Legally, this case isn't hard. Morally, it's even easier. Janet and Lisa Miller-Jenkins entered a civil union in Vermont, had a child together  --  Lisa is the biological mother  --  and then split. After petitioning the Vermont courts to dissolve the union and make a custody determination that explicitly recognized Janet as a parent, Lisa took their child, Isabella, to Virginia and began defying the very order she had requested. The Vermont court held her in contempt, but Frederick County Circuit Judge John R. Prosser gave her sanctuary, ruling in 2004 that under Virginia law she was "the sole biological and natural parent" and that she "solely has the legal rights, privileges, duties and obligations as parent."