Hot Corner Harbor
A Baseball Blog - Scientific and Speculative Thoughts from Third Base
Retired Numbers Series
Future Hall of Fame Series
Sporcle Quizzes
Cape Cod League 2012
Why MLB Should Seed Playoff Teams Based on Record Alone
Over time, I've written several pieces about the change to baseball's playoff system. Overall, I'd say my position on it has shifted from "Get rid of the second wild card" to "if we're going to have a fifth team, at least do it better than we are now". I would hope that prospective improvement is something that we can all agree is a good goal, right? So what would prospective improvement for the current system be?
Well, I think there are a number of things that could be fixed, but the one I want to focus on today is seeding. You may or may not have heard, but the three best records in the majors this year all belong to teams in the NL Central. Despite this, the Pirates and Cubs will need to play one game to determine which one of them "really" deserves a post-season spot, at which point the winner will face the Cardinals. So we are guaranteed to see only one of the best records in the majors making the Championship Series round.
That's a little absurd. Why can't baseball switch to seeding solely based on record, like the NBA recently decided to do? I see people arguing against it all the time, but the arguments just don't make sense to me. The Pirates won 98 games; the Cubs won 97. You mean to tell me that, because they were assigned to the Central division back in 1994, that the 92-win Dodgers and 90-win Mets deserve those automatic bids to the ALDS more? Sure, sure, you can scream "DOESN'T MATTER, JUST WIN YOUR DIVISON" all you want, that still doesn't explain why teams that did less to win their division (in just about every conceivable way) than the Pirates and the Cubs should see benefits. It's not even like the Mets and Dodgers were noticeably better at beating the Cardinals; they went 3-4 and 2-5 versus St. Louis respectively, while the Cubs went 8-11 and the Pirates went 9-10.
Some might point out that it's rare for the three best teams in the majors to all come from one division, and that is true. However, what's not uncommon at all is for a wild card winner to have a better record than a division winner; since the first full season with the new format in 1995, there have been thirteen seasons in the AL and fourteen seasons in the NL where the top Wild Card has had a better record than at least one division winner.
Yep, out of 42 league-seasons, over half have ended with a wild card playing well enough to win a division other than their own. I'd like to think that the regular season means something, that doing well over 162 games gets you some benefit for the final twenty, but as it's structured now, there's a good chance that you finishing with a better record will be rendered moot. This isn't some once-in-a-lifetime fluke; it's a real issue that needs addressing. It's admittedly a lot more unusual for both wild cards to finish so well; this season marks the sixth time the second wild card team (or the team that would have filled that role, had it existed prior to 2012) would have pulled it off. But that just makes this season different in extent rather than in kind.
But what about the unbalanced record, you might say. Baseball has an unbalanced schedule, and it wouldn't be fair if the wild card team's record was just a case of fattening up on a weaker division. Well, there are a lot of issues with that statement. For instance, I don't see how letting the record be the unseen deciding factor is significantly worse than letting geography be the tie-breaker, as it is now.
More notably, though, is that the case doesn't seem to hold up in the abstract. Picture two divisions, one with a wild card team better than the other division's winner. If the schedule was unbalanced towards more games with intra-divisional foes, which team would have the easier schedule?
Well, knowing only that one division has a wild card team with a better record than the other division's winner, you'd be safer betting on the wild card having a harder schedule. Why is that? Well, picture it with numbers attached; say that the wild card has the third best record while the worse division winner has the fourth best. Just based on that, we KNOW that the wild card played a lot of games against the best or second-best record in the league, but the weak division winner's hardest rival was at-best, the fifth-best in the league. Those are the only things we know FOR CERTAIN, so assuming the rest of the league's records are randomly distributed, we can't guarantee anything other than what we've previously stated, meaning that the two-team division is just as likely as the "weak" division gets a stacked bottom three.
That's great in theory, but does it hold up in practice? To find out, I used ESPN's strength of schedule numbers. These are the weighted average record of a team's opponents, based on how many times they played (and factoring out games the opponent played against the first team, to make sure you aren't penalizing a good team for making their opponents look even worse). The numbers only go back to 2002, but that's still a good amount to look at.
