Created with Sketch. Watch Live
NewsMore
DocumentariesMore
ShowsMore
Inside Story Episodes
Who in Pakistan should have protected Malala?
As the 14-year-old girl is shot by Taliban gunmen, we ask what does this mean for the rule of law in the country.
Inside Story 11 Oct 2012 12:23 GMT Pakistan, United Kingdom
There has been intense public reaction in Pakistan to the shooting of Malala Yousafzai, a 14 year-old schoolgirl, by Taliban gunmen.
"I was shocked and I feel ashamed ... because we could not protect her and she was fighting a fight that should have been fought by us. We should have been on the frontline, not her... They [Malala's family] were offered this protection but they refused to take it so you cannot really put all the blame on the government ... it is a mindset that we are fighting, it is the mindset that has to be changed."
- Rubina Khalid, a senator with the ruling Pakistan People's Party
She was shot in the neck and head by the Taliban on her way home from school in the Swat Valley in the country's northwest.
Yousafzai, who was seriously injured in the attack, is unconscious while she recovers from an operation. Two other girls were also injured in the attack.
Private schools closed for the day in protest and students gathered to pray for her.
Yousafzai had come to public attention at the age of 11, when she publically criticised the Pakistani Taliban for its violent action against girls' schools in the area which was then under its control, and became the first recipient of Pakistan's National Peace Award for Youth.
The government has condemned the attack, with Asif Ali Zadari, the Pakistani president suggesting that Yousafzai should get medical treatment in Dubai. But the teenager does not have a passport and is too unstable to be moved.
There have been many instances of clashes between tribal law, custom and a democratic constitution in Pakistan.
But in claiming responsibility for this shooting the Pakistani Taliban made clear the motive was rooted in a particular interpretation of Islamic law.
"It [the attack] damages the softer image of Pakistan which Malala was representing. I think it was the duty of the government to protect her, knowing fully well that she is the holder of the International Peace Award for writing her diaries, and they failed..."
- Amjad Malik, chairman of the Association of Pakistani Lawers, UK
In an official statement, the group's spokesman Ehsan ullah Ehsan said: "The Pakistani Taliban successfully targeted Malala Yousafzai in Mingora. Although she was young and a girl and Taliban does not believe in attacking women but whomsoever leads any campaign against Islam and Shariah is ordered to be killed by Shariah. It is not merely allowed to kill such a person but it is obligatory in Islam."
Inside Story asks: So what does this mean for the rule of law in Pakistan and the role of those who are supposed to apply it?
To answer this question, presenter Mike Hanna is joined by our guests: Rubina Khalid, a senator with the ruling Pakistan Peoples Party; Amjad Malik, the chairman of the Association of Pakistani Lawyers UK, and a member of the Supreme Court Bar Association of Pakistan; and Marium Fatima Khan, the women co-ordinator for Pakistan International Human Rights Organisation.
"Malala Yousafzai is like our sister. We pray for her earliest recovery and wellbeing. We also pray that other students can benefit from Malala's enlightened views."
-- Shamaila, 14, a female student
"The terrorists fired bullets at her to suppress her voice but their attempt failed. We pray from the bottom of our hearts for her early recovery."
-- Mohammad Ali, 16, a male student
TALIBAN ATTACK ON MALALA YOUSAFZAI:
The teenager is reported to be in stable condition after operation
She was shot by Taliban fighters for demanding education for girls
Pakistani Taliban fighters captured the Swat Valley in 2007
The Taliban was driven out of the valley by Pakistani forces in 2009
There have been fewer attacks since the Taliban was pushed out of Swat Valley
Says a Taliban spokesman: "We are deadly against secular education system"
A Schoolgirl's Odyssey
One Pakistani man and his talented daughter fight to educate girls in the Swat Valley.
Human Rights, Pakistan, Education, Taliban, Asia
Commenting has been disabled. To find out more, click here.
MORE FROM AL JAZEERA
Interactive, Child rights, Human Rights
United Kingdom, Racism, Europe
Environment, Canada, US & Canada
Visualising every Saudi coalition air raid on Yemen
Since March 2015, Saudi Arabia and a coalition of Arab states have launched more than 19,278 air raids across Yemen.
Yemen, Houthis, Saudi Arabia
United States, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Donald Trump, Mohammed bin Salman
Donald Trump, United States, US & Canada
Khashoggi messages show distrust of 'Beast Pac-Man' MBS
US, China declare trade war ceasefire
CNN: Facts first, just not on Israel
Poroshenko for 'Normandy format' talks with Russia
Pablo Escobar's legacy 25 years on: Tributes and disgust
US Navy's Middle East chief found dead in Bahrain
Macron tells PM to hold talks with protesters
G20 Summit 2018: All the latest updates
Moon: Trump says likes North Korea's Kim, will fulfill his wishes
'World is at a crossroads. Act now or risk disaster'
MUST-SEE PROGRAMMES
South Africa Corruption Inc
Investigating a major scandal that exposes the corrupt relationship between business and politics in South Africa.
South Africa, Jacob Zuma, Corruption
Daughters of al-Shabab
What draws Kenyan women to join al-Shabab and what challenges are they facing when they return to their communities?
Al-Shabab, Kenya, Women's Rights
Hungary: Europe's Bad Boy
We investigate why Hungary, under its authoritarian leader Viktor Orban, has repeatedly clashed with the European Union.
The Far Right, Hungary, Europe
The Men Who Stole the World: Inside the 2008 Financial Crisis
A look at how top executives on Wall Street helped trigger a global financial crisis - and how it may happen again.
Business & Economy, United States, Wall Street