Do Your Research, Featured, From Our Collections, Technical Stuff
What Happened to Fanny?
August 5, 2016 Meghan Lyon	5 Comments
I wanted to share one of the most powerful letters I've seen while working here at the Rubenstein Library: a letter from Fanny, a former slave, writing from Texas in 1867 (149 years ago today!). Here's the letter. (Click to enlarge; transcript below.)
Texana, Jackson Co., Texas, August 5th, 1867
Dear Sister,
Your kind favor of a July 3rd to hand a few days ago, it affords me such pleasure to be in a position where I can converse, if not in person through this medium. it found us all in tolerable good health and delighted to hear of [your?] being well.
I am yet so very anxious about my children that I want you to take this letter and show it to Mr Slade urgently requesting him to write to Mr J. Paul Jones (to above address.) stating all he knows in connection with the sale of my children and Mr Jones has kindly consented to write for me. He could not afford me a greater pleasure or favor and in return beg to assure him of the fervent and constant prayer of one who though humble hopes that her prayers are heard.
I hope to have a longer letter the next time for paper must be scarce in your section.
Say to Brother Slade that he is in position to require all his prayers, for he was the cause of my children being sent away, or rather my being separated, for if God can forgive him for this sin he will forgive the balance —
You forget to state anything about John Wilkins, who was your first husband. how came you to be separated or is he dead. are you a member of any church you seem so silent on that subject.
George says to send his son out here and he will go home with him next spring.
When you write to sister Lotty write the general substance of what I have written to her. I am ashamed to hear you [?] of old age. I never feel old unless after a hard day's work. I am more like a girl of sixteen than an old woman. Receive the love of one who may never see you, but constantly has you in mind. Love from all to your family.
Your sister,
Unfortunately we don't have the letter's envelope, so I don't know who Fanny's writing to. Although she addresses her sister, I can't be sure they're actual relatives. I don't know Fanny's last name. I don't know her sister's name, or where her sister lives. I'm not sure which Mr. Slade she's referring to, or where he lived (it could be North Carolina, Georgia, or somewhere else). There's a lot I don't know about the people in this letter. But, one thing is very clear: Fanny's looking for her children. The Slades sold them away, or sold her away, at some point before 1865. This letter is concrete, powerful evidence of the devastating impact slavery had on African American families, with ramifications lasting long after the the end of the Civil War.
I found this letter breathtakingly sad. I couldn't stop thinking about Fanny. Did she ever find her children? All I could know for sure was that her sister did show the letter to Mr. Slade — because now it is held in the Slade Family Papers. But, unfortunately, I found no further correspondence with Fanny or J. Paul Jones in the collection.
I decided to look for circumstantial evidence instead. I returned to the pre-war years of the Slade Family Papers to look for evidence of her existence in the plantation records. Despite being able to trace many of the slaves owned by the Slades from the 1830s through the 1860s, Fanny was a mystery. The only hint of a slave named Fanny lies in this estate inventory for Henry Slade, who died in 1838.
1838: Liley (34, dropsical, 100) Fanny (15, 500) Stephen (12, 500) Atwood (10, 450) Maranda (7, 350) Clay (5, 300) Reuben (3, 200)
The majority of the papers in the collection stem from Thomas B. Slade and William Slade, two brothers who appear to have inherited the majority of Henry Slade's estate. In 1838, Fanny was 15, and the estate inventory suggests she was unmarried and had no children. She is listed in what appears to be a family group with Liley (presumably her mother), Stephen, Atwood, Maranda, Clay, and Reuben. Fanny does not appear on William B. Slade's slave census for 1850, and is not listed on his slave inventories for 1861 or 1864. My guess is that Henry Slade's Fanny was separated from her mother and siblings shortly after 1838. I base this theory on an undated slave valuation scrap that I found tucked into William Slade's account book.
Undated scrap from William Slade's account book. It lists Liley, Reuben, and Clay — but no Fanny.
It has the same names and similar ages as the Henry Slade estate inventory, except several slaves, including Fanny, are missing. I'm guessing this scrap represents the slaves that William Slade acquired as part of the settling of Henry's estate around 1838. It's possible that Fanny, Stephen, Atwood, and Maranda moved with Thomas B. Slade down to Georgia, where he ran the Clinton Female Seminary. It appears that Liley, Clay, and Reuben were transferred to William Slade and stayed in Martin County, North Carolina. Clay and Reuben continue to show up on William Slade's accounts in the 1850s.
