Zeller, Bruno
International commercial law conventions (or "transnational law") increasingly have become the legal device of choice regulating international commercial transactions. These treaties contain substantive provisions that define the legal entitlements of parties to transactions within their scope. At the same time, they also mandate how the treaty's text is to be interpreted. In particular, international commercial law conventions require that uniformity be taken into account in interpreting the text. UNCITRAL conventions, such as the CISG, are the most prominent example of these international commercial law conventions. An international convention, once ratified, displaces domestic law to the extent that domestic law is inconsistent with the convention's provisions. But the incorporation of international commercial law conventions into domestic law has a further legal consequence. Its incorporation adds a method of textual interpretation for transnational law—"the uniformity directive"--to the methods in force in domestic law for the interpretation of treaties. As a result, the interpretation of transnational law texts relies on both generally applicable methods of treaty interpretation and interpretive methods specific to transnational instruments. We maintain that international commercial conventions, once incorporated into domestic law, make legal interpretation more difficult and its results less predictable. Textual interpretation of transnational law is made more difficult not because transnational law introduces substantive rules into a legal system that differ from those of domestic law. Any incorporation of transnational law into national law does this. Instead, transnational law makes its interpretation more complex and less predictable because it introduces an interpretive method that differs from the methods for interpreting treaties generally. The increased difficulty in interpretation is exhibited in the tendency to rely on well-known domestic law methods to interpret transnational law.
Steven D. Walt & Bruno Zeller, Interpretation Revisited—Has Transnational Law Complicated the Interpretive Mandate? (2021).
Biden Administration Pushes for Multilateral Cooperation and Domestic Action to Combat Climate Change
Kristen Eichensehr
On August 9, 2021, the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) released a report scientifically establishing that "[c]limate change is... MORE
Tax Law as Foreign Policy
Andrew Hayashi
Ashley S. Deeks
The use of economic statecraft is at a high-water mark. The United States uses sanctions, tariffs, and import and export controls more than ever... MORE
Huawei's Meng Wanzhou Released to China After Entering into Deferred Prosecution Agreement with U.S. Justice Department
On September 24, 2021, Canadian authorities released Meng Wanzhou, Chief Financial Officer of Huawei Technologies and daughter of its founder, to... MORE
The United States, Australia, and the United Kingdom Announce "AUKUS" Alliance Focused on Indo-Pacific Security
On September 15, the United States took concrete steps to shift its security and defense focus to the Indo-Pacific region by announcing a new "... MORE
United States Grapples with Aftermath of Withdrawal from Afghanistan
On August 31, 2021, President Joseph R. Biden, Jr. announced that the war in Afghanistan was over. Before departing, U.S. forces evacuated roughly... MORE
The Legitimacy of International Law
Assessing the legitimacy of any legal system is hard, but especially if the system in question is the volatile and contested field of international... MORE
Antibribery Law
The first part of this chapter describes the rise of transborder antibribery law in this century against the background of its twentieth century... MORE
Has China's Labor Contract Law Curtailed Economic Growth?
J. H. Verkerke
As China reformed its economy during the past 44 years, it experienced the fastest sustained expansion by a major economy in history, with an annual... MORE
United States Indicts Iranian and Chinese Government Agents for Targeting Individuals in the United States
In July 2021, the U.S. Department of Justice announced two indictments charging Iranian and Chinese government officials and others acting at their... MORE
Contemporary Practice of the United States Relating to International Law
A section of the American Journal of International Law
Transnational Civil Litigation: Principles and Prospects
George Rutherglen
This text on transnational civil litigation presents the basic legal doctrine within a larger, illuminating conceptual framework. The book organizes... MORE
Biden Administration Continues Efforts to Change Immigration Policy Amidst Surges of Migrants and Court Losses
After quickly reversing a number of Trump-era policies related to immigration, the Biden administration has struggled to deal with large numbers of... MORE
The Fine Print on the Global Tax Deal: Domestic Politics Could Prevent Sweeping Reform
Ruth Mason
The global tax deal endorsed by world leaders at the recent G-20 meeting in Rome reflects the adage "To retain tax sovereignty, a state must... MORE
The Duty of Creditors to Cooperate in Sovereign Debt Workouts
Lenders are perfectly free to decide for themselves whether, when, how, to whom and on what terms they will extend credit to a sovereign borrower.... MORE
U.S. Withdraws from Afghanistan as the Taliban Take Control
Nearly twenty years after the U.S. military began operations against the Taliban in Afghanistan, President Joseph R. Biden reported on August 31,... MORE
United States Joins with Allies, Including NATO, to Attribute Malicious Cyber Activities to China
In July, the United States, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), the European Union (EU), and other allies attributed a variety of... MORE
United States Sanctions Belarus for Diversion of Ryanair Flight and Ongoing Repression
On May 23, 2021, Belarusian authorities forced a Ryanair flight from Athens, Greece to Vilnius, Lithuania to land in Minsk in response to a false... MORE
Biden Administration Rescinds Sanctions Against International Criminal Court Officials
On April 1, 2021, the Biden administration issued an executive order reversing the Trump administration's sanctions on International Criminal Court (... MORE