Museum Whisperings
Thinking critically about museums and art galleries.
Category Archives: songlines
On Australia Day – how museums can use the power of interpretation? Bungaree -the exhibition in my head.
Bungaree's breastplate from http://budawagroup.com/history/
"Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people should be aware that this blogpost may contain images or names of people who have since passed away."
Before Australia Day, there is always discussion about the date, 26th January, what it means to every Australian and the conversations are quite thought provoking. I don't believe that you can change history, but you can certainly change the way you look at the facts and think more critically about them. Australia was not the only country to be colonised by the British. I am certain that had it not been the British, it would have been the Dutch, French or Portuguese who were all active on our coastline at that time. I believe that the outcome for Indigenous Australians would have still been quite bleak.
We may not be able to change history but museums have the power to revisit and reinterpret the facts. Australians still have much to learn about our nation's history and perhaps learning new things can help all of us to build on our cultural heritage and celebrate the contribution of Indigenous Australians to our country and to resolve the issue of January 26th as a contested date for Australia Day.
A few years ago, I saw a great art exhibition of works on paper about Bungaree: First Australian at Mosman Art Gallery (in Sydney), which made me think about the man, his place in Australian history and the way that these artists created works that acknowledged and critically re-interpreted the story of Bungaree – an important Indigenous figure in the colonial Sydney era. Bungaree's story would fit well into the vision and exhibition strategy of museums such as the Australian National Maritime Museum, Australian Museum or the National Museum of Australia.
Merve Bishop Bungaree: The showman 2012, digital photography, Giclee on archival pigment, 100 x 200 cm. From an exhibition curated by Djon Mundine at Mosman Art Gallery, Sydney 1 September – 25 November 2012
King Bungaree (c1775-1830) was well respected by the Indigenous Australian community and developed a reputation as a negotiator between Aboriginal and European cultures during his lifetime. He accompanied Matthew Flinders on several journeys in 1798, 1799, 1801 and 1802-03 where he acted as interpreter and intermediary, a role which he undertook several times for European explorers in Australia. Bungaree was the first Indigenous person to circumnavigate Australia and contribute to the mapping of the Australian coastline and yet more is known about "Trim", Matthew Flinders' "sea-faring" cat than the man Flinders described as having "a good disposition and open and manly conduct that attracted my esteem"[1]. I have often thought that the life of King Bungaree would make a wonderful museum exhibition – to rediscover the voyages undertaken by Bungaree with Matthew Flinders, and in particular the circumnavigation of Australia but with more emphasis on Bungaree – his character, his family and his exchanges with other indigenous people during those journeys.
A great deal is known about Australia's maritime heritage but this would be an opportunity to engage with a different audience, reinterpret the existing historical record and to be more "inclusive" of an indigenous audience with a more meaningful dialogue about the place of King Bungaree in Australian history[2]. This indigenous man was well respected by the Governors and officials in colonial Sydney. He was not only known in NSW but his fame spread to nineteenth century Europe both in artworks inspired by colonial Australia and in the journals of men that he sailed with. Considering that "Reconciliation" is an important theme for Australian museum projects recently, then public learning and collaboration with indigenous communities offers a museum the opportunity to become a driver for social change and inclusion[3]. It is a chance to research and communicate factual information to visitors about some of the relationships formed between the newly arrived colonial settlers and the indigenous population at that time.
In the past, most exhibitions on the exploration of Australia tend to be Eurocentric, and yet here is a perfect opportunity to develop a more "inclusive" exhibition for the public with an opportunity to reinterpret Australian history so that more is known about the man who contributed much to the exploration and development of our nation. The following themes could be examined:
Bungaree the man – with paintings, prints and writings about Bungaree. Bungaree was a tribal chief who had the ability to straddle both the indigenous and colonial worlds. Bungaree spoke English well and his sense of humour was well noted[4]. There are several portraits and writings about Bungaree available to assist in developing a picture of his character, his family and his contribution to the circumnavigation and mapping of Australia with Matthew Flinders and Phillip King. He was the subject of at least 17 portraits during his life time and several more after his death – many by well known artists (The National Library of Australia[5] collection has portraits by Augustus Earle, Charles Pye, Charles Rodius, and W.H. Fernyhough).
By Ambrose Wilson From the collections of the State Library of New South Wales [a1114016 / SAFE/PXA 615, 20] (Mitchell Library)
Augustus Earle (1793─1838), Portrait of Bungaree, a Native of New South Wales, with Fort Macquarie, Sydney Harbour, in Background c.
