About DV
"Aid" (34) "Regime Change" (37) "The Left" (72) "The Right" (26) "The West" (250) "Third" Party (310) (Ex-)Yugoslavia (131) 1989 Tiananmen Square (1) 2008 Financial Collapse (15) 9-11 (194) Abortion (30) Academic Freedom (189) Activism (2,254) Adani Corporation (1) Admissions/Fraud (2) Adoption (9) Afghanistan (907) Africa (257) Age of Enlightenment (7) Agriculture (217) Agrochemicals (16) Agrochemicals (3) Agroecology (5) Air Travel (8) Al-Qaeda (18) ALBA (16) Alcohol and Drug Addiction (2) Algeria (14) Amazon Rain Forest (9) Amnesty International (7) Anarchism (188) Anarchists (10) Andrés Manuel López Obrador (8) Angola (17) Animal Cruelty (2) Animal/Plant Extinction (1) Annexation (10) Antarctica Ice Melt (18) Anti-racism (1) Anti-semitism (5) Anti-slavery (91) Anti-war (1,180) Aotearoa (New Zealand) (55) Apartheid (56) Architecture (3) Arctic Ice Melt (36) Argentina (84) Armenia (17) Armistice Day (1) Art (7) Artificial Intelligence (AI) (8) Arts and/or Entertainment (181) ASEAN (2) Asia (117) Assassinations (249) Asylum seekers (27) Athletes (8) Austerity (223) Australia (329) Austria (19) Authoritarianism (3) Azerbaijan (15) Bahrain (61) Bangladesh (30) Bank of Japan (2) Bank of North Dakota (7) Banks/Banking (20) Barack Obama (571) BDS (Boycott Divestment and Sanctions Movement) (72) Beer (4) Beirut (6) Belarus (9) Belgium (26) Belize (2) Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) (10) Benjamin Netanyahu (130) Bernie Sanders (12) Bicycles (2) Bill Clinton (5) Bitcoin (6) Blowback (163) Bolivia (127) Book Review (671) Boris Johnson (33) Borneo (13) Bosnia-Herzegovina (4) Botswana (6) Bourgeois-deconstruction (1) Bourgeois-state-capitalism (13) Boycott (194) Brazil (175) Brexit (57) BRICS (34) Budhism (3) Bulgaria (13) Burkina Faso (7) Burma (2) Burundi (11) Bush Fires (1) Buthan (1) Cambodia (57) Cameroon (4) Canada (823) Canada's Foreign Policy (71) Canada's Green Party (1) Canadian Armed Forces (7) Canadian Corporations (4) Canadian hypocrisy (103) Canadian Imperialism (2) Canadian Media (19) Canadian Military (1) Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) (3) Capital Gains/Capital Gains Taxes (1) Capitalism (2,370) Capitalist totalitarianism (2) Career-Pathways Curriculums (2) Caribbean (32) Cartoon (133) Catholicism (9) Caucasus (41) Celebrities (1) Censorship (361) Central African Republic (1) Central Ixachilan (America) (65) Chad (3) Chagos Archipelago (3) Chancellor Angela Merkel (19) Charter Schools (86) Che Guevara (3) Chelsea Manning (21) Chemical weapons (28) Child Abuse (14) Child Labour (2) Child soldiers (4) Children's Rights (11) Children/Youth (405) Chile (101) China (761) Christianity (13) Chronic Diseases (9) Church and State (5) CIA (477) Cities (9) Citizenship (5) Citizenship and Immigration Canada (2) Civil Disobedience (129) Civil Liberties (506) Classism (812) Climate Change (643) Climate Justice (1) Cluster bombs (12) Co-operatives (17) Coal Mining (2) Colombia (130) Colonel Muammar Gaddafi (1) Colonialism (477) Colour Revolutions (8) Communal Councils (1) Communes (1) Communism/Marxism/Maoism (257) Community Schools (1) Concentration Camps (7) Conformism (1) Conspiracy Theories (6) Consumer Advocacy (191) Consumerism (1) Corporate "Environmentalism" (2) Corporate Globalization (1,092) Corporate Tax (2) Corporate/Finance Criminality (2) Corruption (936) Costa Rica (13) Coup (19) Courts