What is the Continuing Effect of Brokerage Robinhood on the Stock Market? | UC Davis Skip to main content Menu UC Davis Open Search Search Quick Links + myUCDavis MyAdmissions Make a Gift to UC Davis Emergency Services Campus Map Calendar Visit Apply Jobs Athletics Academic Dates Canvas General Catalog Schedule Builder Commencement Student Health Alumni UC Davis Stores Directory Main navigation (extended config) About Us Administration Initiatives Principles and Policies Top Administrative Units Org chart Staff Resources Computing Resources Diversity and Inclusion Rankings Locations In the Middle of Everywhere Bay Area day trips Beach day trips Sierra Nevada day trips Wine country day trips Transportation Join 'Team Bike' Unique to UC Davis Sustainability Visit UC Davis Campus Tour Campus Tour Plan your visit Directions and Parking Tour Guides Olivia Sanchez ’22 Brady Beach ’22 Sammy Abrego ’22 Gehena Girish ’22 Mia Zidan ’22 Hannah Bireschi ‘22 Henna Kabra ‘22 Jeff Simpson ‘22 Jeremy Brown ‘22 Jojo Carusa ‘23 Katie Phillips ‘22 Michelle Lester ‘23 Morgan Hall ‘22 Paige Kaufman ‘22 Welcome Center Virtual Tour UC Davis Health Campus Safety Emergencies and FAQs Help Contact Us Admissions Undergraduate Admissions Apply to UC Davis After You Apply Deferred Enrollment Reporting Changes After Admission Applicant Waitlist Application Review Criteria Personal Insight Questions Freshman Admission Freshman Admission Requirements Advanced Placement Exams International Baccalaureate Exams Freshman Application Tips Freshman Timeline Freshman Special Situations College Preparation Programs Transfer Admission Plan Your Transfer Transfer Admission Requirements Transfer Application Tips Transfer Timeline Transfer Admission Guarantee TAG Requirements TAG Decisions TAG FAQs TAG Counselor Resources Counselor Contacts TAG Evaluations Selective Major Requirements Major Requirements: CAES Major Requirements: CBS Major Requirements: CLS Major Requirements: COE Transfer with International Records Transfer Special Situations International Admission International Exam and Visa Requirements International Records International Student Resources Events College Fairs National College Fairs International College Fairs Discover UC Davis Aggie Transfer Scholars Weekend Aggie to Be Contact Undergraduate Admissions Parents and Families Counselors More Information Undocumented Applicants Graduate Admissions Professional Admissions Cost & Aid Financial Aid and Scholarships Higher Education Emergency Relief Fund Next Steps Educational Opportunity Program Apply to UC Davis Academics Majors Majors Blog Career Preparation Research Advising Beyond the Classroom Honors Programs Internships Individual Majors Undeclared and Exploratory Majors Subscribe Top 10 majors Minors Graduate Programs Professional Programs Colleges and Schools Academic Departments College of Agricultural and Environmental Science College of Biological Sciences College of Engineering College of Letters and Science Graduate School of Management Graduate Studies School of Education School of Law School of Medicine School of Nursing School of Veterinary Medicine Our Faculty Faculty Resources Teaching Resources Student Resources Women in STEM Battling Barriers, Bias to Retain and Recruit STEM Talent Building Community to Benefit Physics Students For the love of wild things Heart health pioneer, STEM champion The STEM Road Less Traveled Using STEM to improve lives Study Abroad Research Undergraduate Research Graduate Research Office of Research Library Museums and Collections Research Partners UC Davis Discoveries Agricultural discoveries Blazing the way for chardonnay Breeding better bees Mechanical tomato harvester Rice genetics Biology discoveries Chloroplasts contain DNA Surviving Extreme Drying Engineering discoveries Broadband communications Plug-in hybrid cars Environmental discoveries Getting lead out of gasoline Saving Lake Tahoe Medical discoveries Feline AIDS Fragile X syndrome (FXTAS)B HIV Treatment protocols One bead, one compound Real-time imaging of single DNA enzymes Whole-body PET scan Social science discoveries Early hunters were female Science of love Veterinary science discoveries Treating animal burns with tilapia skins Campus Life California’s College Town The College Tour Housing Dining Things to Do Calendar Campus Poster Calendars Academic Dates and Deadlines University Holidays Quarter Registration Dates Quarter Dates and Deadlines Quarter Fees and Billing Dates Undergraduate Admission Dates College Fair Dates California College Fair Dates National College Fair Dates International College Fair Dates Undergraduate Graduation Filing Dates Commencement Schedule and Graduation Celebrations Academic Events College of Agricultural and Environmental Studies College of Biological Sciences Events Calendar College of Engineering Events Calendar College of Letters and Science Events Calendar Graduate School of Management Events Calendar School of Law School of Veterinary Medicine Research Library UC Davis Extension Arts and Entertainment Athletics Health, Wellness, and Safety Diversity and Inclusion Student Life Staff and Faculty Global Events Other Calendars Arts and Culture UC Davis Eggheads Robert Arneson: Serious Ideas Behind that Humor Traditions #ourUCDavis Fall Welcome Grad Cap Contest Homecoming Picnic Day Arboretum Commencement Student Jobs Clubs and Communities Athletics News Latest News Social Media Social Media Guidelines University News Dateline Student News Blogs Podcasts and Shows Face to Face That May Be the Chancellor The Backdrop Thursday Thoughts UC Davis LIVE Unfold Outgrow the Expected What is the Continuing Effect of Brokerage Robinhood on the Stock Market? by Karen