And in that time, I made an interesting discovery; teams face relatively balanced schedules. That's not to say totally balanced; the average difference in strength of schedule (measured as opponents' winning percentage) between the toughest schedule and the weakest came out to .027. That translates to about 4.4 wins, or about the difference between the Phillies and Braves this season.
But that number isn't entirely what we're looking at; the hardest schedule and the weakest schedule rarely come from the same league, and since the two leagues are competing for different playoff spots. When we separate by league, we get the following:
Average AL Range: .019 (3.1 wins)
Average AL Standard Deviation: .0056 (0.9 wins)
Average NL Range: .021 (3.4 wins)
Average NL Standard Deviation: .0062 (1.01 wins)
So over a full season, a large majority of teams in the same league have a schedule within 2 wins of each other in difficulty. This range condenses even further when you look at just the teams vying for the postseason; the average range in strength of schedule among teams finishing first or second in their division or the wild card race is .0151 in the AL and .0154 in the NL, or between 2.4 and 2.5 wins. While those numbers aren't as equal as a perfectly balanced schedule, I'd say that's pretty damn close, even given the logistics that need to be factored in around the current schedule.
But let's just go back to my original hypothesis; when wild card winners have a better record than division winners, do they generally have harder schedules as well? Well, in the 28 league-seasons since 2002, there have been 20 cases where a wild card team has had an equal or better record than an AL or NL division winner. In seventeen of those, the wild card team had a harder schedule as well. Of the remaining three cases, the division winner had a harder schedule than the wild card team only once (twice, the wild card was tied with an equal-or-worse division winner on the schedule strength).
So why not switch to an entirely record-based seeding method? To recap, we average over one wild card winner per season with a better record than a division winner so it's not an uncommon problem; and they are almost guaranteed to have played an equal or harder schedule than their division-winning foe (not that there's a huge difference between teams' schedule strengths to begin with). What reason is there beyond that to deny strong wild cards a free bye into the division series? They already showed they've earned it over 162 games. If we have to punish any teams with a one-game play-in for "sneaking into" the postseason, it should be weak division winners.
Posted by Theo at 12:21 AM
Labels: 2015 Playoffs, Divisional Imbalance, Divisions, Opinion, Playoffs, Second Wild Card, Studies, Wild Cards
