About Motown Junkies
Alan, Lee
Andantes
Anthony, Richard
Ben, LaBrenda
Blakely, Cornell
Bohanon, George
Breen, Bobby
Burnadettes
Burnette, Dorsey
Campbell, Choker
Channel, Bruce
Chuck-a-Lucks
Clark, Chris
Crawford, Carolyn
Crockett, Howard
Dalton Boys
Darnells
Day, Danny
Dean, Debbie
Diamond, Hank & Carol
Downbeats
Dozier, Lamont
Eckstine, Billy
Elgins
Equadors
Funk Brothers
Gaye, Marvin
Golden Harmoneers
Good, Tommy
Gorman, Freddie
Gospel Stars
Greer, Paula
Griffin, Herman
Griffith, Johnny
Griner, Linda
Hamilton, Dave
Haney & Armstrong
Hartfield, Pete
Heard, Oma
Henslee, Gene
Hillsiders
Hit Pack
Holland, Eddie
Holland-Dozier
Holloway, Brenda
Holloway, Patrice
Isley Brothers
Joanne & the Triangles
John, Mable
Johnson, Marv
Jones, Wade
Kayli, Bob
Lands, Liz
Lee & the Leopards
Leverett, Chico
Lewis Sisters
Little Iva
Little Lisa
Little Otis
Littles, Hattie
Long, Shorty
Lumpkin, Henry
Majestics
Mallett, Saundra
Mann, Columbus
Martin, Tony
Marvelettes
McCullers, Mickey
McKenzie, Don
McNair, Barbara
Merced Blue Notes
Merritt, Billy
Mike & the Modifiers
Milburn, Amos
Morrocco Muzik Makers
Mullins, Dee
Nick & the Jaguars
Oddis, Ray
Parks, Gino
Paul, Bunny
Remus, Eugene
Ron & Bill
Ruffin, Jimmy
Satintones
Sebastian, Joel
Serenaders
Strong, Barrett
Swinging Tigers
Taylor, R. Dean
Taylor, Sherri
Terrell, Tammi
Turner, Sammy
Twistin' Kings
Valadiers
Valvano, Mike
Van Dyke, Connie
Van Dyke, Earl
Vells
Velvelettes
Walker, Junior (& All-Stars)
Ward, (Singin') Sammy
Washington, Earl
Wells, Mary
Weston, Kim
Williams, André
Wilson, Frank
Wonder, Stevie
Woods, Mickey
Wright Specials
Wylie, Richard "Popcorn"
Great Songwriters
Gordy
Mel-o-dy
Melodyland
MoWest
Tamla
Workshop Jazz
Marks Out Of Ten
I Disagree!
Motown Junkies
~ because it's what's in the grooves that counts
454. Carolyn Crawford: "I'll Come Running"
Posted by The Nixon Administration in Carolyn Crawford
Motown M 1064 (B), August 1964
B-side of My Smile Is Just A Frown (Turned Upside Down)
(Written by Carolyn Crawford)
I've got to stop being surprised by this sort of thing.
Regular readers will hopefully by now know that this is my own personal evaluation of the Motown legacy, and that I understand it'll likely differ in some key respects from their own, and that no two people's versions of this exercise will end up the same. Nonetheless, there have been a few times when I've apparently ruffled feathers by lauding something widely-panned, and there have been rather more times when I've seen (or heard) nothing particularly special in a song and reviewed it accordingly, only to discover it's someone's cherished all-time favourite. And I walk into these things every time.
At least with this one I can pre-emptively defend myself, having had a tip-off; a comment on the entry for the A-side here, My Smile Is Just A Frown (Turned Upside Down), from a very well-respected contributor (who I hope won't mind me shoving him into the spotlight!), opined that this B-side was a 10/10, and "couldn't have been better". I'm really glad of this, because it's always good to be reminded of just how subjective this whole exercise really is – it's not only a case of one man's meat being another man's poison, but a stark underlined reminder – for me more than you, dear reader – that these reviews are simply the highly subjective opinions of one Motown junkie, and your mileage, as always, may vary considerably. As I used to say in the early days, if any review of mine (good or bad), or any dissenting comment in the ensuing discussion, sends a reader to seek out a song for the first time they might otherwise have ignored, well, my work here is done.
Oh, right, I'll Come Running. Well, it's quite nice, but I find it both meandering and sloppy.
