The Reinvestment Rate Assumption Fallacy for IRR and NPV: A Pedagogical Note
Magni, Carlo Alberto and Martin, John D. (2017): The Reinvestment Rate Assumption Fallacy for IRR and NPV: A Pedagogical Note.
The mistaken notion that the internal rate of return (IRR) and net present value (NPV) have required reinvestment rate assumptions built into them was debunked long ago in the academic finance literature. There are no reinvestment rate assumptions built into, or implicit to, the computation and use of either the IRR or NPV. In this brief note, we first review the theoretical underpinnings of the rate of return assumption fallacy and offer two possible origins from the academic finance literature that may have been responsible for the fallacy.
internal rate of return, reinvestment rate, NPV, MIRR
G - Financial Economics > G0 - General
G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G11 - Portfolio Choice ; Investment Decisions
Carlo Alberto Magni
R. Brealey, S. Myers, and F. Allen, 2011, Principles of Corporate Finance, 10 th ed., (McGraw-Hill Irwin).
C. Dudley, 1972, A note on reinvestment assumptions in choosing between net present value and internal rate of return, The Journal of Finance, Vol. 27, No. 4 (September), pp. 907-15.
J. Hirshleifer, 1958, On the theory of optimal investment decisions, Journal of Political Economy, 66, 329-352.
S.M. Keane 1979, The Internal Rate of Return and the reinvestment fallacy, Abacus, 15(1), 44-55.
S.P. Keef and M.L. Roush, 2001, Discounted cash flow methods and the fallacious reinvestment assumption: a review of recent texts, Accounting Education: An International Journal, 10(1), 105-116.
C.A. Magni, P. Veronese, R. Graziani, 2017, Chisini means and and rational decision-making: Equivalence of investment criteria. Mathematics and Financial Economics. DOI 10.1007/s11579-017-0201-4
S. Rich and J. Rose, 2014, Re-examining an old question: Does the IRR Method Implicitly Assume a Reinvestment Rate? Journal of Financial Education, Spring/Summer, pp. 152-166.
E. Renshaw, 1957, A note on the arithmetic of capital budgeting decisions, The Journal of Business, Vol. XXX, No. 3 (July), pp. 193-201.
S. Ross, R. W Westerfield, and B. D. Jordan, 2011, Essentials of Corporate Finance, 7 th ed., (McGraw-Hill Irwin).
E. Solomon, 1956, The Arithmetic of Capital Budgeting Decisions, Journal of Business, 29, pp. 124-29.
J. Walker, H. Check, JR., and K. Randall, 2010, Does the internal rate of return calculation require a reinvestment rate assumption? There is still no consensus, Journal of the Academy of Business Education, 11, Proceedings, November.