A Blog by Jonathan Low
Overtourism and the Role of Tech
This is probably more about affluence and population growth. But technology, as always, makes a convenient scapegoat - especially in Europe. JL
Farhad Manjoo reports in the New York Times:
In 1960, when the jet age began, around 25 million international trips were taken. Last year, the number was 1.3 billion.As for the cities that are the major destinations? They are "the same size they were back in 1959, and they'll probably stay that way,"
Over the summer, my wife and I traveled with our two young kids on a two-week vacation through Europe.
It wasn't as highfalutin as it sounds. In London, our Airbnb had ample skylights — which rendered the place all but uninhabitable during Europe's heat wave. In Paris, our charming home-share had a cavernous hole in the ceiling of the entryway, revealing load-bearing beams that appeared to have been rotting since Napoleon's reign. And in Amsterdam, our Airbnb advertised a kids' bedroom stocked with toys — but failed to mention the mosquitoes and mice.
I'm not complaining. If travel mishaps are the stuff of memory, my vacation was unforgettable. And without home-sharing services like Airbnb, review sites like TripAdvisor and conveniences like Uber, OpenTable and Expedia, the trip would have been far more expensive, less accessible and, in a strange way, less authentic.
But my tech-abetted trip was illuminating, too, because it provided a firsthand look into a vexing problem that has gripped much of Europe lately — the worry of "overtourism," and the rising chorus that blames technologies like Airbnb, Uber and other internet-enabled travel conveniences for the menace.
Every summer, the most popular European destinations get stuffed to the gills with tourists, who outnumber locals by many multiples, turning hot spots into sweaty, selfie-stick-clogged, "Disneyfied" towns. They offer a taste of a growing global threat: Across the world, thanks in part to rising affluence, travel is becoming a more widely shared pastime. International trips were up 6 percent in the first half of the year, surpassing experts' forecasts, according to the United Nations' World Tourism Organization.
This growth might once have been considered unambiguously good news. But the world's most popular destinations cannot expand to accommodate an infinite flood of visitors. Advocates of curbing tourism say too many visitors are altering the character of historic cities, and making travel terrible, too.
"It's a level of tourism which is degrading the enjoyment that residents have, but it's also degrading the tourist experience, because the tourist who is endlessly queuing behind backpacks of hundreds of other tourists is not discovering the real or the authentic place," said Justin Francis, the chief executive of Responsible Travel, a company that arranges "sustainable" travel for customers.
What's to blame? In addition to broad prosperity, there's technology, defined very broadly.
Over the last few decades, innovations in aviation — wider, more efficient jets and the rise of low-cost airlines — significantly reduced the cost of flying. Bigger cruise ships capable of holding many thousands of passengers now take entire floating cities to coastal ports (which is why Venice recently banned these). Then there are the many splendors enabled by the internet, among them online booking, local reviews, smartphone mapping, and ride-hailing and home-sharing, which have collectively democratized pretty much every step involved in travel.
Finally, as in almost every other issue these days, there is the influence of social media.
"You can't talk about overtourism without mentioning Instagram and Facebook — I think they're big drivers of this trend," Mr. Francis said. "Seventy-five years ago, tourism was about experience seeking. Now it's about using photography and social media to build a personal brand. In a sense, for a lot of people, the photos you take on a trip become more important than the experience."
That so many different forces play into overtourism highlights the difficulties of doing much about it. Managing a tourist destination is something like managing a natural resource, like a mine or a fishery; a sustainable level of tourists brings widespread gains to the local economy, but too many ruin it for everyone. Cities that are looking to tame the number of tourists must manage a delicate balance — to gently discourage some forms of travel without appearing unwelcoming to others.
That brings us to the hand-wringing over Airbnb, which has been singled out by lawmakers across Europe as a primary driver of overtourism. In Amsterdam, the authorities are pushing to slash the number of nights that residents can rent their homes to 30 from 60. Several other cities, including London and Barcelona, Spain, have also instituted stringent home-sharing rules.
The measures reflect Airbnb's jaw-dropping growth. In just a few years, the company has become a significant force in the tourism economies of many cities. In Amsterdam, according to the company, Airbnb accounted for 12 percent of all overnight bookings in 2017. In Barcelona, Airbnb had an 18 percent market share. And in Kyoto, Japan, it was 22 percent.
