Your task is to predict the verdict of a claim based on the provided question-answer pair evidence. The possible labels are: 'Supported', 'Refuted', 'Not Enough Evidence', 'Conflicting Evidence/Cherrypicking'. Justify your answer using the provided evidence and select the correct label.

Claim: The South African Government have recently built 4 million houses.

Q1: How many houses has the South African Government delivered in South Africa ?
A1: 1. 2018/19 figures are for 9 months only (April to Dec 2018) and are preliminary;
2. EEDBS* (or DBS): Enhanced Extended Discount Benefit Scheme refers to the Housing Programme
that provides state subsidies to repair / rehabilitate and even demolish & re‐build where necessary,
Govt (rental) houses built before 1994 and then transfer houses into the ownership of legitimate occupants.
3. In some years, such as 2014/15, 2016/17 and 2017/18, the numbers for EEDBS were removed after
verification processes from the figure for Units as they are to be counted only under the EEDBS programme.
4. Twenty Year totals are still: Serviced Sites Houses/ Units Total H/O
903 543 2 835 275 3 738 818

Q2: How many people own property in South Africa ?
A2: Between 2002 and 2015, the percentage of households that lived in formal dwellings and whose dwellings
were fully owned increased from 52,9% to 53,8% while the percentage of partially owned dwellings
declined from 15,5% to 9,7%. About 13,6% of households had ‘other’ forms of tenure arrangements in
2015.
More than three-quarters (78,1%) of South African households lived in formal dwellings, followed by 14,1%
who lived in informal dwellings, and 6,9% in traditional dwellings. The highest concentration of households
in Limpopo (90,5%) lived in formal dwellings, followed by the households in Northern Cape (86,1%). The
highest percentage of informal dwellings were found in North West (22%) and Gauteng (21%).
At the time of the survey, 14,4% of South African households were living in ‘RDP’ or state-subsidised
dwellings. A higher percentage of female-headed (18%) than male-headed households (12%) received a
government housing subsidy. Some residents have, however, raised concerns about the quality of
subsidised houses and 14,2% said that the walls were weak or very weak while 13,8% regarded the
dwellings’ roofs as weak or very weak.
user
justification: The source in the first answer shows that 3 263 331 were built in 24 years so the claim is refuted as the number is below 4 million. 24 years is not classed as recently either.

verdict: 'Refuted'
assistant