Since that 1838 Estate List is the only evidence of any Fanny I could find in the papers, I turned back to her 1867 letter. She lived in Texana, in Jackson County, Texas, and referenced J. Paul Jones, a literate man who was writing for her. I decided to look for a Fanny from Texana in the 1870 U.S. Census, using the library's subscription to Ancestry.com. One problem I faced was the location, Texana, which is not referenced in the 1870 Census (too small, I suppose) and is now a ghost town under the Lake Texana Reservoir. I ended up using J. Paul Jones as a reference point. By 1870, he was living in Victoria, Texas, near enough to Jackson County for me to feel confident that it was him.
He was a relatively successful landowner originally from Maryland. I then narrowed the search with a birthplace of North Carolina and a race of Black or Mulatto. And I eliminated the Fannys who were too young in 1870 to have had children before 1865.
I ended up with two possible Fannys in Texas; but, neither matched the age of the Fanny on the Henry Slade estate inventory. The first, Fanny Ward, was 26 in 1870; her estimated birth year was 1844. At the time of the census she lived with Lucas Ward (30) and George Nicholson (62) in Matagorda County, Texas, near Jackson County. The letter mentions a George, which is why this Fanny seemed like a possibility. But I'm also thinking that Fanny Ward seemed too young to be referring to herself as an old woman in her letter to her sister. The other option in Texas was Fanny Oliver, from Victoria County, Texas, also near Jackson County. In 1870, Fanny Oliver was about 58 years old, and was married to John Oliver (62). The tone of the letter reads to me like an older adult woman; between these two Fannys, I was leaning toward Fanny Oliver.
That of course presumed that Fanny still lived in Texas three years after she wrote her letter to Mr. Slade. I began to wonder if I had it wrong. Maybe by 1870, she had reconnected with her children and had returned to the East Coast. In looking around the 1870 census, I found several former Slade slaves who had taken the Slade name; I decided to see if there was a Fanny Slade living somewhere outside of Texas. It turns out yes, there were several Fanny Slades in 1870. I narrowed my census search to slaves born in North Carolina in or around 1820, and found the following:
Slade, Fanny. 45. F. Black. Works on Farm. Birthplace: NC. Cannot Read. Cannot Write.
And with her: Slade, Rose. 15. F. Black. Works on Farm. Birthplace: GA. Cannot Read. Cannot Write.
Circumstantial evidence suggests this is the right Fanny. She adopted the Slade last name. In 1870 she was 45, meaning that in 1867 she was 42 — she was old enough to have children pre-war. She would have been born around 1825, only 2 years off from the 1838 estate valuation from the Slade Family Papers, which put Fanny's birth year as 1823. In 1870, Fanny Slade was living in Dooly County, Georgia, which was home to numerous other Slades, both black and white, in the 1870 Census. And most gratifying, in my mind, was to see that in 1870 she was living with Rose, a daughter, which suggests that her quest to be reunited with her children was partially successful.
It could be that I'm totally wrong; the Slade Family Papers are frustratingly silent and I'm out of ideas as to how to cross-reference this hypothesis. Too many blanks in the evidence means I have too many unanswered questions, the first being, What Happened to Fanny's Other Children? I doubt we'll ever know.
Letters from former slaves to their masters, like Fanny's, are extraordinary documentary evidence of freedmen and women claiming their freedom and their rights. What's amazing to me is that this letter was not only written, but has survived. So many former slaves did not have Fanny's resources, especially friends like J. Paul Jones, to help her find her children. I hope that she at least found some answers, even if I never do.
New Online Exhibit! Early Studies in Parapsychology at Duke
Found in the Stacks: "On the Slave Trade," Author Unknown
Oil Blue (Väylä)
1860scensuscivilwarGeorgiaNorth CarolinaslaveryTexas
Previous PostForces of Change against Forces of Death: The Jean Rabel Massacre in the Radio Haiti ArchivesNext PostMeasuring the Children of the Corn
5 thoughts on "What Happened to Fanny?"