But Airbnb — which, like Uber, is a veteran of combating regulatory pushback across the globe — disputes being a cause of overtourism and argues that in many ways it can be a solution. In the company's report on "healthy tourism" this year, it presented a blizzard of geographic and economic data to show that the service is producing a more "authentic" travel experience.
Airbnb said that because it offered lodging across a city — rather than only in the tourist hot spots where hotels typically congregate — it could distribute crowds more evenly.
In an interview, Chris Lehane, Airbnb's vice president for public affairs, also argued that the site benefited local economies more directly than hotels did.
"Our local hosts make 97 percent of the money that they list their homes for," Mr. Lehane said. "Our guests stay longer than a typical hotel guest, and they're spreading the economic gains across a whole community in a way that doesn't happen with hotels." He said that while there was some friction with cities over the company's huge growth, he had seen signs of a more recent thaw.
"Amsterdam is an outlier right now," he said. "For the most part, we are generally in the ballpark in our discussions with cities."
Mr. Lehane pointed to Barcelona, where Airbnb's negotiations with the authorities over what sort of rules make sense for home-sharing broke down acrimoniously last summer. Since then, the two sides have mended their relationship. Airbnb agreed to remove thousands of listings that violated the city's rules, as well as to set up a system to collect taxes and help hosts comply with regulations.
These challenges are unlikely to remain fixed for long, because the technology that exacerbates it is always changing. One recent problem is the rise of a more professional class of home-sharers — people who buy up properties to rent out full time on home-sharing sites, often in violation of local rules.
Airbnb said it tries to crack down on rule-breaking hosts, but even some of its nominal allies wonder how diligently.
"The issue for Airbnb, and I've said this to them, is that there are listings that are not home-sharing — the people who buy up multiple flats and list them all, which really changes the character of a city," said Jonathan Tourtellot, the founder of the Sustainable Stewardship Center, a nonprofit group that promotes sustainable tourism. Airbnb commissioned Mr. Tourtellot to write the foreword of its report.
Another issue is that Airbnb has faced more competition from newer home-sharing services — and the authorities have had trouble policing some of its competitors.
The more general problem is nonstop growth everywhere.
"At the end, this story is just a numbers problem," Mr. Tourtellot said. He noted that in 1960, when the jet age began, around 25 million international trips were taken. Last year, the number was 1.3 billion.
As for the cities that are the major destinations? They are "the same size they were back in 1959, and they'll probably stay that way," he said.
Save And Share :
As a Partner and Co-Founder of Predictiv and PredictivAsia, Jon specializes in management performance and organizational effectiveness for both domestic and international clients. He is an editor and author whose works include Invisible Advantage: How Intangilbles are Driving Business Performance.
jon@thelowdownblog.com
