What else Qatar has built with its absurd wealth besides the 2022 World Cup
November 26, 2022 by administrator
By Jonathan Guyer,
Qatar is a player. In the Middle East and across the world, the petrostate of fewer than 3 million people plays an outsized role in politics, media, and art. Its cultural diplomacy has established the country's influence — and now it's doing the same with sport.
Al Bayt Stadium ahead of the opening match of the FIFA World Cup, built to resemble a traditional Qatari tent.
Christopher Pike/Bloomberg via Getty Images
The country's absurd wealth is on display this month: It spent about $300 billion on stadiums and groundwork to host the 2022 FIFA World Cup, which kicked off Sunday. That money totaled more than all previous World Cups and Olympics combined.
Qatar exports more liquified natural gas than any other country. Its energy resources have made the royal family among the world's richest, and with a $335 billion sovereign wealth fund, it is one of the biggest landowners in the United Kingdom, and owns a major stake in the Empire State Building.
Yet Qatar has arguably been a more strategic spender than neighboring oil-rich states. It has focused on successfully constructing domestic cultural and educational institutions for Qataris and creating a national identity. But it's a national identity presented by the royal family that does not tolerate dissent and does not guarantee human rights.
The achievement of the first World Cup being convened in the Arab world embodies those tensions: Qatar is a state that uses its immense wealth and power to elevate itself and the region, that cares deeply about culture, and yet has few freedoms.
Qatar's elaborate hosting of the World Cup parallels its art prowess
Doha rapidly developed in recent decades from a small port to a dramatic cityscape in what Qatari artist Sophia Al-Maria describes as "Gulf Futurism."
Yet for all its lavish spending and foreign-policy influence, Qatar has managed to avoid criticism over the years for restricting rights for women and LGBTQ people and labor violations, including relative silence from its Western allies. (It must help that it's home to the largest US military base in the Middle East.)
The incredible development of World Cup arenas mirrors Qatar's staggering art investments. The sister of Qatar's emir and the head of its network of museums, Sheikha al-Mayassa bint Hamad bin Khalifa al-Thani, reportedly spends about $1 billion annually on art. That's much higher than any major US museum.
Qatar has commissioned epic works by Western artists, like Richard Serra's hulking steel plates in the desert ("East-West/West-East") and Damien Hirst's series of large bronze sculptures, some 46 feet high, of human reproduction from conception to embryo ("The Miraculous Journey"). Qatar has also bought some of the most expensive paintings in the world: Rothko's "White Center" ($70 million), Cézanne's "The Card Players" ($250 million), and Gauguin's "When Will You Marry?" ($300 million).
There has been a huge emphasis on "starchitects" — largely American and European architects building outlandish structures that few other countries could afford, among them Rem Koolhaas and Jean Nouvel.
But Qatar, importantly, hasn't only imported from the West.
It has created institutions that have helped forge its national identities as a Muslim and Arab country. The breathtakingly minimalist Museum of Islamic Art in Doha's center, designed by famed architect I.M. Pei, contains a remarkable international collection. On the outskirts of Education City, among satellites of universities like Georgetown, Northwestern, and Virginia Commonwealth, is the Mathaf: Arab Museum of Modern Art, which contains one of the most extensive collections of 20th-century Arab art. (Qatar and the UAE are engaged in a cutthroat race to buy up Arab modern art from across the Middle East.) And part of the capital has a new downtown made to look old, called Msheireb, with many cultural museums including one focused on the country's history of slavery.
"Qatar has always been much more connected, if you will, to that sense of their own past and their historical memory," Kishwar Rizvi, a professor of art history and architecture at Yale University, told me. "There's this global stage on which they want to present themselves," she explained, but also a sense that, "We have oil, wealth, and all of that, but we also need cultural capital, because that also is part of what makes a nation."
Perhaps because Qatar's cultural investments have been so savvy, I've been taken aback by the ostentatiousness of its World Cup stadiums. One stadium is shaped like a traditional Qatari tent and another is made of shipping containers. Most of the marquee stadiums for world sporting events are showy or trying to represent the host country's culture, but with this year's, everything looks ornamental or too obvious.
