It's funny, you say that since he doesn't have power in the minors that his OBP will go down because pitchers won't fear him. Hmmm…I've heard that argument before, but where? That's exactly what they said about Gardner and I think he's had himself a fine rookie season and is likely to just get better. He isn't backing down because he can't hit for power. It just means more singles.
Steve, I am assuming this post is in response to my comment from yesterday. If I am wrong, I apologize, but if I am, please re-read it. I did not say I want Posada gone. I said I want him where he belongs, a DH. As for Cervellis stats, theres is no arguing that. The only thing I can say is, the kid (wow, I can't believe I am saying that) is 23. I would like to see a little bigger sample before writing his offense off.
With both Hideki Matsui and Johnny Damon due to become free agents, I don't think it's entirely out of the question to consider a Miranda/Duncan platoon to fill one of those spots.
While I wholeheartedly agree that Cervelli – at least for now – is no better than a solid backup catcher, I disagree with you attempt to link Molina to missing the playoffs last season. There were a number of factors that contributed to that, and honestly if we had our starting pitching in decent shape, we likely could have contended with Molina.
Posada should remain the Yankees starter next year. He may not be a great defender, but they've been a very good team with him over the past decade because of his hitting. Offense may be that very reason the Yankees are not overly concerned about a future with Jesus Montero behind the plate. His upside suggests he'll be a better hitter than Posada, who is one of the best-hitting catchers ever.
Cervelli's future is not as a starter; it's as a back-up catcher. Molina's days on the Yankees are nearing the end as the Yankees can have Cervelli take his role and save about $2 million in the process.
For all the Posada "defensive" detractors: Did you see last night second out in the bottom of the ninth?. As i saw the game Mo was getting in deep trouble and a great shot to Cano put away the Angel�s pinch hitter and clears the scenario for the win.
Cervelli, no doubt, is the future and has to back up Posada for at least two more seasons. We can say good bye to Molina with no worries.