Nativity Scenes Or Naïve Activity Scene?:
It's June, always a great time to get riled-up early about whether or not those nativity scenes with the mannequins should return to Palisades Park this Christmas. Before I launch into any discussion about that, you are probably owed a few disclaimers.
Full disclosure: I grew up Methodist in Wisconsin. Because of my age, I was a kid at a time when there was never any issue that the birth of Jesus might be represented in people's front yards by means of molded plastic figurines with light bulbs in them. We never had any of those in our own front yard, which instead featured flood lights and a plywood cut-out of the ubiquitous Coca Cola Santa, sans Coke bottle.
Second disclosure: My favorite statement on the meaning of Christmas continues to be the animated "A Charlie Brown Christmas" TV special. It's charming, beatnik hip, appealing, and funny. And it still manages to capture a true spirit of the holiday season if not the only spirit of the holidays for all. It may not surprise you to learn that initially execs at CBS Television were not big on the show. Then it aired as a special on Dec. 9, 1965 and drew in 15.4 million viewers, placing it second in the ratings that week after the western series "Bonanza." We'll return to the Peanuts gang in a moment.
It might be time to deal with some hard truths about the Palisades nativity scene dust-up. The decorations themselves, first displayed in 1953 and by mere dint of that somehow "traditional" for Santa Monica, now have a somewhat dingy and even bizarre appearance. To protect the mannequin scenes, each is covered with storm fencing that causes the entire display to look like the figures are being held for questioning. Any uplifting impact the display might have is, by my lights, mitigated by its real appearance.
America in 1953 was more like the Wisconsin neighborhood of my youth. Times have changed. We now recognize and accept that the time of the year we call "the holiday season" involves celebrations of all kinds, not just the story of the nativity. Yet I feel that any attempts to mitigate the Palisades display with balancing displays reflecting other views, whether fairly realized by a lottery or not, are doomed to only reduce the potential for the entire tableau to echo any sort of joy.
In dealing honestly with the Palisades display issue, it should be recognized by all sides that a city park public land venue holiday display that leans heavily on any one religion or religious view has an inherent advocacy or even proselytizing intent: It's just naïve to think otherwise. But it's in this simultaneously clear yet often murky area that Santa Monica struggles with the Palisades nativity issue. The Christian holiday of Christmas becomes "Christmas time," and that "time" becomes a default zone in which representations of the nativity seem natural and even correct. And then because that's been the case for decades, attacks on nativity representations become attacks on "tradition."
A few years back the folks that manage the Third Street Promenade invested in holiday decorations that featured a theme of ice and snow, beautifully evading any religious issues. While Christmas reds and greens appear here and there in the Promenade's display there's also a lot of blue ice and silver white snow, blue and silver/white being traditional Hanukkah colors. The Promenade loves the holiday season for obvious reasons, and most definitely does not intend to put-off any potential shoppers. I now find their wily navigation of potential conflicts to be contemporary and pleasing. I like the downtown temporary ice skating rink, open to skaters of all faiths, even better.
But a person who likes traditional holiday representation might quibble. And I don't think we need more plastic ice floes installed in Palisades Park. So what are we to do about the Palisades nativity scenes? There's a quandary in the City asserting that the nativity scenes be banned, because it will feel like a loss of freedom of speech no matter how you parse it. Yet I strongly disagree with those who assert that the loss of the nativity scenes would cause Santa Monica to lose a sense of community.
Allow me to call on Linus from the Peanuts gang to help me make a modest proposal. In the aforementioned TV special, Linus uses his endearing scratchy voice to remind Charlie Brown "what Christmas is all about." True, he then quotes from the Gospel of Luke. But Linus ends on this: "… and on earth, peace, good will toward men."
Linus of course meant women as well as the LGBT community; back in 1965, Linus was pressed for time. But how about peace as a theme for any display in Palisades Park? Could students be persuaded to contribute new displays that spoke to the global yearning for peace? Could Santa Monica artists be involved in the creation of new works for the season inspired by the simple notion that all unite in a wish for peace on earth? I don't know for certain that these new displays would all be cheerful or even bright. But they would, unlike our now perennial debates over the nativity scenes, be filled with a beautiful hope.
By mirrormmg June 2, 2012
"Between crafting COVID-era return-to-school plans, fine-tuning Distance Learning, developing major district-wide campus improvements, giving fair process to the Santa Monica High School History Building (slated to be bulldozed this summer along with the cafeteria, main administrative building, a gym, and a wide swath of mature trees and greenspace), and appointing a new member to fill the SMMUSD School Board vacancy, our School Board has a lot on its plate." Photo: Sam Catanzaro.
Education, News, Opinion, Santa Monica
January 7, 2021 SM.a.r.t
Between crafting COVID-era return-to-school plans, fine-tuning Distance Learning, developing major district-wide campus improvements, giving fair process to the Santa Monica...