Can cultural diplomacy thrive without human rights?
I visited Qatar in 2016 to attend a blue-chip conference of artists and architects, all presided over by Sheikha al-Mayassa. Conceptual artist Marina Abramović equated her and Qatar's royal family to modern-day Medicis, with the funds to support artists like Serra in creating monumental works.
That money, it seems, does buy the complicity of powerful people. "To just come and criticize, it's such an easy way to close the culture forever, but I want to open this culture," Abramović told me.
On the sidelines of the swish confab at the W Hotel Doha, I interviewed Jeff Koons, one of the world's most expensive living artists and a frequent guest of the royal family. I asked him: Why Qatar? "I would say because of the openness of Qatar to ideas, to education, to the humanities, to psychology and philosophy and all the different things that can stimulate the public for growth and development," he told me.
I pushed Koons to discuss reported labor violations, that his nudes could never be exhibited in the conservative country, and the fact that a Qatari poet was imprisoned at the time for a protest song. "Going back to some of the problems here in Qatar and these different things, I'm naïve of some of the aspects," Koons told me. "I know that internationally there has been a movement to try to make working conditions better for laborers, and I think that a lot of problems, not only here but internationally, have been addressed to try to make situations where, if abuses take place, they're corrected."
Qatar is a monarchy with a large expat and migrant labor population that has very limited rights. Migrant workers can't join labor unions. The Guardian has reported that 6,500 migrant workers died over a decade, and a Kenyan blogger who wrote about it was arrested in 2021.
Beyond that, women are stifled by guardianship laws, LGBTQ people lack rights, and internet activists have been imprisoned. The courts are not independent, the press cannot freely cover the country's politics, and there are no serious elections for leadership and no political parties.
"If you're in Qatar, and your rights are trampled on as a woman or as a queer person or anything, if you don't like it, you're just thrown into jail and good luck," Wafa Ben-Hassine, a human rights attorney based in Washington, DC, told me. "It's like you have certain rights and freedoms only if you belong to a certain class of protected people" — the wealthy or certain expats — "then they become not human rights."
Qatar has largely eluded scrutiny over the years. Now that the country is getting so much attention, there have been some articles criticizing a double standard that Qatar is being held to. But Ben-Hassine said that scrutiny is merited.
"I'm happy that an Arab nation is hosting one of the most lucrative spectacles in the world," Ben-Hassine said. "But it can be better, and it should do better. We should be clear-eyed about the state of affairs that this country has and aim to hold it to the highest standards."
And it's not just about Qatar. It's about the world systems in which Qatar operates, and the ways in which the tournament serves Western interests, as Guardian columnist Nesrine Malik writes, at the expense of those who lack rights in Qatar.
Nasser Rabbat, a professor of Islamic architecture at MIT, put it this way: "I don't want to absolve the patrons, the contractors, and the builders, from the amazing human rights violations they have sustained all these years. I'm not going to come to the defense of any of these countries in saying that their labor treatment is acceptable. It is absolutely unacceptable. But I'm not going to blame them as well."
"Because, at the end of the day, those who are making the most amount of money from the construction boom in the Gulf are companies from our part of the world, from the United States and from Europe," Rabbat told me. "They are responsible for the deaths of hundreds, if not thousands, of workers, but we too are responsible for those deaths. And we too have benefited from those deaths."
So the World Cup — with the blitz of global media and the arrival of a million visitors — exposes Qatar to new pressures from the outside. In welcoming teams and fans from around the globe, the cameras may reveal the country's limitations. Qatar's deep investments in culture can't shield it from criticism for the shallowness of rights there.
