Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Significant progress has been made in using remote sensing as a means of acquiring information about wetlands. This research provides a brief review of selected previous works, which address the issues of wetland identification, classification, biomass measurement, and change detection. Suggested new research emphases include compiling basic spectral‐reflectance characteristics for individual wetland species by means of close‐range instrumentation, analyzing canopies architectures to facilitate species identification, and assessing the impact on composite spectral signatures of wet soils and variable depths of standing water beneath emergent canopies. These research foci are justifiable when considered in the context of environmental change / variability and the production of trace gases. <s> BIB001 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Mire monitoring can be facilitated through a combined use of high resolution imagery and objectbased mapping. We demonstrate a mapping methodology in which multiple scales of image-objects within a single aerial photograph are delineated through segmentation and, in a second step, heuristics are encoded to hierarchically link the image-objects. Through this linking, knowledge specific to the local mire ecology and its state of integrity is integrated into a hierarchical ‘rule base’. The recursive and hierarchical modelling of image-objects to ‘real’ objects, we hypothesize, allows us to capture ecological processes of interest better than pixel-based image analysis. We call the methodology multiscale segmentation / object-relationship modelling (MSS/ORM). We suggest that this expert-based methodology should transfer neatly to other international wetland monitoring programmes. <s> BIB002 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> An approach to classification of satellite images aimed at vegetation mapping in a wetland ecosystem has been presented. The wetlands of the Biebrza Valley located in the NE part of Poland has been chosen as a site of interest. The difficulty of using satellite images for the classification of a wetland land cover lies in the strong variability of the hydration state of such ecosystem in time. Satellite images acquired by optical or microwave sensors depend heavily on the current water level which often masks the most interesting long-time scale features of vegetation. Therefore the images have to be interpreted in the context of various ancillary data related to the investigated site. In the case of Biebrza Valley the most useful information was obtained from the soil and hydration maps as well as from the old vegetation maps. The object oriented classification approach applied in eCognition software enabled simultaneous use of satellite images together with the additional thematic data. Some supplementary knowledge concerning possible plant cover changes was also introduced into the process of classification. The accuracy of the classification was assessed versus ground-truth data and results of visual interpretation of aerial photos. The achieved accuracy depends on the type of vegetation community in question and is better for forest or shrubs than for meadows. <s> BIB003 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> To conserve and manage wetland resources, it is important to inventoryand monitor wetlands and their adjacent uplands. Satellite remote sensing hasseveral advantages for monitoring wetland resources, especially for largegeographic areas. This review summarizes the literature on satellite remotesensing of wetlands, including what classification techniques were mostsuccessful in identifying wetlands and separating them from other land covertypes. All types of wetlands have been studied with satellite remote sensing.Landsat MSS, Landsat TM, and SPOT are the major satellite systems that have beenused to study wetlands; other systems are NOAA AVHRR, IRS-1B LISS-II and radarsystems, including JERS-1, ERS-1 and RADARSAT. Early work with satellite imageryused visual interpretation for classification. The most commonly used computerclassification method to map wetlands is unsupervised classification orclustering. Maximum likelihood is the most common supervised classificationmethod. Wetland classification is difficult because of spectral confusion withother landcover classes and among different types of wetlands. However,multi-temporal data usually improves the classification of wetlands, as doesancillary data such as soil data, elevation or topography data. Classifiedsatellite imagery and maps derived from aerial photography have been comparedwith the conclusion that they offer different but complimentary information.Change detection studies have taken advantage of the repeat coverage andarchival data available with satellite remote sensing. Detailed wetland maps canbe updated using satellite imagery. Given the spatial resolution of satelliteremote sensing systems, fuzzy classification, subpixel classification, spectralmixture analysis, and mixtures estimation may provide more detailed informationon wetlands. A layered, hybrid or rule-based approach may give better resultsthan more traditional methods. The combination of radar and optical data providethe most promise for improving wetland classification. <s> BIB004 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> This article deals with the development and application of a cartographic database for a synoptic Geographic Information System (GIS). Its purpose is the storage and evaluation of the heterogeneous datasets of the interdisciplinary scientific research program MADAM (Mangrove Dynamics and Management), which aims to develop recommendations for a tailored integrated coastal management scheme for the mangrove ecosystem at Braganca (North Brazil). The article describes the integration of remote sensing data, aerial photographs, as well as point data provided by fieldwork from different scientific fields. Using various innovative processing techniques and different scale-resolution levels, an assessment of temporal–spatial changes of the mangrove peninsula and the adjacent rural socioeconomic impact area, the type of mangrove structure, as well as a land-use cover analyses was undertaken. The definition of the spatial level of detail was found to be a major issue in the development of the GIS, as well as during the processing and analysis procedures. A division between strong and weak patterns in the mangrove ecosystem could be made, which implies different management measures and sets of specific interdisciplinary studies and monitoring at hierarchical scales. <s> BIB005 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Up-to-date information on the distribution and changes associated with wetlands is essential for their effective conservation and management. Satellite remote sensing is arguably the only practical way for mapping and monitoring wetlands in a timely manner over a large area, and therefore has been chosen by the Canadian Wetland Inventory (CWI) initiative to map Canada's wetlands and by the Environment and Sustainable Development Indicators (ESDI) initiative to monitor the extent of wetlands indicators. As a contribution to these initiatives, this paper presents a rule-based wetland mapping method using Landsat-7/ETM+, two-season Radarsat-1/SAR images and DEM data. Three study sites in eastern Canada were selected to test this new method. The test results indicate that the classification accuracy of the new method ranges from 71% to 92%, for open bog, open fen, treed bog, marsh and swamp at the three sites. In comparison, two traditional methods based on Landsat-7/ETM+ alone or both Landsat-7/ETM+ and Rada... <s> BIB006 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Boreal forests and wetlands