Your task is to predict the verdict of a claim based on the provided question-answer pair evidence. The possible labels are: 'Supported', 'Refuted', 'Not Enough Evidence', 'Conflicting Evidence/Cherrypicking'. Justify your answer using the provided evidence and select the correct label.

Claim: Former health secretary Janette Garin points to Senator Risa Hontiveros as the root cause of the current anomalies involving the Philippine Health Insurance Corporation.

Q1: current anomalies involving the Philippine Health Insurance Corporation?
A1: Unnecessary procedures Doctors in some clinics performed "unnecessary" procedures just so they can claim more benefits from the Philippine Health Insurance Corporation (PhilHealth), health officials said on Wednesday, July 8.

Q2: When did these allegations occur?
A2: Reports go as far back as 2006.  CNN’s “The Source” episode posted on its official website on June 12, 2019, Garin talked about how PhilHealth has been infested with corruption issues even before she took office.

Q3: Was Hontiveros on PhilHealth's board of directors at this time?
A3: Hontiveros, on the other hand, only joined PhilHealth’s board of directors from November 2014 to October 2015. She then stepped down to file her certificate of candidacy for the senatorial elections in 2016. Moreover, Hontiveros has sought an investigation into the PhilHealth funds that supposedly went to a dialysis center that claimed benefits for “ghost patients.”
user
justification: The answers and sources show that there were allegations before Senator Hontiveros so the claim is refuted.

verdict: 'Refuted'
assistant