Source: https://www.vox.com/world/23475120/qatar-wealth-rich-2022-fifa-world-cup-human-rights?sponsored=0&position=1&scheduled_corpus_item_id=5ce82b16-9ba7-4f1a-bec9-ecc4049d0a43
Naira Zohrabyan: the scandalous statements of Sasun Mikayelyan regarding the Armenian army (VIDEO)
This was Sasun Mikayelyan's second immoral statement. Sasun Mikayelyan made his first statement in 2018, which can be described as an ideology, anthem, manifesto of velvet coup, and velvet banditry. We are talking about the statement according to the "revolution" has greater value than the Artsakh liberation war. Naira Zohrabyan, the chairwoman of the "Security […]
Israeli TV Spews Repulsive Azeri, Propaganda Against Armenia & Iran
By Harut Sassounian, On January 27, Israel's international TV station, i24NEWS, aired a half-hour program full of falsehoods to glorify Azerbaijan's relations with Israel and vilify Armenia, Iran, and Russia. This scandalous program had nothing to do with journalism, and everything to do with Azerbaijan's notorious 'caviar diplomacy.' Here are excerpts from the TV program […]
A strong earthquake, with a preliminary magnitude of 5.9, struck off the southeastern Greek island of Rhodes on Wednesday, according to the Athens Geodynamic Institute.
There were no immediate reports of damage or injuries. The quake was also felt in the nearby Turkish provinces of Mugla, Izmir, and Antalya, with Turkey's AFAD emergency management agency saying it had a preliminary magnitude of 5.4. The undersea quake struck at 14:37 Greek time and had an epicentre nearly 400 kilometres southeast of […]
In 2022, Armenia's public debt increased by 15.3%, crossing the threshold of 10 billion dollars.
Armenia's state debt has crossed the threshold of 10 billion dollars. It does not violate the fiscal rules, but the debt service is becoming more and more burdensome, the billions of drams from the budget are directed to interest rates. The strengthening of the dram against the dollar was in favor of the national debt. […]
Salpi Ghazarian Steps Down as Director of the USC Dornsife Institute of Armenian Studies
LOS ANGELES – Salpi Ghazarian is stepping down as director of the USC Dornsife Institute of Armenian Studies after serving in the role since 2014. She will remain at the Institute and will work on special initiatives. Dr. Shushan Karapetian, formerly deputy director of the Institute, is the new director as of January 2023. "Towards the […]
Armenia's third President Serzh Sargsyan issued a message on the occasion of Army Day:
Armenia's third President Serzh Sargsyan issued a message on the occasion of Army Day:It is very important, that we realize and accept simple truth which is critical for our future victories. Any nation or state is doomed to perish as long as there is no understanding that the army is the guarantee of the nation's […]
Egypt General SISI coming to Armenia, Egypt's Counterrevolution experience must be implemented in Armenia
Egypt Like Armenia went through a Color Revolution supported by Turkey, But Egypt Had general SISI take Counterrevolution and remove Turkish Agent Morsi from power now Egypt is a stable and powerful country. Armenian military Generals have to take the advantage of SISI Vist and ask SISI advice on how to do a Counterrevolution and […]
The Armenian army will be the first to straighten it's injured back. Seyran Ohanyan
Seyran Ohanyan, former Minister of Defense of the Republic of Armenia, and head of the Armenia faction, sent a message on the occasion of Army Day. "Happy holiday, Armenian army. My eternal bow to the generations who, from the first heroic battle of Artsakh to today, have fought for your glorious victories at the cost […]
Not only our friends have been made enemies with us, but also with each other, Edgar Ghazaryan Video
The gratitude rally on the occasion of the Day of the Armenian Army, called by political and public figure Edgar Ghazaryan, has started in Republic Square. According to Edgar Ghazaryan, the authorities are consistently destroying the army. Touching upon the work of the diplomatic corps, Ghazaryan said that as a result of incompetent diplomacy, Armenia's […]
Armenia ex-President Kocharyan: I want to believe that this situation will be corrected
Second President of Armenia Robert Kocharyan on Saturday issued a congratulatory message on the occasion of Army Day. "Congratulations on Armenian Army Day. Our army goes through daily trials. It seems that nothing is being done for the army to finally straighten [its] back. I want to believe that this situation will be corrected, and […]