Bungaree, a native of N.S.Wales, lithograph, hand-coloured with watercolour, on paper by Augustus Earle. Image: Augustus Earle
The Journals of Flinders and King – There are original documents written about Bungaree and his family members. Matthew Flinders'[6] and Phillip King's[7] comments on Bungaree in their daily journals. (National Library of Australia and State Library of NSW collections). A clever mimic, Bungaree could imitate the walk, gestures and expressions of past Governors of New South Wales. Like Shakespeare's clown in Twelfth Night, he was 'wise enough to play the fool' and used his humorous talents to obtain clothes, tea, tobacco, bread, sugar and rum for himself and his people. As author and historian Geoffrey Dutton commented: 'He mocked the white men by mocking himself[8]'. When in town, Bungaree was known to wear cast off uniforms and a tricorn hat given to him by the NSW Governors of the period and officers in the regiment. This period clothing should be researched and replica uniforms and hats produced as accurately as possible from illustrations and historical knowledge of the dress at that time. The breastplates of King Bungaree and Queen Gooseberry awarded by Governor Macquarie in 1815 are held in the Mitchell Library Collection, State Library NSW.
Bungaree's Family Tree (This would be require significant research because he supported 5 wives and many descendants).The existing family tree for Bungaree and his wives is quite complex. His first wife was Matora, followed by three other women, Gooseberry (Cora), Charlotte Ashby and Biddy Salamander. There are many descendants of Bungaree and his wives identified in the literature which also details the places that they lived. Research may extract further evidence about the number of wives he had and about his known descendants which could be presented using an interactive display. This would assist existing and new descendants to find out more information about the family tree. Such a display could include some web links for searching Bungaree's family history.
Indigenous Languages – A study of Indigenous dialects/lifestyles in the early 1800s. Bungaree was a Kuringgai man from the Broken Bay area along the Hawkesbury River and would have been quite unfamiliar with the languages and types of housing in other parts of Australia – contrary to the incorrect European view that all Indigenous Australians were the same and had no cultural heritage to speak of. In the early 1800s there were an estimated 300 distinct indigenous languages in Australia[9]. Currently there are 145 languages still spoken but of these 110 are critically endangered which is the largest and most rapid loss of languages in the world. In this display, show the spread of aboriginal dialects, comparing 1800s to today. Use audio examples of a couple of words to compare the different dialects. Bungaree was taken as a translator on these sea voyages which showed that early settlers had no idea that the culture and language of indigenous settlements was extremely variable in different parts of Australia. Discuss "terra nullius" presumption and note all the places that they anchored on the voyage.
Map making – Present a series of maps of Australia from Bungaree's time including discussion about mapping instruments and techniques used to map the coastline – something which we take for granted in modern times. Demonstrate the navigational feat of the Matthew Flinders' expeditions using audio visual support to show a map of Australia during Cook's time and how that map changed after each of Flinders' journeys with Bungaree and including the final circumnavigation aboard the HMS Investigator. Discuss the fact that it was Flinders who named Australia.
Indigenous Australia in Bungaree's time – How did Indigenous people travel Australia via the ocean and waterways? How did they use the stars to navigate? How did they use Songlines to travel and to pass information down through the generations? Compare the knowledge of Indigenous Australians with the instruments used in early 1800s for navigation and mapping. Demonstrate how Australia would be mapped today -(showing modern photographic and satellite techniques. (Maps and instruments to be sourced from the ANMM collection and the National and State libraries).
HMS Investigator – Look at the history of HMS Investigator and the other vessels which Bungaree sailed on to Norfolk Island, Bribie Island and Hervey Bay before the circumnavigation of Australia with Flinders. The Investigator carried a crew of 88. He also made other expeditions with Philip Parker King. Use diagrams and refer to the HMS Investigator using a scaled model such as the model – 1:48 inches with decking, rigging and fine detail (Object D 7835 sourced from State Library of SA). Also discuss the fact that there were nine different HMS Investigators in British naval history showing the lifespan of each ship on a historical timeline.
