Your task is to predict the verdict of a claim based on the provided question-answer pair evidence. The possible labels are: 'Supported', 'Refuted', 'Not Enough Evidence', 'Conflicting Evidence/Cherrypicking'. Justify your answer using the provided evidence and select the correct label.

Claim: Sen. Cory Booker claimed private insurance overhead was 15 percent, while Medicare’s was “only at 2 percent.”

Q1: What were Medicare's admin expenses as a percentage of total expenses in 2018?
A1: 1.3%

Q2: How does the overhead charge for healthcare compare to the admin cost of healthcare?
A2: Comparing data for the public Medicare with private Medicare, we show that the administrative expenses percentage of benefits for the public system is much lower.
The definitions are incompatible and not reconcilable between the systems.
We expand the focus to more financial data. Per-member income and benefits are larger for the public Medicare and grew faster than Medicare Part C, reversing earlier trends. The public Medicare is not solvent in many years, whereas the insurers’ Medicare has an 85% loss ratio.

Q3: Are there other reasons that these numbers are incomparable.
A3: Yes, because Medicare beneficiaries are all age 65 or over, or disabled, and on average have much larger medical bills than the mostly under-65 population served by private health insurance. A 2006 study estimated that in 2003, the average medical cost for Medicare was $6,600 per person per year while the average medical cost for private health insurance (excluding out-of-pocket costs) was less than half that — $2,700 per person per year.

Q4: Did Sen. Cory Booker actually claim this?
A4: Yes, because The debate season for the 2020 presidential election kicked off with 10 Democratic candidates taking the stage in Miami and exaggerating or garbling the facts on Iran, wages, Medicare, the opioid crisis and guns.
user
justification: Q&A 4 states that the claim was made by the person as claimed in the claim, 
Q&A 1 states that Medicare's overhead is only 1.3% not 2 as claimed, (0.7%diffrence)
Q&A 3 shows that actually The definitions are incompatible and not reconcilable between the systems. so comparing Medicares overhead cost  to private health cares in this way is incorrect, with Q&A 3 listing good points why these figures are incompatible in the way claim shows.


verdict: 'Conflicting Evidence/Cherrypicking'
assistant