and Judges (49) Crime (277) Crimes against Humanity (871) Crimes against Peace (88) Croatia (2) Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (5) Crusades (1) Cryptocurrency (11) Cuba (282) Cultural Marxism (1) Culture (1,318) Culture Capital (1) Currency (93) Cyber attacks (28) Cyprus (17) Czech Republic (22) Darfur (8) Death Penalty (52) Death Squads (4) Debt (166) Debtor's Prison (5) Deep State (28) Deforestation (3) Democracy (1,398) Democratic Rep. Congo (105) Democratic Socialism (3) Democrats (1,159) Demolitionism (2) Denmark (55) Deposits/Depositors (2) Derivatives (3) Diego Garcia (3) Diplomacy (2) Disasters (184) Discrimination (500) Disinformation (1,611) Djibouti (8) DNA (1) Documentaries (6) Dominican Republic (11) Donald Trump (1,006) Doomsday Clock (2) Doomsday Machines (1) Drones (310) Drought (2) Drug Trafficking (6) Drug Wars (142) Earthquakes (1) East Siberian Arctic Shelf (ESAS) (3) East Timor (37) Ecocide (9) Ecological Socialism (1) Ecology (46) Economic Inequality (8) Economic Resistance (2) Economic Warfare (3) Economy/Economics (1,585) Ecosocialist Green New Deal (4) Ecosystems (55) Ecuador (123) Education (757) Education Technology (1) Edward Snowden (2) Egypt (356) El Salvador (41) Elections (90) Elementary Schools (1) Elitism (17) Elliot Abrams (8) Embargoes (11) Empire (884) Employee Stock Option Plan (ESOP) (1) Employment (284) Energy (436) England (5) Enlightenment meta-narratives (3) EnMo Economics (3) Entrapment (5) Environment (1,360) Equal Rights (9) Equatorial Guinea (4) Eritrea (20) Espionage/"Intelligence" (822) Estate Tax Exemption (1) Estonia (1) Ethics (1) Ethiopia (54) Ethnic Cleansing (93) EU (408) Eugenics (4) Eurasia (5) Europe (375) Evangelicals (2) Existentialism (2) Extinction (62) Extinction Rebellion (9) Extradiction (15) Facebook (6) Facial Recognition (1) Fake News (249) False Flag (63) Famine (12) Fascism (404) Fatah (9) FBI (180) Federal Reserve (44) Feminism (57) Feudalism (5) Fiction (81) Fidel Castro (10) Fifth Column (1) Fiji (2) Film Review (213) Finance (611) Finland (17) Fishing/Fish farming (27) Food Security (24) Food Sovereignty (27) Food/Nutrition (313) Forest Fires (7) Fracking (128) France (469) Free Trade Agreement (FTA) (3) Freedom of Expression/Speech (398) French Revolution (1) Fukushima Daiichi (8) G20 Summit (1) G7 Summit (1) Gabon (2) Gaza (121) Gender (167) Gender Equity (1) General (1,059) Genetics (5) Genocide (367) Gentrification (2) George W. Bush (53) Georgia (9) Germany (342) Ghana (4) Glaciers (1) Global Capitalism (4) Global Green Party (3) Global Inequality (43) Global Warming (142) Globalization (22) Glyphosate (17) GMO (182) Google (6) Graffiti (2) Great Barrier Reef (2) Greece (221) Green New Deal (2) Grenada (9) Gross Domestic Product (GDP) (1) Guantanamo (86) Guatemala (56) Guinea (5) Guns (146) Haiti (189) Hamas (49) Hate Speech (8) Health/Medical (914) Herd Mediocrity (12) Heroes (108) Hezbollah (12) Hillary Clinton (34) Hiroshima (10) History (801) Hollywood (21) Honduras (118) Hong Kong (14) Honour Killings (1) Hope/Awareness (5) Housing/Homelessness (279) Human Rights (1,237) Human Rights Watch (1) Humor (165) Hungary (29) Hunger (132) Hunter-gatherer (4) Hypocrisy (84) Iceland (39) Identity (16) Identity Politics (5) IMF (151) Immigration (4) Impeachment (5) Imperialism (1,582) impossibilists (2) Incarceration (375) Income tax (3) India (290) Indigenous Peoples (1) Indonesia (124) Industrial Farming (10) Industrial Hemp Cultivation (1) Infrastructure (2) Infrastructure and Development Bank (2) Insects (30) Interest (8) International Court of Justice (4) International Criminal Court (62) International Law (69) Internationalism (16) Internet (169) Interracial Adoptions (1) Interview (376) Iran (993) Iraq (1,307) Ireland (51) Islam (13) Israel (223) Israel/Palestine (3,308) Israeli Defence Force (IDF) (25) Israeli Lobby (2) Israeli Military Courts (5) Italy (109) Ivory Coast (3) Jagmeet Singh NDP Leader (3) Jakarta (6) Jamaica (3) Japan (303) Java (1) Jeremy Corbyn (101) Jerusalem (47) Joe Biden (1) John Bolton (51) John F. Kennedy (8) Jordan (96) Journalism (138) Julian Assange (103) Justice (771) Kabul (24) Kalaallit Nunaat/Greenland (29) Kazakhstan (3) Kenya (16) Kings Bay Plowshares 7 (2) Korea (227) Kosovo (8) Kurds (1) Kuwait (47) Kyrgyzstan (13) Labor (774) Labor Theory of Value (1) Land ownership (71) Land Theft (33) Land Use (137) Language (312) Laos (37) Latvia (9) Lebanon (222) Legal/Constitutional (504) LGBTQ (73) Liberalism (4) Liberia (2) Libertarianism (36) Libra (3) Libya (547) Lies (10) Life/Animal Rights (253) Literature (88) Lithuania (1) Logging (35) M16 (9) Macedonia (1) Madrid COP25 (Conference of the Parties 25) (2) Mafia (1) Mahmoud Abbas (46) Malaysia (39) Malcolm X (4) Mali (33) Manus Island (10) Marijuana (23) Markets (7) Marshall lslands (2) Martin Luther King Jr. (10) Massacres (56) Maurice Bishop (1) Mauritania (2) Media (3,008) Media Bias (194) Media Censorship (47) Media Criticism (22) Media Lies (1) Medical Ethics (10) Medical Insurance (8) Medical records security (2) Medicare for All (2) Medievalism (2) Memorial Day (3) Mental Health (16) Mercenaries (234) Meritocracy (3) Methane gases (4) Mexico (227) Micronesia (4) Middle Class (2) Middle East (567) Migration/Migrants (98) Mike Pence (24) Mike Pompeo (49) Militarism (3,461) Military doctors (3) Mind Control (9) Minimum Wage (8) Mining (176) Modernism (3) Mohamed Morsi (1) Monarchy (1) Money supply (92) Mongolia (4) Monsanto (now Bayer) (19) Morocco (15) Mossad (56) Motor vehicles (9) Movies (8) Mozambigue (1) Mueller Report (8) Multiculturalism (4) Murder (13) Museums (2) Music (164) Myanmar/Burma (48) Mythology (19) NAFTA (9) NAFTA-2 (2) Nagasaki (10) Nakba (27) Namibia (11) Nancy Pelosi (4) Narrative (612) NASA (3) National Public Radio (1) National Security (2) Nationalism (51) NATO (584) Nauru (5) Neo-Nazis (5) Neoliberalism (921) Neopatrimonial Factionalism (NF) (1) Nepal (16) Net Neutrality (5) Netherlands (18) New Democratic Party (NDP) (20) New Orleans (98) NGOs (213) Nicaragua (76) Niger (3) Nigeria (35) Non-violence (23) North Africa (1) North Korea (110) Northern Ireland (1) Norway (57) NSA (154) Nuclear Disarmament Agreements (1) Nuclear Energy (77) Nukes (350) Obituary (118) Occupation (165) Occupied East Jerusalem (10) Occupy movement (115) Oceania (14) Oceans/Rivers/Seas (11) Oil, Gas, Coal, Pipelines (501) Okinawa (2) Olympics (19) Oman (2) One Democratic State (ODS) (1) Opera (1) Opinion (976) Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) (3) Organization of American States (OAS) (2) Original Peoples (491) Osama Bin Laden (58) Oslo Accords (15) Over population (2) Pakistan (364) Palestine (102) Palestinian Authority (14) Palestinian Christians (3) Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) (9) Palestinian Refugee Camps (6) Panama (29) Papua New Guinea (8) Paraguay (32) Paris 2015 (13) Parole (1) Patient Privacy (6) Patient Rights (16) Patriarchy (15) Patriotism (97) Paul Kagame (4) Peace (26) Peace Accords (1) Peace Activism (25) Pension Plans (3) Permafrost (24) Peru (38) Pesticides (78) Pete Buttigieg (1) Pharmaceuticals (158) Philanthrocapitalism (1) Philippines (77) Philosophy (406) Plagiarism (1) Planet Earth (33) Plastic (33) Poetry (2,754) Poland (37) Police (643) Police brutality (47) Police militarization (45) Political Correctness (5) Political Prisoners (155) Politics (496) Pollution (215) Pope Francis (1) Population (2) Populism (6) Portugal (29) Post-modern Anarchist Revolution (1) Postal Banking (2) Postmodernism (5) Poverty (530) Prejudice (466) President Bashar al-Assad (77) President Daniel Ortega (5) President Emmanuel Macron (40) President Evo Morales (13) President Hugo Chavez (39) President Jair Bolsonaro (15) President Kim Jong-un (29) President Lenin Moreno (3) President Mauricio Macri (10) President Miguel Díaz-Canel Bermúdez (2) President Moon Jae-in (9) President Nicolas Maduro (99) President Recep Tayyip Erdogan (15) President Sebastian Piñera (2) President Vladimir Putin (93) President Xi Jinping (27) Presidential Debates (2) Press Freedom (2) Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed Ali (1) Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras (1) Prime Minister Imran Khan (1) Prime Minister Justin Trudeau (36) Prime Minister Norendra Modi (7) Prime Minister Scott Morrison (1) Prime Minister Shinzo Abe (5) Prime Minister Viktor Orbán (2) Prison (9) Prison Industry (36) Prison Population (24) Prisoner Rights/Protections (3) Privacy (140) Private Property (4) Privatization (196) Procreationism (1) Productionism (1) Propaganda (1,840) Prostitution (8) Protests (35) Proxy Armies (9) Psychology/Psychiatry (244) Public banks (10) Public Relations (16) Public Schools (24) Public Spaces (19) Public-Private Partnerships (1) Puerto Rico (48) Purges (1) Puritanism (1) Qasem Soleimani (7) Qatar (128) Racism (1,409) Radiation (5) Rain Forests (26) Realism (3) Rebellion (3) Recuperated Workplaces (1) Referendum (3) Refugees (340) Religion (635) Religious Fundamentalism (1) Renaissance Humanism (3) Rendition (16) Renewables (81) Republic of Mauritius (2) Republicans (61) Repurchase Agreements ("repo") (2) Resistance (694) Resistance Art (4) Revolution (489) Revolutionaries (19) Right of Return (13) Right Wing Jerks (598) Riots (2) Robert F. Kennedy (10) Robert Mugabe (4) Romania (7) Romanticism (9) Royal Canadian Mounted Police (1) Ruling Elite (2) Russia (1,096) Rwanda (75) Salmon (27) Sanctions (235) Satire (265) Saudi Arabia (471) School Yard Fights (120) Schools (1) Science (5) Science/Technology (459) Scotland (2) Sea Level Rise (5) Security (308) Security Council Veto (10) Segregation (10) Semites (1) Serbia (20) Settler Colonization (122) Sex (1) Sexual Misconduct (12) Sexuality (94) Seychelles (1) Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) (1) Sierra Leone (5) Singapore (10) Slavery (17) Slovakia (5) Slums (5) Snapchat (1) Social Darwinism (9) Social Justice (2) Social media (167) Social Movements (75) Social Realism (2) Social Security (147) Socialism (456) Socialist Realism (1) Socialist Revolution (5) Society (45) Socioemotional-learning Legislation (1) Solar Energy (10) Solidarity (698) Solitary confinement (14) Solomon Islands (3) Somalia (103) South Africa (86) South Ixachilan (America) (170) South Sudan (14) Spain (107) Speciesism (2) Sports (199) Sri Lanka (63) Standing Armies (1) State Repression (3) Statism (69) Strikes (7) Structural-anarchism-economics (2) Student Loans (15) Students (298) Students/Teachers (5) Sudan (43) Suicide (8) Supreme Court (140) Surrogacy (2) Sustainability (205) Sustainable Economy (1) Sweat shop (31) Sweden (83) Switzerland (43) Syria (1,116) Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) (1) Syrian Golan Heights (16) Taiwan (11) Tajikistan (4) Taliban (18) Tanzania (8) Tariffs (7) Tax (213) Tax Collection (1) Tax Cuts (2) Tax reform (8) Tea Party movement (123) Teachers' Strikes (4) Teamsters (1) Technology (24) Television Review (1) Terrorism (state and retail) (1,015) Thailand (27) The Commons (15) The Cuban Five (1) The Lobby (378) The Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) (1) The Rohingya (2) The Ruling Class (6) The Soviet Union (38) The Vatican (1) Theatre (1) Theatre Review (2) Theresa May (58) Tibet (10) Tony Blair (8) Torture (33) Touring (4) Tourism (8) TPP (112) Trade (156) Tradition (1) Transition towns (1) Transparency/Secrecy (127) Transportation (92) Tribalism (1) Tulsi Gabbard (1) Tunisia (59) Turkey (333) Turkmenistan (2) Turtle Island (65) Twitter (8) Uganda (37) UK Corporations (1) UK Greens (4) UK Hypocrisy (129) UK Labour Party (54) UK Lies (30) UK Media (150) UK Politics (103) Ukraine (364) UN General Assembly (6) Unemployment (15) UNESCO (5) Unions (390) United Arab Emirates (63) United Kingdom (1,411) United Nations (793) United Nations Charter (3) United States (1,361) Universal Basic Income (12) Universities (12) UNRWA (6) Urbanization (5) Uruguay (22) US Civil War (3) US Congress (22) US Corpocracy (25) US Dollar (4) US Foreign Policy (22) US Green Party (6) US H-Bombs (1) US Hypocrisy (520) US Imperialism (8) US Lies (328) US Media (115) US Military (33) US Military Bases (51) US Terrorism (193) US Time Change (1) US Veterans (1) US War Crimes (122) Uyghur (1) Uzbekistan (6) Vedic Civilization (2) Venezuela (466) Venezuelan Embassy Protectors (1) Veterans Day (1) Video (421) Viet Nam (295) Violence (136) Vote (11) Wage (91) Wahhabism (4) Wales (2) Wall Street (224) War (169) War Crimes (1,126) War Games (5) War Industry (136) War on Terror (2) Water (227) Weaponry (532) Weapons Sales (101) West Bank (78) West Papua (16) Western Sahara (6) Whistleblowing (343) White Helmets (7) White Supremacy (33) WikiLeaks (339) Wild Fires (1) Workers' Assembly (2) Workers' Safety (6) Working Class (19) World Bank (34) World Cup (3) World Government (7) World Trade Organization (6) World War One (25) World War Two (27) Yellow Vest (Gilets Jaunes) Movement (8) Yemen (332) Yuan (14) Zambia (4) Zimbabwe (20) Zionism (1,391)
Poetry on Sunday
A Matter of Quality: Air Pollution, Tennis, and Sporting Officialdom
Binoy Kampmark / 01/16/2020
Canada's Dark History vis-à-vis Iran
Yves Engler / 01/16/2020
China, Number One Economic Power for Half Decade, Dashes on
John V. Walsh / 01/16/2020
Russia: A Groundbreaking Powershift?
Peter Koenig / 01/16/2020
RCMP are Now Blocking Access to Wet'suwet'en Territory
UnistotenCamp / 01/15/2020
Colin Todhunter / 01/15/2020
Ramzy Baroud / 01/15/2020
King Tides and Who's King of the Hill?
