Media -- Dont Quote Me | News Features | Talking Politics | This Just In
Bozzio appeals jail sentence, goes on tour
See all in This Just In
Boston's $10 Million Boo-Boos
Righting a wrongful conviction
By DAVID S. BERNSTEIN | July 1, 2009
The bill continues to come due for the string of nine wrongful convictions discovered in Boston between 1999 and 2004 — a tab that has now topped $10 million in court settlements.
The Boston Phoenix has learned that the city of Boston paid $3.8 million in December to settle a civil lawsuit brought by Anthony Powell, who spent more than 12 years in prison for a rape and kidnapping he did not commit. This is the third, and largest, settlement so far from these cases: the city previously paid $3.2 million each to Neil Miller and Stephan Cowans.
Powell was convicted in 1992 of attacking a woman at knifepoint in Roxbury. He was released in 2004, after DNA testing proved his innocence. The December settlement is in addition to $500,000 awarded to Powell under the state's wrongful-conviction compensation law.
Criminal Trials
Several other wrongful-conviction suits against the city are still pending, including those of Ulysses Rodriguez Charles, Laurence Adams, and Angel Toro. Shawn Drumgold, perhaps the best-known of the cases, is nearing trial in the second phase of his complicated action against the city and several individual officers. In another case, the city prevailed when a jury ruled that police did not violate the civil rights of Donnell Johnson.
Powell and his attorneys declined to discuss the settlement with the Phoenix, which discovered the settlement amount through a public-information request. The city's corporate counsel, William Sinnott, cited a confidentiality agreement, but said that, "In general terms, we've got a universe of cases we've been dealing with over the past couple of years, and we try to deal with them fairly." He added that the city feels that it has an added obligation in cases like Powell's, where "actual innocence" has been determined through DNA testing.
In court documents and previous interviews, Powell's attorneys have claimed that Boston police officers committed a series of sins in their rush to pin the crime on him: they pressured the victim into identifying Powell, even though he did not match her description; they ignored hairs that they knew did not match Powell's; and they failed to check other evidence.
With the city choosing to settle before trial, the question of whether this was a case of alleged negligence or worse will remain a matter of dispute. As in the other wrongful-conviction cases, the city and the Boston Police Department have not admitted to any wrongdoing. But perhaps the most troubling aspect of Powell's conviction was who didn't get caught.
Even before Powell's conviction, there was reason to suspect that two other attacks — including one that took place after Powell had been jailed — were committed by the same rapist. That could have been confirmed through DNA testing, which was not conducted. After Powell's exoneration, the link between those rapes was confirmed, as was a fourth, committed in 1999.
Last year — just a few months before the city settled Powell's lawsuit — Suffolk County prosecutors charged one Jerry Dixon with the rapes, based on a DNA match. The pursuit of Powell, despite evidence of his innocence, may have prevented police from getting Dixon off the streets earlier, some local observers contend.
Stephen Hrones, the attorney who helped free Powell, adds that the case holds another lesson: the need for a state law governing post-conviction DNA testing .
A controversial Supreme Court ruling earlier this month leaves it to states to decide whether to provide convicted individuals access to DNA evidence when attempting to prove their innocence. Massachusetts is one of only three states with no law giving the convicted such automatic access — which leaves the decision in the hands of the district attorney's office.
In Powell's case, the Suffolk County DA agreed to turn over the evidence, but in other Massachusetts instances, that has not been the case.
Related: Patriots daze, Boston's Best City Life 2009, Boston's Best Food and Drink 2009, More
Patriots daze
The ugly legacy of the late-'80s Pats gets even uglier
Boston's Best City Life 2009
Rocking in the cradle of eccentricity
Boston's Best Food and Drink 2009
Keeping it all back home
Boston's Best Arts and Entertainment 2009
What a difference 100 years makes
Black History Month lands on City Hall
Panther Party
Can Sam Yoon win?
An Obama-loving city counselor aims to be mayor of Boston
Speak no evil?
Why tightening up on anti-Obama speech is a bad idea
The Earth moves
The Life of Galileo ; Spring Awakening ; Picasso at the Lapin Agile
Mary Gaitskill carries on
Dictator McCain?
Don't laugh: if the Arizona 'maverick' is elected, he'll complete the job Bush started
Topics: This Just In , Criminal Trials, Trials, Boston Police Department, More , Criminal Trials, Trials, Boston Police Department, Neil Miller, wrongful conviction, Stephen Hrones, Supreme Court, Anthony Powell, Anthony Powell, rape, Less
Re: Boston's $10 Million Boo-Boos
Bernstein says that "In Powell's case, the Suffolk County DA agreed to turn over the evidence," as if, in other cases, the Suffolk County DA has not. In fact, as Bernstein knows very well, it was District Attorney Conley who made it a policy not to oppose post-conviction DNA testing for relevant evidence. Stephen Hrones knows this as well and has lauded the policy for what it is -- an affirmative, permanent, and uniformly-applied protocol with the specific intent of reducing the likelihood of a wrongful conviction to the smallest degree possible in a human endeavor like the criminal justice system.
By jakewark on 07/01/2009 at 5:12:39
No, Jake, that's not the implication of Bernstein's statement, as it is immediately followed by "in other Massachusetts incidents [as opposed to Suffolk county/Boston incidents], that has not been the case." And it's lovely that Conley has such a just policy- but there should be legal requirements and safeguards for this kind of thing, so they are not to be decided at the whim of a particular DA. Conley will not be Suffolk DA forever, nor is he DA for all of Massachusetts. I take it you oppose legislative intervention and are untroubled by these types of multi-million dollar settlements?
By Farnkoff on 07/02/2009 at 9:41:44
[MUSIC] Dancing on the Charles: July 4th 2009
ARTICLES BY DAVID S. BERNSTEIN
BOSTON'S $10 MILLION BOO-BOOS | July 01, 2009
MASSHOLES | June 17, 2009
A timeline of modern-day state house corruption
MASS BETRAYAL | June 19, 2009
How House progressives have let you down — and why they'll do it again
FEMALE TROUBLE | June 03, 2009
A shocking dearth of Republican female pols should have the party in a panic. So why doesn't it care?
ROAST PORK | May 27, 2009
As our state's bumbling, craven, and inept elected officials stumble toward summer, we get a few good laughs out of their promises for reform
See all articles by: DAVID S. BERNSTEIN
THE STRAIGHT DOPE: MICHAEL JACKSON AND THE BEATLES
You think an overdubbed Beatles tune could be any weirder than a new Beatles song with John Lennon? Then again, "I Want to Hold You Hand" overdubbed by a guy with a hand on his crotch and his hair on fire would be pretty hard to top. But don't worry, it won't happen, or anyway, it won't happen as a result of Jackson owning the Beatles library.
BOSTON IN THE 70S: PART TWO
Photos of Boston in the '70s
HEAD WITH WINGS
Mark Sandman died with his boots on. Or at least the rock-and-roll equivalent of the Old West gunfighter's epitaph.
RULING THE WAVES
The Dutch emerged at the dawn of the 17th century as a pre-eminent military and commercial power on the sea. They were in the midst of throwing off Spanish rule and developing a shipping empire that would reach from the Americas to South Africa to Asia.
Al Gore , Michael Bloomberg , Christopher Dodd , Hillary Clinton , Therese Murray , Martha Coakley , Boston Red Sox , George W. Bush , Ed Davis , John Edwards (Politician)
Photos: Camera Obscura at the Somerville Theatre
Featured Articles in This Just In:
Miles for meals
Amnesty International liberates City Hall
Unveiling the new (old) Planned Parenthood