Stan Brown says:
Fascinating, great work!
Richard Cox says:
Have you tried our Digital Library on American Slavery (http://library.uncg.edu/slavery/)?
By way of example, and after a quick search:
A listing of all of the slaves named "Fanny" we have currently: http://library.uncg.edu/slavery/index.aspx?s=fanny&r=0&v=0&y=0&t=0&e=zz&d=0
Here are 2 court cases which feature *a* Slade and *a* Fanny, though they may not be the ones you're hoping for:
http://library.uncg.edu/slavery/petitions/details.aspx?pid=10714
I hope this is helpful as a continuing point!
There's a Slade Road in Blanch, NC. My family used to live there once upon a time. A very small town right outside of Yanceyville, NC. I think that may be a place to look into since there is a Fanny registered in NC.
Erika Taylor says:
Wow, what a fascinating article. Thanks a lot for sharing this!
Rosemary Prior says:
Thank you Mr. Rubenstein and staff for all you do to make the world a better place. My neighbor Clarice Thorpe , a brillant senior citizen visited your library celebrating the achievements of her family. I believe because he was a man who stood tall in the face of slavery and inhuman conditions The Rubenstein Library has documentatipn about his life. I pray that someday racial hatred will end and we demonstate
in word and deed "All Lives Matter". This library is a treasure
and the staff is very kind . I use a walker and they made sure I
was comfortable without me ever asking.
Dispatches from the David M. Rubenstein Rare Book and Manuscript Library at Duke University
Welcome to the blog of the David M. Rubenstein Rare Book & Manuscript Library at Duke University.
Questions? E-mail us at special-collections(at)duke.edu.
Search The Devil's Tale
Categories Select Category Archive of Documentary Arts Audiovisual Materials Bingham Center Digital Collections TRLN CCC Project Do Your Research Instruction Research Tips Travel Grants Economists' Papers Archive Events Exhibits Films Readings and Talks Symposia and Conferences Workshops Featured Franklin Research Center From Our Collections New at the Rubenstein Library Hartman Center History of Medicine Human Rights Archive Jazz Archive Just for Fun Manuscripts Early Manuscripts Meet the Staff News and Features In the Conservation Lab My Rubenstein Library Publications Renovation RL Photos RL Scholars RL Wire Rubenstein Move Photography Radio Haiti Rare Books RL Magazine Rubenstein Library Test Kitchen Students and Interns Technical Stuff New Finding Aids University Archives
Rubenstein Library Website
RL Magazine
Rubenstein Library
Sallie Bingham Center
Franklin Research Center
Hartman Center
Bingham Center
Duke University Archives
2011acquisitions
2012acquisition
artistsbooks
civilwar
dorisduke
dukehistory
durhamhistory
durham history
fullframe
JHF@100
lisa unger baskin collection
longcivilrights
madmenmondays
movediary
rubensteinstaff
The Devil's Tale Archive
The Devil's Tale Archive Select Month January 2021 (1) December 2020 (2) November 2020 (2) October 2020 (5) September 2020 (6) August 2020 (7) July 2020 (1) June 2020 (3) May 2020 (1) April 2020 (7) March 2020 (3) February 2020 (4) January 2020 (5) December 2019 (1) November 2019 (5) October 2019 (6) September 2019 (3) August 2019 (2) July 2019 (2) June 2019 (4) May 2019 (5) April 2019 (9) March 2019 (3) February 2019 (6) January 2019 (3) December 2018 (5) November 2018 (4) October 2018 (9) September 2018 (1) August 2018 (3) July 2018 (5) June 2018 (5) May 2018 (5) April 2018 (5) March 2018 (10) February 2018 (4) January 2018 (3) December 2017 (4) November 2017 (3) October 2017 (8) September 2017 (5) August 2017 (8) July 2017 (6) June 2017 (2) May 2017 (4) April 2017 (7) March 2017 (4) February 2017 (6) January 2017 (5) December 2016 (3) November 2016 (8) October 2016 (6) September 2016 (6) August 2016 (6) July 2016 (10) June 2016 (3) May 2016 (5) April 2016 (13) March 2016 (7) February 2016 (14) January 2016 (8) December 2015 (7) November 2015 (5) October 2015 (9) September 2015 (4) August 2015 (8) July 2015 (8) June 2015 (9) May 2015 (7) April 2015 (16) March 2015 (17) February 2015 (10) January 2015 (13) December 2014 (8) November 2014 (7) October 2014 (12) September 2014 (5) August 2014 (4) July 2014 (8) June 2014 (8) May 2014 (10) April 2014 (16) March 2014 (13) February 2014 (10) January 2014 (9) December 2013 (8) November 2013 (11) October 2013 (15) September 2013 (10) August 2013 (11) July 2013 (16) June 2013 (15) May 2013 (13) April 2013 (16) March 2013 (11) February 2013 (13) January 2013 (12) December 2012 (9) November 2012 (15) October 2012 (15) September 2012 (10) August 2012 (16) July 2012 (15) June 2012 (11) May 2012 (10) April 2012 (15) March 2012 (18) February 2012 (16) January 2012 (14) December 2011 (11) November 2011 (24) October 2011 (14) September 2011 (11) August 2011 (15) July 2011 (18) June 2011 (8) May 2011 (6) April 2011 (15) March 2011 (11) February 2011 (9) January 2011 (13) December 2010 (5) November 2010 (8) October 2010 (16) September 2010 (14) August 2010 (6) July 2010 (9) June 2010 (8) May 2010 (8) April 2010 (14) March 2010 (14) February 2010 (11) January 2010 (11) December 2009 (5) November 2009 (10) October 2009 (12)
New Archival Collections at the Rubenstein Library
Bill of sale for Lawson, an enslaved man, from A.M. Boyle to A. Carson, 1863 February 26 : manuscript.
Bill of sale for Harriet and Martha, two enslaved women, from John Hunter to J.E. Calhoun, 1858 February 8 : autograph manuscript signed.
Hannah More papers, 1808, 1828.
Bill of sale for Sue, an enslaved woman, from James Garvin to Tully Bolling, 1813 December 9 : autograph manuscript signed.
Sally Maria Beers Leffingwell papers, 1827.
New Books and Other Publications at the Rubenstein Library
A dissertation on the motion of the blood : and on the effects of bleeding, verified by experiments made on living animals : to which are added, observations on the heart, proving that irritability is the primary cause of its motion / by the celebrated Dr. Alb. Haller, president of the Royal Society of Sciences at Gottingen, member of the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris, fellow of the Royal Societies of London, Berlin, Stockholm, &c. ; translated by a physician.
Traité des maladies des artères et des veines / par Jos. Hodgson, membre du Collége royal des chirurgiens et de la Société médico-chirurgicale de Londres, correspondant de la Société de la Faculté de médecine de Paris, de la Société médicale d'Emulation de la même ville, etc. ; traduit de l'anglais et augmenté d'un grand nombre de notes par Gilbert Breschet, docteur en médecine, prosecteur à la Faculté de médecine de Paris, premier aide de clinique chirurgicale à l'Hôtel-Dieu de la même ville, professeur particulier d'anatomie et de chirurgie, membre du Bureau central d'admission dans les Hôpitaux et Hospices civils, chirurgien adjoint du premier dispensaire de la Société philanthropique, Secrétaire général de la Société médicale d'Emulation, et membre de plusieurs sociétés savantes françaises et étrangères.
Курсъ глазныхъ болѣзней / Kurs glaznykh boli͡ezneĭ / д-ра. А. Крюкова, Э.О. Профессора Императорскаго Московскова Университета ; изданіе А.А. Карцева. / d-ra. A. Kri͡ukova, Ė.O. Professora Imperatorskago Moskovskova Universiteta ; izdanīe A.A. Kart͡seva.
Views of society and manners in America : in a series of letters from that country to a friend in England, during the years 1818, 1819, and 1820 / by an Englishwoman.
New Rubenstein Library Materials Added to the Internet Archive
Il libro dell'arte .. January 14, 2021
Gesamt-Ausgabe der Werke. Endgültige Fassung January 14, 2021
The Roman Law of Marriage January 11, 2021
La Table Claudienne de Lyon January 8, 2021
The Excavations at Dura-Europos January 8, 2021
The Devil's Tale