Pashinyan A lion at home, a cat outside. why He does not neutralize the threat from the Russian military base
Russia says it is building a bipolar or multipolar world, where there will be other power centers besides the US or the collective West led by the US: Russia, China, or both. In order to become a pole of power, Russia needs not only to get out of the influence of the West but also […]
Artsakh State Minister: The Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh will not leave their homeland spite difficulties
Minister of State of the Nagorno-Karabakh Republic, Chief of the Operational Staff Ruben Vardanyan continued his visits to the communities. Vardanyan continued his visits to the Nagorno-Karabakh communities, On January 27, he held meetings in Spitakashen, Agorti and Mushkapat communities of NKR Martuni region. Minister of Territorial Administration and Infrastructures Suren Galstyan, head of the […]
Jerusalem: "Death to Christians Death to Armenian", Jewish extremists allegedly attacked an Armenian restaurant in Jerusalem last night Video
Yesterday January 26 in Jerusalem, about 30 to 40 Jewish extremists attacked the restaurant belonging to the Armenian Mihran Grigoryan, and damaged the property with cries of "death to Christians" and "death to Arabs". restaurant owner Mihran Grigoryan said the incident happened in the evening, around 10:30 p.m. As a result of the incident, which […]
Turkish nationalist claims bomb threat on Athens Airport: "Establish Sharia Law, Return Cyprus to Turkey"
A Turkish nationalist claimed responsibility for the bomb threat at Athens International Airport on Friday. A person claiming to be a Turkish nationalist and a friend of the Russian prankster, who on Tuesday morning sent bomb threats against Athens International Airport and six hospitals in Athens through an email, took responsibility for today's bomb scare. […]
AGBU Orange County Saturday School hosts Prof. Abazajian presenting "History of the Universe"
On Saturday, January 28 the AGBU Orange County Saturday School is proud to host Prof. Kevork N. Abazajian, Professor of Physics & Astronomy and the Director of the Center for Cosmology at the University of California, Irvine. His research focuses on the nature of dark matter at the interface between particle physics and astrophysics, the […]
Motion Led By L.A. County Supervisors Barger and Horvath Passes with a Unanimous Vote Calling for End to #Artsakh Blockade
Anna Gasparyan, ANCA The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors convened on Tuesday, January 24th to discuss a motion calling for an end to the blockade of the Lachin corridor, the sole route that connects Artsakh with the rest of the world. The motion was spearheaded by Supervisors Kathryn Barger and Lindsey Horvath as an […]
An Open Letter from the Women of Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) to Ursula von der Leyen
Dear President Von der Leyen, We, the women of Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) make this appeal to the world and personally to the president of the European Commission Ursula von der Leyen. Change.org We are starving and freezing before the eyes of the whole world! We are under a blockade by Azerbaijan which is stealing our gas […]
An instruction was issued not to pronounce the word #Artsakh. Pashinyan said Nagorno Karabakh 19 times
Ani Arakelyan It is possible that Nikol Pashinyan seems to be doing a very important job by publicizing the monstrous plans of the Azerbaijani authorities to subject Artsakh to ethnic cleansing. It is possible that he thinks that the international community is not informed about what is happening with Artsakh and around Artsakh and his […]
The main demand of Azerbaijan is Ruben Vardanyan. Opinions are divided in Artsakh
It is the 46th day of the siege of Artsakh. Today, the Prime Minister of Armenia presented the plan of his Azerbaijani partners at the government meeting: "according to our information, Baku's plan is as follows: to bring the economic and psychological pressure in Nagorno-Karabakh to a certain culmination point, after that to open the […]
Katia Tavitian Karageuzian's "Forbidden Homeland" Book Launch Gathers Crowd of Over 200 Community Members
By ANNA GASPARYAN, ANCA The ANCA-Western Region Education Committee organized a "kinetzon", or wine blessing, for one of its own members, author Katia Tavitian Karaguezian, in a book launch for Forbidden Homeland, a personal account of diaspora with a focus on the Armenian Genocide and the ongoing Nagorno Karabakh (Artsakh) conflict. "The ANCA-WR Education Committee was pleased to host […]