1990s (1) 1995 Season (1) 2001 Season (2) 2006 HoF (3) 2008 Season (1) 2011 Awards (10) 2011 Hall of Fame (11) 2011 Playoffs (9) 2011 Season (1) 2011 World Series (4) 2011-12 Hot Stove (2) 2012 All Star Game (3) 2012 Awards (10) 2012 Hall of Fame (7) 2012 Playoffs (5) 2012 Season (4) 2012 Trade Deadline (7) 2012 World Series (2) 2012-13 Hall of Fame (1) 2012-13 Hot Stove (11) 2013 Awards (1) 2013 Draft (21) 2013 Hall of Fame (5) 2013 Playoffs (1) 2013 Predictions (6) 2013 Season (11) 2013 Trade Deadline (1) 2013 World Series (2) 2014 Awards (1) 2014 Draft (1) 2014 Hall of Fame (7) 2014 Offseason (2) 2014 Playoffs (3) 2014 Predictions (6) 2014 Season (3) 2014 Trade Deadline (1) 2015 Hall of Fame (3) 2015 Playoffs (3) 2015 Predictions (2) 2015 Season (2) 2015 World Series (1) 2016 Hall of Fame (1) 2016 Playoffs (3) 2016 World Series (4) 2017 Hall of Fame (3) 2017 Playoffs (2) 2017 Trade Deadline (1) 2017 World Series (3) 2018 Hall of Fame (8) 2018 Playoffs (9) 2018 Season (3) 2018 World Series (2) 2019 All-Star Game (1) 2019 Hall of Fame (8) 2019 Playoffs (5) 2019 Season (8) 2019 World Series (4) 2020 Hall of Fame (11) 2023 Hall of Fame (1) 25 Best 2016 (1) 300 Wins (1) 3000 Hits (3) 3000 Strikeouts (2) 400 Home Runs (3) 50 Best 2011 (7) 50 Best 2012 (8) 50 Best 2013 (2) 50 Best Players Not in the Hall (19) 500 Home Runs (4) A.J. Hinch (1) Aaron Blair (3) Aaron Judge (2) Aaron Nola (2) Abbreviated Commentary (4) Active Players (3) Adam Darowski (1) Adam Dunn (3) Adam Jones (7) Adam LaRoche (1) Adam McCreery (1) Adam Wainwright (6) Adrian Beltre (11) Adrian Gonzalez (1) AJ Hinch (4) AJ Pierzynski (1) AJ Reed (2) AL Central (3) AL East (7) Al Oliver (1) AL West (7) Alan Trammell (5) Albert Belle (2) Albert Pujols (19) ALCS (2) ALDS (4) Alex Anthopoulos (1) Alex Blandino (2) Alex Bregman (4) Alex Gordon (1) Alex Liddi (1) Alex Rios (1) Alex Rodriguez (9) Alfonso Soriano (1) All-Star (9) All-Star Game (8) All-Star Rosters (11) Allen Craig (3) Alternate Universes (1) Ambiguity (7) Andre Dawson (1) Andre Ethier (1) Andrew Cashner (1) Andrew Knapp (3) Andrew McCutchen (10) Andrew Miller (1) Andrew Thurman (1) Andruw Jones (10) Andy Pettitte (5) Angel Pagan (1) Anibal Sanchez (3) Anniversary (1) Announcements (3) Anthony Rendon (3) Anthony Rizzo (2) Aramis Ramirez (1) Arizona Diamondbacks (8) Arky Vaughan (1) Aroldis Chapman (2) Atlanta Braves (10) Audio (2) August (1) Austin Kubitza (1) Austin Voth (1) Austin Wilson (3) BABIP (3) Backyard Baseball (1) Bad Ideas (10) Bad Luck (7) Bad Teams (1) Baltimore Orioles (24) Barry Bonds (16) Barry Larkin (4) Barry Zito (1) Bartolo Colon (3) Baseball Bloggers Alliance (15) Baseball Galactus (1) Baseball Gods (2) Baseball Nation (1) Baseball Past and Present (3) Baseball Players Hate 8 (1) Baseless Accusations (1) BBWAA (3) Beer-and-Cheese Laden Pastures (1) Ben Lively (1) Ben Sheets (1) Ben Zobrist (4) Bengie Molina (1) Bernie Williams (2) Bert Blyleven (1) Bert Campaneris (1) Best of a Generation (1) Best of Teams (5) Best Players Without a World Series (4) Big Six Sports (1) Big Three (1) Bill James (1) Bill Madden (1) Billy Butler (2) Billy Martin (4) Billy Southworth (1) Billy Wagner (9) Blog Exclusive (8) Bob Friend (1) Bob Johnson (1) Bobby Abreu (7) Bobby Bonds (1) Bobby Cox (3) Bobby Grich (6) Books (2) Boston Red Sox (15) Bourne Braves (1) Brad Kuntz (1) Brad Radke (1) Brady Anderson (1) Brainstorming (1) Brandon Phillips (3) Brandon Trinkwon (1) Brandon Webb (2) Brazil (2) Brent Strom (1) Bret Saberhagen (6) Brett Austin (3) Brett Lawrie (2) Brett-Michael Doran (1) Brewster Whitecaps (1) Brian Giles (11) Brian McCann (3) Brian Ragira (1) Brian Roberts (2) Bruce Bochy (3) Bryan Verbitsky (1) Bryant U (1) Bryce Harper (19) Buck Showalter (3) Buck/McCarver (1) Bud Black (1) Bud Norris (1) Bud Selig (1) Bud Selig at work (8) Buddy Bell (4) Buddy Carlyle (1) Buster Olney (1) Buster Posey (5) Cael Brockmeyer (1) Cal Ripken Sr. (1) Cameron Maybin (1) Cap Anson (1) Career Metaphors (1) Carl Crawford (2) Carlos Beltran (17) Carlos Correa (8) Carlos Delgado (1) Carlos Gomez (1) Carlos Gonzalez (3) Carlos Martinez (4) Carlos Santana (2) Casey Kelly (1) Casey Turgeon (2) Catchers (3) CC Sabathia (12) CCBL (25) CCBL Standouts (12) Center Field (6) Chad Green (1) Chad Pinder (4) Charlie Morton (2) Charts (1) Chase Headley (2) Chase Utley (8) Chatham Anglers (3) Chicago Cubs (14) Chicago White Sox (11) Chipper Jones (11) Chris Carpenter (4) Chris Davis (2) Chris Devenski (1) Chris Sale (14) Cincinnati Reds (11) Cities (2) Cito Gaston (2) CK Irby (1) Clay Buchholz (1) Clayton Kershaw (22) Cleveland Indians (15) Cleveland Spiders (1) Cliff Lee (6) Closers (2) Coco Crisp (1) Cody Bellinger (1) Coincidences (1) Colby Rasmus (7) Colby Suggs (1) Cole Hamels (13) Cole Sturgeon (1) Colin Moran (3) Colorado Rockies (10) Columbus Ohio (1) Comeback Player of the Year (1) Comparisons (5) Congress (1) Conrad Gregor (1) Cooperstown Confidential (2) Corey Kluber (2) Corey Littrell (1) Cotuit Kettleers (1) Craig Biggio (7) Craig Counsell (1) Craig Kimbrel (7) Craig Schlitter (3) Cuba (1) Curt Schilling (22) Cy Young Award (7) Dale Carey (2) Dale Murphy (4) Dallas Keuchel (4) Dan Duquette (1) Dan Haren (1) Dan Hudson (1) Dan Quisenberry (1) Dan Slania (1) Daniel Aldrich (1) Daniel Palka (1) Danny Espinosa (2) Darrell Evans (3) Darryl Kile (1) Darryl Strawberry (1) Dave Parker (4) Dave Roberts (2) Dave Stieb (5) Davey Johnson (7) David Cone (3) David Freese (1) David Garner (1) David Ortiz (8) David Price (3) David Wright (11) Debates (1) Decades (2) Defense (1) Delmon Young (1) Derek Holland (1) Derek Jeter (8) Derrerk Lee (2) Designated Hitter (1) Detroit Tigers (9) Dick Allen (4) Dick Williams (1) Divisional Imbalance (3) Divisions (2) Dizzy Dean (1) Dominant (2) Domingo Santana (1) Dominic Ficociello (1) Dominic Jose (1) Don Mattingly (3) Don Sutton (1) Double Digit Home Runs (1) Draft (30) Draft Picks (5) Drew Dosch (2) Droughts (9) Duke Snider (1) Dustin Ackley (2) Dustin Pedroia (2) Dusty Baker (1) Dusty Isaacs (1) Dwight Evans (6) Dwight Gooden (1) Dylan Bundy (3) Dynasties (3) Ed Walsh (1) Eddie Campbell (1) Eddie Collins (1) Eddie Mathews (1) Eddie Plank (1) Edgar Martinez (14) Eduardo Rodriguez (1) Edwin Jackson (4) Ellis Burks (1) Elrod Hendricks (1) Elvis Andrus (4) Enos Slaughter (1) Environmental Pressure (2) Epiphanies (1) ERA (1) ERA+ (3) Eric