Paul Haeder / 01/15/2020
Ajamu Baraka and Bahman Azad / 01/15/2020
Short of Time: Julian Assange at the Westminster Magistrates Court
Understanding Socialism Richard D. Wolff
Unsettling Truths: The Ongoing, Dehumanizing Legacy of the Doctrine of Discovery Mark Charles and Soong-Chan Rah
Civilized to Death: The Price of Progress Christopher Ryan
Responsibility of Intellectuals: Reflections by Noam Chomsky and Others after 50 years Nicholas Allott, Chris Knight, and Neil Smith (Eds)
The (Real) Revolution in Military Affairs Andrei Martyanov
The Plot to Overthrow Venezuela: How the U.S. Is Orchestrating a Coup for Oil Dan Kovalik
Are We Done Fighting? Building Understanding in a World of Hate and Division Matthew Legge
In Defense of Julian Assange Tariq Ali and Margaret Kunstler (Eds)
Plunder of the Commons: A Manifesto for Sharing Public Wealth Guy Standing
Eclipse of Man: Human Extinction and the Meaning of Progress Charles T Rubin
More books »
The Fateful Collision: Floods, Catastrophe And Climate Denial
by Media Lens / February 25th, 2014
An epic struggle is currently taking place that will determine the fate, and perhaps the survival, of our species. It is a collision between natural limits and rational awareness of the need to respect those limits, on the one hand, and the forces of blind greed, on the other.
Over the next few years, fundamental questions about who we are as a species really will be answered: Are we fundamentally sane, rational? Or are we a self-destructive failure that will end in the evolutionary dustbin?
As former Conservative energy minister Charles Hendry says, the recent UK floods "have ended political debate about climate change impacts". Indeed, recent global weather extremes suggest that something of "enormous magnitude is happening".
Even taken in isolation, the UK floods may constitute an "absolutely devastating environment incident", a recent study by conservation scientists reports:
Noxious hydrogen sulphide fumes and lead poisoning are among the threats from floodwater contamination – while animals at almost all stages of the food chain, from insects to small mammals and birds, are already thought to be drowning or dying from lack of food.
And these floods are merely the latest in a very long list of extreme events, including the ongoing, record-breaking California drought. Of this, University of California, Irvine, hydrologist James Famiglietti has said: "We are standing on a precipice here."
In addition, we have seen the vast US 'polar vortex' and 'Frankenstorm' Sandy. Last year, Australia 'recorded its warmest year on record,' while Supertyphoon Haiyan, 'the strongest tropical cyclone on record to hit land', devastated the Philippines. India was also afflicted by massive floods. 2013 was 'the 37th consecutive year with a global temperature above the 20th century average'.
Tony Juniper, former director of Friends of the Earth, commented to us: "The period of consequences is evidently upon us."
The Bottom Line – Preparing For Human Extinction
Let us look more closely at the nature of this fateful collision.
In a quietly despairing blog, Guy McPherson, professor emeritus of natural resources, ecology and evolutionary biology at the University of Arizona, nutshells one-half of the problem facing us:
If you're too busy to read the evidence presented below, here's the bottom line: On a planet 4 C hotter than baseline, all we can prepare for is human extinction.
Could that happen? McPherson quotes professor of climatology Mark Maslin:
We are already planning for a 4°C world because that is where we are heading. I do not know of any scientists who do not believe that.
That second sentence is worth reading again. Or we can recall the comments made by Professor Kevin Anderson, director of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research, on the BBC website in 2010:
Yet over a pint of ale or sharing a coffee it is hard to find any scientist seriously engaged in climate change who considers a 4C rise within this century as anything other than catastrophic for both human society and ecosystems.
Moreover, ask those same scientists if 4C is likely to be as high as it could get prior to the temperature beginning to fall, and many will shake their heads pointing to a range of discontinuities (tipping points) that may see us witness temperatures increasing well beyond 4C.
This, then, is one-half of our problem: McPherson is right about the significance of a 4 C rise in temperature, and he is right that scientists widely believe that we are indeed heading for a catastrophic 4 C warmer world, or worse.