14-year-old Carolyn Crawford was a writer as well as a singer – she'd penned her Motown début single Forget About Me – and the label were clearly still comfortable with her bringing her own material to the table almost a year later. But this is a vibe and a riff in search of a song.
It's atmospheric, no question; the jaunty stabs of piano/organ play nicely against the stuttering, hissy rhythm track and Carolyn's soaring vocal (once again, you'd never guess she was fourteen on this evidence). Carolyn shows off her power and control right from the opening line in the song's biggest hook, a loud, leaping, repeated extended third note – Give me-a-lil' TIIIIIIIIIIME to think it over – that's recalled throughout the song to pleasing effect.
But the big strong voice on those extended notes sounds in marked contrast to the out-of-breath bark she uses on other lines, forcing in as many words per bar as will possibly fit; the effect is much closer to the shrill, unintelligible bits of Forget About Me than the impossibly cool A-side.
There aren't any more really good ideas in play afterwards. The song loses both direction and steam after barely thirty seconds; that jauntily pounded piano keeps on going like a tape loop and Carolyn keeps kicking up to make the big notes, but nothing much else happens structure-wise (there's a rudimentary middle eight that's essentially another verse with a key change, but that's about it).
The result, for me anyway, was that it got quite boring before it was finished – a pity, because Carolyn is trying so very hard, and I feel guilty for ragging on a defenceless teenage talent, but I can't get away from the feeling that this is the work of an immature songwriter. I'll Come Running has run out of ideas after half a minute, but keeps on ploughing the same determined furrow for another two regardless.
I didn't enjoy it as much as I wanted to. Your mileage, of course, may vary.
MOTOWN JUNKIES VERDICT
(I've had MY say, now it's your turn. Agree? Disagree? Leave a comment, or click the thumbs at the bottom there. Dissent is encouraged!)
You're reading Motown Junkies, an attempt to review every Motown A- and B-side ever released. Click on the "previous" and "next" buttons below to go back and forth through the catalogue, or visit the Master Index for a full list of reviews so far.
(Or maybe you're only interested in Carolyn Crawford? Click for more.)
Carolyn Crawford
"My Smile Is Just A Frown (Turned Upside Down)" Kim Weston
"Looking For The Right Guy"
DISCOVERING MOTOWN
Like the blog? Listen to our radio show!
Motown Junkies presents the finest Motown cuts, big hits and hard to find classics.
Listen to all past episodes here.
17 thoughts on "454. Carolyn Crawford: "I'll Come Running""
Dave L said:
Having never heard this, I must remain neutral -like Portugal or Canada- but I look forward to Robb's defense.
Had I been handed a copy of this in my late teens or later however, I'm sure I would have been more drawn to the side with Smokey's name on the writer and producer lines. Then, if I found anything wanting with the b-side, would have wondered if there was another Smokey production laying about, or even better, an HDH session with the lady (still) going unheard.
Bearing in mind that the Supremes' "It's All Your Fault," and the Marvelettes' "Knock On My Door" weren't allowed daylight till they were over 20 years old(!), we have no way of assuring ourselves that the best of Crawford at Motown has already reached our ears.
The Nixon Administration said:
Indeed, it's well documented she recorded quite a bit of stuff while at Motown – presumably extending beyond the three singles and the four tracks that have surfaced via the Cellarful series (one on each!), and I'm fervently hoping – as I'm sure lots of fans are – that the excellent Ace/Kent series of anthologies continues with a Carolyn set somewhere along the line.
MichaelS said:
I had never heard this recording until the other day when I read the comment by our "well-respected contributor" rating this 10/10. Not finding it on YouTube, I listened to its preview on iTunes and liked what I heard. I liked it even more after downloading it! Everything about it is infectious and catchy. Although I wouldn't give it a 10, it does deserve, imo, a solid 8.
Everyone who comments here is well-respected (by me anyway! – the stats show something like one reader in every 150-200 actually steps in and comments, so big thanks to everybody who does), I just didn't want to seem like I was having a dig at anyone other than myself (I'm fair game!)
Hooray for downloading the song – I'm delighted you like it!