play an important role in the climate system, in particular through biosphere-atmosphere flux exchanges. They are an important pool of carbon and their role as sink or source of greenhouse gases is not fully understood. Accurate mapping of the vegetation of Siberia can therefore contribute to a better understanding of these processes at regional scale and of their effects on the climate through regional biosphere modeling. The potential of the combination of radar data with medium-resolution optical data to obtain regional-scale land cover mapping is investigated using multi-spectral imagery from the MERIS sensor at 300 m resolution and a high resolution radar mosaic (pixel spacing of 100 m) covering Western and Eastern Siberia compiled in the framework of the Global Boreal Forest Mapping project. For this purpose, capabilities of oriented-object image analysis associated to wavelet multi-resolution techniques are investigated. Results show that wavelet multi-resolution textures bring relevant additional information for land cover classification. Suggestions are made for the implementation of an object-based wavelet multi-resolution texture estimator. <s> BIB007 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> The Canadian Wildlife Service, Quebec region, of Environment Canada tested a multiscale object-based classification method on two test sites using satellite images to map wetlands in the context of the Canadian Wetland Inventory (CWI). The objective of this study was to assess the method most adapted for the Canadian inventory program to map five wetland classes (bog, fen, swamp, marsh, and shallow water), for a minimal geographical unit of 1 ha, from RADARSAT-1 and Landsat-7 enhanced thematic mapper (ETM) data. The top-down object-based classification selected was based on the Canadian Wetland Classification System and identifies quickly and precisely the ecologically meaningful polygons of wetlands. Validation was done on two levels: (i) between “other” versus “wetland” and (ii) between each class of wetland. Global accuracy values for the first level are greater than 80% for both test sites and about 76% and 67%, respectively, for the two sites for the second level. This approach is well adapted to wet... <s> BIB008 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> ARTICLE I NFO This study examines the effectiveness of using multi-temporal satellite imagery, field spectral data, and LiDAR top of canopy data to classify and map the common plant communities of the Ragged Rock Creek marsh, located near the mouth of the Connecticut River. Visible to near-infrared (VNIR) reflectance spectra were measured in the field over the 2004-2006 growing seasons to assess the phenological variability of the dominant marsh plant species, Spartina patens, Phragmites australis and Typha spp. Phragmites was best distinguished from other species by its high NIR response late in the growing season. Typha spp. had a high red/green ratio and S. patens had a unique green/blue ratio relative to other species throughout the bulk of the growing season. The field spectra and single date (2004) LiDAR canopy height data were used to define an object-oriented classification methodology for the three plant communities in multi-temporal QuickBird multispectral imagery collected over the same time interval. The classification was validated using an extensive field inventory of marsh species. Overall maximum fuzzy accuracy for the classification was 97% for Phragmites, 63% for Typha spp. and 80% for S. patens meadows and improved to 97%, 76%, and 92%, respectively, using a fuzzy acceptable match measure. This study demonstrated the importance of the timing of image acquisition for the identification of targeted plant species in a heterogeneous marsh. These datasets and protocols may provide coastal resource managers, municipal officials and researchers a set of recommended guidelines for remote sensing data collection for marsh inventory and monitoring. <s> BIB009 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> (Studies on greenhouse gases (GHG) emitted by hydroelectric reservoirs have shown until now that the fate of carbon, following impoundment, seems to reach the fate of carbon in natural aquatic ecosystems after a decade or so. To adequately assess this assumption and then obtain the net GHG emissions from the Eastmain-1 hydroelectric reservoir, the carbon stock and GHG emissions from peatlands and different succession stages of forested areas need to be characterized prior to the reservoir impoundment. It is therefore important to characterize the carbon flow process (surface fluxes and sequestrated carbon) from these terrestrial systems prior to impoundment. The Canadian Wildlife Service of Environment Canada, Quebec region, has developed an approach for mapping wetlands using Landsat/RADARSAT-1 satellite images. The method is based on image segmentation using the Definiens Professional software. The top-down object-based classification is based on the Canadian Wetland Classification System and quickly an... <s> BIB010 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> With the all-weather and day/night imaging capability, synthetic aperture radar (SAR) plays an important role in inundation extent detection. The inundation area detection using SAR will be easy as a result of the dark image tones yielded by specular reflection to the radar wave. Object oriented method (OOM) was applied to detect inundation extent using multi-polarized ENVISAT ASAR data. The traditional pixel-based methods used in information extraction and classification focus on the single pixel, so when they are applied in SAR imagery no perfect results can be achieved because of the speckle of SAR imagery. On the other hand, the pixel-based methods have limitations for detecting inundation extent and flood monitoring because of the neglect of the information of the adjacent pixels. The OOM, which no longer looks at individual pixels, but rather homogeneity areas (image objects), would be much more effective. In this paper, the OOM is applied in the ENVISAT ASAR alternative polarized (VV/VH) images using the software eCognition. The study site is located in Poyang Lake wetland, which has different inundation extent at different time. The images were segmented firstly, then the standard nearest neighbor classifier and the membership function classifier were used to classify the image objects, finally the different inundation areas were detected. The classification accuracies for two classifiers from the OOM are 95.78% and 92.24%, which are higher than that of the maximum likelihood classifier, 86.02%. <s> BIB011 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Wetland vegetation plays a key role in the ecological functions of wetland environments. Remote sensing techniques offer timely, up-to-date, and relatively accurate information for sustainable and effective management of wetland vegetation. This article provides an overview on the status of remote sensing applications in discriminating and mapping wetland vegetation, and estimating some of the biochemical and biophysical parameters of wetland vegetation. Research needs for successful applications of remote sensing in wetland vegetation mapping and the major challenges are also discussed. The review focuses on providing fundamental information relating to the spectral characteristics of wetland vegetation, discriminating wetland vegetation using broad- and narrow-bands, as well as estimating water content, biomass, and leaf area index. It can be concluded that the remote sensing of wetland vegetation has some particular challenges that require careful consideration in order to obtain successful results. These include an in-depth understanding of the factors affecting the interaction between