There is, of course, debate about the timing of this temperature rise. McPherson could hardly be more pessimistic, arguing that it is already too late to save ourselves. He writes:
Even mainstream scientists minimize the message at every turn. As we've known for years, scientists almost invariably underplay climate impacts. I'm not implying conspiracy among scientists. Science selects for conservatism. Academia selects for extreme conservatism. These folks are loathe to risk drawing undue attention to themselves by pointing out there might be a threat to civilization. Never mind the near-term threat to our entire species (they couldn't care less about other species). If the truth is dire, they can find another, not-so-dire version.
A recent report by the Climate Council found that "the frequency of heatwaves in parts of Australia has already surpassed levels previously predicted for 2030".
Breaking The Back Of "The Beast"
The second half of our problem is that evidence of this terminal threat to our existence is being obstructed by literally hundreds of millions of dollars of organised propaganda.
Earlier this month, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse made a courageous and crucial speech to the US Senate. He commented:
I have described Congress as surrounded by a barricade of lies. Today, I'll be more specific. There isn't just lying going on about climate change; there is a whole, carefully built apparatus of lies. This apparatus is big and artfully constructed: phoney-baloney organisations designed to look and sound like they're real, messages honed by public relations experts to sound like they're truthful, payrolled scientists whom polluters can trot out when they need them. And the whole thing big and complicated enough that when you see its parts you could be fooled into thinking that it's not all the same beast. But it is. Just like the mythological Hydra – many heads, same beast.
Whitehouse's speech made repeated reference to a ground-breaking new study by Robert J. Brulle, professor of sociology and environmental science at Drexel university, which describes the organisational underpinnings and funding behind climate denial. This is the first peer-reviewed, comprehensive analysis ever conducted on the topic.
Brulle finds that from 2003 to 2010, 140 foundations made 5,299 grants totalling fully $558 million to 91 major climate denial organisations. These 91 organisations have an annual income of just over $900 million, with an annual average of $64 million in identifiable foundation support. The UK also has its own denial network.
Disturbingly, Brulle writes that "while the largest and most consistent funders behind the countermovement are a number of well-known conservative foundations, the majority of donations are "dark money," or concealed funding".
This is part of a trend:
The data also indicates that Koch Industries and ExxonMobil, two of the largest supporters of climate science denial, have recently pulled back from publicly funding countermovement organizations. Coinciding with the decline in traceable funding, the amount of funding given to countermovement organizations through third party pass-through foundations like Donors Trust and Donors Capital, whose funders cannot be traced, has risen dramatically.
In other words, as scientific evidence of looming climate disaster has become simply overwhelming, the funders blocking action to prevent disaster have knowingly hidden their support for fear of negative publicity.
As for the high-profile "deniers" embraced by the media, Brulle comments:
Like a play on Broadway, the countermovement has stars in the spotlight – often prominent contrarian scientists or conservative politicians – but behind the stars is an organizational structure of directors, script writers and producers, in the form of conservative foundations. If you want to understand what's driving this movement, you have to look at what's going on behind the scenes.
The truth, then, is this: that climate denial is a wholly artificial, manufactured creation; a gigantic corporate fraud. Without the "apparatus of lies" it simply would not exist as a "serious" argument and would certainly not be able to challenge the consensus of 97 per cent of climate scientists on the reality of the threat posed by climate change. It is this outright fraud subordinating human welfare to profit that the corporate media continues to indulge in the name of "balance".
Senator Whitehouse sums up the significance:
This apparatus is a disgrace. When the inevitable happens and the impact of climate change really starts to hit home, people will want to know: why? Why we didn't take proper steps in time. It's not as if there's not enough scientific evidence out there for us to act. Why not?
This denial operation – The Beast – will then go down as one of our great American scandals, like Watergate or Teapot Dome – a deliberate, complex scheme of lies and propaganda that caused real harm to the American people, and to our country. All so that a small group of people could make more money a little longer.
So why has this "disgrace" not been exposed?
The reason is that, for the last quarter of a century, corporate politics and corporate media – close allies and even "limbs" of "the beast" – have censored the truth about its workings. Guy McPherson explains:
Worse than the aforementioned trolls are the media. Fully captured by corporations and the corporate states, the media continue to dance around the issue of climate change. Occasionally a forthright piece is published, but it generally points in the wrong direction, such as suggesting climate scientists and activists be killed (e.g., James Delingpole's 7 April 2013 hate-filled article in the Telegraph).