Blog Archive January 17 - January 24 (17) January 10 - January 17 (35) January 3 - January 10 (42) December 27 - January 3 (33) December 20 - December 27 (25) December 13 - December 20 (42) December 6 - December 13 (41) November 29 - December 6 (42) November 22 - November 29 (41) November 15 - November 22 (42) November 8 - November 15 (42) November 1 - November 8 (41) October 25 - November 1 (42) October 18 - October 25 (42) October 11 - October 18 (38) October 4 - October 11 (42) September 27 - October 4 (42) September 20 - September 27 (42) September 13 - September 20 (42) September 6 - September 13 (43) August 30 - September 6 (42) August 23 - August 30 (42) August 16 - August 23 (41) August 9 - August 16 (42) August 2 - August 9 (42) July 26 - August 2 (42) July 19 - July 26 (42) July 12 - July 19 (41) July 5 - July 12 (40) June 28 - July 5 (45) June 21 - June 28 (46) June 14 - June 21 (44) June 7 - June 14 (43) May 31 - June 7 (49) May 24 - May 31 (42) May 17 - May 24 (45) May 10 - May 17 (46) May 3 - May 10 (49) April 26 - May 3 (44) April 19 - April 26 (45) April 12 - April 19 (42) April 5 - April 12 (48) March 29 - April 5 (48) March 22 - March 29 (47) March 15 - March 22 (47) March 8 - March 15 (40) March 1 - March 8 (41) February 23 - March 1 (41) February 16 - February 23 (43) February 9 - February 16 (44) February 2 - February 9 (42) January 26 - February 2 (47) January 19 - January 26 (49) January 12 - January 19 (46) January 5 - January 12 (33) December 29 - January 5 (47) December 22 - December 29 (47) December 15 - December 22 (42) December 8 - December 15 (45) December 1 - December 8 (48) November 24 - December 1 (39) November 17 - November 24 (44) November 10 - November 17 (44) November 3 - November 10 (48) October 27 - November 3 (48) October 20 - October 27 (46) October 13 - October 20 (42) October 6 - October 13 (45) September 29 - October 6 (45) September 22 - September 29 (40) September 15 - September 22 (45) September 8 - September 15 (46) September 1 - September 8 (45) August 25 - September 1 (47) August 18 - August 25 (45) August 11 - August 18 (38) August 4 - August 11 (32) July 28 - August 4 (48) July 21 - July 28 (41) July 14 - July 21 (38) July 7 - July 14 (43) June 30 - July 7 (37) June 23 - June 30 (44) June 16 - June 23 (46) June 9 - June 16 (46) June 2 - June 9 (20) May 26 - June 2 (12) May 19 - May 26 (34) May 12 - May 19 (42) May 5 - May 12 (47) April 28 - May 5 (40) April 21 - April 28 (48) April 14 - April 21 (44) April 7 - April 14 (43) March 31 - April 7 (44) March 24 - March 31 (44) March 17 - March 24 (44) March 10 - March 17 (43) March 3 - March 10 (43) February 24 - March 3 (42) February 17 - February 24 (42) February 10 - February 17 (43) February 3 - February 10 (44) January 27 - February 3 (42) January 20 - January 27 (44) January 13 - January 20 (38) January 6 - January 13 (30) December 30 - January 6 (42) December 23 - December 30 (43) December 16 - December 23 (42) December 9 - December 16 (42) December 2 - December 9 (42) November 25 - December 2 (42) November 18 - November 25 (42) November 11 - November 18 (43) November 4 - November 11 (42) October 28 - November 4 (43) October 21 - October 28 (42) October 14 - October 21 (43) October 7 - October 14 (42) September 30 - October 7 (42) September 23 - September 30 (42) September 16 - September 23 (42) September 9 - September 16 (38) September 2 - September 9 (30) August 26 - September 2 (38) August 19 - August 26 (38) August 12 - August 19 (45) August 5 - August 12 (42) July 29 - August 5 (43) July 22 - July 29 (36) July 15 - July 22 (33) July 8 - July 15 (42) July 1 - July 8 (25) June 24 - July 1 (41) June 17 - June 24 (40) June 10 - June 17 (42) June 3 - June 10 (42) May 27 - June 3 (41) May 20 - May 27 (40) May 13 - May 20 (42) May 6 - May 13 (42) April 29 - May 6 (42) April 22 - April 29 (42) April 15 - April 22 (42) April 8 - April 15 (42) April 1 - April 8 (42) March 25 - April 1 (42) March 18 - March 25 (42) March 11 - March 18 (42) March 4 - March 11 (42) February 25 - March 4 (42) February 18 - February 25 (33) February 11 - February 18 (42) February 4 - February 11 (41) January 28 - February 4 (42) January 21 - January 28 (42) January 14 - January 21 (42) January 7 - January 14 (42) December 31 - January 7 (42) December 24 - December 31 (41) December 17 - December 24 (40) December 10 - December 17 (42) December 3 - December 10 (42) November 26 - December 3 (41) November 19 - November 26 (34) November 12 - November 19 (42) November 5 - November 12 (42) October 29 - November 5 (41) October 22 - October 29 (38) October 15 - October 22 (41) October 8 - October 15 (42) October 1 - October 8 (41) September 24 - October 1 (40) September 17 - September 24 (38) September 10 - September 17 (20) September 3 - September 10 (40) August 27 - September 3 (30) August 20 - August 27 (42) August 13 - August 20 (42) August 6 - August 13 (36) July 30 - August 6 (36) July 23 - July 30 (42) July 16 - July 23 (42) July 9 - July 16 (42) July 2 - July 9 (42) June 25 - July 2 (42) June 18 - June 25 (37) June 11 - June 18 (41) June 4 - June 11 (42) May 28 - June 4 (42) May 21 - May 28 (42) May 14 - May 21 (42) May 7 - May 14 (42) April 30 - May 7 (42) April 23 - April 30 (42) April 16 - April 23 (41) April 9 - April 16 (41) April 2 - April 9 (42) March 26 - April 2 (43) March 19 - March 26 (43) March 12 - March 19 (42) March 5 - March 12 (42) February 26 - March 5 (42) February 19 - February 26 (42) February 12 - February 19 (39) February 5 - February 12 (43) January 29 - February 5 (43) January 22 - January 29 (42) January 15 - January 22 (42) January 8 - January 15 (42) January 1 - January 8 (32) December 25 - January 1 (23) December 18 - December 25 (42) December 11 - December 18 (42) December 4 - December 11 (42) November 27 - December 4 (42) November 20 - November 27 (42) November 13 - November 20 (42) November 6 - November 13 (44) October 30 - November 6 (43) October 23 - October 30 (36) October 16 - October 23 (42) October 9 - October 16 (43) October 2 - October 9 (43) September 25 - October 2 (43) September 18 - September 25 (42) September 11 - September 18 (41) September 4 - September 11 (35) August 28 - September 4 (16) August 21 - August 28 (36) August 14 - August 21 (42) August 7 - August 14 (42) July 31 - August 7 (42) July 24 - July 31 (43) July 17 - July 24 (40) July 10 - July 17 (42) July 3 - July 10 (44) June 26 - July 3 (44) June 19 - June 26 (44) June 12 - June 19 (44) June 5 - June 12 (42) May 29 - June 5 (44) May 22 - May 29 (50) May 15 - May 22 (43) May 8 - May 15 (46) May 1 - May 8 (42) April 24 - May 1 (43) April 17 - April 24 (41) April 10 - April 17 (43) April 3 - April 10 (46) March 27 - April 3 (44) March 20 - March 27 (43) March 13 - March 20 (7) March 6 - March 13 (38) February 28 - March 6 (43) February 21 - February 28 (45) February 14 - February 21 (42) February 7 - February 14 (42) January 31 - February 7 (42) January 24 - January 31 (42) January 17 - January 24 (42) January 10 - January 17 (42) January 3 - January 10 (43) December 27 - January 3 (43) December 20 - December 27 (40) December 13 - December 20 (42) December 6 - December 13 (42) November 29 - December 6 (43) November 22 - November 29 (38) November 15 - November 22 (39) November 8 - November 15 (40) November 1 - November 8 (38) October 25 - November 1 (39) October 18 - October 25 (35) October 11 - October 18 (35) October 4 - October 11 (33) September 27 - October 4 (31) September 20 - September 27 (38) September 13 - September 20 (40) September 6 - September 13 (39) August 30 - September 6 (32) August 23 - August 30 (24) August 16 - August 23 (30) August 9 - August 16 (27) August 2 - August 9 (23) July 26 - August 2 (41) July 19 - July 26 (42) July 12 - July 19 (42) July 5 - July 12 (44) June 28 - July 5 (41) June 21 - June 28 (42) June 14 - June 21 (37) June 7 - June 14 (42) May 31 - June 7 (43) May 24 - May 31 (44) May 17 - May 24 (43) May 10 - May 17 (42) May 3 - May 10 (42) April 26 - May 3 (39) April 19 - April 26 (39) April 12 - April 19 (42) April 5 - April 12 (40) March 29 - April 5 (41) March 22 - March 29 (42) March 15 - March 22 (41) March 8 - March 15 (40) March 1 - March 8 (37) February 22 - March 1 (31) February 15 - February 22 (35) February 8 - February 15 (34) February 1 - February 8 (32) January 25 - February 1 (30) January 18 - January 25 (33) January 11 - January 18 (30) January 4 - January 11 (31) December 28 - January 4 (26) December 21 - December 28 (24) December 14 - December 21 (29) December 7 - December 14 (26) November 30 - December 7 (30) November 23 - November 30 (31) November 16 - November 23 (28) November 9 - November 16 (30) November 2 - November 9 (26) October 26 - November 2 (19) October 19 - October 26 (20) October 12 - October 19 (21) October 5 - October 12 (21) September 28 - October 5 (21) September 21 - September 28 (23) September 14 - September 21 (22) September 7 - September 14 (21) August 31 - September 7 (18) August 24 - August 31 (21) August 17 - August 24 (21) August 10 - August 17 (21) August 3 - August 10 (21) July 27 - August 3 (21) July 20 - July 27 (21) July 13 - July 20 (21) July 6 - July 13 (22) June 29 - July 6 (23) June 22 - June 29 (22) June 15 - June 22 (21) June 8 - June 15 (21) June 1 - June 8 (21) May 25 - June 1 (21) May 18 - May 25 (21) May 11 - May 18 (21) May 4 - May 11 (21) April 27 - May 4 (19) April 20 - April 27 (21) April 13 - April 20 (20) April 6 - April 13 (21) March 30 - April 6 (21) March 23 - March 30 (21) March 16 - March 23 (21) March 9 - March 16 (21) March 2 - March 9 (21) February 23 - March 2 (20) February 16 - February 23 (20) February 9 - February 16 (22) February 2 - February 9 (21) January 26 - February 2 (21) January 19 - January 26 (21) January 12 - January 19 (20) January 5 - January 12 (21) December 29 - January 5 (21) December 22 - December 29 (18) December 15 - December 22 (21) December 8 - December 15 (21) December 1 - December 8 (21) November 24 - December 1 (21) November 17 - November 24 (21) November 10 - November 17 (21) November 3 - November 10 (20) October 27 - November 3 (21) October 20 - October 27 (21) October 13 - October 20 (21) October 6 - October 13 (21) September 29 - October 6 (21) September 22 - September 29 (21) September 15 - September 22 (21) September 8 - September 15 (21) September 1 - September 8 (21) August 25 - September 1 (21) August 18 - August 25 (21) August 11 - August 18 (21) August 4 - August 11 (21) July 28 - August 4 (19) July 21 - July 28 (21) July 14 - July 21 (19) July 7 - July 14 (19) June 30 - July 7 (21) June 23 - June 30 (21) June 16 - June 23 (21) June 9 - June 16 (21) June 2 - June 9 (18) May 26 - June 2 (21) May 19 - May 26 (21) May 12 - May 19 (21) May 5 - May 12 (21) April 28 - May 5 (21) April 21 - April 28 (21) April 14 - April 21 (21) April 7 - April 14 (21) March 31 - April 7 (15) March 24 - March 31 (21) March 17 - March 24 (21) March 10 - March 17 (21) March 3 - March 10 (21) February 24 - March 3 (21) February 17 - February 24 (20) February 10 - February 17 (20) February 3 - February 10 (21) January 27 - February 3 (21) January 20 - January 27 (21) January 13 - January 20 (21) January 6 - January 13 (18) December 30 - January 6 (16) December 23 - December 30 (13) December 16 - December 23 (21) December 9 - December 16 (21) December 2 - December 9 (21) November 25 - December 2 (21) November 18 - November 25 (21) November 11 - November 18 (21) November 4 - November 11 (20) October 28 - November 4 (21) October 21 - October 28 (20) October 14 - October 21 (20) October 7 - October 14 (22) September 30 - October 7 (17) September 23 - September 30 (21) September 16 - September 23 (21) September 9 - September 16 (21) September 2 - September 9 (21) August 26 - September 2 (21) August 19 - August 26 (21) August 12 - August 19 (8) August 5 - August 12 (21) July 29 - August 5 (21) July 22 - July 29 (17) July 15 - July 22 (18) July 8 - July 15 (19) July 1 - July 8 (22) June 24 - July 1 (22) June 17 - June 24 (20) June 10 - June 17 (21) June 3 - June 