(on a complete tangent, my ipod threw up the Beach Boys' Charles Manson-penned (!?) Never Learn Not To Love shortly after this, and they're actually not totally dissimilar, such that my brain is now mixing them together when I start singing either…)
Robb Klein said:
I'd give this a 10 out of ten. It's one of my all-time favourite vinyl recordings. I can't see how it could have been made better. I wonder if I'm the "well-repected contributor"? In any case, it's just a matter of taste. 1964 was my favourite music year, and this song is right up there with the best.
Yes, it was you 🙂 And indeed, it's all a matter of taste – would be great to get another perspective. What do you particularly like about this one?
>>the stats show something like one reader in every 150-200 actually steps in and comments<<
Wow. That certainly makes me feel like a blabber mouth LOL …and I'm not about to stop 🙂
I suppose it's now been about 18 months or a little more since I discovered Motown Junkies, and I consider that among my luckiest days net surfing. I'm also aware of a warm and agreeable camaraderie among those of us who comment most frequently, and it makes MJ a place I'm eager to get to in the first half hour on the computer with my wake-up coffee next to me.
Let's hope it stays that way and encourages more of the shy lurkers to speak up.
Seconded, all are welcome! And on that note I'd also like to personally apologise to anyone and everyone I might have inadvertently offended when replying to comments (especially when I'm explaining my reasoning or process for reviewing something the way I did) – I read some of my old replies back and wince at how prickly I sound in some of them. It's never intentional – we don't bite, I promise 🙂
144man said:
I think the A-side is great; this side I find tuneless. Maybe OK for any other label, but for Motown it's worth a below-average rating.
Oh, and looking ahead to the next review, what on earth were Motown thinking of, in the wake of Mary Wells' departure, releasing two singles by solo female artists within four days of each other? Surely that didn't make commercial sense.
No it doesn't, but in retrospect it may have a great deal to do with why I didn't learn about "Right Guy" till it was 13 years old, and "Smile/Frown" till it was 28. Or maybe with "Where Did Our Love Go" pulling up to No. 1, some voice inside Motown said "They like girls! Give 'em more girls!"
Nelson George notes the same thing in his Where Did Our Love Go, that in the face of the onslaught of the "more masculine Brits," and changing teenage music tastes, "four decidedly feminine Motown records would capture the top spot, Mary Wells' 'My Guy,' and the Supremes 'Where Did Our Love Go,' 'Baby Love' and 'Come See About Me'. They were Motown's only No. 1 records of 1964."
I find it interesting that you say this song is "tuneless". To me the "tune" of a song is BY FAR the most important feature. Lyrics are of almost no importance, unless they are terrible and nonsensical, and even then, they can't ruin a song for me that has a tune I like. Songwriting and tune, and the structure of that tune are what I like most. That is why I like this song so much, and don't like Carolyn's "Forget About Me" so much, as that song wanders all over the place. But, even though the latter has poor structure, I wouldn't call it "tuneless". There is a tune here. You may not like this combination of notes because of its structure, but it has a tune.
Perhaps a monotonal "song" like "Talk Talk" by Music Machine, or "Funky Broadway" by Dyke and The Blazers have no real tune. But, this song has a tune. And, I like this particular order of notes, and the combinations of sounds coming out of the musical instruments, the songwriting, and Carolyn's singing performance. I like this song better than all her others, including "Just a Frown" and those great unreleased cuts.
I can hum most records after I hear them. I can't do that with this one. THat's why I call it tuneless.
I can hum it, and sing it, too. It has a very pleasant melody to me. I call that a tune. To each his own. Different taste keeps everything from being boring.
Berry Gordy must have seen potential in Carolyn Crawford and/or this song if he chose to produce it, don't you think?
Mickey The Twistin' Postman said:
I think all of Carolyn's releases, including this one, are good. This is one of my favorites. Rating: 8/10
Abbott Cooper said:
My mileage may vary is on the button. My ears have gotten a lot of mileage out of this one. If you're looking for a song that defines the R in R&B, "I'll Come Running" is it. The piano, organ and that great beat can wake the dead. Boring it certainly is not. Sure it has a few flaws. Carolyn hits that high note she uses on the word "time" and in other places a bit much, and too many of the lyrics can't be understood. However, the pluses far outweigh the minuses, and that rhythm and melody are superb. A "9" to be sure. If this song was in my alarm clock, I'd awaken every day dancing.
nafalmat said:
I quite agree with the 9 mark given in the most recent comments above. However, unlike the 'A' side which I loved from the very first time I heard it, this side took a while to grow on me. The song itself I don't think is that strong, and as the previous comment stated some of the lyrics are unclear. What really makes this shine is 'The Master' Berry Gordy's superb prodcution. That shuffling beat enhanced by the piano and organ make this irresistable to me. It really is quite a unique record.