Chavez (1) Eric Jagielo (3) Erick Aybar (1) Ervin Santana (1) ESPN (11) Europe (1) Evan Longoria (14) Ex-Astros (2) Expansion Teams (13) Extensions (1) Falmouth Commodores (6) Felix Hernandez (11) Fernando Rodney (1) Fernando Valenzuela (1) Fielding (1) FIP (3) First Base (2) FJM'ing (1) Footnotes (2) Franchise Players (2) Francisco Lindor (3) Francisco Rodriguez (2) Frank Robinson (1) Frank Thomas (2) Fred McGriff (4) Front Office Evaluation (1) FTIN (7) Future 40 (1) Future Hall of Fame (26) Future Hall of Fame Series (22) Gambling (1) Game Recaps (5) Games (3) Garrett Richards (1) Garrett Stubbs (1) Gary Carter (1) Gary Sheffield (5) Gavvy Cravath (1) General Manager (1) Geography (1) George Foster (1) George Springer (5) Gerrit Cole (5) Giancarlo Stanton (9) Good Ideas (2) Grady Sizemore (1) Graham Womack (1) Graig Nettles (2) Greg Maddux (4) Haiku (1) Hall of Fame (115) Hall of Fame Managers (2) Hall of Fame Run Downs (17) Hall of Merit (2) Hall of Stats (3) Hank Aaron Award (2) Hanley Ramirez (4) Hardball Talk (1) Harold Baines (3) Harwich Mariners (2) Heath Bell (1) High Heat Stats (3) Hiroki Kuroda (2) Hiroshima Carp (1) History (15) Hitters (3) HoF Tiers (3) Home Runs (4) Hot Corner Harbor (14) Houston Astros (82) How Big Should the Hall of Fame Be? (3) Hoyt Wilhelm (1) HSAC (1) Humor (4) Hunter Pence (1) Hyannis Harbor Hawks (3) Ian Kennedy (2) Ian Kinsler (6) Ichiro (6) Indiana State (2) Inexplicable (3) Injuries (6) Instant Replay (5) Interesting (1) Interesting Trivia (2) International Baseball (6) Interviews (9) Italy (2) Ivan Rodriguez (5) J.J. Hardy (4) J.R. Richard (3) Jack Morris (4) Jack Wilson (1) Jackie Robinson (2) Jacob deGrom (1) Jacob Turner (1) Jacoby Ellsbury (3) JaCoby Jones (2) Jaime Garcia (1) Jaime Schultz (1) Jake Arrieta (3) Jake Hernandez (1) Jake Joyce (1) Jake Peavy (1) Jake Rodriguez (1) James Shields (1) Japan (1) Jared King (2) Jared Ruxer (1) Jaron Long (1) Jarred Cosart (1) Jarrett Arakawa (1) Jason Giambi (3) Jason Hammel (1) Jason Heyward (9) Jason Kendall (6) Jason Vargas (1) JAWS (3) Jay Bruce (3) Jean Segura (1) Jeff Bagwell (17) Jeff Hoffman (2) Jeff Kent (5) Jeff Luhnow (2) Jeff Samardzija (1) Jeff Suppan (1) Jeff Thompson (1) Jeffrey Loria is Awful (2) Jered Weaver (1) Jhonny Peralta (3) Jim Edmonds (14) Jim Johnson (1) Jim Kaat (1) Jim Leyland (1) Jim Thome (8) Jimmy Rollins (4) Jimmy Wynn (3) Joe Blanton (1) Joe Carter (1) Joe Jackson (2) Joe Maddon (5) Joe Mauer (3) Joe Musgrove (1) Joe Nathan (3) Joe Posnanski (2) Joe Torre (5) Joey Votto (4) Johan Santana (6) John Farrell (1) John Franco (1) John Murphy (1) John Olerud (4) John Schuerholz (1) John Simms (2) John Smoltz (1) Johnny Cueto (4) Johnny Damon (4) Johnny Magliozzi (1) Johnny Mize (1) Jon Keller (1) Jon Lester (1) Jon Singleton (3) Jonathan Holder (1) Jonathan Lucroy (1) Jonathan Papelbon (1) Jonathan Schoop (2) Jorge De La Rosa (1) Jorge Posada (1) Jose Abreu (1) Jose Altuve (11) Jose Bautista (6) Jose Cruz Jr (2) Jose Fernandez (3) Jose Molina (1) Jose Reyes (4) Jose Rijo (1) Josh Beckett (1) Josh