electromagnetic radiation and wetland vegetation in a particular environment, selecting appropriate spatial and spectral resolution as well as suitable processing techniques for extracting spectral information of wetland vegetation. <s> BIB012 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> There has been an increasing interest in characterizing and mapping isolated depressional wetlands due to a 2001 U.S. Supreme Court decision that effectively removed their protected status. Our objective was to determine the utility of satellite remote sensing to accurately detect isolated wetlands. Image segmentation and object-oriented analysis were applied to Landsat-7 imagery from January and October 2000 to map isolated wetlands in the St. Johns River Water Management District of Alachua County, Florida. Accuracy for individual isolated wetlands was determined based on the intersection of reference and remotely sensed polygons. The January data yielded producer and user accuracies of 88% and 89%, respectively, for isolated wetlands larger than 0.5 acres (0.20 ha). Producer and user accuracies increased to 97% and 95%, respectively, for isolated wetlands larger than 2 acres (0.81 ha). Recently, the Federal Geographic Data Committee recommended that all U.S. wetlands 0.5 acres (0.20 ha) or larger should be mapped using 1-m aerial photography with an accuracy of 98%. That accuracy was nearly achieved in this study using a spatial resolution that is 900 times coarser. Satellite remote sensing provides an accurate, relatively inexpensive, and timely means for classifying isolated depressional wetlands on a regional or national basis. <s> BIB013 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> An airphoto survey carried out at the La Grande hydroelectrical complex (James Bay, Quebec) revealed numerous signs of degradation of patterned fens, with a decrease in terrestrial vegetation and increase in ponds, a process known as aqualysis. The principal goal of this study is to provide information on the present and past (the last 50 years) state of patterned peatlands, associated with the pattern of the aquatic and terrestrial compartments, and to evaluate their changing cover using remote sensing techniques. In this paper, we present a semi-automated, object-based method for QuickBird panchromatic image classification. The method emphasizes contextual information. We have also integrated texture images calculated in advance as supplementary data layers in the process of segmentation and classification. The validation of QuickBird image classification shows that the proposed method can delineate peatlands with 95% producer’s accuracy and 88% user’s accuracy. The overall classification accuracy in th... <s> BIB014 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Occupancy models provide a useful tool for examining relationships between species' occurrences and environmental or ecological covariates when detection probability is less than one. This research is focused on the secretive and rare California Black Rail ( Laterallus jamaicensis coturniculus ) and its wetland habitats in a newly discovered part of its range in the Sierra Nevada foothills of California, USA. In order to examine the Black Rail's distribution, residency, density, relationship to a larger conspecific, the Virginia Rail ( Laterallus limicola ), and relationship to livestock grazing, three classes of occupancy models were utilized: single-species/single-season models, single season/two-species models, and multi-season/single-species models. In order to develop a wetland classification procedure for identifying potential Black Rail habitats, we evaluated the utility of combining topographic features with spectral and geometric features using high-resolution satellite imagery and a digital elevation model (DEM). The secretive California Black Rail has a disjunct and poorly understood distribution. After a new population was discovered in Yuba County in 1994, we conducted call playback surveys from 1994-2006 in the Sierra foothills and Sacramento Valley region to determine the distribution and residency of Black Rails, estimate densities, and obtain estimates of site occupancy and detection probability. We found Black Rails at 164 small, widely scattered marshes distributed along the lower western slopes of the Sierra Nevada foothills, from just northeast of Chico (Butte County) to Rocklin (Placer County). Marshes were surrounded by a matrix of unsuitable habitat, creating a patchy or metapopulation structure. We observed Black Rails nesting and present evidence that they are year-round residents. Assuming perfect detectability we estimated a lower-bound mean Black Rail density of 1.78 rails ha -1 , and assuming a detection probability of 0.5 we estimated a mean density of 3.55 rails ha -1 . The probability of detecting occupancy from a single call playback survey at a marsh was high (mean = 0.84), and the estimated proportion of marshes occupied (across all years) was 0.58. The proportion of sites occupied by Black Rails in the foothills remained relatively stable from 2002-2006 despite turnover from year to year of specific sites. Irrigation ditches were the primary water source at 75% of the marshes that had Black Rails. Approximately two-thirds of marshes with Black Rails were on private land. Black Rails are more widespread in the Sierra foothills than was previously known, and the foothills distribution appears to be discontinuous with populations in the San Francisco Bay-Delta Estuary. Occupancy surveys may be an improved method for monitoring population trends of this secretive marsh bird where habitat patches are highly fragmented. Two-species occupancy models that account for false absences provide a robust method for testing for evidence of competitive exclusion, but previous model parameterizations were inadequate for incorporating covariates. We present a new parameterization that is stable when covariates are included, the conditional two-species occupancy model, that can be used to examine alternative hypotheses for species' distribution patterns. This new model estimates the probability of occupancy for a subordinate species conditional upon the presence of a dominant species. It can also be used to test if the detection of either species differs when one or both species are present, and if detection of the subordinate species depends on the detection of the dominant species when both are present. We apply the model to test if the presence of the larger Virginia Rail affects probabilities of detection or occupancy of the smaller California Black Rail in small freshwater marshes that range in size from 0.013-13.99 ha. We hypothesized that Black Rail occupancy should be lower in small marshes when Virginia Rails are present than when they are absent, because resources are presumably more limited and interference competition should increase. We found that Black Rail detection probability was unaffected by the detection of Virginia Rails, while, surprisingly, Black and Virginia Rail occupancy were positively associated even in small marshes. The average probability of Black Rail occupancy was higher when Virginia Rails were present (0.74 p however, spring cover was not well predicted by RDM. Accurate, transferable and efficient mapping procedures are needed for wetland inventory, assessment and monitoring. Wetland mapping is typically carried out using two types of inputs: (1) spectral reflectance data from imagery and (2) topographic/hydrologic data derived from digital elevation models (DEMs). Hybrid approaches that integrate remotely-sensed imagery with topographic data have shown improved wetland mapping accuracy in several studies. Here we evaluate the performance of nine topographic features (aspect, downslope flow distance to streams, elevation, horizontal