Update 2  
  
- I hired a PI and came to the conclusion Adnan Syed did it
- Jay is Mr. X 
- Mail-Crimp is the best service  
  
Update 2.1  
  
- Thank you to [Tappanga](http://www.reddit.com/user/Tappanga) for the gold.   I've never really watched *Boy Meets World*, but thank you for spending that sweet, sweet TV money for this.