By way of a bitter irony, we need only consider the media response to Brulle's study. A Lexis database search of the UK press finds that Brulle's ground-breaking, peer-reviewed research has been mentioned in one article in the Guardian with a further mention in passing in the Daily Mail. The study has been mentioned by no other UK newspaper. A Factiva database search of US newspapers by analyst David Peterson finds that the study has been mentioned in a single, 500-word piece in the Washington Post.
This is consistent with a growing trend of corporate media suppression. In 2012, Douglas Fischer reported that corporate media coverage of climate change "continued to tumble in 2011, declining roughly 20 percent from 2010′s levels and nearly 42 percent from 2009′s peak".
The problem, of course, as McPherson notes, is that the corporate media is indeed "fully captured" by Sheldon Whitehouse's "beast".
The impact on public awareness is clear. Between 2007-2011, in the face of rapidly growing scientific evidence, the proportion of the US population who accepted that industry was causing climate change dropped from 71% to 44%. Between 2005 and 2013, the number of British people who believed the climate was not changing rose from 4% to 19%.
A separate poll finds that "two thirds of people have never talked about climate change outside their immediate social circle, and a third of people never talked about it with anyone at all".
The climate denial "beast" is actually a tentacle of a much bigger monster that has fought to destroy all environmentalism, socialism, indeed any movement threatening corporate control and profits. In 1991, Bob Williams – a consultant to the oil and gas industry – described the corporate priority:
To put the environmental lobby out of business… There is no greater imperative… If the petroleum industry is to survive, it must render the environmental lobby superfluous, an anachronism. 1
But the problem is more deeply entrenched even than this suggests. American historian Elizabeth Fones-Wolf has written of the US corporate propaganda campaigns of the 1940s and 1950s:
Manufacturers orchestrated multi-million dollar public relations campaigns that relied on newspapers, magazines, radio, and later television, to re-educate the public in the principles and benefits of the American economic system… This involved convincing workers to identify their social, economic, and political well-being with that of their specific employer and more broadly with the free enterprise system. 2
The climate denial "beast" is just the latest example of these ongoing "public relations campaigns". With such powerful institutions locked into securing ever more profits through ever greater control, and with the public persuaded to pursue ever more consumption at any cost, what are our chances? What can we do?
A quarter of a century ago, Frank Mankiewicz, a senior executive at PR firm Hill and Knowlton, provided a clue in referring to the fall of the Romanian dictator Ceausescu:
I think the companies will have to give in only at insignificant levels. Because the companies are too strong, they're the establishment. The environmentalists are going to have to be like the mob in the square in Romania before they prevail. 3
This may well be the case. Senator Whitehouse told Congress:
We must break the back of the beast… For the sake of our democracy, for the sake of our future, for the sake of our honour – it is time to wake up.
As NASA climate scientist James Hansen has suggested, Nuremberg-style trials must be held for senior corporate (including corporate media) and political executives responsible for crimes against humanity and planet that almost defy belief. They must be held to account for their crimes.
But much more importantly, of course, we must act – now – to save ourselves from utter disaster.
Williams, US Petroleum Strategies in the Decade of the Environment. Quoted, Sharon Beder, Global Spin – The Corporate Assault on Environmentalism, Green Books 1997, p.22 [↩]
Fones-Wolf, Selling Free Enterprise – The Business Assault on Labour and Liberalism, 1945-60,' University of Illinois Press, 1994, p.6 [↩]
Quoted, Beder, op.cit., p.22 [↩]
Media Lens is a UK-based media watchdog group headed by David Edwards and David Cromwell. The second Media Lens book, Newspeak: In the 21st Century by David Edwards and David Cromwell, was published in 2009 by Pluto Press. Read other articles by Media Lens, or visit Media Lens's website.
This article was posted on Tuesday, February 25th, 2014 at 12:13am and is filed under Climate Change, Corporate Globalization.
All content © 2007-2020 Dissident Voice and respective authors | Subscribe to the DV RSS feed | Top