distance to sinks, horizontal distance to streams, plan curvature, profile curvature, slope and topographic wetness index) on freshwater wetland classification accuracy in the Sierra foothills of California. To evaluate object-based classification accuracy we test both within-image and between-image predictions using six different classification schemes (naive Bayes, the C4.5 decision tree classifier, k-nearest neighbors, boosted logistic regression, random forest, and a support vector machine classifier) in the classification software package Weka 3.6.2. Adding topographic features had mostly positive effects on classification accuracy for within-image tests, but mostly negative effects on accuracy for between-image tests. The topographic wetness index was the most beneficial topographic feature in both the within-image and between-image tests for distinguishing wetland objects from other green objects (irrigated pasture and woodland) and shadows. Our results suggest that there is a benefit to using a more complex index of topography than simple measures such as elevation for the goal of mapping small palustrine emergent wetlands, but this benefit, for the most part, has poor transferability when applied between image sections. Occupancy models provide a robust method for examining species-environment relationships when detection probability is imperfect. The Black Rail study system in the Sierra foothills provides a unique and valuable opportunity for examining the effects of interspecific competition and grazing on a threatened subspecies at a regional scale. Further development of wetland mapping procedures will allow for a more complete description of the distribution of this rare and enigmatic marsh bird. <s> BIB015 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Land-use/cover change dynamics were investigated in a Mediterranean coastal wetland. Change Vector Analysis (CVA) without and with image texture derived from the co-occurrence matrix and variogram were evaluated for detecting land-use/cover change. Three Landsat Thematic Mapper (TM) scenes recorded on July 1985, 1993 and 2005 were used, minimizing change detection error caused by seasonal differences. Images were geometrically, atmospherically and radiometrically corrected. CVA without and with texture measures were implemented and assessed using reference images generated by object-based supervised classification. These outputs were used for cross-classification to determine the 'from-to' change used to compare between techniques. The Landsat TM image bands together with the variogram yielded the most accurate change detection results, with Kappa statistics of 0.7619 and 0.7637 for the 1985-1993 and 1993-2005 image pairs, respectively. <s> BIB016 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Conceptually, plant functional types represent a classification scheme between species and broad vegetation types. Historically, these were based on physiological, structural and/or phenological properties, whereas recently, they have reflected plant responses to resources or environmental conditions. Often, an underlying assumption, based on an economic analogy, is that the functional role of vegetation can be identified by linked sets of morphological and physiological traits constrained by resources, based on the hypothesis of functional convergence. Using these concepts, ecologists have defined a variety of functional traits that are often context dependent, and the diversity of proposed traits demonstrates the lack of agreement on universal categories. Historically, remotely sensed data have been interpreted in ways that parallel these observations, often focused on the categorization of vegetation into discrete types, often dependent on the sampling scale. At the same time, current thinking in both ecology and remote sensing has moved towards viewing vegetation as a continuum rather than as discrete classes. The capabilities of new remote sensing instruments have led us to propose a new concept of optically distinguishable functional types ('optical types') as a unique way to address the scale dependence of this problem. This would ensure more direct relationships between ecological information and remote sensing observations. <s> BIB017 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> This study used geographic object-based image analysis (GEOBIA) with very high spatial resolution (VHR) aerial imagery (0.3 m spatial resolution) to classify vegetation, channel and bare mud classes in a salt marsh. Three classification issues were investigated in the context of segmentation scale: (1) a comparison of single-and multi-scale GEOBIA using spectral bands, (2) the relative benefit of incorporating texture derived from the grey-level co-occurrence matrix (GLCM) in classifying the salt marsh features in single-and multi-scale GEOBIA and (3) the effect of quantization level of GLCM texture in the context of multi-scale GEOBIA. The single-scale GEOBIA experiments indicated that the optimal segmentation was both class and scale dependent. Therefore, the single-scale approach produced an only moderately accurate classification for all marsh classes. A multi-scale approach, however, facilitated the use of multiple scales that allowed the delineation of individual classes with increased between-class and reduced within-class spectral variation. With only spectral bands used, the multi-scale approach outperformed the single-scale GEOBIA with an overall accuracy of 82% vs. 76% (Kappa of 0.71 vs. 0.62). The study demonstrates the potential importance of ancillary data, GLCM texture, to compensate for limited between-class spectral discrimination. For example, gains in classification accuracies ranged from 3% to 12% when the GLCM mean texture was included in the multi-scale GEOBIA. The multi-scale classification overall accuracy varied with quantization level of the GLCM texture matrix. A quantization level of 2 reduced misclassifications of channel and bare mud and generated a statistically higher classification than higher quantization levels. Overall, the multi-scale GEOBIA produced the highest classification accuracy. The multi-scale GEOBIA is expected to be a useful methodology for creating a seamless spatial database of marsh landscape features to be used for further geographic information system (GIS) analyses. <s> BIB018 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Segmentation and object-oriented processing of single-season and multi-season Landsat-7 Enhanced Thematic Mapper Plus (ETM+) data was utilized for the classification of wetlands in a 1560 km2 study area of north central Florida. This segmentation and object-oriented classification outperformed the traditional maximum likelihood algorithm (MLC) in accurately mapping wetlands, with overall accuracies of 90.2% (single-season imagery) and 90.8% (multi-season imagery), compared to overall accuracies for the MLC classifiers of 78.4 and 79.0%, respectively. Kappa coefficients were over 1.5-times greater for the segmentation/object-oriented classifications than for the MLC classifications, and producer and user accuracies were also higher. The producer accuracies of the segmentation/object-oriented classifications were 90.8% (single-season) and 91.6% (multi-season), compared to 70.6 and 74.4%, respectively, for the MLC classifications. User accuracies were 73.9 and 73.5% for the single-season and multi-season segmentation/object-oriented classifications, respectively, compared to 54.1% (single-season) and 55.0% (multi-season) for the MLC classifications. The use of multi-seasonal data resulted in only a slight increase in overall accuracy over the single-season imagery. This small increase was primarily due to better discrimination of riparian wetlands in the multi-season data. Segmentation and