Hamilton (2) Josh Johnson (3) Josh Reddick (6) Josh Willingham (1) Juan Soto (1) Julio Urias (1) Jurickson Profar (1) Justin Masterson (1) Justin Morneau (1) Justin Upton (10) Justin Verlander (29) Kameron Loe (1) Kansas City Royals (9) Kansas State (1) Karsten Whitson (1) Keep Colby Rasmus (3) Keith Hernandez (5) Ken Boyer (3) Ken Griffey Jr. (3) Kenley Jansen (1) Kenny Lofton (7) Kenny Rogers (1) Kerry Wood (2) Kevin Appier (4) Kevin Brown (9) Kevin Youkilis (1) Kevin Ziomek (2) Kirk Gibson (2) Knee-Jerk Reactions (18) Kolten Wong (2) Kris Bryant (1) Kyle Crockett (1) Kyle Lohse (1) Kyle Ruchim (1) Kyle Schwarber (2) Kyler Finnegan (1) Labor (1) Lance Berkman (18) Lance McCullers (5) Larry Jackson (1) Larry Walker (16) Last Player of 1990s (1) Laws (1) League-Wide Retired Numbers (1) Lee Smith (4) Legislation (1) Link Overload (4) Links (10) Lists (11) Long Term Contracts (10) Los Angeles Angels (11) Los Angeles Dodgers (15) Lou Piniella (4) Lou Whitaker (9) Louie Lechich (2) Luis Gonzalez (2) Luis Severino (1) Luis Tiant (4) Madison Bumgarner (9) Make-Ups (1) Manager of the Year (4) Managers (7) Manny Machado (16) Manny Ramirez (5) Marc Rzepczynski (1) Marco Gonzales (1) Marcus Stroman (1) Mariano Rivera (9) Mark Appel (1) Mark Buehrle (6) Mark Grace (1) Mark McGwire (6) Mark Reynolds (2) Mark Teixeira (2) Marshall (1) Martin Prado (1) Marvin Miller (4) Mason Robbins (1) Mat Latos (1) Match-ups (5) Math (1) Matt Adams (1) Matt Boyd (1) Matt Cain (2) Matt Carpenter (4) Matt Chapman (1) Matt Harvey (1) Matt Holliday (8) Matt Kemp (5) Matt Moore (1) Matt Wieters (5) Max Scherzer (7) Meandering Thoughts (3) Melky Cabrera (5) Melodrama (1) Melvin Mora (1) Memories (2) Miami Marlins (11) Micah Owings (1) Michael Bourn (3) Michael Brantley (3) Michael Conforto (1) Michael Montville (1) Michael Morse (1) Michael O'Neill (1) Michael Pineda (2) Michael Wacha (4) Michael Wagner (1) Michael Young (4) Midseason Awards (2) Miguel Cabrera (17) Miguel Tejada (1) Mike Fiers (1) Mike Flanagan (1) Mike Lowell (2) Mike Matheny (2) Mike Mayers (1) Mike Moustakas (1) Mike Mussina (21) Mike Olt (1) Mike Piazza (10) Mike Scoscia (3) Mike Trout (26) Milestones (6) Milwaukee Brewers (10) Mini-Articles (22) Minnesota Twins (5) Minnie Minoso (1) Minor Leagues (1) Mitchell Garver (1) Moises Alou (1) Molina Brothers (1) Moneyball (1) Montreal Expos (1) Mookie Betts (4) Mott Hyde (1) Movies (4) Mr. 3000 (1) MVP (9) MVP Candidates (4) Nap Lajoie (1) Nate Colbert (1) Nate McLouth (2) Nathan Eovaldi (1) Ned Yost (1) Nelson Cruz (2) Netherlands (3) New CBA (7) New York Mets (10) New York Yankees (13) Nicholas Rumbelow (1) Nick Markakis (10) Nick Swisher (2) NL Central (5) NL East (4) NL West (3) No really who thought this was a good idea? (1) Noah Syndergaard (1) Nolan Arenado (3) Nolan Ryan (1) Nomar Garciaparra (1) Nori Aoki (1) NPB (1) Oakland Athletics (10) OBP (1) Octavio Dotel (1) Odds (1) Offseason Plans (4) Olympics (1) Omar Freaking Infante (3) Omar Vizquel (3) OotP (9) Opening Day (2) Opinion (8) OPS+ (4) Optimism (1) Orel Hershiser (2) Orlando Hernandez (1) Orleans Firebirds (1) Oscar Taveras (2) Out of Left Field (13) Out of the Park Baseball 14 (2) Out of the Park Baseball 15 (1) Out of the Park Baseball 16 (1) Out of the Park Baseball 17 (1) Out of the Park Baseball 18 (3) Out of the Park Baseball 19 (1) Outfielders (4) Ozzie Guillen (2) Pablo Sandoval (1) Parity (1) Park Effects (1) Patrick Biondi (1) Paul Goldschmidt (1) Paul Konerko (8) Paul Molitor (1) Paul O'Neill (1) Payrolls (1) Pedro Martinez (3) PEDs (2) Pennants (1) Pete Rose (4) Phantom Opening Day (1) Phil Ervin (3) Phil Hughes (1) Phil Niekro (1) Phil Rizzuto (1) Philadelphia Phillies (17) Pitchers (16) Pitching (3) Pittsburgh Pirates (10) Players I've Never Heard Of (4) Playoff Races (3) Playoff Trivia (4) Playoffs (27) Poetry (1) Politics (1) Polls (1) Pop Culture (5) Position Versatility (1) Postseason (1) Potential Hall of Fame (10) Predictions (58) Preview (8) Prince Fielder (3) Projections (6) PSA (12) Pure Prose (5) RA Dickey (4) Rafael Palmeiro (1) Rance Mulliniks (1) Randall Delgado (1) Random Renderings (5) Randy Johnson (7) RBIs are Dumb (1) Re-Run (18) Real World (1) Really Long Pieces (1) Rebuilding (14) Recaps (2) Recommendations (4) Reconsideration (2) Reflections (3) Reggie Smith (2) Relievers? (2) Replacement Level (3) Responses (14) Retired Number Candidates (5) Retired Numbers (46) Retired Numbers Series (37) Retired Numbers Spin-Offs (4) Retrospective (3) Review (6) Rice U (1) Rick Reuschel (4) Right Field (1) Robbie Ray (1) Robert Pehl (1) Roberto Clemente (2) Robin Ventura (2) Robinson Cano (8) Robinson Chirinos (1) Roger Clemens (16) Rogers Hornsby (1) Ron Cey (1) Ron Gardenhire (1) Ron Santo (3) Ron Washington (1) Ronald Acuña (1) Rookie of the Year (3) Roundups (13) Roy Halladay (11) Roy Oswalt (8) Run Differential (1) Ryan Braun (8) Ryan Connolly (1) Ryan Howard (5) Ryan Howard Award (2) Ryan Ludwick (1) Ryan Pressley (1) Ryan Zimmerman (14) Ryan Zimmerman Award (1) Ryon Healy (1) Sad Things (1) Sal Bando (3) Salvador Perez (1) Sam Dove (1) Sam Moll (1) Sam Travis (1) Sammy Sosa (1) San Diego Padres (9) San Francisco Giants (13) Sandy Koufax (1) Sarcasm (7) Scapegoats (1) Schedule (2) Scorecasting (1) Scott Feldman (1) Scott Kazmir (1) Scott Rolen (25) Sean Manaea (5) Sean McHugh (1) Season Preview (5) Seattle Mariners (8) Second Base (5) Second Wild Card (3) September 28 2011 (2) Sequels (17) Series (14) Serious Business (1) Shelby Miller (5) Sherry Magee (1) Shin-Soo Choo (1) Shortstop (3) Simulations (7) Slumps (1) Small Things that Bug Me (5) Softball (1) Son of a Gun (1) Sonny Gray (1) Spectacular Blunders (3) Speculative Fiction (1) Sporcle (23) Sports Illustrated (3) Spring Training (1) St. Louis Cardinals (38) Stan Coveleski (1) Starlin Castro (2) Stephen Strasburg (9) Steroids (9) Steve Carlton (1) Steve Garvey (5) Strange Analogies (2) Strategy (1) Stray Thoughts (3) Studies (51) Suspensions (1) Tampa Bay Rays (11) Tanking (1) Tanner Roark (1) Team Relocation (2) Ted Simmons (8) Teddy Higuera (1) Terry Francona (2) Texas Rangers (11) The Crawfish Boxes (33) The Detroit News (1) The Hall Ballot Backlog (4) The Platoon Advantage (4) Theoretical (2) Third Base (11) Thomas Lawrence (1) Thought Experiments (11) Thurman Munson (2) Tim Hudson (5) Tim Lincecum (2) Tim McCarver's Speaking Light (1) Tim Raines (9) Tim Salmon (1) Todd Frazier (2) Todd Helton (11) Tom Glavine (3) Tom Seaver (1) Tom Windle (2) Tommy John (5) Tony Fernandez (1) Tony Kemp (2) Tony La Russa (8) Torii Hunter (1) Toronto Blue Jays (9) Trade Analysis (9) Trade Comparisons (2) Trade Deadline (9) Trade Rumors (2) Trade Suggestions (12) Trevor Bauer (2) Trevor Cahill (1) Trevor Hoffman (8) Trevor Mitsui (1) Trevor Rosenthal (2) Trey Masek (1) Triple Crowns (3) Tris Speaker (1) Trivia (29) Troy Tulowitzki (6) Tyler Burgess (1) Tyler Clippard (1) Tyler Horan (2) Tyler White (1) Ubaldo Jimenez (2) UC Berkley (1) Underrated (11) Underrated Third Basemen (6) Upcoming Ballot Apocalypse (2) Updated Re-Runs (1) Updates (11) Veterans Committee (9) Video Games (11) Vinny Castilla (1) Virginia Tech (2) Vladimir Guerrero (9) Voting (5) Wade Miley (1) Walk Rates (1) Walter Johnson (1) Wandy Rodriguez (1) WAR (34) Wareham Gatemen (2) Washington Nationals (14) Wayne Taylor (2) What If (2) Whitey Herzog (1) Wil Myers (2) Wild Cards (4) Will Clark (4) Willie Randolph (2) Wilson Ramos (2) Wins (2) Winter Meetings (1) Women in Baseball (1) World Baseball Classic (3) World Series (29) Worst-to-First (1) wRC+ (1) Xander Bogaerts (1) Yadier Molina (6) Yan Gomes (1) Yarmouth-Dennis Red Sox (2) Yasiel Puig (3) Yasmani Grandal (1) Year in Review (3) Yordan Alvarez (2) Young Players (1) Youngstown State (1) Yuli Gurriel (1) Zach Davies (1) Zack Britton (3) Zack Cozart (1) Zack Greinke (13) Zak Blair (1) Zev Chafets (2)
2020 Hall of Fame Voting Is Looking Like a Turning Point, and Scott Rolen is Leading the Way
[ also posted at The Crawfish Boxes ] Two weeks ago, when I was covering Jeff Kent 's case for the Hall of Fame, I noted just how packe...
Breaking Down the 2019 Veterans Committee Voters
I mentioned in my Veterans Committee piece that seeing who all gets a ballot in the sixteen-person vote could give us a little extra insigh...
Revisiting Lance Berkman's Hall of Fame Case, and How It Relates to Larry Walker's Candidacy
Just like with my last Hall of Fame piece, this one is also up over at The Crawfish Boxes. ---- Hall of Fame season is well underway...
Another Pair of Astros Articles
First, here's a recap of tonight's win over the Angels, #101 on the year. Next, here's a look at Justin Verlander's histor...
This week, I did a couple of summaries for the Angels series, including Monday's loss and Wednesday's big win. The latter marked m...
HCH Archive
The Long-Fabled All-Expansion World Series Is Fina...
Why MLB Should Seed Playoff Teams Based on Record ...
I write about baseball at https://hotcornerharbor.blogspot.com/ and pop culture at https://hchoutofleftfield.blogspot.com/.Contact me at hotcornerharbor@gmail.com
Baseball Bloggers Alliance
baseballmusings.com
Replacement Level Baseball Blog