Your task is to predict the verdict of a claim based on the provided question-answer pair evidence. The possible labels are: 'Supported', 'Refuted', 'Not Enough Evidence', 'Conflicting Evidence/Cherrypicking'. Justify your answer using the provided evidence and select the correct label.

Claim: COVID-19 Infection rates in Allegany, Cattaraugus and Chautauqua counties have consistently been among the lowest in the state.

Q1: What is the infection rate in the Allegany, Cattaraugus and Chautauqua counties
A1: 30 in Allegany, 
34 in Cattaraugus and 
25 in Chautauqua

Q2: Which counties  have the highest prevalence
A2: NYC with 138, 806
Nassau with 30, 677
Suffolk with 27, 662
Westchester with 24, 306

Q3: How do these three counties in the claim compare with the remaining counties in New York State based on published COVID-19 positive result data at the time?
A3: Up to May 11, 2020 data from Governor Cuomo of New York State for COVID-19 total positive figures by state in ascending order.

From COVID-19 Infection rate data for 58 counties; Allegany, Chautauqua, and Cattaraugus counties as referenced in the in the claim rank 8th, 9th & 13th respectively from the bottom of NY state county data.

Therefore these three counties fall in the bottom 1/4 of results for the 58 counties listed with data.

County - Total Positive
Hamilton - 5
Schuyler - 7
Lewis - 11
Franklin - 17
Yates - 21
Cortland - 29
Essex - 32
Allegany - 38
Chautauqua - 41
Schoharie - 46
Seneca - 49
Cayuga - 60
Cattaraugus - 61
Delaware - 65
Montgomery - 67
Otsego - 67
Jefferson - 68
Oswego - 75
Clinton - 76
Wyoming - 77
Herkimer - 81
Wayne - 81
Livingston - 102
Ontario - 107
Tioga - 107
Fulton - 109
Chenango - 111
Orleans - 130
Chemung - 131
Tompkins - 132
Genesee - 173
St. Lawrence - 190
Greene - 206
Washington - 210
Warren - 217
Steuben - 228
Madison - 251
Columbia - 314
Broome - 378
Saratoga - 403
Rensselaer - 411
Schenectady - 575
Niagara - 655
Oneida - 669
Putnam - 1098
Sullivan - 1109
Onondaga - 1287
Ulster - 1454
Albany - 1456
Monroe - 1850
Dutchess - 3378
Erie - 4483
Orange - 9584
Rockland - 12484
Westchester - 31384
Suffolk - 36911
Nassau - 38337
NYC - 185357
user
justification: The answer and source show that the 3 counties have been in the lowest quarter of all the counties so the claim is supported.

verdict: 'Supported'
assistant