object-oriented processing provides a low-cost, high-accuracy method for classification of wetlands on a local, regional, or national basis. <s> BIB019 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Visual image interpretation and digital image classification have been used to map and monitor mangrove extent and composition for decades. The presence of a high-spatial resolution hyperspectral sensor can potentially improve our ability to differentiate mangrove species. However, little research has explored the use of pixel-based and object-based approaches on high-spatial hyperspectral datasets for this purpose. This study assessed the ability of CASI-2 data for mangrove species mapping using pixel-based and object-based approaches at the mouth of the Brisbane River area, southeast Queensland, Australia. Three mapping techniques used in this study: spectral angle mapper (SAM) and linear spectral unmixing (LSU) for the pixel-based approaches, and multi-scale segmentation for the object-based image analysis (OBIA). The endmembers for the pixel-based approach were collected based on existing vegetation community map. Nine targeted classes were mapped in the study area from each approach, including three mangrove species: Avicennia marina, Rhizophora stylosa, and Ceriops australis. The mapping results showed that SAM produced accurate class polygons with only few unclassified pixels (overall accuracy 69%, Kappa 0.57), the LSU resulted in a patchy polygon pattern with many unclassified pixels (overall accuracy 56%, Kappa 0.41), and the object-based mapping produced the most accurate results (overall accuracy 76%, Kappa 0.67). Our results demonstrated that the object-based approach, which combined a rule-based and nearest-neighbor classification method, was the best classifier to map mangrove species and its adjacent environments. <s> BIB020 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> A multi-temporal analysis of Landsat panchromatic data was applied to the Usanga wetlands in Tanzania, where there are concerns that irrigated agricultural development is reducing downstream water availability. As there are many small fields, and even smaller areas of continuous vegetable cultivation throughout the year, 15-m resolution multi-temporal Landsat Enhanced Thematic Mapper Plus (ETM+) panchromatic data, acquired in the months of March, May and October, were used to extract information on the seasonal land use/cover in order to investigate agricultural water use. Object-oriented analysis was used to interpret these high-resolution data through definition of image segments, which were then classified using a pixel-based unsupervised classification method. This hybrid approach helps to process high-resolution data quickly and efficiently, so as to economically and effectively understand and classify land use/cover in highly heterogeneous and seasonally dynamic tropical conditions, where land units are typically small. <s> BIB021 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Abstract Remote sensing-based analyses of vegetation function such as photosynthesis and productivity are challenging in wetlands with complex cover and difficult field access. Recent advances in object-based image analysis (OBIA) and machine-learning algorithms offer new image classification tools; however, few comparisons of different approaches have been discussed to date. We applied OBIA to delineate wetland plant functional types (PFTs) for Poyang Lake, the largest freshwater lake in China and Ramsar wetland conservation site, from a spring 2008 Landsat TM image. We targeted major PFTs that represent dominant vegetation groups along wetland inundation gradients and affect ecosystem biogeochemical cycles and ecological habitats. Classification results were compared among: a) several “small” object segmentation scales (with average object sizes 1350–9000 m 2 ); b) algorithms from six families of statistical machine-learning classifiers (Bayesian, Logistic, Neural Network, Decision Trees, K-Nearest Neighbors and Support Vector Machines) and c) two hierarchical levels of vegetation classification, a generalized 3-class set and a more specific 6-class set. We also examined the response of classification accuracy to four basic object-level texture metrics. The highest accuracies (> 85–90%) and best agreement among algorithms occurred at coarser object scales rather than close-to-pixel scales. No single machine-learning algorithm was consistently superior at all scales, although support vector machine, k-nearest neighbor and artificial neural network most frequently provided the highest overall and PFT-specific accuracies. Including texture metrics had both positive and negative low-magnitude effects on classification accuracy that were not consistent among scale values, algorithms or PFT classes. Individual PFTs differed in scales at which they were best discriminated from others, reflecting their unique landscape positions, ecology of dominant species and disturbance agents. There was a 29–35% disagreement between mapped areas of generalized PFTs and their respective subclasses, suggesting potential mismatches between the ecological classification scheme and PFT landscape patch structure, and raising concern on error propagation in multi-scale classifications. We conclude that OBIA with machine-learning classifiers is useful for landscape vegetation analyses, however, considerations of spatial scale and image segmentation outcomes are critical in mapping PFTs and should be more thoroughly investigated in future work. <s> BIB022 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Blanding’s turtle (Emydoidea blandingii) is a threatened species under Canada’s Species at Risk Act. In southern Quebec, field based inventories are ongoing to determine its abundance and potential habitat. The goal of this research was to develop means for mapping of potential habitat based on primary habitat attributes that can be detected with high-resolution remotely sensed imagery. Using existing spring leaf-off 20 cm resolution aerial orthophotos of a portion of Gatineau Park where some Blanding’s turtle observations had been made, habitat attributes were mapped at two scales: (1) whole wetlands; (2) within wetland habitat features of open water, vegetation (used for camouflage and thermoregulation), and logs (used for spring sun-basking). The processing steps involved initial pixel-based classification to eliminate most areas of non-wetland, followed by object-based segmentations and classifications using a customized rule sequence to refine the wetland map and to map the within wetland habitat features. Variables used as inputs to the classifications were derived from the orthophotos and included image brightness, texture, and segmented object shape and area. Independent validation using field data and visual interpretation showed classification accuracy for all habitat attributes to be generally over 90% with a minimum of 81.5% for the producer’s accuracy of logs. The maps for each attribute were combined to produce a habitat suitability map for Blanding’s turtle. Of the 115 existing turtle observations, 92.3% were closest to a wetland of the two highest suitability classes. High-resolution imagery combined with object-based classification and habitat suitability mapping methods such as those presented provide a much more spatially explicit representation of detailed habitat attributes than can be obtained through field work alone. They can complement field efforts to document and track turtle activities and can contribute to species inventory planning, conservation, and management. <s> BIB023 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> QuickBird satellite imagery and object-based classification were used to map emergent macrophyte response in wetlands that were