Turkey and Hungary should be suspended from NATO
by Tom Rogan, National Security Writer & Online Editor Washington examiner In order to be credible, a defensive military alliance requires the common confidence of its members that, should one member be attacked, other members will provide it with decisive support. Whatever other interests they may have with the United States and its NATO allies, it is now […]
Hiring in Armenia must have a low IQ as of the PM The new candidate for the position of ombudsman was a clothing store manager
Yesterday, Human Rights Defender Kristine Grigoryan submitted her resignation to the National Assembly, and without waiting for the one week prescribed by law to expire in order to reaffirm her application, she hastily left the HRD office. Yesterday we received news that he left Armenia. Before that, saying goodbye to the HRD staff, she announced […]
Russian tennis star Khachanov defends Nagorno-Karabakh messages
The pro-Armenian sentiment expressed during the Australian Open sparked a complaint from Azerbaijan tennis officials. Karen Khachanov has defended himself after his support at the Australian Open for the contested Armenian enclave Nagorno-Karabakh sparked a strongly worded complaint from Azerbaijan tennis officials. The Russian, who has Armenian roots, wrote a message on a television camera […]
2 dead, and 2 were injured in a fire in the Armenian church in İstanbul
Two people died and two were injured in a fire that broke out in the Surp Pırgiç Armenian Catholic Church in İstanbul, the Demirören news agency (DHA) reported on Tuesday. According to DHA, the fire broke out late on Monday in the residential quarters of the 190-year-old church in the Kadıköy district and it was […]
Armenia: Street Activists In a short time, they managed to get rich and accumulate serious wealth, robbery in Progress
168.am writes: Today's state officials, when they first came to power, declared that the results of economic growth should be distributed equally among all groups of society. From January 1, the salary of the president of the republic will increase by 341 thousand drams, that of the prime minister – by 324 thousand, and the […]
Azeris Shoot Themselves in the Foot By Blocking the Lachin Corridor #ArtsakhDefiant
By Harut Sassounian 120,000 Armenians in Artsakh are trying to survive in sub-zero temperatures without heat, food and medicines due to the blockade of the Lachin Corridor by Azeri eco-terrorists who are masquerading as environmentalists. However, Azerbaijan is not going to get away with its grave human rights violations without paying a steep price. Azerbaijan […]
Azerbaijani Strongman's Business Partner Builds Property Empire in Georgia "Azerbaijan's North Korea"
Turkish businessman Emin Uchar has made a fortune in Nakhchivan, an autonomous Azerbaijani territory between Iran, Turkey, and Armenia. New documents and interviews provide evidence he may have acted as a proxy for the family of autocrat Vasif Talibov, who ruled Nakhchivan for 27 years before resigning on December 21. Across the street from the […]
Secretary Blinken's Call with Azerbaijani President Aliyev, Spokesperson Ned Price:
The following is attributable to Spokesperson Ned Price: Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken spoke today with Azerbaijan's President Ilham Aliyev to urge an immediate reopening of the Lachin corridor to commercial traffic. He underscored that the risk of a humanitarian crisis in the Lachin corridor undermined prospects for peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan. The […]
We believe that we have the right to independence. Ruben Vardanyan's interview with BBC's Hard Talk
Artsakh Republic State Minister Ruben Vardanyan gave an interview to BBC's Hard Talk program. The video can be downloaded here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WEIH6OYAyhg The interview is translated below. Steven Sakur – Mr. Vardanyan, maybe our HardTalk audience doesn't know much about Nagorno Karabakh, but you are the Minister of State for a small area with a population […]
The Pashinyan oligarch of the heart of the government arrived at the National Assembly
Hraparak: A little while ago, the oligarch of the government, Narek Nalbandian, arrived at the parliament, our journalist met him at the entrance of the parliament, the businessman was escorted to the NA building by a group of security guards, and the SUVs bringing him to the NA stopped him on the second lane, violating […]
