Gwynne Dyer
Author, Historian & Independent Journalist
Meet Gwynne
Excerpts of Gwynne Dyer's Books
WAR – Chapter One – Book Excerpt
WAR – Chapter Three – Book Excerpt
WAR – Chapter Eight – Book Excerpt
Radio Series
Lecture Topic: Is It 1939 Yet?
India: The Weight of History
Politics / By Gwynne Dyer
"India is emotional as decades of wait has ended," declared India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi, laying the cornerstone of a new temple in Ayodhya a week ago. "For years our Ram Lalla (the infant Lord Ram) lived beneath a tent; now he will reside in a grand temple." As if infants cared about the size of their dwelling.
The 16th-century mosque that once stood on the site was destroyed by a Hindu mob in 1992, sparking riots that killed more than 2,000 people. Modi had visited the location the previous year, swearing not to return until the mosque was gone and a Hindu temple was under construction on the site, and lo! – there he was laying a 40 kg. foundation stone of pure silver for the new temple.
Does Narendra Modi really believe that Rama, 7th avatar of the Hindu god Vishnu, was born at this particular site in Ayodhya at 12.05 pm on January 10, 5114 BC? As with any politician who exploits religion to gain power, we'll never really know, and in any case it doesn't matter.
What does matter is the exploitation, which is destroying the secular Indian democracy of the past. And of course not only Hindu extremists exploit religion: on Sunday police opened fire on Muslim demonstrators in Bangalore, killing three, after local Muslim leaders spotted a Facebook post by a Hindu politician that allegedly "offended" the Prophet Muhammad. (Does he really take offense so easily?)
But there are six Hindus in India for every Muslim Indian, so this is not going to end well for the Muslims. Indeed, it has already ended very badly for some. Kashmir, the only Indian state with a Muslim majority, suddenly had its special status stripped away last August by Modi.
Kashmir has been split in two and is occupied by hundreds of thousands of Indian troops. Most of its politicians were kept under arrest for six months without charge, and the most senior ones have been charged under the Public Safety Act, which allows detention without trial for up to two years.
Five years ago, Indian-born artist Anish Kapoor called Prime Minister Modi a 'Hindu Taliban', and Modi's role in promoting an anti-Muslim pogrom that killed 2,000 (including some Hindus) when he was chief minister of Gujarat state in 2002 gave early evidence of his promise. But he was surprisingly low-key about religion during his first term as prime minister of all India in 2014-19.
That went well economically, and Modi was rewarded with a landslide majority in the May, 2019 election – whereupon he dropped his mask of moderation and went on an anti-Muslim spree. Kashmir last August, Ayodhya this August – and in between, a pair of new laws that threaten to take away the citizenship of many of India's Muslims. (They're less trouble if they can't vote.)
One new law is the National Register of Citizens, which everyone must be inscribed in. To be registered, however, you have to prove you are a citizen, which would pose a problem for many people who lack the necessary documents to prove they were born in India. It's a particular problem for Muslims, who are on average poorer than Hindus, and therefore less likely to have such documents.
But never mind: the Citizenship Amendment Act, passed at the same time, says that most illegal immigrants and refugees will be allowed to register without such documents. Since undocumented people living in India will effectively be treated as illegal immigrants, that will give them automatic citizenship if they are Hindu, Sikh, Christian or Buddhist. Muslims, however, do not get a free pass. No documents? Problems.
India can never expel 170 million Muslims. There's nowhere else for them to go. The goal of Narendra Modi and his Hindu supremacist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP – Indian People's Party) is to redefine them as an underclass without rights, and at the same time to preserve them as a permanent 'threat' that keeps Hindus united behind the BJP.
Why do so many Hindus go along with this vicious nonsense? Because for about seven centuries waves of Muslim invaders from central Asia ruled over most of India. It ended in the 18th century with the establishment of British rule (which didn't interfere with religion), but by then one-third of the population of the subcontinent was Muslim.
Very few of today's Muslims in India (or Pakistan or Bangladesh, for that matter) are descended from Central Asian conquerors. Most are descended from native-born Hindus who were forcibly converted to Islam, or changed their religion later to escape the Hindu caste system or the higher taxes paid by non-Muslims, or even sometimes for genuinely religious reasons.
It was all a very long time ago, and it shouldn't matter now. In a truly secular India, it wouldn't matter, which is why the country's founders insisted that it should be secular. But that's not what Modi wants, and Modi is winning.
To shorten to 700 words, omit paragraphs 9 and 10. ("One…Problems")
Welcome to Gwynne Dyer
Welcome to the site of author Gwynne Dyer. Gwynne Dyer is an historian and independent journalist, has published several books and has had his articles widely syndicated for many years. He is also available for university and corporate speaking engagements.
Suggested Read:
Crawling From the Wreckage
Want to Carry Articles?
Note for publications who carry or would like to carry articles. Gwynne Dyer's distribution email has changed, so please contact him through the contact form on this website if you are no longer receiving articles and would like to continue.
