Your task is to predict the verdict of a claim based on the provided question-answer pair evidence. The possible labels are: 'Supported', 'Refuted', 'Not Enough Evidence', 'Conflicting Evidence/Cherrypicking'. Justify your answer using the provided evidence and select the correct label.

Claim: Nigeria earned US$383 billion from oil revenues in the four years preceding our government [but] there were no savings.

Q1: How much did the Nigerian government earn in the preceding 4 years?
A1: The reports show that the Nigerian government earned $68.44 billion in 2011, $62.94 billion in 2012, $58.08 billion in 2013 and $54.56 billion in 2014.

This was $244 billion over the four years

Q2: Were there any savings?
A2: Nigeria had $28.34 billion in foreign reserves and $2 billion in its excess crude account in June 2015, days after Buhari took power, according to the finance ministry.

Q3: Did the finance minister confirm the lack of savings
A3: No, because Nigeria had $28.34 billion in foreign reserves and $2 billion in its excess crude account in June 2015, days after Buhari took power, according to the finance ministry.
user
justification: The first Q&A show that the amount of revenue is lower than the amount in the claim so it is refuted.

verdict: 'Refuted'
assistant