Leave a Reply to 144man Cancel reply
This is Motown Junkies, an unofficial track by track history of Motown: in-depth analysis and discussion of both sides of every Motown single ever released between 1959 and 1988. Enjoy!
Index of all reviews to date
Lucky Dip (a random review)
Best Music & Entertainment Blog
Wales Blog Awards 2012
693. The Four Tops: "Just As Long As You Need Me"
692. The Four Tops: "Shake Me, Wake Me (When It's Over)"
691. Marvin Gaye: "When I Had Your Love"
690. Marvin Gaye: "One More Heartache"
689. The Isley Brothers: "There's No Love Left"
Robb Klein on 593. The Spinners: "Tomo…
Bill Hales on 593. The Spinners: "Tomo…
Bill Hales on 684. The Elgins: "Darlin…
Bill Hales on 612. The Marvelettes: "D…
Donald White on 666. The Marvelettes: "D…
144man on 544. Martha & the Vandella…
Don'tMessWithWill on 544. Martha & the Vandella…
Steve Eaton on 354. The Supremes: "When…
Steve Eaton on 101. The Marvelettes: "S…
Robb Klein on 346. Kim Weston: "Just L…
308. The Wright Specials: "I Won't Go Back"
339. Marvin Gaye: "I'm Crazy 'Bout My Baby"
Motown Junkies presents
"Discovering Motown"
a Motown radio show
Hand-picked hits, harmonies and hard-hitting soul from the world's greatest record label, specially chosen by Motown historian and writer Steve Devereux. Whether you're new to Motown or a seasoned veteran, you'll find something good here
LATEST EPISODES:
Discovering Motown: our radio show Listen to old episodes here
Soul Source Forum Great discussion forum.
Don't Forget the Motor City Keith Hughes' indispensable guide to Motown recording and songwriting information
Seabear Studios LG Nilsson's Motown discography and collection of label scans
Soulful Detroit Motown Forum Motown discussion forum
Made in Wales
Check out our radio show:
This is Motown Junkies, an unofficial guide to every Motown single ever released, or planned for release, on every US Motown label (or via Tamla Motown in the UK), featuring reviews of each A-side and B-side in chronological order. New reviews appear every couple of days.
Think of it as an unauthorised track-by-track companion to the magnificent The Complete Motown Singles CD box sets, and beyond, with marks out of ten.
I'm NOT Paul Nixon.
More info about the blog (and me) can be found here. If you want to leave a comment on any review, please feel free to do so - all feedback, corrections, disagreements and encouragements gratefully received. If you've something you'd rather not say in public, I can be contacted at fosse8 at gmail dot com.
(Oh, and if you arrived here looking for the Motown Junkies music group, they're nothing to do with me, I'm afraid - but they are very nice people, and they can be found at www.motownjunkies.com instead.)
HOW TO USE THIS BLOG
You can jump straight to the full list of reviews so far in the Master Index, or browse by label instead.
If you're looking for something a bit more specific, you can click an artist's name in the "Artist" menu at the top of the screen to see a little biography and all the reviews we've done for them so far. Only people whose records I've already discussed appear there at the moment - more names will be added to the lists all the time as I work my way through Motown's history, so do keep checking back!
Alternatively, the front page displays excerpts from the most recent reviews, and on the right hand side of the screen you'll see a list of the most recent entries and also a sampling of the most popular entries from the last 48 hours, as well as the latest comments left by visitors.
Dive in, explore and have fun!
This is an unofficial site, and is not affiliated in any way with Universal Motown, Hip-O Select or any of the artists referred to in the blog.
Where indicated, label scan images appear by kind permission of Lars "LG" Nilsson (as originally prepared for the Complete Motown Singles series).
Digital images courtesy of Gordon Frewin are supplied for use at motownjunkies.co.uk by arrangement. All applicable rights reserved. No unauthorised republication is permitted.
Many label images were kindly provided by Robb Klein, together with invaluable historical research.
All text © Motown Junkies, 2009-19. All rights reserved.