partially drawn down during a three-year period (2007–2010) in the Saskatchewan River Delta, Manitoba, Canada. Generalized logistic models were used to classify vegetation genera in three drawdown and three high-water (control) wetlands. User accuracy of models averaged 74 %, and was lower in partial drawdown wetlands (72 %) than in high-water wetlands (77 %). In partial drawdown wetlands, emergent macrophytes (especially Typha spp. and Carex spp.) senesced significantly after the first year of lowered water levels but senescent areas decreased over following years. Plants were not completely dead in dewatered areas and emergent stands recovered by the third year after drawdown. Open water area in the partial drawdown wetlands gradually decreased due to clonal expansion of Sparganium spp. Vegetation areas in high-water wetlands remained unchanged throughout the study period. Although partial water-level drawdowns temporarily influenced the growth of emergent macrophytes they did not expose the seed bank and did not result in substantial, prolonged changes in spatial arrangement of vegetation areas. The combination of high-resolution satellite imagery, object-based classification and logistic modeling was useful for documenting vegetation response to management in these remote, boreal wetland systems. <s> BIB024 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> During its spring and fall migrations, the Greater Snow Goose (Chen caerulescens atlanticus) stages in the marshes along the St. Lawrence Estuary in southern Quebec, where it feeds on three-square bulrush (Schoenoplectus americanus) rhizomes. The goose population has grown from 70 000 birds to around one million over the last 40 years, thus increasing pressure on these tidal marshes. To determine the impact of geese on the ecological integrity of the marshes over this period, we used IKONOS satellite imagery and aerial photographs to classify vegetation types. We estimated changes in bulrush cover using the eCognition image analysis software (Trimble). We examined the spectral, textural, and contextual characteristics of the identified classes. The proportion of bulrush cover has declined significantly in the lower marsh since around 1980, and bulrush has been gradually replaced by wild rice (Zizania aquatica var. brevis). We also documented the erosion between the lower and upper marshes along most of the shoreline. <s> BIB025 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Accurate and informative vegetation maps are in urgent demand to support the Kissimmee-Okeechobee-Everglades ecosystem restoration project in South Florida. In this study, we evaluated the applicability of fine spatial resolution hyperspectral data collected from the HyMap sensor for both community- and species-level vegetation mapping. Informative and accurate vegetation maps were produced by combining machine learning methods (Support Vector Machines (SVM) and Random Forest (RF)), object-based image analysis techniques, and Minimum Noise Fraction (MNF) data transformation. An overall accuracy of 90% was obtained in discriminating 14 vegetation communities. Classification of a large number of species is also promising. An overall accuracy of 85% was achieved in identifying 55 species using a SVM model. The results indicate that fine spatial resolution hyperspectral data classification using such automated procedure has great potential to replace the manual interpretation of aerial photos for vegetation mapping in heterogeneous wetland ecosystems. <s> BIB026 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Climate change mitigation schemes, such as REDD and biodiversity conservation in tropical rainforests, necessitate remote sensing based forest monitoring capabilities with high spatial resolution and temporal coverage. Regular monitoring has to be capable of detecting rapid changes in forest extent, i.e. deforestation, and subtle changes to the forest cover caused by logging and/or fire, described as forest degradation. Particularly the early detection of illegal logging activities is important for the conservation of tropical forests. In the present study, a forest disturbance monitoring approach was developed and tested, which makes use of high resolution satellite imagery. A time series consisting of three images, acquired between May 2009 and June 2010, was analyzed covering a remote area of tropical peat swamp forest in Central Kalimantan, Indonesia. The forest area was assessed by an object-oriented classification. Logging activities and the impact of fire were detected by a pixel-based spectral mixture analysis. Forest, non-forest and logging trails could be differentiated with an overall classification accuracy of 91.5% (Kappa of 0.87). A high forest disturbance rate of 8.7% was found in the study area. Low impact logging could be detected reliably and the progress was tracked over time. The results show that the timely detection of forest disturbances is necessary because of the fast regrowth of vegetation. The study emphasises the importance of high resolution satellite imagery for tropical forest monitoring and for timely updating forest status assessments, which is important for the implementation of REDD. <s> BIB027 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Abstract This paper explores the use of ALOS (Advanced Land Observing Satellite) PALSARL-band (Phased Array type L-band Synthetic Aperture Radar) and RADARSAT-2 C-band data for land-cover classification in a tropical moist region. Transformed divergence was used to identify potential textural images which were calculated with the gray-level co-occurrence matrix method. The standard deviation of selected textural images and correlation coefficients between them were then used to determine the best combination of texture images for land-cover classification. Classification results based on different scenarios with maximum likelihood classifier were compared. Based on the identified best scenarios, different classification algorithms – maximum likelihood classifier, classification tree analysis, Fuzzy ARTMAP (a neural-network method), k-nearest neighbor, object-based classification, and support vector machine were compared for examining which algorithm was suitable for land-cover classification in the tropical moist region. This research indicates that the combination of radiometric images and their textures provided considerably better classification accuracies than individual datasets. The L-band data provided much better land-cover classification than C-band data but neither L-band nor C-band was suitable for fine land-cover classification system, no matter which classification algorithm was used. L-band data provided reasonably good classification accuracies for coarse land-cover classification system such as forest, succession, agropasture, water, wetland, and urban with an overall classification accuracy of 72.2%, but C-band data provided only 54.7%. Compared to the maximum likelihood classifier, both classification tree analysis and Fuzzy ARTMAP provided better performances, object-based classification and support vector machine had similar performances, and k-nearest neighbor performed poorly. More research should address the use of multitemporal radar data and the integration of radar and optical sensor data for improving land-cover classification. <s> BIB028 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Abstract Despite the long history of vegetation mapping with remote sensing, challenges remain in effectively linking remote sensing observations with plant traits and environmental disturbance across species and functional types. This study proposes a classification of aquatic and wetland vegetation plant functional types (PFTs) using time series remotely sensed data applicable to wetland