I want to play Halo 3 use a PS3 controller - that be I . I have countless hour log play FPS game on PS3 like mag and be not try to re-learn how to walk on my 360 . plus I find the 360 controller uncomfortable , it cramp my finger and that creep into my neck . ok , so the version I get be obviously open-box , it come in a plastic bag mark `` make in China '' . usually , this would cost a star on my review , but I do love this gizmo . here be the rule : have everything set up with this device before you turn the 360 on . use a Sony brand ps2 controller and a m brand wire 360 controller -lrb- not a `` plug in '' wireless controller -rrb- . turn rumble off through the 360 dashboard . if this do not work , return the item for a replacement , and if that do not work , post in you review which 360 you be use so people can figure out what work and what do not . I be use a old white 20 gig 360 . BTW , this also work on a pc - I be able to get it to work with some emulator .