"Without a comprehensive and realistic plan, our goose, as the saying goes, will be cooked, and the ever-expanding infrastructure costs will impose an increasingly heavy burden on our residents and businesses. The denser the city gets, the less room we have for mistakes in planning," writes SMa.r.t. their latest column. Photo: Sam Catanzaro.
Development, News, Opinion
[We wrote this article 6.5 years ago. Today, the issues it raises continue to bedevil the city, and with more...
"Wishes can be realized only if our community stands together and the new City Council does what's required in order to move our city back to common sense solutions, directions and sustainable goals." Photo: Sam Catanzaro.
December 24, 2020 SM.a.r.t
It's that time of year again, but tragically this year so many things are staggeringly different and difficult on many...
"This City Council vote signals a City that is moving toward meeting the real needs of its residents instead of the needs of developers. It represents the residents flexing their muscles to take back their City and preserve its beach side charm," writes SMa.r.t. on the ending of The Plaza at Santa Monica development.
SMa.r.t. Column: Citizen Victory!
Tuesday night Santa Claus brought Santa Monica a gift that we have waited 7 years for. That evening the City...
"In reality the City does not have a housing problem. It permits annually about twice the amount of housing it needs to absorb its natural growth, but it cannot produce enough AFFORDABLE housing for the full spectrum of its current residents' incomes," writes Mario Fonda-Bonardi in the latest SMart Column. Photo: Sam Catanzaro.
News, Opinion, Real Estate, Santa Monica
Santa Monica Under SCAG's Boot
As most of you know the Southern California Association of Governments (SCAG) is now forcing Santa Monica to permit 8873...
"We want our ship to stop taking on water. We need to act with the utmost urgency as we bring residents back to the seat of power in the City of Santa Monica," writes councilmember-elect Phil Brock in the latest SMa.r.t. Column. Photo: Sam Catanzaro.
News, Opinion
SMart Column: A Better Ship of State
December 3, 2020 SM.a.r.t
On Tuesday, December 8th, shortly after 5:30 PM, Oscar de la Torre, Christine Parra, and I will be among the...
SMa.r.t. Column: Our Brave New World: How the Residents Can Help Realize Their Goals
November 27, 2020 SM.a.r.t
As the weather chills, we enter a Holiday Season like no other that the City of Santa Monica has seen...
Santa Monica High School's History Building, circa mid-century. Photo: National Archives and Records Administration.
SMa.r.t. Column: Saving Our History Building
SMart has always looked for ways to do more with less and to live within our means on our way...
"there will be a renewed focus on the city's financial integrity, crime and safety, and responsiveness to specific concerns expressed by very many local residents," writes SMa.r.t. in their latest column. Photo: Sam Catanzaro
SMa.r.t. Column: Election's Over–Let's get to Work
The extraordinary results of our municipal election signal a deep desire, by many residents, for a change in the city's...
"This has been a historic election because once every 10 years an incumbent is upset in a Santa Monica City Council race: this year you may have upset three incumbents!" writes SMa.r.t. in their latest column. Photo: Getty.
Opinion, Santa Monica
SMa.r.t. Column: The Big Upset
November 9, 2020 SM.a.r.t
Dear Faithful readers of the SMart Column, For over seven years you have loaned us your attention about City planning,...
"This election, unlike all previous elections, has provided the residents with a clear choice in the determination of our future quality of life. In may ways, it is our last chance to significantly influence the imminent major decisions that will impact our lives for decades to come," writes SMart in their latest column. Photo: Sam Catanzaro.
SMa.r.t. Column: The Opportunity to Re-unite the Residents with their City"
October 29, 2020 SM.a.r.t
As election season draws to a close, we are all deciding on how to best to provide for our city's,...
"The focus of our city government seems to always be how to grow the city, how to build it up. No one listens to the neighborhood associations that are the voice of the residents of our city. Wouldn't it be an act of healing for our city council, our planners and our city staff to take a holistic approach to the city…to listen to all residents and preserve what has made us such an enviable Paradise?" writes SMart in their column. Photo: Getty
SMa.r.t. Column: Santa Monica's Divine Comedy
[SMa.r.t. originally published this article four years ago. We believe it remains current, with slight alterations. The elections, in the...
Santa Monica City Hall. Photo: Sam Catanzaro
City Council Endorsements: Santa Monica Needs a Change
October 22, 2020 Sam Catanzaro
Santa Monica City Council endorsements from the Santa Monica Mirror The following are two endorsement articles from Santa Monica Mirror...
"This election will be Santa Monica's most consequential in decades. Let's turn this election into an opportunity! We need to preserve our beachfront community with its low scale and natural environment and live within our means!" writes SMa.r.t. in their latest column. Photos: Ron Goldman.
Development, News, Opinion, Santa Monica
SMa.r.t. Column: Which Santa Monica Do You Prefer to Live & Work In?
Santa Monica's Governance Last I heard, we are a country "by the people and for the people." But Santa Monica...