10 (23) May 27 - June 3 (22) May 20 - May 27 (20) May 13 - May 20 (22) May 6 - May 13 (22) April 29 - May 6 (22) April 22 - April 29 (21) April 15 - April 22 (23) April 8 - April 15 (21) April 1 - April 8 (20) March 25 - April 1 (21) March 18 - March 25 (20) March 11 - March 18 (21) March 4 - March 11 (19) February 26 - March 4 (20) February 19 - February 26 (17) February 12 - February 19 (21) February 5 - February 12 (20) January 29 - February 5 (21) January 22 - January 29 (19) January 15 - January 22 (15) January 8 - January 15 (15) January 1 - January 8 (17) December 25 - January 1 (15) December 18 - December 25 (18) December 11 - December 18 (21) December 4 - December 11 (20) November 27 - December 4 (18) November 20 - November 27 (20) November 13 - November 20 (18) November 6 - November 13 (17) October 30 - November 6 (21) October 23 - October 30 (25) October 16 - October 23 (22) October 9 - October 16 (25) October 2 - October 9 (24) September 25 - October 2 (23) September 18 - September 25 (27) September 11 - September 18 (23) September 4 - September 11 (30) August 28 - September 4 (29) August 21 - August 28 (28) August 14 - August 21 (19) August 7 - August 14 (23) July 31 - August 7 (21) July 24 - July 31 (25) July 17 - July 24 (28) July 10 - July 17 (34) July 3 - July 10 (27) June 26 - July 3 (35) June 19 - June 26 (31) June 12 - June 19 (36) June 5 - June 12 (29) May 29 - June 5 (40) May 22 - May 29 (38) May 15 - May 22 (55) May 8 - May 15 (60) May 1 - May 8 (83) April 24 - May 1 (58) April 17 - April 24 (65) April 10 - April 17 (78) April 3 - April 10 (87) March 27 - April 3 (61) March 20 - March 27 (81) March 13 - March 20 (73) March 6 - March 13 (74) February 27 - March 6 (66) February 20 - February 27 (37) February 13 - February 20 (43) February 6 - February 13 (55) January 30 - February 6 (51) January 23 - January 30 (46) January 16 - January 23 (18) January 9 - January 16 (6) January 2 - January 9 (3)
Select a label Advertising (677) Asia (263) Brand (620) BRICs (49) China (321) Communications (431) Competition (629) Culture (838) Customer (515) Demographics (455) Disclosure/Governance (519) E-Commerce (308) Economics (1041) Education (311) Emotion (437) Energy (187) Entertainment (321) Environment/Sustainability (282) Ethics (569) Finance (483) Global (517) Government (562) Innovation (548) Intellectual Property/Capital (390) Jobs/Pay (646) Knowledge (709) Leadership (468) Legal (371) Management (484) Markets/Marketing (934) Measurement (658) Media (186) Military (152) Mobile (389) Networks (407) Politics (403) Quality (246) re (1) Regulation (320) Reputation (888) Science (475) Social Media (506) Strategy (815) Talent (535) Technology (919) Television (124) Trends (564) Venture Capital (89)
» Advertising Age
» Digital Tonto
» Intangible Asset Finance Society
» GigaOm
» Intellectual Capital Knowledge Center
» Center for Research in Intellectual Capital
» Intellectual Assets Centre
» New Club of Paris (IC)
» Erik Brynjolfsson
» Fast Company
» Thierry de Baillon
» Value Networks (Verna Allee)
» The Economist
» Gathering 2.0 Networks (Sharon Oriel)
» National Public Radio
» RGSquared Org design (Wendi Bukowitz)
» Slate magazine
» Mashable
» The Reputation Institute
» ReputationXchange (Leslie Gaines-Ross' blog)
» United Nations Environmental Progress Finance Initiative
» Brand Channel
» Intellectual Capital Standards-Europe
» Jonathan Baskin's Brand Identity Website
» Ken Jarboe's Blog on Intangibles Issues
» The Athena Alliance (I-cubed economy)
» Convelop (Karin Grasenick)
» Studio Panzarani (Roberto Panzarani)
» McBassi & Company Human Capital (Laurie Bassi)
» The Big Picture (financial markets)
» Beyond the Deal M&A (Jay Chatzkel)
» Dan Pink (workplace and working innovation)
» Naked Capitalism
Copyright © Jonathan Low / Back to top of Home / About Site by Deïaneira Design