Steven Can Plan
Writing about cities
Find GIS Data
Working with GIS Data
Streetsblog Chicago – transit
Chicago Cityscape – buildings
Bike Product Reviews
Move Chicago – 2019 mayoral platform
The high rises of the Bronzeville lakefront
Two-flat owner journal 1: Peoples Gas charges a lot of money for no gas
What is this place? Des Plaines "park" edition
Chicago bonfire rules
More on Flickr »
Chicagoland's massive parking footprint – as measured on December 25, 2019 – Steven Can Plan on Chicagoland's massive parking footprint – as measured on September 16, 2018
Biss gives a short speech about good city-building policies – Steven Can Plan on Don't know who to vote for? Start your research using my friends voter guide!
Planning for People: Land Use - Transport Nexus on Chicago's TOD rule is the only reason multi-family is being built in neighborhoods
Under-Zoning Is Exacerbating Displacement Pressure Around The 606 – Streetsblog Chicago on Upzone the 606
Steven Vance on Upzone the 606
Open Access (18)
Karachi (2)
Washington, D.C. (2)
Construction Updates (15)
Research/Study (26)
Page 2 (10)
Places and Spaces (128)
Neighborhoods (39)
Readers Ask (2)
Construction & Demolition (4)
School Assignments (9)
States (38)
File Conversion (6)
Web Applications (22)
Bicycling (263)
Bike Parking (27)
Bikes and Transit (14)
High Speed Rail (11)
Roadways (96)
Street Design (33)
Urban Rail (53)
Urban Planning (220)
Urban Design (67)
"My" new bike racks have appeared at CTA and Metra stations
April 26, 2012 / Steven Vance / 0 Comments
I received some exciting news last week in the form of a photo a friend posted to Twitter. He took it at the Chicago Transit Authority (CTA) Loyola Red Line station and it features a double deck bike rack from Dero.
Photo by Erik Swedlund.
Erik didn't know this, but that bike rack was installed there because of a project I worked on at the Chicago Department of Transportation (CDOT) in 2009. The working title was something like "bike parking RTA ICE grant". That means an Innovation, Coordination, and Enhancement grant from the Regional Transportation Authority. It was also known as round 2 of transit bike parking. You might know round 1 as the project that put hard-to-use double deck bike racks at four CTA stations: Midway Orange (well used), Sox-35th Red (mostly well used), Damen Blue (not used), and Jefferson Park Blue (mostly well used) – all opened in 2008. Round 1 was paid for by CMAQ funding CDOT received in 2003.
The scope of my involvement was limited to finding stations "at which sheltered, high-capacity bike parking will be used most effectively". Looking back, that should probably have said, "will be most used". What does "used most effectively" even mean? The scope did not include deciding what the bike parking area would look like, or how many spaces there would be. That was up to an engineer who was managing the overall grant and project – I just recommended stations.
Summary of my methodology
I developed my own method (after researching the method for round 1 selections, and other methods) to select several train stations geographically distributed around the city where bike parking would be most used. I developed a spreadsheet and inputted the station attributes my method required. The formula then ranked the stations. The outcome I wanted was essentially a number that represented the likelihood of people cycling to that station. I tweaked the formula many times based on what rankings it came up with and whether or not the top ranked stations fit expectations I came up with for a station that would have a lot of people cycling there (access mode data didn't exist at all for CTA stations, and was old for most Metra stations).
For example, if my formula ranked Pulaski Orange very high, did that station fit the expectations of a station that attracted a lot of CTA passengers to arrive by bicycle?
After coming up with a "top 30" of geographically diverse CTA and Metra stations, my boss and I rented an I-GO car to visit 15 of them to record measurements of physically available space, take photographs, and discuss things like how people might access the station with their bicycles (it wasn't always clear, and many stations turned out to have sufficient bike parking for the amount of people who cycled there).
To make this project respect geography, and to do it as simply as possible, I divided the stations into north and south categories, separated by Madison Street. Stations in the south category were compared only with fellow south stations. I don't know if this was an appropriate to consider geographic equity, but I had limited time and resources to develop a method and complete this project. In other words, I did the best I could and I think I did a pretty good job. Hopefully time will tell and I can learn from successes and mistakes with this project. That it's actually being constructed makes me very happy.
Considering the stations
Lots of u-racks at the 55th-56th-57th Metra station in Hyde Park. Photo by Eric Rogers.
I recommended that bike racks for the 55th-56th-57th Street station be installed at 57th Street because it has more space than the other entrances. Here's what else I said about the space:
North side of 57th St, east of station house
This space is very large like Space C, but it's extremely grungy and dank. The restaurant in the station house is currently storing its garbage bins here. The space receives natural light all day because of a gap in the viaduct. There's an attendant at this station house on weekdays from 6 AM to 2:30 PM, but this person has NO view of the space. 57th St is one-way east of Lake Park Ave, and two-way west of Lake Park Ave.
Sheltered, except for gap in the viaduct roof.
I'm happy to report that the situation has been improved over the description in my "station profile": the sidewalk concrete was replaced, and the walls and pylons were cleaned and painted white. The restaurant's garbage bins were moved east in the open air (not under the viaduct). Another change was at Loyola Red Line station: I recommended they be installed in one of two outdoor locations but the bike racks were installed inside the station house.
The other tier 1 locations in my recommendation were Western Orange Line and 95th Red Line (both CTA). Howard Red Line was a tier 2 station (and is built), along with Ravenswood Metra and Logan Square Blue Line. I found out later that the Howard Red Line station also received some double deck racks. Ravenswood station is being completely replaced soon so I understand why that didn't get any new bike parking as part of this project. I don't know why Logan Square Blue Line didn't receive any, if Howard did. It might be that there wasn't enough money in the $375,000 grant, or that someone has other plans for the CTA station.
A sixth station was part of the project, but not part of my recommendations. The Clybourn Metra station (2001 N Ashland, serving both the UP-North and UP-Northwest lines) was already in planning and design phases and was included in the RTA ICE grant round 2 project to complete the funding arrangement. The bike parking area at Clybourn was to be paid for by Chicago TIF funds; combining the TIF funds with the RTA ICE grant would provide the local match the RTA ICE grant needed (requiring a local match is typical).
See more photos and information on Grid Chicago.
Categories: Bike Parking, News, Transit, Urban Planning
Tags: analysis, bike parking, CDOT, CTA, Dero, methodology, Metra, RTA
« Tucson's neighborhood friendly ordinances My new favorite traffic crash impact analogy, as heard at a meeting about a road diet »
© 2021 Steven Can Plan