinion | Geoff Duncan's book 'GOP 2.0' is the 202...
Least Vaccinated States Lead Spike in Children's C...
Joe Manchin's Daughter BUSTED In EpiPen Scandal
Reefer Madness: The Science of Marijuana with Neil...
Prosecutor Ramps Up Criminal Probe Into Trump Elec...
Kevin McCarthy's phone records subject to preserva...
See how the GOP is openly trying to thwart the Jan...
New Texas voting bill deepens growing disparities ...
The Masked Professor vs. the Unmasked Student At u...