LA Progressive
Smart Content for Smart People
About Us / Copyright Info
Elections and Campaigns
Progressive Issues
Social Justice / Racism
Steve Hochstadt
Charles D. Hayes
David A. Love
Diane Lefer
Dick Price
Jerry Drucker
John Peeler
Joseph Palermo
Tom Hall
Sharon Kyle
Sikivu Hutchinson
Left Coast Forum
American-Style Drone Warfare and How and When Humans Count
Most drone-strike images show technology, e.g. drones, missiles, or targeting crosshairs with foreigners appearing as ant-like creatures in infrared cameras. Rarely do we see damage, and, rarer still, the shredded and blasted bodies of innocents
When do humans count in drone warfare, and when do they not?
I thought of this question as I read Christopher Fuller's "See It/Shoot It: The Secret History of the CIA's Lethal Drone Program." Revealingly, U.S. pilots and crews who operate these drones, such as Predators and Reapers, reject the terminology of "drones" and UAV (unmanned aerial vehicle) or UAS (unmanned aerial system). They prefer the term RPA, or remotely piloted aircraft. They want to be known as the essential humans in the loop, they want to stand out, they want to count for something, and in fact the Department of Defense at various times has suggested a new "drone medal" to recognize their service.
Whereas American pilots want to stand up and be recognized as the pilots of their "remote aircraft," the Pentagon doesn't want to think about the targets of these drones as human beings.
Whereas American pilots want to stand up and be recognized as the pilots of their "remote aircraft," the Pentagon doesn't want to think about the targets of these drones as human beings. Civilian casualties are grouped and shrouded under the term "collateral damage," a nasty euphemism that combines a banking term (collateral) with the concept of damage that hints at reversibility and repair. But collateral damage really means innocents blown up and blasted by missiles. Shouldn't these humans count?
Another term that Fuller discusses is "neutralization." The U.S. counterterrorism goal is to "neutralize" opponents, meaning, as Fuller notes, "killing, rendition, and imprisonment." Again, with a word like neutralization, we're not encouraged to think of those being attacked as humans. We're just "neutralizing" a threat, right? A terrorist, not a fellow human being. Right?
Interestingly, the whole idea of terrorism is something they do, not us. Why? Because the U.S. defines terrorism as "premeditated, politically motivated violence perpetrated against noncombatant targets bysubnational groups or clandestine agents." Note that word: subnational. By this definition, nations do not commit terrorism, which is handy for the U.S., which presents its drone attacks as defensive or proactive or preemptive.
Finally, the Pentagon and the CIA are at pains to assert they take the utmost care in reducing "collateral damage" in their "neutralization" efforts. Yet as Fuller notes in his book (page 214), "the U.S. government did not always know the identity or affiliations of those killed in its drone strikes."
So who counts, and who doesn't? Whose humanity is to be celebrated (pilots of RPAs?), and whose humanity (innocent victims) is to be suppressed?
Addendum: On how the U.S. seriously undercounts civilian deaths in its air strikes, see this article.
WJ Astore
By William J. Astore posted on February 7, 2019
DISCLAIMER: The opinions expressed here are those of the individual contributor(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the LA Progressive, its publisher, editor or any of its other contributors.
Thank You For Supporting Independent Media. The LA Progressive cannot publish without your support. Please donate. Thanks....
This Weeks Featured Posts
Loving America
It's Up to Nancy Pelosi to Cave
Too Horrible to Understand, Too Horrible to Ignore
Love It or Leave It? Only a Fool Would Say Such a Thing
5 Reasons Why a Researcher's Work Is Beautiful
What Are the Cause and Effects of Gender Discrimination?
More Posts from Sponsored
Book-A-Bus
Africa | Animal Rights | California
Climate Change | Defense | Economic Justice
Education Reform | Elections | Environment
Events | Foreign Policy | Gay Rights
Healthcare Reform | Immigration Reform
Juvenile Justice | Labor | Latin America
Law and Justice | Los Angeles | Prison Reform
Progressive Issues | Science & Religion
Sexism | Social Justice | Terminal Velocity | The Body Politic
| The Media | The Middle East | Veterans
War and Peace | Wellness
The LA Progressive cannot publish without your support. Please donate. Thank you.
Electing Loraine Lundquist for LA's CD 12
Rosemary Jenkins: For years, we in CD 12 have lived with councilmembers who seem to represent only the top tier–the wealthiest and the better off–those who have more power.
Will L.A.'s Homelessness Spike Lead to a Course Correction?
Jessica Goodheart: Youth, the elderly and whole families are tumbling into homelessness at a faster rate than they can be helped onto their feet.
More Posts from Los Angeles
Dogs of War Howl for Blood in Iran While Americans Cheer U.S. Bombers on July 4
Medea Benjamin and Ann Wright: While most Americans have probably forgotten we are still at war in Afghanistan, the Trump administration "eased" the rules of engagement, allowing the military to drop more bombs in 2018 than in any other year since the war began in 2001.
Stop US Imperialist Moves against Iran!
Kevin A. Anderson: Today, the US has the most reckless and aggressive regime in its history. A war with Iran, even a "limited" series of airstrikes, could spin out of control, devastating the region and the global economy, with terrible consequences for the people of the world.
More Posts from The Middle East
How to Pay for It All: An Option the Candidates Missed
Ellen Brown: If robbing Peter to pay Paul is the only alternative, the proposals will go the way of Trump's trillion-dollar infrastructure bill for lack of funding.
Libra: Facebook's Audacious Bid for Global Monetary Control
Ellen Brown: To the crypto-anarchist community, usurping the power of central banks and governments may sound like a good thing. But handing global power to the corporate-controlled Libra Association could be a greater nightmare.
More Posts from Economic Justice
Copyright © 2019 · Dick Price and Sharon Kyle · Log in