Defending the Indefensible December 30, 2020
Archives Select Month December 2020 (9) November 2020 (9) October 2020 (8) September 2020 (9) August 2020 (9) July 2020 (8) June 2020 (8) May 2020 (8) April 2020 (10) March 2020 (9) February 2020 (8) January 2020 (9) December 2019 (9) November 2019 (7) October 2019 (9) September 2019 (9) August 2019 (9) July 2019 (9) June 2019 (9) May 2019 (10) April 2019 (9) March 2019 (8) February 2019 (8) January 2019 (10) December 2018 (8) November 2018 (8) October 2018 (10) September 2018 (8) August 2018 (9) July 2018 (9) June 2018 (5) May 2018 (10) April 2018 (9) March 2018 (9) February 2018 (8) January 2018 (9) December 2017 (8) November 2017 (9) October 2017 (9) September 2017 (8) August 2017 (9) July 2017 (10) June 2017 (8) May 2017 (11) April 2017 (7) March 2017 (8) February 2017 (8) January 2017 (9) December 2016 (8) November 2016 (9) October 2016 (9) September 2016 (8) August 2016 (9) July 2016 (10) June 2016 (10) May 2016 (9) April 2016 (7) March 2016 (9) February 2016 (9) January 2016 (9) December 2015 (8) November 2015 (9) October 2015 (8) September 2015 (9) August 2015 (9) July 2015 (9) June 2015 (9) May 2015 (8) April 2015 (9) March 2015 (8) February 2015 (9) January 2015 (8) December 2014 (9) November 2014 (8) October 2014 (8) September 2014 (9) August 2014 (8) July 2014 (9) June 2014 (10) May 2014 (8) April 2014 (9) March 2014 (9) February 2014 (8) January 2014 (9) December 2013 (9) November 2013 (8) October 2013 (8) September 2013 (9) August 2013 (9) July 2013 (10) June 2013 (9) May 2013 (9) April 2013 (10) March 2013 (7) February 2013 (8) January 2013 (9) December 2012 (9) November 2012 (8) October 2012 (9) September 2012 (9) August 2012 (9) July 2012 (8) June 2012 (8) May 2012 (9) April 2012 (7) March 2012 (7) February 2012 (6) January 2012 (9) December 2011 (10) November 2011 (8) October 2011 (7) September 2011 (7) August 2011 (9) July 2011 (10) June 2011 (7) May 2011 (9) April 2011 (8) March 2011 (7) February 2011 (9) January 2011 (8) December 2010 (8) November 2010 (8) October 2010 (7) September 2010 (7) August 2010 (9) July 2010 (7) June 2010 (8) May 2010 (8) April 2010 (8) March 2010 (8) February 2010 (7) January 2010 (7) December 2009 (10) November 2009 (7) October 2009 (8) September 2009 (9) August 2009 (8) July 2009 (9) June 2009 (7) May 2009 (8) April 2009 (8) March 2009 (9) February 2009 (7) January 2009 (8) December 2008 (9) November 2008 (7) October 2008 (9) September 2008 (8) August 2008 (10) July 2008 (6) June 2008 (11) May 2008 (9) April 2008 (8) March 2008 (8) February 2008 (8) January 2008 (8) December 2007 (8) November 2007 (8) October 2007 (8) September 2007 (7) August 2007 (8) July 2007 (9) June 2007 (7) May 2007 (9) April 2007 (7) March 2007 (9) February 2007 (8) January 2007 (8) December 2006 (10) November 2006 (8) October 2006 (10) September 2006 (8) August 2006 (10) July 2006 (9) June 2006 (10) May 2006 (8) April 2006 (9) March 2006 (9) February 2006 (8) January 2006 (8) December 2005 (8) November 2005 (7) October 2005 (9) September 2005 (7) August 2005 (7) July 2005 (9) June 2005 (8) May 2005 (7) April 2005 (8) March 2005 (8) February 2005 (9) January 2005 (9) December 2004 (9) November 2004 (9) October 2004 (9) September 2004 (9) August 2004 (8) July 2004 (9) June 2004 (7) May 2004 (9) April 2004 (9) March 2004 (7) February 2004 (8) January 2004 (9) December 2003 (8) November 2003 (10) October 2003 (7) September 2003 (10) August 2003 (8) July 2003 (8) June 2003 (10) May 2003 (8) April 2003 (8) March 2003 (6) February 2003 (5) January 2003 (8) December 2002 (8) November 2002 (8) October 2002 (8) September 2002 (7) August 2002 (3) June 2002 (1) April 2002 (1) November 2001 (2) August 2001 (2) July 2001 (2) February 2001 (1) September 2000 (1) April 2000 (1) March 2000 (1) February 2000 (3) January 1999 (1) September 1998 (1) April 1997 (1) October 1979 (1) September 1979 (1)
Afghanistan Africa Australia Baghdad Beijing Brazil Canada China Donald Trump Egypt EU Europe European Union France Gaza Strip Germany India Iran Iraq Islamic State Israel Italy Japan Libya London Middle East Moscow NATO Nigeria North Korea Pakistan Russia Saddam Hussein Saudi Arabia South Africa Soviet Union Spain Syria Turkey Ukraine UN United States US West Bank White House
Copyright © 2021 Gwynne Dyer, All Rights Reserved. | Website by Marketing Coach Karilee Orchard of Outcome Marketing