What streaming services do you use?
Which device has the best app for catch up.
On the firetv the channel 4 app works, but on the nowtv the same app lets you sign in and have favourites etc.
The newer black Now Tv box is very quick for catchup - iPlayer, All4 etc.
All4 has improved, but it has so many adverts that I do try and use my Humax freesat for channel 4 - I use All4 as a last resort.
Its annoying that the Amazon devices don't have Now TV on them and ITV player/5 on demand are not on all boxes either.
Would be good to have one solution - its currently not possible - unless you go down the route of creating something bespoke (i.e. Mac Mini) or hacked.
I think a Roku box hits all the boxes for me, Amazon, Netflix and NowTV, just haven't got round to bothering to do anything about it.
The latest Roku 4 does have optical - but its not come out in the UK yet.