I would rate these 5 star . but , because if they one downside Ill leave it at 4 . these CAN be the most comfortable longest last flip flop you own . but there be a break in period . it usually last about 1 to 2 week . this usually scare most people and i feel that it be where most of the negative review come from . during this time expect the nylon webbing between you toe to be horribly uncomfortable and if you have larger\/wider foot the strap to be too tight around you foot . but with time they will stretch and the footbed will form to you foot like no other sandal . this pair be my second pair . the first pair that i have last I over 6 year before i lose they . and this most recent pair be just begin to be comfortable . soooo if you can put up with a week or 2 of pain , you can have some comfortable sandal to last year . but if not , there be many nice sandal -lrb- my other favorite be sanuk -rrb- that be comfortable right out of the box at a comparable price point . buttt , they just wont last as long . for some , they may not be worth the wait , and i understand . but all my friend who have try they and stick it out have love they and i really think you would too .