"Benevolent" Dictator Kagame?
Paul Kagame (left) has been newly re-elected President of Rwanda with 93% of the vote.
Despite that suspiciously high number, government electoral officials reported that the process functioned properly, without irregularities.
It is hard to cry foul -- except that no one else was allowed to compete.
Leading up to the election, all signs pointed to serious political repression. Opposition candidates and supporters were arrested for holding what was deemed an illegal rally. Moreover, the suspension of newspapers, the removal of a human rights researcher from the country, and the restructuring of military leadership all pointed to a regime consolidating power before the election. Some recent incidents of violence -- the attempted killing of an exiled Rwandan general, killing of the vice president of the Democratic Green Party, and the killing of a journalist -- have been attributed to Kagame's government. (Recall too the subject of a recent guest post, the arrest and detention of a U.S. attorney who was helping a would-be Kagame electoral opponent.)
Yesterday, in an interview with National Public Radio, Kagame denied allegations of impropriety. The interview was a troubling window into Kagame's administration, one in which nearly anything can be done with impunity, a lesson that U.N. Human Rights Committee member Ruth Wedgood, in an EJIL Talk! commentary posted on Sunday, has argued was learned as a result of
the West's failure to address Tutsi violations of the laws of war.
Responding in the NPR interview to criticism over the lack of opposition participation in the election, Kagame implied that there had been no opposition at all, or perhaps that the participation of Rwandan citizens in the electoral process did away with the need for organized political opposition. He said:
Well we've had a lot of criticisms indeed, most of which is just very unfair and have no basis. What we've done wouldn't have been successful if there had not been participation of Rwandans.
Kagame also diminished the responsibility of a ruling party to allow for opposition:
If other leaders are weak or there is no track record or, this is not something that we should be held responsible for. We should be held responsible for what we are doing or what we are not doing.
Most troublingly, Kagame stated:
What Rwanda suffers most is that it's a poor country, and when a country is poor, when a country is developing, there is that tendency for it to be described as undemocratic . . . I don't accept that. We don't accept that. So our future is about unity, stability, development, prosperity for our people, good governance, and so on and so forth.
Despite Kagame's total denial of the label "undemocratic," democracy notably fails to make the list of Kagame's major goals. The rhetoric that democracy is a luxury only available to the developed world, coded in unassailable terms of anti-imperialism, does not bode well. While Kagame has presided over a transition from horrific conflict to relative stability, it begs the question at what cost.
When asked to respond to other labels sometimes ascribed to him -- such as "authoritarian leader with a vision," or "benevolent dictator" -- Kagame replied ominously:
I think this is said by few, but very loudmouthed, people.
The NPR interview doesn't provide much hope that such dissenters will have a space to voice their opinions, let alone form opposition groups, during the next Kagame term. As Wedgwood wrote, and Opinio Juris blogger Kevin Jon Heller agreed, the United States needs to reevaluate its relationship to Rwanda.
In short, the international community needs to pressure Kagame to move away from a platform of unity and towards one that emphasizes civil liberties.
by Kathleen A. Doty at 7:00 AM
Labels: democracy, elections, KAD, Kevin Jon Heller, Paul Kagame, Ruth Wedgwood, Rwanda
Diane Marie Amann said...
Great post, Kate, as recognized in Kevin Jon Heller's post today, at http://opiniojuris.org/2010/08/12/kate-gibson-on-erlinders-arrest-in-rwanda/. Kevin also takes due note of the ASIL Insight that Kate Gibson just published, reprising her earlier IntLawGrrls guest post, which you cite in your own post, on the arrest of the U.S. attorney. The Insight is at http://www.asil.org/insights100811.cfm.
Outsourcing Investigations: The ICC and Intermedia...
On August 31
Caroline postcard
ECOSOC Consultative Status at last
Pitching in for Pakistan
Look On! Hurricane Katrina Documentaries & Series
"Now is the Time:" Human Rights in the U.S. and Ka...
Gender off the agenda in Australian election after...
Look On! Suffragists
Mixed Migration in Southern Africa
Oslo Conference Results
Coral Reefs Dying From Climate Change
Guest Blogger: Betsy Baker
International law & new U.S. ocean policy
The Bombing of Claudy in 1972: Report of the Polic...
The Great Race: Mexico, Trucks & Pigs
On the Job! Bosnia internship
Not liking Lotus in Kosovo
Leviathan below Kosovo
TriskaidekaphiliCourt
Dueling Truths in Sri Lanka
Winding-down staff
3d woman on "15-man" bench
Go On: Women's Rights/Human Rights
Beets banned
Guest blogger: Mary Hansel
Domestic violence as torture
Darfur.Gitmo.dot.
Go On! State Responsibility & Intimate Violence
Climates, Crops, and Migration
New IHL web research tool
Go On! IntLawGrrls @ 4th IHL Dialogs
On the Job! RFK Fellowship
Write On! "Feminism Globally"
Wyclef for President?
Kudos to Jaya
Write On! Vulnerability & the Corporation
International Day of Indigenous People
Guest Blogger: Nancy Amoury Combs
Fact-finding Without Facts
Work On! International organizations
On August 9
Read On! Women in armed conflict
Darfur, again
Prosecutor Haag confirmed
Congratulations to Diane!
Dispatch from Oslo
All in the Family?
The Creation of International Law
Elena Kagan confirmed
Extraterritoriality in flux?
U.S. court overturns state marriage ban
Guest Blogger: Yvonne McDermott
Abuse of process & the ICC trial in Lubanga
The torture ban & cultural relativism
ASIL honorees, awardees sought
Guest Blogger: Heather Goodman
Gender Crimes and Canada's Genocide Prosecutions
Write On! IHL Yearbook
Cluster bomb ban in force
On the job! HRW researcher