ecosystems with large annual water level changes like Poyang Lake, the largest freshwater lake–wetland of China. We first developed the aquatic and wetland PFT classification scheme which included perennial C 4 grasses, perennial C 3 reed, C 3 (sedges and taller forbs), short C 3 forbs, floating aquatic macrophytes, and submerged aquatic macrophytes. Using this scheme, time series normalized difference vegetation index (time series NDVI) images and time series vegetation–water index (time series VWI) images extracted from 32-m spatial resolution Beijing-1 microsatellite data were applied to perform two PFT classifications with a support vector machine (SVM) algorithm. We found that the time series NDVI-based SVM classification method mapped aquatic and wetland PFT distribution with an overall accuracy of 81.3%. However, when the information on water level fluctuation was combined with time series NDVI into a new time series index (referred to as time series VWI), the overall accuracy increased to 90.4%. Results suggest that time series VWI has a stronger capability in distinguishing wetland PFTs with different submersion times and flood tolerances than time series NDVI, and thus may be considered as a key input dataset for future PFT classifications in seasonally dynamic wetlands. <s> BIB029 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> article i nfo An informative and accurate vegetation map for the Greater Everglades of South Florida is in an urgent need to assist with the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan (CERP), a $10.5-billion mission to restore the south Florida ecosystem in 30+ years. In this study, we examined the capability of fine spatial resolution hyperspectral imagery collected from Airborne Visible/Infrared Imaging Spectrometer (AVIRIS) for vegeta- tion mapping in the Everglades. In order to obtain an efficient and accurate procedure for vegetation discrim- ination, we developed a neural network classifier first and then combined the object-based texture measures with the classifier to examine the contribution of the spatial information for vegetation mapping. The neural network is capable of modeling the characteristics of multiple spectral and spatial signatures within a class by an internally unsupervised engine and characterizing spectral and spatial differences between classes by an externally supervised system. The designed procedure was tested in a portion of the Everglades. An object- based vegetation map was generated with an overall classification accuracy averaged 94% and a kappa value averaged 0.94 in discriminating 15 classes. The results are significantly better than those obtained from conventional classifiers such as maximum likelihood and spectral angle mapper. The study illustrates that combining object-based texture measures in the neural network classifier can significantly improve the classification. It is concluded that fine spatial resolution hyperspectral data is an effective solution to ac- curate vegetation mapping in the Everglades which has a rich plant community with a high degree of spatial and spectral heterogeneity. <s> BIB030 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Over the past few decades, clearing for shrimp farming has caused severe losses of mangroves in the Mekong Delta (MD) of Vietnam. Although the increasing importance of shrimp aquaculture in Vietnam has brought significant financial benefits to the local communities, the rapid and largely uncontrolled increase in aquacultural area has contributed to a considerable loss of mangrove forests and to environmental degradation. Although different approaches have been used for mangrove classification, no approach to date has addressed the challenges of the special conditions that can be found in the aquaculture-mangrove system in the Ca Mau province of the MD. This paper presents an object-based classification approach for estimating the percentage of mangroves in mixed mangrove-aquaculture farming systems to assist the government to monitor the extent of the shrimp farming area. The method comprises multi-resolution segmentation and classification of SPOT5 data using a decision tree approach as well as local knowledge from the region of interest. The results show accuracies higher than 75% for certain classes at the object level. Furthermore, we successfully detect areas with mixed aquaculture-mangrove land cover with high accuracies. Based on these results, mangrove development, especially within shrimp farming-mangrove systems, can be monitored. However, the mangrove forest cover fraction per object is affected by image segmentation and thus does not always correspond to the real farm boundaries. It remains a serious challenge, then, to accurately map mangrove forest cover within mixed systems. <s> BIB031 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Abstract Mapping and monitoring mangrove ecosystems is a crucial objective for tropical countries, particularly where human disturbance occurs and because of uncertainties associated with sea level and climatic fluctuation. In many tropical regions, such efforts have focused largely on the use of optical data despite low capture rates because of persistent cloud cover. Recognizing the ability of Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) for providing cloud-free observations, this study investigated the use of JERS-1 SAR and ALOS PALSAR data, acquired in 1996 and 2008 respectively, for mapping the extent of mangroves along the Brazilian coastline, from east of the Amazon River mouth, Para State, to the Bay of Sao Jose in Maranhao. For each year, an object-orientated classification of major land covers (mangrove, secondary vegetation, gallery and swamp forest, open water, intermittent lakes and bare areas) was performed with the resulting maps then compared to quantify change. Comparison with available ground truth data indicated a general accuracy in the 2008 image classification of all land covers of 96% (kappa = 90.6%, tau = 92.6%). Over the 12 year period, the area of mangrove increased by 718.6 km 2 from 6705 m 2 to 7423.60 km 2 , with 1931.0 km² of expansion and 1213 km² of erosion noted; 5493 km² remained unchanged in extent. The general accuracy relating to changes in mangroves was 83.3% (Kappa 66.1%; tau 66.7%). The study confirmed that these mangroves constituted the largest continuous belt globally and were experiencing significant change because of the dynamic coastal environment and the influence of sedimentation from the Amazon River along the shoreline. The study recommends continued observations using combinations of SAR and optical data to establish trends in mangrove distributions and implications for provision of ecosystem services (e.g., fish/invertebrate nurseries, carbon storage and coastal protection). <s> BIB032 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Land cover change has been one of the major drivers of change leading to an alteration of critical habitats for many of the threatened species worldwide. Species with a narrow range and specialized habitats such as wetland ecosystems are at higher risk. The present paper describes spatial and temporal land use and cover change over the period of last 34 years (1976–2010) in the Koshi Tappu Wildlife Reserve (KTWR), Nepal. High spatial resolution Indian Remote-Sensing Satellite (IRS) Linear Imaging and Self Scanning Sensor (LISS-4) from 2005 and medium spatial resolution Landsat Multispectral Scanner (MSS) from 1976; Thematic Mapper (TM) from 1989; Enhanced Thematic Mapper Plus (ETM+) from 1999 and TM from 2010 were used to generate a land use/land cover map and change analysis. Acquired IRS LISS-4 and Landsat image was orthorectified into Universal Transverse Mercator (UTM), Zone 45 based on generated digital terrain model (DTM) from a topographic