Trim and Bungaree. Finally the story of "Trim" and Bungaree and including the place of ship's cats on these exploration vessels using a text panel discussing the role of ship's cats in colonial times. There should be a reference to Bungaree and Trim. Bungaree first met when Trim was the rat catcher aboard HMS Norfolk in the 1790s. Trim and Bungaree are often mentioned in Flinders' daily journal entries and both were present during the circumnavigation of Australia in the HMS Investigator in 1801-1803. Sadly Trim was killed in Mauritius in 1804. Sculptor John Cornwall created a statue of Trim which is located on the ledge of the Mitchell Library wing at the State Library of NSW.
The ideal Visitor Experience
Visitors will come to the exhibition with their own knowledge, thoughts and motivation – hopefully curious and asking "Who was King Bungaree?" The exhibition could be factual about the "first contact" between Indigenous Australians and colonial settlers through the eyes of Bungaree, a well-known Sydney character and identity. By wandering through the exhibition and interacting with its components, more could be understood about Bungaree's place in history.
The audience will learn how little the British colonials knew about the Australian Aborigines, their culture and diversity of language and begin to understand how the divide between them came about. A point of interest is that the High Court's Mabo judgment in 1992 overturned the terra nullius fiction. In the same judgment, however, the High Court accepted the British assertion of sovereignty in 1788, and held that from that time there was only one sovereign power and one system of law in Australia.
The exhibition content should fit within the context of the National curriculum particularly into the areas of Australian History, Geography, Civics and citizenship, Indigenous content and cross cultural perspectives as well as for Visual Arts and design.
Public programs could include storytelling, canoe building, dance and art workshops to explore aspects of country and culture (Bungaree used dance to communicate with other tribes when he did not know their language). Preparation should be carried out in consultation with members of Bungaree's Kuringai (Guringai) clan from Broken Bay, Sydney.
[1] Matthew Flinders, A Voyage to Terra Australis, W Nicol, London, 1814, p cxciv
[2] Simpson, M.G. 1996, Making representations: museums in the post-colonial era/Moira G. Simpson Routledge London; New York
[3] Kelly, L. and Gordon, P.2002. Chapter 11. Developing a community of practice: museums and reconciliation in Australia. Richard Sandell (Ed).pp 153 -174 in Museums Society and Inequality.
[4] McCarthy, F.D.1966. Bungaree (?-1830) in Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University at http:adb.anu.edu.au/biography/Bungaree-1848/text2141, published hardcopy 1966, accessed online 26 March 2014.
[5] National Library of Australia collections database at http:// www.nla.gov.au/collections accessed online 26 March 2014
[6] Flinders, M. A voyage to Terra Australis (Volumes 1 and 2) London 1814
[7] King, P. Narrative of a survey of the Intertropical and Western Coasts of Australia (Volumes 1 and 2) London 1827.
[8] William Shakespeare, Twelfth Night, Act 111, Scene 1; Geoffrey Dutton, White on Black: The Australian Aborigine portrayed in art, Macmillan, South Melbourne, 1974, pp 28–31
[9] Schmidt, A. (1990). The loss of Australia's aboriginal language heritage. Canberra: Aboriginal Studies Press.
Smith, K. (1992).King Bungaree: A Sydney Aborigine meets the Great South Pacific Explorers, 1799-1830.Kenthurst, NSW: Kangaroo Press.
Simon, N. (2010) The Participatory Museum. California: Santa Cruz. Museum 2.0 pp 139-152
Weil, S.E. (2002) "From being about Something to being for Somebody: The Ongoing Transformation of the American Museum" in Making Museums Matter. Washington Smithsonian Institution. pp 28-53.
https://australianmuseum.net.au/bungaree
This entry was posted in Aboriginal Australia, art galleries, art museum, audience engagement, audience research, Australia Day, blogging, Bungaree, Cultural heritage, Cultural Institutions, GLAM sector, heritage, heritage and cities, museum, museums, Museums and the Digital, Museums and the Web, songlines, The Arts in Australia and tagged Aboriginal Australians, art, Australia, best practice, blogging, Bungaree, Colonial Australia, Contested Heritage, Country, culture, exhibitions, Exploring Australia, history, inclusive museums, Indigenous Australians, information, King Bungaree, library, Mapping Australia, Matthew Flinders, Memory, PP King, reinterpreting history, Social Justice, sydney on January 25, 2019 by lyndalllinaker.
Songlines and the coded memory
First Life – single cell male
Evidence of the inland sea
First life – single cell female
On a recent visit to the Flinders Ranges in South Australia, I was shown evidence of fossils which were the earliest forms of life on earth and saw some amazing Indigenous Rock Art. When you visit an ancient landscape with such natural beauty and spirituality, it encourages you to look deeper into the rich culture of our First Australians.