Nikos-Rose February 05, 2021 Blog Getty Images Editor’s Note: This is an updated version of an earlier blog, with a UC Davis expert explaining that the most recent GameStop, AMC and Nokia stock price surge episodes are part of a broader pattern of trading in Robinhood users. By Michelle Villagomez, UC Davis Media Relations Intern Zero-fee brokerage Robinhood is named after the legendary outlaw who stole from the rich to give to the poor. However, a new study indicates the exact opposite is happening, with sophisticated traders exploiting Robinhood’s “naive” investors, as reported recently in various media. Further, recent GameStop, AMC and Nokia stock price surge episodes are part of a broader pattern of trading in Robinhood users, said Brad Barber, a behavioral finance expert and professor at University of California, Davis, Graduate School of Management. In fact, the stocks with the biggest increase in Robinhood users each day go on to underperform the market, Barber said. He is the co-author of a report, “Attention Induced Trading and Returns: Evidence from Robinhood Users.” He said in a recent media report that half of Robinhood users are first-time investors. And they tend to be drawn to “attention-grabbing” stocks in the news. Brad Barber As a result, herding takes place, the authors say in their working paper, with Robinhood investors flocking into the same stocks at the same time. This gets noticed by short-sellers, who then bet against these same stocks. Betting against Robinhood users is a profitable business; the top stocks bought by Robinhood users fall by five percent over the next month while the most extreme herding events see reversals of nine percent. Free trading, it seems, can be a costly business, says an Irish Times columnist who wrote about the paper. What about the GameStop, AMC and Nokia frenzied stock surges? The scholars analyze counts of Robinhood users holding each stock on its platform using data from May 2018 to August 2020, when Robinhood stopped sharing this granular data. The research shows that the recent GameStop, AMC and Nokia stock price surge episodes are part of a broader pattern of trading in Robinhood users. For example, the stocks with the biggest increase in Robinhood users each day go on to underperform the market by about 5 percent over the next month. Interestingly, the observed negative return is roughly twice as large in the pandemic period for which the researchers have data (March to August 2020), a period that also saw a spike in retail trading. “This all suggests the footprints of Robinhood traders could be seen in returns long before the GameStop episode,” Barber said. The scholars also analyze the aggregate returns of the Robinhood community by accounting for the prices at which Robinhood investors buy during these episodes — including those who buy before the price spikes. They found that, in aggregate, the Robinhood community loses about 5 percent relative to the market in each of these herding episodes and would have been better off had they just invested in an S&P 500 index fund. More about the paper The study is available at the Social Science Research Network. The authors are Barber, Xing Huang, and assistant professor of finance at the Olin Business School of Washington University in St. Louis, Terrance Odean, professor of finance at UC Berkeley’s Haas School of Business, and Christopher Schwarz, associate professor of finance at UC Irvine’s Merage School of Business. In this paper, researchers found that Robinhood users are more subject to attention biases and more likely to chase stocks with extreme performance and volume than other retail investors. “We systematically identify the Robinhood herding episodes and document that these episodes are followed by abnormal negative returns,” the authors wrote in the paper. “We show that Robinhood herding is influenced by information that is prominently displayed on the Robinhood app. And we show that Robinhood herding can be forecasted by attention measures, such as lagged absolute returns and lagged abnormal volume, previously shown to affect the buy-sell imbalances of retail investors.” “As we show, simply focusing the attention of many investors on a small number of stocks can promote herding behavior that affects market returns and redounds to the investors’ detriment,” the authors conclude in their paper. “Thus, while it is important that investors have access to transparent, pertinent information, disclosure alone is not sufficient to assure good investor outcomes; how information is displayed influences decisions in ways that can both help and hurt investors.” Part of this story is excerpted from an Irish Times story by Proinsias O'Mahony Primary Category The Curiosity Gap Tags Graduate School of Management Robinhood Stock Market UC Davis UC Davis Health Veterinary Medicine UC Davis Continuing and Professional Education UC Davis Stores UC Davis Arts UC Davis Mobile Apps Hiring UC Davis Students and Alumni Make a Gift to UC Davis Students Orientation Student Resources Graduate Students Commencement Internship and Career Center Jobs and Internships Parents Alumni Cal Aggie Alumni Association Career Connections Member Benefits Transcripts UC Davis Magazine Faculty Resources Teaching Research Benefits Faculty Governance Staff Resources Training Benefits Jobs Staff Assembly Website Feedback University of California, Davis, One Shields Avenue, Davis, CA 95616 | 530-752-1011 Questions or comments? Privacy & Accessibility Principles of Community University of California Last update: October 18, 2021 Copyright © The Regents of the University of California, Davis campus. All rights reserved. This site is officially grown in SiteFarm.