map and Ground Control Point (GCP) from the field. After rectifying all the images, eCognition developer software was used for object-based image analysis (OBIA). The change in the land cover and land use types were compared with the potential habitat of twenty globally significant species present in the reserve. The habitat information was collected from the literature and a map was prepared based on ‘presence’ data, habits and habitats used to identify their distribution pattern. The analysis revealed that the KTWR has gone through significant changes in land cover and ecosystems over the last 34 years due to the change in river course and anthropogenic pressure leading to direct change in habitats of the species. Forests have been reduced by 94% from their original state whereas the grassland has increased by 79% from its original state. On the basis of total land cover, forests, river and stream, swamp and marshes decreased by 16%, 14% and 3% respectively over the last 34 years whereas the grassland has increased by 45%. These ecosystems are also an important habitat for the majority of the species, which is resulting in habitat loss. Notably, the wetland ecosystems (marshes/swamps and river/streams), being one of the most important habitat for many globally threatened species, have changed by more than 30% from their original state in 1976. Based on the analysis, recommendations for management interventions were made. <s> BIB033 </s> Object-Based Image Analysis in Wetland Research: A Review <s> Importance of the Classification Method <s> Abstract Periodically inundated wetlands with high short-term surface variation require special approaches to assess their composition and long-term change. To circumvent high uncertainty in single-date analyses of such areas, we propose to characterize them as dynamic cover types (DCTs), or sequences of wetland states and transitions informed by physically and ecologically plausible surface processes. This study delineated DCTs for one 2007–2008 flood cycle at Poyang Lake, the largest freshwater wetland in China, using spatial and temporal orientation modes of extended principal components analysis (EPCA) and supervised object-based classification of multi-spectral and radar image series. Classification accuracy was compared among three sets of attributes selected by machine-learning optimization from object-level mean and standard deviations of: 1) image time series alone; 2) the most informative EPCA outputs alone and 3) image time series and EPCA results together. Classification uncertainty was additionally assessed as low values of object's maximum class membership ( <s> BIB034
The choice of a specific classification method may strongly affect wetland mapping outcomes with both pixel-and object-based approaches BIB001 BIB004 BIB012 BIB022 BIB031 . Most of the reviewed analyses (Figure 3 ) used either custom knowledge-based rule sets BIB023 BIB007 BIB002 BIB003 , or supervised nearest-neighbor classification in eCognition software which uses estimates class membership values from training samples and assigns classes to unlabeled objects based on fuzzy logic  BIB018 BIB013 BIB019 BIB020   BIB009 BIB010 BIB034 BIB003 . In contrast to pixel-based wetland literature, reviewed studies did not employ unsupervised clustering or statistical ordination techniques at object level, except one study using unsupervised clustering of image regions to obtain wetland and non-wetland mask BIB014 . Several studies used unsupervised pixel-based classification to generate preliminary cover types and then performed more specific object-based analyses for wetland delineation BIB024 , classification of wetland units BIB032 or mapping their intrinsic cover types BIB003 BIB006 . Such hybrid approaches combining pixel and object units were especially useful in complex wetlands with heterogeneous surface cover and fuzzy boundaries. Among the statistical supervised approaches, various methods were used from conventional maximum likelihood classifiers BIB025 to novel machine-learning algorithms BIB026 BIB022 BIB033 BIB027 BIB011 BIB031 . Supervised approaches based on minimum distance in the feature space were more intensively employed at the early stages of wetland OBIA (Figure 3) , while recent years have been marked with more active use of machine-learning algorithms. Their potential, however, remains somewhat under-utilized compared to rule-based techniques and eCognition's fuzzy logic classifier   BIB015 BIB003  . In part, this could be explained by the "black box" nature of common machine learning methods and their reliance on iterative learning to improve predictive capacity, which constrains the interpretability of their parameters and error in the outcome. Relative performance of various algorithms in wetland setting also remains unclear; few studies have compared multiple techniques for the same objective, and among those which did, similar approaches were ranked differently  BIB011 BIB031 . Several machine-learning method families, however, are particularly promising to circumvent the challenges of heterogeneity and limited reference data in wetland OBIA. For example, support vector machine (SVM) methods perform classification by fitting a hyperplane along the class boundaries in the feature space, and therefore may not require training sample sizes as large as methods comparing distances to class means. Superior performance of SVM compared to other popular methods was reported in mapping of wetland plant communities and species in Florida, USA BIB026 , object-based classification of Galapagos mangroves in BIB027 and the study of wetland plant functional types in Poyang Lake, China BIB022 . Decision tree learning methods such as classification and regression trees (CART) and random forest have also been successful in wetlands BIB026 BIB022 BIB016 ; in BIB031 , two decision tree methods and k-nearest neighbor (k-NN) classifier surpassed in accuracy logistic regression, SVM and Bayesian algorithms. Neural networks BIB022 BIB011 BIB028 can be internally customized for complex classification tasks, as demonstrated by >13% improvement in accuracy of wetland plant community mapping with new adaptive learning vector quantization neural network compared to minimum distance, maximum likelihood and spectral angle mapper classifiers BIB011 . Importantly, the success of machine-learning algorithms strongly depends on their parameter specifications, which could partially explain the lack of consensus on their relative performance. Pre-classification testing for the optimal parameters should be an integral part of their use, such as the "grid search" for controls on decision margin and error penalty in SVM BIB029 , the number of hidden layers in neural networks or limits on regression tree "growth" and "pruning" in decision tree approaches BIB021 . Method specifications and the order of their implementation become particularly important in hierarchical and stepwise OBIA BIB005  . While accuracy is often assessed at the final map stage, errors at individual steps, threshold rules and hierarchical levels may accumulate and disproportionately contribute to final accuracy values. Furthermore, classifications schemes are often designed based on the expected hierarchical relationships among land cover types and management units BIB008 , ecological hierarchies in vegetation communities BIB022  , topography and hydrology BIB018 BIB030 , but not as often with spectral characteristics and spatial attributes ultimately affecting class separability in given data. More profound understanding of the sources and pathways of error propagation in multi-step wetland analyses is necessary to inform hierarchical studies and more effectively reconcile ground-based structure of landscape entities with their optical properties BIB017 .