Under the leadership of Aliyev the Azerbaijanis want to erase the Armenian people – Le Figaro's Jean-Christophe Buisson
YEREVAN, JANUARY 10, ARMENPRESS. Under the leadership of Aliyev the Azerbaijanis want to erase the Armenian people, their faith, and their identity, the Deputy Director of the French Le Figaro newspaper Jean-Christophe Buisson said. "The Azerbaijanis don't respect the living or dead, yesterday in Nakhijevan, today in Artsakh, tomorrow in Armenia," Jean-Christophe Buisson tweeted. "Under […]
What life is like in Artsakh amid blackouts
Azerbaijan has been keeping the Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) Armenians under siege since December 12.A coupon system has been unveiled in the country to ration basic foodstuffs. People are facing shortages of medicine. The Artsakh authorities have announced rolling blackouts because of damage to the power line bringing electricity from Armenia through Azerbaijani-held territory. Azerbaijan has partly […]
All the steps of Pashinyan and his team should be considered in the context of the Turkification of Armenia
Many people are angry and wonder how someone like Gurgen Arsenyan can appear in the Armenian parliament and make open Turkish propaganda, convince Armenians that the Turks are not the enemies of the Armenians, they have never been a threat to us, when just a few months ago the Turkish attack More than 200 Armenian […]
Escalation is to be expected: Iskandaryan assesses the likelihood of a new Armenian-Azerbaijani war
Some kind of escalation is to be expected, but there will not be a large-scale war yet, Alexander Iskandaryan, director of the Caucasus Institute, told NEWS.am on the program the Power Factor. He connected it with the fact that Russian peacekeepers are deployed around Nagorno-Karabakh. "If Azerbaijan starts a large-scale war, it will be necessary […]
Sergey Markedonov: Baku pushes back the red lines
The blocking of the Lachin corridor can be seen in the context of the new status quo, which was established in November 2020 as a result of the second Karabakh war, as well as in the context of last year's events, Sergey Markedonov, a leading researcher at the Center for Euro-Atlantic Security at the Moscow […]
Aliyev complains about India's weapon sales to Armenia being an "unfriendly" action
Azerbaijan President Ilham Aliyev has complained about India's weapon sales to Armenia being an "unfriendly move" as they have "only one target, Azerbaijan." "If we are facing a serious threat, we will deal with that threat immediately, regardless of where that threat arises, within our territory or outside our borders. It is our legitimate right […]
Mirzoyan and Pashinyan help Aliyev to make the enslavement of Artsakh look legal
Avetis Babajanyan A few days ago, Ararat Mirzoyan had a telephone conversation with UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres and emphasized the importance of sending a UN fact-finding mission to the Lachin Corridor. Mirzoyan's superior, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, is constantly talking about sending a fact-finding mission of the ILO, OSCE or other international structures to the […]
Soros paid 131 million dollars to the leading media to cover the events "in his own way". MRC Business:
For years, the American billionaire George Soros has paid large sums of money to representatives of prestigious and leading American media to cover and present the international transition and geopolitical developments in his convenient way. Fox News informs about it with reference to the research of MRC Business organization. According to the information, Soros' money […]
Under Pashinyan Dictatorship: Medicine Deficit in Armenia: What does the head of the pharmaceutical company offer?
The shortage of some types of medications, for example, a number of antibiotics, including children's syrups, is indeed observed in the medication market in Armenia, Director General of Eskulap Pharmaceutical Company Gagik Grigoryan told NEWS.am Medicine. According to him, the reason is that large international drug producing companies leave the Armenian market, as they are […]
UN High Commissioner calls for immediate free movement through the Lachin corridor
UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk calls for immediate and complete free and safe movement through the Lachin corridor. According to him, unrestricted access to food, medicine and other basic goods and services is essential for the human rights of the affected population. 0 0