Review- You Will Meet A Tall Dark Stranger
Posted on February 14, 2011 by bernardovillela
This film will be released on video tomorrow.
Naomi Watts and Anthony Hopkins in You Will Meet a Tall Stranger (Sony Pictures Classics)
I, unlike many, will attest to the fact that reports of Woody Allen's demise are greatly exaggerated. While last year's reviews for Whatever Works were greatly mixed it does not seem like the kind of film that you can use to illustrate that someone had "lost it."
In You Will Meet a Tall Dark Stranger you can see why people would say that, however, the way I see it is that you get in the film a pastiche of what's both great and not so great about Allen. At the risk of sounding like a stereotypical fan who likes the "early, funny movies" it must be stated for the record that this film is a drama before all else.
Moreover, it examines some similar questions as both Whatever Works and Vicky Cristina Barcelona examined. It's principally about life and love but to paraphrase Allen's idol Ingmar Bergman "What else is there?" Where the film is somewhat lacking is that it could dig deeper.
What really holds the film back is that fears that were caused by the trailer are realized and it's the voice over. It is perhaps the worst-delivered most poorly-acted voice over narration that I've been privy to listen to. Zak Orth's delivery could not be be drier if he tried. The only thing that helps this film overcome it is the fact that there's not a whole lot of it and he's speaking Allen's words. Sadly, it also unnecessarily spoon-feeds a relatively simple film and by speaking the film's conclusion to its hypothesis this renders it more banal than it otherwise would've been.
The Bergman reference above is not totally misplaced as this is another examination by Allen of a subject that obsessed Bergman: death. Through these intertwining tales Allen not only examines how we deal with mortality but conversely, of course, with life and what the point to all of it is.
Barring the aforementioned narration the acting is good across the board. The characters are actually a bit less neurotic than Allen's usual dramatis personnae and feel more like well-rounded, less erudite types. While these characters can come across as more flat it is a tribute to the actors in this film that they breathed life into them.
Another problem the film battled was the edit. The film is a bit too methodical. It never quite gets slow but it could quicken its step through the second and into the third act. True there are four interconnected storylines to resolve but they all end up more or less where we expect them to when we expect them to such that not as much time need be devoted to each to make the point that each segment is trying to make.
While the valid point that sometimes "delusion works better than medicine" is well-made and ties up the film nicely albeit heavy-handedly there is a surprise that develops towards the end that is never really resolved. Now while we can surmise what will happen and the dilemma the character in question is left with it would still have been nice to add a little more closure to that chapter than we get.
Although not a great work and not a minor work, Woody Allen's films are still vital because he is not overly-concerned with genre or the trappings therein. He through his writing and his cinema is still one of the few American auteurs who is willing to ask real and serious questions with every film he takes on and for that reason his audience should spring eternal and not age with the great cineaste.
Auteur Bergman Drama edit Voice Over Woody Allen You Will Meet a Tall Dark Stranger Zak Orth
Mini-Review- Day & Night
Oscar Nominated Short Films, Animated
Pingback: Review- Hereafter « The Movie Rat