Xanthorrea – Flinders Ranges
Arkaroo Rock walk – Flinders Ranges
I am slowly beginning to understand the connection of Indigenous people to country after visiting the Flinders Ranges and having listened to 702 ABC radio's Conversations with Richard Vidler. Richard interviewed Lynne Kelly about her book "The Memory Code". Lynne has researched traditional Indigenous Australian songlines as a key to memory, unlocking many layers of information which have been encoded into the Australian landscape. Songlines can be shared through stories, songs and through traditional dance.
The strong unwritten and oral history of Aboriginal Australians is passed down by Elders within the community. So much of this knowledge is key to survival. Knowledge about the landscape, navigation, ancestral totems, food and medicine, trade routes, culture, law and history. Information is shared through stories, traditional dance and song. Kelly speaks about the way that non-written memory systems are coded into the natural and built environment. She believes that this system was not only used in Australia but may have been used by other ancient cultures around the world.
The understanding of the way that Songlines work has changed my thinking about the damage caused by the removal of Indigenous Australians from their connection to country. This must have had a devastating impact – causing much pain through the loss of culture and access to key information for survival. Australians can empathise with other displaced peoples around the world and yet the issue on our our doorstep is even more complex. I'm not saying that colonial Australians did this on purpose but the end result is still the same and incredibly significant for our Indigenous people. I had these new thoughts on board when I attended the Royal Botanic Gardens in Sydney to see Jonathan Jones's exhibition "barrangal dyara (skin and bones)" which was Kaldor Public Arts Project no.32.
The Garden Palace, Sydney
Jonathan has reinterpreted one of Sydney's great cultural losses which was the destruction of the vast Garden Palace in Sydney, which burned to the ground in 1882.
Bleached gypsum shields forming the border of what was The Garden Palace
The Palace contained many Indigenous artefacts which were culturally significant and represented a link to country, part of the collective memory handed on from Elder to community and which can never be replaced.The loss was also greatly felt by the Colonials who lost many archival records, art works and museum objects (remembering that at this time there were no public museums or art galleries in Sydney, only in Melbourne). In a strange way there was some commonality of loss and understanding for all Australians arising from such a catastrophic event.
What I liked most about Jones's interpretation was the way that the installation took the physical components such as the kangaroo grass meadow and thousands of bleached gypsum shields to mark the perimeter of the original Garden Palace. In addition, the soundscapes of 8 indigenous languages floated through the air, creating an atmosphere which took the observer into a different world. There were also daily conversations from historians, theorists, curators, artists, writers amongst the public program activities allowing the audience to reimagine the building and the history and cultural loss – both from an Indigenous and Colonial perspective. It was actually a great conversation starter.
I think that the arts have a lot to offer as far as highlighting social injustice and human rights issues – bridging the gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians through increasing our awareness of the richness of Indigenous culture and the significance of "connection to country" and the sophisticated coding of unwritten knowledge into the natural environment. We have so much to learn and have an opportunity that our forbears underestimated the value of.
This entry was posted in archaeology, art galleries, audience engagement, audience research, blogging, Cultural heritage, GLAM sector, heritage, museum, museums, songlines, visitor feedback, visitor tracking and tagged Aboriginal Australia, Aboriginal History, Australia, Colonial Australia, Conversations 702 Sydney, Country, education, exhibitions, First Australians, First Life, Flinders Ranges, Fossils, heritage, history, Indigenous Australia, Jonathan Jones, Kaldor Public Arts, Lynne Kelly, Memory, memory codes, museum blog, museum management, museum practice, museum whisperings, Richard Vidler, Rock Art, songlines, South Australia, Sydney Botanic Gardens, The Garden Palace on December 5, 2016 by lyndalllinaker.
Museums – does one size fit all when it comes to audience engagement?
Audience Research 101
The NGV Triennial Giving Art to the People
"The Museum is our backyard…." Do you have families visiting your cultural institution weekly?
lyndalllinaker on On Australia Day – how m…
Hector on On Australia Day – how m…
Suellen Jonusys on On Australia Day – how m…
Aboriginal Australia
Bungaree
digital museums
GLAM sector
heritage and cities
museum maps
Museums and the Digital
Museums and the Web
OH & S in Museums
The Arts in Australia
UNESCO heritage